Don't judge a book by its cover ! Unassuming fast food type building with 4.5 star food inside. Friendly service, large menu, huge selection of beverages. We shared an eggplant parm hero ( called a wedge here) and a slice of spinach and artichoke pizza. This is as close as it gets to gourmet in a roadside restaurant. Right near last exit of NY 22 before you get to 684. Great dinner spot en route to NYC from Berkshires. read more

Pizza & Pasta 22 - Logo - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

Ick. I'm sorry but we spent a fortune here last week on take out and it was a disaster on all levels. It was suppose to be a fun girls night and we all opted for pizzas, appetizers, bread knots, ect. 1. The wait was extended about 30 minutes longer than predicted. But that's ok, things happen and if they are making sure we get fresh good, hot foods...we will wait. But they weren't! 2. The order was wrong. We got over charged and wrong food was delivered or made. Both were not in our favor in the slightest. There was no sense in ruining more of our evening by sending the kid back with the messed items so, he got a big tip and we sent him in his way. 3. This one is major and the reason we won't eat there again...all 3 pizza were raw dough, soggy crust that was undercooked and a pale whiteish tan color on the crust. It was flavorless, badly made, just ugly. That's petty sounding but pizza generally looks delicious but this looked like it had been dropped. Not to mention all 3 boxes were stacked on each other in the delivery drivers car and the stream of pizzas softened the cardboard boxes so they collapsed in on each other. How this kid couldn't see or resolve the issue before he brought us squished pizzas is beyond me. 4. But the taste, right? That's what makes or breaks a place. Broken, it's just broken. The dough, which is specifically the pizza and the garlic knots, was not even good enough to be used in the marinara sauce. The pizzas were doughy, gooey, flavorless, unsalted, not yeasty, no chew to the dough and it was not a good vessel to carry toppings. The cheeses were greasy, rubbery and waxy. That fake cheap bulk bought cheese that only the cheapest places buy...the cheap restaurants really seem to like buying a using cheap cheeses that the customers don't enjoy and that make any effort to prepare good food automatically hit below the mark consistently. It isn't that difficult to make fresh mozzarella cheese to use on your dishes. It's lazy. How lazy is it to be a real Italian pizza joint and everything tastes bland and like the place is doomed. The cook would seem soulless and depressed by what he or she is putting out for public consumption. So they got a ton of money for a bunch of garbage that was delivered in squashed boxes and we were overcharged for food we ended by throwing away. Everyone tried everything and no one enjoyed any of it. I don't recommend wasting money here unless you looking for expensive badly made garbage. We are all getting squeezed to death financially but I refuse to support a local small business that doesn't care about it customers anymore. read more

Catered my party. Chicken Francese and eggplant parmigiana were absolutely delicious. A cut above!! read more

Really good food and a great group of guys, we worked out a menu for my workplace, fantastic! It's simple, do yourself a favor, just order some food or stop in and see why it's not your average pizzeria, ciao. read more

The chicken scarp and Philly cheese steak slices are so good!! Owner is real nice too.

Came to eat a late lunch after apple picking and my family and I absolutely love Pizza and Pasta 22 !! The owner is so nice and the service was great ! The food portions are generous and made with love ! We got the chicken marsala with spaghetti, chicken marsala slice, pepperoni slice, chicken and bacon Russian slice and a white slice. The pizza was not soggy the crust was good ! And my daughter said the cheese tasted awesome ! Everything was so tasty ! We are definitely coming back ! read more

See all

We made a special trip across the Connecticut/New York line to is if I could find pizza I remembered from my childhood. Connecticut has been sorely lacking lately. The crust had the perfect fold &the pizza was delicious!!! I'm thinking I have a new place to visit when I want to take a drive. Connecticut what happened Also the Pasta e Fagioli was perfecto, the best I've had! I want the recipe!! Thank you, it was worth the trip read more

Pizza & Pasta 22 - In my opinion this is the beginning of a perfect fold - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

This was the best slice I've ever had. Tons of fresh toppings, yet a firm crisp crust that held everything perfectly and didn't drip grease everywhere. I wish they were near my house. read more

Very nice and clean place. People there super friendly and helpful. Food quality was 4.9/5 as well.... Pretty good. This was a quick stopover on our road trip but definitely worth the stop. read more

Really good pizza!! Don't hesitate to order from here. Just ordered the regular pie. Nothing fancy. But when I picked it up I saw lots of specialty slices that looked good! read more

I wanted to wait until I eat here three or four times before writing a review. The pizza is good and the service is great. I will definitely be back more than three or four times. read more

Very good neighborhood pizzeria. Fast delivery. They listen to your requests. If you're close by, drop in.

Delicious food and very generous portions. Everyone is welcoming and friendly. We've become regulars!

Excellent pizza!! So many slices to choose from. Will definitely come back. Close to the hockey rink and a great place to stop after a game!

