I haven't eaten here since I was attending the University pre-pandemic. From what I can tell the prices have stayed pretty much the same and pretty affordable for a buffet! The pizza is just as good as I remember it being and this is great spot to eat! There is a huge variety of pizzas, a salad bar, dessert pizzas, garlic knots, cheese sticks and a pasta bar. Food: 4/5 Price: 5/5 Wow Factor: The Root beer! I don't know what brand it was, but boy was it good! Leaps and bounds above the commonly found root beer brands (Mug, A&W, Barqs) Overall: 5/5 You can get full on some pretty tasty pizza for a pretty reasonably price! read more

Visited at 130 PM on Monday Nothing is Fresh! Everything was served at room temperature. It was my first time there and was very disappointed. I will tell everyone I know about my experience read more

It was delicious! I wish we had one in California!! They had so many to choose from in the buffet! Didn't even have room to try the pasta buffet! Very reasonable price too! read more

This place is a decently affordable place to eat dinner however, it's pretty hit or miss. I would say in my most recent trip that about 40% of the pizzas were well over cooked to the point that the dough was as hard as a cracker. And the dessert pizzas were worse. In fact I tried a small slice of each dessert pizza and was only able to finish the cinnamon roll one since all the others were incredibly overcooked. This made the affordable price almost negligible since I wasn't even able to enjoy a large portion of the pizzas. read more

I'll preface this review by saying two things. One - I hope the management and the owners pay attention to EVERYTHING I say here. They need to hear it and take it into account. Two - shout out to the girl that helped me. I think Katrina was her name. She deserves a raise or a promotion or SOMETHING. Management, GET ON THAT. - It was Friday night and we ordered three pizzas for pick-up. We arrived at the provided time to pick up our food, which as about 30 minutes after ordering. This place was easily the busiest restaurant I've ever seen, post-COVID. Good for them. However, poor Katrina was the unfortunate person that assisted me and had to tell me that they didn't know what happened, but my order was gone. Her best guess was that someone else on staff had inadvertently given it away to another person. I don't know how that happens. Bummer. But it was Friday and the place was busy. I've made mistakes at work too. I get it. I'm not going to get mad. Katrina offered to have them start my order up again and she'll throw a little something into the order for the trouble. Sure, no prob. The hope and the expectation was that I might have my order after another 15 minutes. But sadly, that wasn't the end of it. I would've had to wait about 30-40 minutes. That is, if my order didn't get messed up again, by the KITCHEN this time. So what ended up happening was I stood in the lobby for a little more than a HOUR with nothing else to do but watch how this place operates. And while I did, Katrina was the only constant. She checked in with me multiple times to update me on my order's progress. And that was on top of everything else she was doing. Let me tell you, that girl was bouncing all over the place trying to make sure that everything was taken care of. During my hour-long wait, I can tell you from my perspective that Katrina was doing twice as much as the rest of the staff was. SERIOUSLY. To the management - Katrina is your saving grace as far as I'm concerned. Ya'll better give her some recognition for it. So there's my reasoning for the one star review. We had a long day, didn't want to cook, and we purposefully ordered out because we were tired and ready for dinner. The 90 minute wait for our food did not sit well with the family. We will not be going back. I think there are some logistical and process-driven changes that would improve this place, if management and the owners would give it consideration. But I've got a bad taste in my mouth, besides the pizza. * One last time, Katrina did everything she could to try and make my poor experience right. She was genuine, helpful, and apologetic. If this had to happen, I'm glad it happened to me because I wouldn't want an unhappy customer yelling at her over the apparent incompetence of her co-workers. She wouldn't have deserved it. The one star is not a reflection on her service in the slightest. Lastly, during my hour wait, there were two other occasions that other parties came in and the front staff spent unusual amounts of time talking with them before they got their food. I can't say what it was about, but it's hard to not assume that those folks' orders got screwed up too. My experience with this establishment is actually not a reflection of the staff but of poor ownership/management. Ya'll need to put some new processes in place. Everyone on your team was running around like chickens with their heads cut off. Make a good leader our of yourselves and help your team succeed. Just FIX IT. read more

This pizza place is awesome. Not only can you get pizza, they also have a pizza bar, so you can try all kinds. They also have a pasta bar with different pastas and sauces. Make your own if you want. They have dessert pizzas also. To top it all off they have a great salad bar. We came in to try it out and Macie helped us. She was great. Very helpful and friendly. Great customer service. Thanks Macie! read more

