POSITIVES: For all-you-can-eat pizza, it's pretty good! Great variety of tasty pizzas with unique flavors and toppings (especially the dessert pizzas). The staff is some of the most accommodating and friendly in Rexburg. Some days (or hours) are cheaper. Some deals are well worth it. NEGATIVES: you often need to wait a while for the pizza you want to come out. Tables aren't always the cleanest. PRICE: about $8 per person. RECOMMENDED: definitely try the chipotle chicken pizza, firefighter rick, the oreo and the cookie dough dessert pizzas. read more

This restaurant has really good pizza for a buffet, and the price was shockingly low. My only issue was that it seemed a little understaffed, it took a while to get some pasta. They portion out and cook pasta fresh, and the sauces were way better than what I expected at a buffet. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

Good salad bar, great dessert pizza, below average pizza. Probably the worst pizza in town, but who cares when you can eat as much as you want. read more

Best part is the price & the fact that it's a buffet... but the food isn't all that great.

It's good for the price. It's a buffet, so you get your fill. They also have a pasta and salad bar. It's pretty good. Just don't expect quality flavor. my boyfriend thinks the crust on the dessert pizzas was too hard. Overall just something was missing, but good. Will be back with update . read more

I love this place! The pizza is amazing! They have good service! I totally thing you should try this place! It is a little expensive but a good price for a buffet! I love there salads and pastas! SO GOOD!!! read more

I never got the hype of this place.... Prices were descent for a buffet, but it was frustrating never having enough pizza out. They always seemed to be running behind on quantity and the pizza was very mediocre. I however did enjoy their desert pizza, that stuff was pretty good. read more

Pizza is good. Manager not so much. We did not have a good experience with him. Cleanliness could also be improved.

Good pizza for the price. It's a buffet so you get what you pay for- It's not the highest quality but pretty good. I like the option for pasta and salad as well. Pretty good pizza variety! I will say, every time I get a soda it comes out watery. read more

This is a great place! Pizza is good, service is awesome, and the value.... can't say enough about the value. For the amount I paid I got more than I bargained for. This the five stars. I wish they had more of this place, especially in Honolulu. This is a must stop the next time I'm in Idaho. I'm so full I can't even touch the desserts, which I was told was good. Come here hungry and it will be worth it! read more

Food is a little better than the quality you might expect from a $6 buffet. Salad bar is my favorite. It has always been fresh and crisp. Pasta is good too but some of the sauces are swimming in grease. Pizza is mostly bread. I don't come for the pizza though. I come for the salad bar and the Apple beer. As a side note, their dessert pizzas are incredible! You must try the cookie dough and the Oreo dessert pizzas. read more

Very few kinds of pizza when we arrived. I posted this photo to Google, and the owner replied by asking if I ate it all.

A pizza buffet that has pretty good pizza? Gasp! It's true! They have some very flavorful and unique combinations that will grab your attention and their dessert pizzas are pretty delish! Nice ambiance and cute décor make this a great little stop when you want pizza without the wait. :) read more

What can I say? It is all you can eat and is delicious! It feels a little cramped inside but I can't complain with how great of the buffet deal is. Lot's of options and a restaurant you can't get enough of! read more

For being the first founded pizza pie, It's disappointing. They can't keep up with the demand. The pizza is always dried out, I don't think they replace it when they should. Went to one in Utah and was sooooo much better. read more

As time passed from my last review, I've found they have gone through a small remodel and I feel better service and more selections!!! This place is STILL my favorite place to eat in Rexburg, Idaho!! read more

Delicious pizza, salad, and pasta Buffet. Go there all the time. Only $7 for the lunch Buffet. You can add a gluten free pizza for $2 and you also get the salad bar and gluten free pasta. The desert pizza is wonderful! Great place to take the whole family! They have lower prices for child Buffet, based on age. Highly recommend it! read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - They have delicious desert pizza! Oreo, Cookie Dough, Apple pie, and raspberry. - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Starving on our way back from Yellowatone, was desperate to not eat burgers again. Alli was so nice to let us stay even though they were closing. We were lucky to enjoy super yummy pizza, even oreo pizza. My super picky toddler approved it!!! read more

This place is sooo bad for you but tastes really good...at least most of the flavors do. My favorite kind of pizza was their Oreo dessert pizza. They had so many pizza choices it's hard to choose just one. It's nice that they cut the slices small, so that you can sample each one. I didn't try the pasta bar, but it looked really good. Their salad is fresh, and I like that they have daily deals. read more

The food isn't the best, but it's the best deal in town. The salad bar is ok, the pasta is decent, and the pizza is pretty good. The pizzas are unique, offering a wide array of flavors and choices. The dessert pizzas are phenomenal, worth the price alone. read more

I've had their pizza buffet more than once and it's not bad. As others have said, it's not hands-down the best pizza you'll ever have but it's not entirely terrible. The atmosphere feels a bit run-down and shabby, and the plates they give to take the pizza back to your table are supremely, ridiculously tiny. One slice will slide around that thing, just waiting to fall off... (I suggest just grabbing one of their salad plates instead). But it's Rexburg, not a ton of options, and the variety of the pizza types is pleasant. I do wish they would have more cheese pizza at the ready, but this is a common complaint with pizza buffets. You'll get an abundance of screaming children on weekends and during their happy hours, huge families and groups of annoying teens are also common. I once witnessed the manager lecturing a group of 20-something men who ordered two pizzas to go but decided to dine-in instead. "Each one of those boxes costs us fifty cents, gentlemen. And now we're out a dollar and you didn't even need the box after all. Next time you need to figure out if you're taking out or dining in." Embarrassing paying customers over two pizza boxes felt a bit unprofessional, but that's just what this place is like. Ramshackle. Verdict: I like this place better than the Pizza Hut buffet and better than Fazzoli's. It's even better if you're poor! But make sure you prepare yourself mentally for the Rexburg-ness of it all. read more

