Always a good pizza, at good price! Kind of surprising for pizza made at a gas station.read more

This place has some of the best pizza and wings I have ever had. I am not a very big pizza fan. I…read moreonly eat pizza every once in awhile but this place definately has me wanting to eat more pizza. Check it out. You won't be disappointed!!

Stopped in at Benny D's for a slice and it was out of this world! Staff was friendly, food came…read moreout fast, slices were huge, and the whole place was super clean. We will be back soon!

Good slice on the go. Its gigantic!!! It's a good place to stop and get a quick bite.read more

We arrived on a Sunday afternoon, actually Mother's Day. And there were only 2 booths left. The…read moreinterior was a nicely renovated older building. Complete with stamped tin ceilings, antique doorways, and lights! As it was our first time here we were directed to seat ourselves, and we were promptly seated as. Our drink order was taken. We ordered 14" pepperoni and sausage pizza. Ot was delivered straight out of the oven, piping HOT!! It turned out to be very good! Everyone commented on the sauce, large chunks of sausage and crispy crust. My wife commented that she especially enjoyed the crust and sauce. I found it to be really good pizza! We'd agreed we'd come here again when looking for good pizza.

I've been going here for years and it was always very good. I don't know if the owners have…read moreretired and the kids have taken over or what, but it's not what it used to be. We were not greeted when we walked in the door - we stood there for a while waiting to be seated and they just stared at us, we asked for a table and were rudely told to seat ourselves. Sat down and waited a long time. When the waitress came by didn't apologize for the wait - there was only one other table with people in the whole restaurant. We didn't want to wait again so we went ahead and ordered. Ordered cheese bread for an appetizer and a pizza. Food took forever, and the waitress never stopped to check on us even though our drinks were empty. When the food came they brought it all at once, we were hoping for the cheese bread first but nope it all came at once, no apologies. After that they never came to check on us, and when they came to take the order and bring the food they acted rude like they didn't want to be there and we were just a bother. Both the pizza and the cheese bread were dry, the dough developed big bubbles all over which disintegrated the cheese and sauce so it was basically mostly inedible. Didn't even finish half of it, and still nobody came to check on us even though the restaurant was empty and the phone wasn't even ringing with orders. All the workers there are very young and rude. Cheese bread was supposed to come with marinara but we had to ask for it TWICE to get them to bring it to us by the time the cheese bread was cold - and couldn't eat it without the marina because it was so dry. Had to flag someone down after waiting forever for the bill, just for them to throw the bill on the table and tell us to pay at the counter. This used to be I e if my favorite pizza places in town, but sadly it has gone downhill and the employees are rude, to the point that I will never be back.

Easiest one star view I could ever dream of, I thought the 55 minutes was a reasonable amount of…read moretime to get a pizza, since they said it would be 40 minutes, then said it would be 10 more minutes, then just five more minutes, if the staff spent less time complaining to each other, I might've had Pizza, some older woman back behind there was incredibly rude, really nice kid that tried to wait on me at the counter, obviously under trained, a delivery person that couldn't figure anything out, obviously under trained, I'm gonna say really poor ownership and poor management for sure, the place is kind of dirty and gross inside, I don't mind eating dirty, gross places, but I can't stand rude, and I can't stand being lied to

I've ordered pizza on three different occasions. The crust is not good. Poor quality sauce and the…read morecheese seems artificial. I decided to go ahead with another try and was told it would be 90 minutes? I went to another pizza shop! Poor service, food quality is bad and the place looks terrible! Wouldn't recommend!

Ordered a pizza with sausage and onion to go. Their pizza is New York style which I'm not a fan of…read morebeing from Chicago. Estimated time for pickup was 35 minutes. This order was ready in 15, which wasn't a good sign as I based what I was doing on the time the text said. Got there about 10 minutes after I received the text it was ready, and it was sitting on the counter with the rest of the orders, none of which were being kept hot. Pizza was room temp by the time I got home and not good. Very bland, not much flavor. Won't be back.

Great service. And good food . Nick is awesome!!! He's a great guy!!!!! Very kind . Clean inside…read moreand everything.

I really wish they would make their crust from scratch and make their sauce more flavorful. I went…read morehere as a kid all the time and if I want a taco pizza this is the place I want it from. I don't remember the crust tasting this way and I feel like they have lost their touch. It's a family business and I hope they have many more generations of success. Lots of memories here, I just can't convince myself to eat their crust often enough to do the same with my kids.

Gave it another try and the pizza just doesn't make the cut. One of the most flavorless pizza's…read moreI've sadly even had.

I had Pizza Sam's delivered to my hotel while staying in town for a conference. I had one of the…read morespecials and it was pretty tasty. I do enjoy more of a thin crust that they offered flavors were pretty much on point. I would order it again.

Been going to Pizza Sam for at least 30 years had a personal size pepperoni pizza a few weeks ago…read moreand it was delicious. I grabbed up the garlic butter side and was dipping it. I would definitely give it a eight out of 10 and I will be going back $10 worth every penny of it

This has become our go-to pizza spot in the area…read more The pizza itself is very solid, and consistent, which is a problem around town, a lot of places can be hit or miss any given day. We do a lot of takeout here but I love coming in and sitting at the bar, great staff that always takes care of you. Also a lot of regulars which makes for a cool vibe, plus they have live music sometimes.

I stopped by Maestro's Pizza over the weekend to give the place another shot. I went in hopeful, or…read moreat least mildly optimistic, that maybe something would feel different. Spoiler: it didn't. The same bartender I've mentioned before was still there, and honestly, nothing about the experience with them has changed. At this point, it's almost impressive how consistent the energy is like a character who shows up every episode with the exact same line delivery. And when I say the place still has a "greasy" vibe, I don't mean the pizza. I mean the overall atmosphere.