See all

Pizza Pie Cafe is best described as quantity over quality, a place you go when you want to chill with family, have lunch with a friend, or hold a birthday party. It is not a place you come to get amazing pizza, but rather a place to get unlimited mediocre pizza. They also have both a salad bar and a pasta bar for those who want more than just pizza. The dessert pizza is the best thing here by far but sadly after one or two pieces you will have a stomach ache. The atmosphere here is perfect for family gatherings or lunch breaks. One of the best things I've found is that even when the place is jam-packed, it is quiet enough that you can hear your friend talk to you from across the table. One thing I wish they would improve is the pizza serving area. It is quite difficult to get a piece of pizza with the serving tool they give you, and most of the time the pizza you are looking for is not there and you have to wait 5 minutes for them to put a new one out. I would only suggest coming here if you just want to have a good night out with people and the quality of the food is not super important to you. read more

See all

I wasn't pleased. I felt like it was too quiet and empty and the food was just ok. It was nothing to brag about.

There were no open tables to sit at- a bunch of them were empty but not cleared off for new customers to sit. We had to wait around and asked twice to have a table cleared to sit at. The floor at our booth had liquid on the ground. The food wasn't great to top it all off, I Thought it was expensive for the quality. I'm not sure if they were short staffed or what was going on. read more

We rolled in a gaggle of kids and the staff couldn't have been more accommodating and helpful. Pleasw give everyone who works there a raise. Thank you. we'll be back! read more

Stopped by here when on a road trip. Looking at the reviews the pizza looked delicious. However looks are and can be deceiving. We order a large pizza, drinks. The service was incredibly slow. When asked about the wait the manger said it would be a just a few more minutes, those minutes turned into 15. My kids started acting up because they waited so long and the manger came over and told our kids to settle down... with that we left. Rude owners and who know how the food is. Go at your own risk. read more

Fun place to try on our road trip to Yellowstone! I'm gluten free and was happy with the salad bar options, that they had gluten free penne pasta and that they make you your own gf pizza any way you want. You pay $2 more for gluten free. Their dessert pizzas looked great! My family's favorite was the Oreo pizza! Wish there was something GF for dessert. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

We have since moved across the country but we still pine for pizza pie cafe their carbonara pasta sauce is to die for and I craved it all through my pregnancy. I searched the dark webs endlessly for the secret recipe but sadly never found it. I found a copy cat that was halfway decent but just not the same. We took our 3 year old daughter to pizza pie on a cross country road trip back through town. She shares the love!!! I will always eat at pizza pie anytime I am ever back in Rexburg! Die hard fan. read more

Went here tonight. Service is mediocre. The price to come in is way more expensive than it should be. The pizza tastes worse than it used to. So just a few months ago or so the price has gone up, the pizza tastes worse, and the service has gotten worse. Amazing improvements guys read more

$45 for a trashed buffet experience. Absolutely no salad bar. Dirty pasta options. Little pizza options. And the best part...no forks. We all had to wait 10 minutes to eat our food. Buy some more forks. They absolutely should not be charging people the prices they are for such an awkward and gross experience. read more

This used to be "Craigo's," but now it's called "Pizza Pie Cafe." Whatever you call it, it's still a great place for lunch or dinner. They have expanded their successful business model throughout the region. Most people just order the buffet, which comes with a salad bar, pasta bar, and a wide range of specialty pizzas. They have an unbelievable variety of unique pizzas in addition to the classics. The buffalo chicken and the pepperoni & jalapeño are two of my favorites. They also feature 4 or 5 different dessert pizzas; they're all great. You can also order the giant "Cookie Monster," which is my kids' favorite, but not included in the buffet. The pasta bar is very nice, featuring many kinds of pasta and sauces. My favorites include the spinach fettucini with roasted red pepper sauce (incredible) and the radiatori with spicy sausage sauce (wow). The buffet is generally $6.99, but they frequently have specials and e-coupons. The food is always fresh, tasty, and plentiful. You will not walk away disappointed (or hungry). read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Great service and pizza! The pasta isn't the best but overall would highly recommend. Worth your money!

