Pizza Place &amp; Trattoria

This place is constantly making the best foods. The food is stupendous, delicious, flavorful, fun,…read moreprofessionally made, wonderfully crafted with fresh fresh fresh ingredients. They even pop into the grocery store next door to them frequently to buy fresh ingredients as they prepare food, nothing frozen or sub-quality. Almost unheard of in the dining experience today. The chef who prepares the food is always making the most mouth watering, addicting meals and appetizers. The food looks equally delicious. It smells amazing. All made to order and the portions are generous. They are so friendly. We have literally never had a bad experience with them in over 4 years. Even if a mistake was made on an order, they have always been courteous and apologetic, they immediately remedy the problem in which everyone is happy. I just love the owners...I think Brewster is very lucky to have them in their town. We have several favorites on their menu but honesty, we haven't found a dud yet. Their hollandaise sauce is scrumptious and addictive!! I could eat it on an apple. The salads are fresh and creative. The specials are always a treat. For the prices, which seem a little high....i don't think they are. They provide fresh food, prepared by a legit professional who has common sense and a great knowledge of flavors and flavor combos. They give generous potions and you never feel like you were ripped off when devouring their creations. I would eat here daily if we could. I love supporting small local business and I love supporting good people just as much. They are the best. I'm getting hungry thinking about the waffles, chili and hollandaise sauce.

would have been to say, "I am a bit short-handed this morning, but please sit anywhere you want and…read moreI'll be with you shortly." Tip number 2) Water should be brought to the table as soon as possible, especially if a coughing customer requests it. Don't snap at the customer because she made a simple request. Prices have gone up and customer service has gone down, so we will like pass on this place from now on.

Inside

See all

Mexican Skillet

Southeast Grille House

4.2(108 reviews)

1.0 mi

Service is great. Wonderful views. Menu is pretty big. A lot to choose from. Owners should invest…read morein some updates to the dining room.

I'm just gonna come out and say it- run like a thief in the night and come to Southeast G. on Rt 6…read morein Brewster, NY. This is truly comfort food on the cheap. Trust, the quality is all here. This was the best thing for us especially since we were in the area catching up with a few errands. Southeast G's chic, dark grey+black outside design is softened by flowers, the bar area has light wood flooring, large counter off to one side, tables and booths. The space honestly gives out an inviting atmosphere without feeling stuffy. There's also a dining area which faces the reservoir making it perfect for casual events/gatherings. The Tito's Raspberry Tom Collins called me. That sucker started refreshing and its strength soon crept up! My $16 salad with pan seared salmon was fantastic. The dressing was done simply in lemon+oil. Hubs' sliced hanger steak over potatoes, sautéed veggies and drizzled with an demi glace was his winning ticket- and at $20, he enjoyed it to the fullest. Unlike eateries with jacked up prices, this is a terrific all-in-one for us: fantastic prices+strong drink+tasty food. We really couldn't ask for more. These folks take their menu seriously. And by the way- our server Heather, was spot on and pleasant.

Frontal

Lasagna

See all

Pull Up

Bam's

3.3(47 reviews)

3.4 mi

I used to stop in during COVID. They were one of the breakfast places open at that time. At that…read moretime his food was great but service was really slow. I have not been back in a while, and the owner was a little wacky and was in the middle of a divorce. He had troubles finding help. Sadly I drove past this morning and the weeds are high outside and it appears that it's permanently closed. I'm seeing lots of restaurants close In the area.

Seems to be out of business or moved somewhere. Does anyone know what happened to Bam's restaurant?read more

Breakfast all day!

See all

Food is great. Don't miss the fresh cut fries!

Fiddler's Green Pub

4.0(39 reviews)

3.0 mi

Have been coming here for as long as I can remember…read more.. Fidd's is a staple of Carmel, with friendly faces, great prices on drinks, and great food. Definitely has that homey Irish pub feel to it. Just remember it's cash only! ATM is available in the front entrance.

Not like having a hot bowl of French onion soup on a freezing cold day. Chicken quesadillas are…read morevery cheesy if you like cheese.

See all

Red Rooster Drive-In

3.3(291 reviews)

3.0 mi

Izzy was the nicest women ever. adorable little mini…read moregolf place. highly recommended

The food was delicious and service was amazing. The atmosphere was family friendly and we had such…read morea good time!