Our first time ordering from here... ordered two large pizzas, Chicken Marsala, Eggplant Rollatini, roasted veggies, garlic knots.... It was all very good! The Pizzas had a nice thin crispy crust, and plenty of topping. Nice tasting sauce - not too sweet nor sour. The chicken Marsala was excellent, with a generous portion of chicken breast, and plenty of mushrooms in the sauce. The Eggplant Rollatini was nice, ut more heavy on the cheese than the eggplant... would have liked to taste more eggplant, but still enjoyable . The roasted veggies were a nice side to balance all the bread and cheese. The main courses provided pasta with sauce as our chosen side.. it was good. Order was ready when predicted, and I was greeted with friendly smile and owner who wanted to know his customers. All in all, our family of 6 gave it great reviews. Definitely recommend! read more

Family owned and run, it's one of the better pizzas around. Great service and quality ingredients. Really impressive work for only being open a little while now. Worth checking out! Will definitely return myself. read more

My new favorite place !! We have ordered from here several times and never disappoints, from their plain pizza to their artichoke pizza !!! Amazing !! My new favorite is the eggplant . Trust me you will not be disappointed. read more

Ordered off of Slice last night- we had garlic knots, calamari, chicken francese, and some pizzas. The food was very tasty. The calamari was crispy which was a huge deal since it's not often we find good calamari locally. You get a lot for what you pay for and it's not some tiny little rubber pieces! I feel things needed a bit more salt, but that's fixable. I can't negatively review their francese because I see this elsewhere too, but when you ordered pasta with francese, it's typically meant to go UNDER the chicken in the same sauce, not with red sauce on the side. But next time I order I'll call and see if they'll do this. Everything else was very good. They're still brand new, and busy as ever, so kinks are bound to happen. We definitely will order from them again. I know they'll go far! Great job! read more

Pizza & Pasta 22 - Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Excellent! I was visiting from out-of-town and had a hackering for a couple slices of real New York pizza. They had at least a dozen different pies to choose from; it was a hard decision but went with pepperoni/meatball/sausage and Margherita style and I wasn't disappointed. The staff was great, too! read more

Food is ok, prices are high for what they serve. We have order take out a few times from there now hoping the food will not be premade. Last time we order a large pie cheese went from $19 to over $25 after all the charges . read more

Fantastic NY pizza! Pizza was perfectly baked and flavors burst in our mouths. Loved the crust and the sauce. We had a large cheese, a large sausage & onions and large eggplant & garlic. The pizza was only outdone by the excellent service and friendly staff. I don't think we are the only ones that like this place, as it was a pretty good crowd there when we arrived to pick up our pizza. Enjoy! read more

I tried this fairly new pizza place for the first time today. I ordered a large cheese pizza to go. I placed the order in advance and it was ready for the time I requested. The service was friendly and the pizza was tasty. I plan to return to this place in the future and look forward to exploring more of their offerings. read more

The food is absolutely amazing here! The bread that they give you is even better lol everything is very fresh and beautiful presentation even for delivery. The portions are very large. Chicken francese was delish and chicken scarp had some great kick to it! Highly recommend!!! read more

Never have I spent close to a hundred dollars on a dinner where you are so interested of trying a new place because you never know of how great things can be and try their food but was so horrible! The pizza pie was so dry and so hard, the calamari was too crispy, couldn't even taste the seameat lol and the penne ala vodka was not cooked correctly with stinky of too much Parmesan! read more

Had dinner food 2xs in last month. Good experience. Friendly people, good food, nice portions. Reheated well and tasty. Will add P&P 22 to our take out rotation GLopez read more

Their pizza is delicious!!!!! We ordered the cheese pizza, Buffalo chicken pizza, and the beet salad. My whole family was happy!

My first time trying this place and my last. Ordered two wedges. The eggplant was fine. The meatball parmigiana was absolutely disgusting. The meatballs were flavorless. No seasoning in them at all. They also fell apart and were like mush. It was inedible. A total turnoff and waste of money. Never going back. read more

Our family has only recently gotten around to trying Pizza & Pasta 22 and I only wish we had gotten to it earlier. We have been hearing good things around town and I can now say that we agree as well, they are very good. We have now ordered from them several times and each time they have not disappointed. Their pizza is very, very good and they have many varieties to choose from. Their penne ala vodka is outstanding, everyone loved it. The chicken cutlets are done to perfection. They are one of our favorite places to get chicken cutlets now as they are nice and thin and not too thick. Their customer service is wonderful which is not always the case these days. They are very friendly and accommodating. The young man behind the register is very helpful and appreciative of your business which is nice. Lastly, they offered us some kind of special bread they make and it is out of this world. We will definitely be coming back for more of that! read more

Very good pizza - a lot of flavor throughout. The crust is not tough and chewy like many other places . Really nice owner and staff as well. Couldn't stop eating it. Highly recommend read more

I must say when I first saw that another pizza place was coming to Brewster I shook my head thinking " dont we have more than enough already " . Now that I have tried rt 22 pizza I am truly thrilled they are here. What fantastic food they are making. Salads, pizza, calzones are all a slice above the rest. What a great addition to Brewster !! Going to pick up another order right now, cant wait for dinner !!! read more