Great pizza. Good selection in the buffet - they even brought out new things while we were eating our first course that we could try. Great price without drinks and during lunchtime (11am - 4pm) They have pasta, pizza, salad, and a variety of dipping sauces / toppings available in the buffet Better choice than Righteous slice for me. No wait when we came in either. read more

It's pretty decent. The best is obviously the desert pizza, but really I've never had something I didn't like. It can get really crazy in there sometimes, but they try really hard to make sure all their pizzas are in stock. The salad bar is also yummy, I feel like they've got a good selection of toppings. Even if it's not the most healthy ;) read more

Very great place! They have really good system, and the pizza isn't bad, but pretty good!! Really fun place to go for a pizza eating competition with your friends! read more

So here's the deal I have gone here countless times the food has always been good and service great but when we recently went during corona virus the food was not very good and if you are worried about corona than don't go they don't have any precautions in place except for wax paper sheets to grab tongs with maybe it was just a bad day to go or something but out of all the times I have gone one failed attempt won't stop from going back. Sometime for now I don't plan on being there any time soon read more

Pretty good place and decently priced. Offers a variety of pizza flavors, pizza desserts, pasta and salad. I'm sorta lactose intolerant, but I come through anyways . Love the cookie dough pizza and the chicken Alfredo pizza. 4/5 because it can get pretty loud with kids throwing food everywhere...and some people just don't have manners when it comes to "not spilling" while serving themselves. Pizza pie cafe gets real messy real quick. But...I live right behind it...so it's all good and I just walk read more

PPC is great if you are looking for volume and decent food. It's not bad and it's not spectacular. Their crust has improved over the last little while. I will definitely go there again . . . and again - it's pizza read more

Love to eat here but a couple of things 1. You guys have been out of things at times I've eaten here please keep on top of restocking stuff like pizza and salad bar. 2. I wish your guys building was bigger it just seems really crowed at times and I feel really rushed to eat and leave not saying I'm going to stay all day but I want to enjoy my food a little and not feel like I have to eat and run. It's not the customers problem that you guys get so busy start opening up you bigger rooms to seat people if there isn't reservations for parties it will help to give more seating to those who need it and make it feel a bit less congested. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe buffet is great for the price. Solid choices of selection from salads, pizza, bread sticks, pastas, and self-serving drink machines. I don't give it a perfect score is because we did see some tables that weren't cleaned for a while and sometimes the counters where food was pretty messy with people serving themselves. With all things considering, this great spot to grab a meal for a good price. read more

Great prices, great food! I love that you can choose half or full portions from the pasta bar. The staff was very friendly. I highly recommend to everyone. read more

It's ok. Just got to keep in mind that it's a pizza buffet place. The pizza isn't that great but it's just like any type of buffet food. You are there to eat a lot and not necessarily eat good food. It's pretty clean and employees are friendly. It's better to go during off times like at 2 pm because if not it's very busy and you have to wait a lot. The restaurant can seem very crowded really fast. read more

Pizza here is as good as a buffet can get, the reason for the low stars is that they advertised happy hour as Monday- Friday 2-4 for $6.00 per buffet. Though we went today and got charged 7.25, after I asked the cashier about happy hour they told me they don't do it on move in dates for the college. I have attached their advertisement and my receipt. Be careful of false advertising here. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Pizza Pie Cafe seemed too good to be true: An all-you-can-eat pizza, pasta, and salad buffet. Not only that, but as a fellow starving college student, I respectfully attended the student special night ($6.35, including tax). All you have to do is simply sign up for the text alerts, which you can do right at the cashier. With their offers, they can also tag on different kinds of deals like discounts on drinks, so be on the lookout for those because the deals are never the same every week. When you walk inside, it's pretty much a seat-yourself situation. Pay for your buffet at the register, and/or if you want their other special offers like their giant cookie, but I just stick to their dessert pizzas. Afterwards, everything is completely unlimited. They will never run out of pizzas. I have even attended on a late night once where they started to slow down due to the lack of customers. There are different pizzas that they don't always serve daily like like one of their off the menu items which was a pesto pizza that day. The manager happened to see me looking for a slice, and asked me to wait a few minutes while they bake up a new one. I didn't stand for hours waiting, but just a few short minutes to have a fresh hot pizza. Not only do they have pizzas, but cheese sticks, and on occasion, garlic knots. All very lovely with their variety of dipping sauces, which are the sauces you can use for your pasta. There's a variety of different kinds of pasta where you can request for half or full serving of pasta. Don't let this stop you from ordering more because they'll heat up the pasta in warm water to serve it to you fresh. You can top it all off with grated, or shredded parmesan. The salad bar is pretty good too with a variety of leafy greens to pasta salad. There's toppings from bacon all the way to pine nuts, and goldfish. Pretty interesting, but makes you feel a bit healthier when you have pasta, and pizza waiting for you. Their dessert pizza's are pretty good too, and are always served hot. Nowadays I see them set out a tray of some other baked good, which I always tend to enjoy. So far, I've seen a birthday cake, brownie, and raspberry chocolate flavor. I like chewy textures with a slight crisp to it, and the special dessert every night I've gone has been the most enjoyable for me. No one is there to tell you to stop eating. This is not the time to feel self-conscious. You are getting such a good deal. There's always someone ready to clear the table to encourage you to eat more, so what's stopping you? read more