Dining Room

Chili con carne

See all

Entrance

The Eveready Diner

3.0(466 reviews)

1.9 mi

My Boyfriend and I went here for brunch and had a lovely time. The food was really good, and the…read moreservice and atmosphere were very nice. Great desert selection (even though we were too full to get any, they definitely looked very yummy.) And I had an amazing waffle. My Boyfriend also really enjoyed his eggs and toast.

Business travel and one thing I love about NY is the diner. Express lunch was just the ticket…read more Definitely a good stop to get home cooked food served pleasantly at a reasonable price.

Fries

See all

Mac & Cheese

Kelly's Corner

3.4(130 reviews)

3.2 mi

Do you know when you're dying for that hamburger I haven't had a long time so it was very…read moredisappointing to come here. Ask for medium rare and get well. Done dried out burger. Service was great woman was pleasant, enjoyable, constantly coming around asking if need anything but we were so hungry. We didn't want to return the burgers. We just ate them very disappointed. We should've returned them as if they make new ones medium likely asked

Food quality / price (value) rating 9. The atmosphere is roadhouse tavern. I had a Grilled…read moreBuffalo Chicken Wrap with a side Caesar salad. It was excellent. The wrap had a generous amount of grilled chicken and the salad was a decent size. The wife had a Tuna Melt with Waffle Fries, which included four good sized pieces of tuna on toast, and a generous serving of some very good waffle fries. They have eight draught beers to choose from. We sat at their 9 seat bar where our personable and attentive bartender Gina took very good care of us. The menu is pretty typical for this type of place. The men's room was a little rough and in need of a remodeling, but it was clean enough. They have several tv's in the bar, and typically have sports playing.

See all

Applebee's Grill + Bar

2.4(89 reviews)

2.0 mi

I have been to this apple bees a few times and is usually pretty good but this time was absolutely…read moreawful The service was soo terrible it's difficult to explain the waitress was very rude and when I spoke to the manager he insulted me multiple times.I was actually afraid to get food because I feel like they would of spit in it. Very rarely I will leave a bad review but wow was the service terrible by the manager specifically I forgot to get his name but I was there around 8pm on 6/10/2026 whoever the manager was should definitely be looked into by corporate

We went to Applebee's around 9:30 pm mainly for the meltdown cake, which we love. The staff at the…read morefront were friendly, and service was okay, though our waiter forgot a straw for the kid's drink. My soup had something in it I couldn't chew, and while they gave a small discount, I never got an explanation. One of the steaks was overcooked and very dry, though the rest of my family's meals were fine. The dessert was excellent as always, but overall the food quality was disappointing. The place is clean and nice 。

See all

Frank's Pizzeria

4.4(66 reviews)

3.9 mi

Stopped by on our way up to New England from Virginia. We always love trying new places when we…read moretravel and the pizza was perfect. Greasy and floppy in the best way.

Iconic local pizza place with onsite owner that really cares…read more Get a slice & a coke. Then some ice-cream for dessert. You'll feel like a kid again.

Vodka grandma and a regular slice

See all

Too well done - didn't ask for this but ate it

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Dan S.

11 years ago

Overall, great place to eat. I ordered the Cheeseburger Deluxe meal and couldn't have been more pleased with it. A burger, with more than generous amount of french fries and a 12 oz. can of soda, couldn't ask for more than that. And only for around 7$? That's unheard of these days. Delivery was extremely quick, and the delivery man was extremely polite. Excellent food, and excellent service, definitely deserving of five stars. read more

Michelle M.

10 years ago

Great food and reasonable prices. Best pizza ever. We had the chicken parm. Loaded with chicken, excellent sauce, and perfect crust. The calamari was hot, crisp and tasty. Thinking of getting take out from there tonight. read more

Joshua P.

8 years ago

Favorite pizza place they are always very kind to me and provide the best service ever I find myself ordering every night and the taste is always the best read more

Ada P.

8 years ago

Great neighborhood pizza. Nice seating with a view of Brewster's historic Main Street.

Jankell G.

9 years ago

This is the best pizza i have ever probably had. Its amazing the pricing is great!

Pizza Place & Trattoria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pizza Place & Trattoria also viewed

Sinapis Pizzeria

3.8

(49 reviews)

I really like this place plenty of room plenty of booths wide open a lot of choices for drinks…read more They have like three refrigerators maybe four well Doors but there's a lot. The pizza is really good too. I had the chicken masala. Oh my God I loved it.