The door says they open at 11am. It's currently 11:05 and there isn't one pizza out. If you have a pizza buffet, don't open till your pizzas are out. This is ridiculous. I'm wondering how long I'll have to wait for a gourmet pizza.... :/ read more

Love eating here!! Has an amazing pasta bar! However it needs to be maned a little more someone needs to stay over there a little more often. I'm tired of having to round someone up every time I want pasta! Over all pricing is pretty good. Staff is friendly. Good place with good food. Pretty clean place sometimes their bathrooms could use a little more up keep but overall not bad. read more

Food is not bad for a buffet but the service is not that great. They seemed understaffed as tables were left uncleaned and guests were not seated promptly. read more

My wife wanted to go here, and so we decided to try it out. As soon as we walked in the door we looked around and the place was a mess. Ignoring the mess, we walked up to the counter and we were greeted by the cashier. There was no clear indicator on the price. We spent over $20 for only two buffets and only one drink to share. This place brags about low pricing when they charge you through the roof for below average pizza. A $2.50 Tony's pizza from Walmart tastes better. This place may have a "wide variety", but it doesn't matter when it all tastes like cardboard. Go to the Mexican restaurant at the end of the street. Great food at a real price. I wish we could have gotten a refund for the crappy food. read more

Skip it unless you like flavorless pasta & sauces. Ranch dressing was watered down to the point of pouring white liquid over my salad. Pizza was mediocre at best BUT their gluten free pizza is pretty good. Overall for the cost there are better choices in Rexburg. read more

Okay, we went back today and the food was MUCH better. The first night we went I have to cut them some slack. They were totally swamped and probably just trying to get pizzas out into the line. The crust is thinner and tastes better today and there is also a lot more consistency with the toppings on the pizza. The service today was also great and the dirty dishes have been pulled from our table right as we finish. Glad I gave them a second chance! read more

I would give it three and a half stars if I could. The pizza isn't the best but they offer a wide range of different types of pizza to choose from. The buffet comes with pasta and salad which makes coming here more worth it. This is a perfect place to come when you are very hungry and can't decide what kind of pizza you want. I always tend to over eat when I come here. read more

Very disappointed in employees inability to handle the processing of just paying to get into the restaurant... if you put someone at the check in counter ... they need to be knowledgeable and not need to keep leaving to find someone to tell them how to process payments on the computer. read more

I mean where else can you go to get a pizza buffet in this area? They have a huge variety of pizzas, even yummy dessert pizzas! I like getting their salad and pasta sometimes too. One thing is for sure, you are getting what you pay for and you won't leave hungry! They also have pretty good pazookies or cookie monsters, I don't know what they are called there. read more

Decent pizza. I didn't like the pasta sauces, I thought they were pretty plain. The pizza buffet is the way to go.

Pizza Pie Cafe is just a place to get lots of food, the service is not great, and of course self serve. The pizza quality could be improved a lot even though it is all you can eat, pizza hut has a buffet as well but they did not sacrifice quality. I wish that the servers would be more helpful, as the only time they really show up is to bring out a pizza, and even then they don't want to help you for anything else. read more

I brought the whole family here. My wife had Eliza's,so pizza is not somewhere she liked to go. But this place had a gluten free pizza that my wife enjoyed. It did cost two dollars more, but she also had access to the salad bar. I liked the selection of pizzas offered, but the best part was the pasta bar. Pizza, salad, and a wide selection of pastas made this place a winner. I recommend the spicy sausage sauce with the penne pasta. This is a great place to hang out with friends, spend time with family, or take a date. read more

As much as you can eat pizza! It's nothing incredible, but you can obviously get a lot of food for a low price. Their salad and pasta bars are also great. And their dessert pizzas are to die for. read more

This place will always be Craigos to me. Pizza Pie Cafe? Lame. That being said the food here is pretty great. The buffet is pricey, but the nice thing is once you've paid you're good to go. You could sit there all day and eat yourself into an oblivion if you want to. The pasta is awesome. I mean generally noodles are noodles but the thing that really makes this place excel is the sauces. I mean it's really good. i just have to knock these guys down a peg because of the prices. read more

Eat at this place ALL the time!! So good! The price is right!! And there are always specials, or coupons so you get more bang for your buck! The salad bar is SO GREAT!! Pizza and pasta is really good too!! I don't have one bad thing to say about PPC! read more

The pizza tastes like cardboard. The only good thing is that it is fairly cheap. But in my opinion it's expensive for such crappy food.

It was good in Rexburg when it Craigos but now it's just bland and dry. It's great for kids but not if you are looking for your tastebuds to dance in delight. read more

A great range of pizzas, but my favorite is the pasta and salad bar. Always offering coupons, and often involved in local charities. Great place. read more

Fun place with a good variety of pizza. They have always been busy when we come but the pizzas stay well stocked. My daughter loves this place and the dessert pizzas. Salad bar is a little weak but overall a great family dining option. read more