This is by far the best pizza buffet of all time. Don't come here to get an artisan or wood-oven baked pizza. Its a buffet, its under $10 a person, stop comparing it to places where a single pizza costs twice as much. They have a huge variety of pizzas, they have a good salad bar and their pasta bar is great. They have a bunch of different sauces all of which are extremely flavorful. You definitely get your money worth. If you are in town or anywhere near a pizza pie cafe. You need to try it out! The dessert pizzas are amazing as well. EAT HERE!!!!! read more

Great experience! Good customer service! Very clean for a buffet and I love how the employees clean off your table as you go back and forth. If you like little Caesars pizza then you'll absolutely love this. Great rewards programs to earn free drinks and buffets and they aren't out of reach like you would expect. read more

I really like the food whenever I come here, though sometimes the food has been out for a while and isnt too warm. But otherwise is great. And friendly staff. read more

Pleasant staff and great food. The pizza assortment is wide. The dessert pizza is delectable, I recommend the cookie dough pizza. The selection of pasta and sauces is good. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Eh. After 3 visits, the pizza starts to taste like cardboard. Pasta is pretty tasty, but also pretty greasy. Good deal though.

The regular pizzas are pretty gross. I like heh dessert pizzas though. The oreo and cookie dough are on point. The salad bar is also pretty good. read more

Upon searching for food choices when visiting Yellowstone Bear World, this place came up on the Yelp & Google searches. On ratings and comments, it seemed too good. But I have to agree, there cannot be anything negative about this place. Upon entering, the service from Stephanie made me & my whole family happy. So not only the place offered like 20+ kinds of pizza, pasta & salad choices, but Stephanie said that any kind of pizza combo that we wanted was also possible to order. Any ingredient or formation that is. We ordered 3-4 different kind, which were all very good. But the best pizza was, without doubt the Oreo one. It was the first of its kind I've ever tasted. Its a must taste for everyone. In the end, Stephanie also offered us a Cookie Dough pie, exclusively for my family for being there for the 1st time. All in all, one awesome place with cool & friendly folks. read more

Good food, good price, Unprofessional staff and Management! my family and I were there last Friday, the busboy was sprinting around clearing off tables faster then people could dirty them, the Vesba that went to Marz was 2 days behind this guy. The Manager\shift leader went up to him, in front of us and other customers and told him he was not cutting it and going way to slow. Then, when he left that area, her, and two other girls stood there for at least 10 mins. talking about their plans for the weekend. Then, they left, and one of the girls came back to the first booth in the front with a plate of food and took a 30min lunch. read more

This place is great! Food is awesome, really unique pizza flavors all really decent. This pizza is hearty. The dessert pizzas are way cool and delicious. The pasta sauces are great especially to dip your crust into, salad bar is nice, and there are times you can go for discounts! Place is clean and a nice warm environment with a cool decor. read more

Great place! They have a fun vibe there. It's a buffet with salad bar, pizza, pasta and dessert pizza all for one price ($8.95/person which I think is very reasonable). Loved the fresh salad bar! It was quite good. They had a wide variety of pizzas which were decent, and my teenaged kids loved the apple dessert pizzas. We would definitely go there again. We spent what we usually would at McDonald's, but got a MUCH better meal. read more

POSITIVES: For all-you-can-eat pizza, it's pretty good! Great variety of tasty pizzas with unique flavors and toppings (especially the dessert pizzas). The staff is some of the most accommodating and friendly in Rexburg. Some days (or hours) are cheaper. Some deals are well worth it. NEGATIVES: you often need to wait a while for the pizza you want to come out. Tables aren't always the cleanest. PRICE: about $8 per person. RECOMMENDED: definitely try the chipotle chicken pizza, firefighter rick, the oreo and the cookie dough dessert pizzas. read more