I grew up in ther Metro NYC area and have been eating pizza for over 6 decades…read more I've been to pizzerias all over Westchester NY, Bergen NJ and Fairfield CT Counties. Same goes for The Bronx and Manhattan. I've consumed pizza in Italy, UK and, Japan. Hands down my favorite is Sinapis. The crust is perfect. I usually have to ask for my pizza to have the crust crispy but I don't have to ask here. Love their toppings too. Last slice I had was eggplant and tomato with basil. It was excellent! Even though I am a fan of Kinchley's Taverns pies in Mahwah, I think Sanapi's is even better.

Pizza & Pasta 22

4.5

(32 reviews)

Don't judge a book by its cover !…read more Unassuming fast food type building with 4.5 star food inside. Friendly service, large menu, huge selection of beverages. We shared an eggplant parm hero ( called a wedge here) and a slice of spinach and artichoke pizza. This is as close as it gets to gourmet in a roadside restaurant. Right near last exit of NY 22 before you get to 684. Great dinner spot en route to NYC from Berkshires.

Ick. I'm sorry but we spent a fortune here last week on take out and it was a disaster on all…read morelevels. It was suppose to be a fun girls night and we all opted for pizzas, appetizers, bread knots, ect. 1. The wait was extended about 30 minutes longer than predicted. But that's ok, things happen and if they are making sure we get fresh good, hot foods...we will wait. But they weren't! 2. The order was wrong. We got over charged and wrong food was delivered or made. Both were not in our favor in the slightest. There was no sense in ruining more of our evening by sending the kid back with the messed items so, he got a big tip and we sent him in his way. 3. This one is major and the reason we won't eat there again...all 3 pizza were raw dough, soggy crust that was undercooked and a pale whiteish tan color on the crust. It was flavorless, badly made, just ugly. That's petty sounding but pizza generally looks delicious but this looked like it had been dropped. Not to mention all 3 boxes were stacked on each other in the delivery drivers car and the stream of pizzas softened the cardboard boxes so they collapsed in on each other. How this kid couldn't see or resolve the issue before he brought us squished pizzas is beyond me. 4. But the taste, right? That's what makes or breaks a place. Broken, it's just broken. The dough, which is specifically the pizza and the garlic knots, was not even good enough to be used in the marinara sauce. The pizzas were doughy, gooey, flavorless, unsalted, not yeasty, no chew to the dough and it was not a good vessel to carry toppings. The cheeses were greasy, rubbery and waxy. That fake cheap bulk bought cheese that only the cheapest places buy...the cheap restaurants really seem to like buying a using cheap cheeses that the customers don't enjoy and that make any effort to prepare good food automatically hit below the mark consistently. It isn't that difficult to make fresh mozzarella cheese to use on your dishes. It's lazy. How lazy is it to be a real Italian pizza joint and everything tastes bland and like the place is doomed. The cook would seem soulless and depressed by what he or she is putting out for public consumption. So they got a ton of money for a bunch of garbage that was delivered in squashed boxes and we were overcharged for food we ended by throwing away. Everyone tried everything and no one enjoyed any of it. I don't recommend wasting money here unless you looking for expensive badly made garbage. We are all getting squeezed to death financially but I refuse to support a local small business that doesn't care about it customers anymore.

La Strada Pizza and Pasta

3.7

(48 reviews)

Ohhh. I love my La Strada!! We moved so we don't get to eat their food much anymore but their…read morepizzas, wedges, chicken strips, chicken cutlets, Marsala and franchise sauces are chefs kiss yummy. They deliver, the staff is wonderful and family oriented. Always friendly. And once you're a regular....this is your go-to take out. I miss having their food more often and the community friendly atmosphere they provide their customers. 5 stars all the way, everyday.

What a gem to find off Rt 84. We were on our way home from our daughter's graduation from…read moreQuinnipiac and we still had almost 2 hours to get home. We did a search for food near us on the highway and this restaurant popped up with only 5 miles to go. So glad we stopped. We ordered wraps to go. The gentleman behind the counter was so friendly to talk to while we waited for the food to go. We were also pleasantly surprised to find delicious fries tucked in with the wraps. We really didn't look to see if they came with anything. I also last minute asked for 2 more sandwiches that looked so good in the case so I didn't have to cook dinner when we got home. Looking forward to eating those later. I'm sure they will be just as delicious as the wraps we ate.

Sal's Pizza

3.5

(72 reviews)

So, this place isn't much to look at, but a friend recommended it to me. Walking in reminded me of…read morea bare bones pizza joint from the early 90's before they all added a fine dining room. Loved it. The staff was super friendly! I ordered a slice of chicken parm and grabbed a Pure Leaf. Slice was out quick, nice and hot. The slice was DELICIOUS! Couldn't have asked for any better. It was LOADED with chicken. Plenty of condiments for the tables as well (garlic, red pepper, etc...). I will certainly be back to try some other menu items. If you're in Carmel give it a go - you'll be happy you did.

First came in two girls behind the counter, so you get served twice as fast. So I had the grandma…read moreSicilian and it tasted exactly like Sal's mamaneck and I asked them and they said no they're not affiliated because it's light and airy and sales in my neck is famous and I think this place should be famous now. My wife had the chicken myself oh my God that sauce on that pizza don't change it. It is rich with taste. On the counter, they had two plastic containers. One said vote for your tree fake or real. I voted for real. How about you guys? Go ahead your vote.

Gaetano Pizza

3.8

(86 reviews)

I love that they have so many different soups there's at least five different ones that pepperoni…read morepinwheel awesome so those are the two things I had today. You order your food they bring it right over to you at the table and then pay later.

I finally tried this place after venturing into their shopping center numerous times…read more The staff are friendly and attentive. We were greeted and helped immediately. They have a nice variety of pizzas on display but I was in the mood for old faithful cheese. GF snagged a slice of their salad pizza. We took everything to go and ate it at home after a few min in our oven. My slice was one of the thinest crusts I've ever seen. It was barely a crust. If you told me it didn't have a crust I would believe you. It was incredible. The sauce was tasty and the cheese ratio was on point. My slice was DELICIOUS. GF stole my word, delicious, when referring to her slice. "Perfect crust" she adds. I might have to wander in again in the future.

Tony’s Pizza

3.0

(6 reviews)

Broadway slice is bomb. I'd call it a grandma slice. Sauce on top. Love that. Also tried the…read morechicken Florentine slice. Thumbs up. Flavor is right. Dough is right. Bunch of pies on the counter. Cool spot in Brewster. Great vibes. Get a slice!!! yeeeeee

Awesome NY-style pizza! Perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and dough -- reheats very well. Chicken…read moreparm hero was great too. Super clean place with easy parking. This is our new favorite spot--can't wait to try more!

Spasi's Pizza And Pasta

4.5

(26 reviews)

Just the best! Daisy and Reggie are like family. The food is made with love. The portions are huge…read moreand everything is made fresh! BYOB is a plus and the cannolis and pizza are delicious. Try some fresh hot bread with olive oil too! It feels like being at grandma's house on a Sunday.

Personally I think Spasis has the best pizza in Danbury. Growing up in Danbury my family always…read morewent to Balmforth Ave. pizza. They had excellent pizza and Spasis tastes just like it. The Pepper and Onion is outstanding. I recently ordered a mushroom for my MIL and she said how fresh the mushrooms were. They use great ingredients. The peppers are the marinated type that don't repeat on you. Just a great pizza and Resturant run by a lovely family. We had a great waitress who was pleasant and very accommodating last Friday evening. Tim one of the pizza makers always does a fantastic job. You're missing out if you haven't tried Spasis!

d'Berto Pizzeria

3.8

(30 reviews)

Best pizza in the area! The crust is always soft, and the pizza isn't overly oily or greasy. We…read morelove both their regular pizza and white pizza. Their Gorgonzola salad is also one of my favorites--they're always very generous with the Gorgonzola, which I love. We usually order delivery, and it's always fast with friendly service. Definitely our go-to for pizza!

Excellent food! A pleasure always to pick up food. Service is exceptional as well. Thank YOU.read more

Putnam Lake Pizza

4.7

(15 reviews)

I have been coming here for the past 8 years and the pizza is always on point. The owners are…read moreabsolutely great and they always make sure I have what I need :). This warm and comfy pizzeria is my go to spot whenever I am around.

BEST PIZZA IN PUTNAM COUNTY!! If you haven't been here yet you don't know what you are missing!…read moreOwners are amazing and hard working, Regina is always so sweet. The food is ALWAYS amazing, but the pizza is seriously hands down the best we've ever had anywhere!

Carmel's Brick Oven Pizza and Cafe

3.7

(46 reviews)