Convenient location in the downtown Norcross area, with ample Street parking and very walker…read morefriendly. The location is on a corner of a beautiful brick building. It's the glass front showcases, unique decor, highlighting comics, and extremely colorful. Across from the entrance is outdoor seating to allow for enjoyment of fresh air and people watching. The interior has a full bar to the right, the colorful seating viewed from the exterior to the left and a full dining area towards the back. There were also arcade light games in the area to the left. Options included, ordering to go at the bar, dining at the bar or the other seating areas throughout. Food selection was vast, with Savage specials, as well as build your own options. I ordered a medium pizza with sun-dried tomatoes, garlic, and selected the traditional tomato sauce. The build your own options allowed for a variety of sauces and toppings. Once I received my estimated time for preparation, we were able to walk through the neighborhood to view area stores and more dining. Once we returned to retrieve the order, I was able to view and was very pleased at the size and proportions of toppings. The taste was equally pleasing. There were different specials, offered on various days for future reference. Will plan to visit again.

Pizza was decent. Great location and decorations, feels like a cool pizza spot. Service was…read moreterrible, even for a small pizza joint. Went in for a quick bite, ended up there for like 2.5 hours bc our table was barely attended. Waters weren't even filled once. Lady that took our orders didn't write any down, then one someone asked for a straw she blamed them for forgetting the orders. She repeated them back and got mine wrong. Didn't say anything because she was walking away as she repeated them and we'd already waited for forever to have our orders taken. The story goes on, but case in point don't come if you've got plans or want attentive service.

Always super flavorful, delicious pizza! Hits the spot every time! Service is quick and friendly…read moreand the owner is very passionate about what he does. Great local place to support! One of our favorite pizza places to visit just about every month!

TLDR: 3.5/5, the Sicilian nona pie was pretty good, meat lovers was not much better than dominos…read more Plenty of meat on the meat lovers but it was very salty and I couldn't really taste the crust or sauce. Meanwhile the Nona pie was better, relatively fluffy in the middle with a nice crust on the bottom. Could taste the sauce more and the bread itself was more flavorful too. Unfortunately it left me wanting more in the amount of sauce and basil. Not bad for a local spot, very friendly service

The service here is what really sets them apart. I placed a pickup order, and the woman on the…read morephone was incredibly sweet. She gave me a pro-tip for the Dagwood Deluxe that I ordered: ask for it "crispy." With all those fresh veggie toppings, the extra time in the oven keeps the crust perfectly firm rather than soggy. The interior is a bit on the smaller side but has a great, low-key pub pizza vibe that feels authentic. Most importantly, the pizza was delicious and hit the spot. Pro-Tip: Definitely listen to the staff suggestions--they know their oven best!

When I went in to pick up an order, I noticed the manager behind the pick up counter stirring a…read morewhite liquid on the floor. I called back to let them know that I found this to be unsanitary and the manager caught an attitude and got defensive and said he was making something for his personal consumption. I told him that the optics of what he was doing was bad, but he continued to make excuses. The public has no idea who would be consuming the mystery liquid, and regardless of the excuses the manager had to make, no one wants to eat at establishment where they see the food being cooked on the floor next to somebody's open toes. I will no longer be eating here after the customer service I received, and the unsanitary practices. I'm considering sending this to the health department. I'm only giving them two stars because I know if I gave them one star they would try to get this removed.

The pizza is top notch and the people there are super friendly. They go above and beyond with the…read morefood and service.

This review is solely on takeout, and I wasn't the one who picked it up, so I have no feedback on…read morethe physical location. But their pizza is good af. From what I heard, the original owner was from Buffalo, NY and this pizza tastes like it! We got cheese, pepperoni, onions, and hot peppers, as well as a half pie of veggie. Quality ingredients. Bomb ass crust. Just GOOD all the way around. This house full of Buffalonians devoured everything from this Atlanta pizzeria in 20 minutes. No crumbs left. Who would have thought - because I normally don't mess with southern pizza. They never get it right, except for Galla's!

I came here with my 8 year old son. Unlike me he had never been here before. I expected great pizza…read moreand was excited for him to try it. After having just a piece of crust from my margarita he was blown away. His slice of pepperoni was the best pizza he ever had. Those were his exact words. I'm happy to say goodbye to the big chain pizzas and welcome Fire and Stone into my home as a monthly dinner place. The service was great too! Friendly staff and very considerate. I loved that I could see the pizza dough being made from the table.

I did pickup through their site. I got a pepperoni and mushroom with extra cheese. The pizza has…read morepotential but something about their sauce and mushrooms gives off an intense garlic flavor which overpowers the flavors. It's almost off-puttingputting and just not as enjoyable. When I went to pick this up, the location had their Togo team standing outside in 95° heat. You could tell these girls were exhausted. This seems like a borderline OCHA violation. Please find a way to handle this better for your staff.

The food is good! The beef patties are yummy! Will now be on the list for got to go there when in…read morethis area. The did not disappoint!!!

This pizza should not be this thin or this crispy. It's nothing like the picture before. They just…read moredon't care!

It's the only place I have found locally that stays true to NY style pizza. And the people are…read moresuper friendly.

Izzy's NY Pizza offers enough deals and "by the slice" options. We got a large because you get more…read morepizza per square inch. It's just math. I also like pizza. The crust is thin and crispy--well, until the "NY Supreme" toppings made the middle a little soggy. I don't didn't mind and it seemed to bother the wife more than me. While the sausage, peppers, and mushrooms were fresh, I was hoping the menu had something more unique about it besides your obvious options. The crust was good too. Pizza by Yandy's is delicious but their crust was almost inedible. The chef is a multitasking machine, juggling a mountain of orders. Judging by the Sunday night crowds, it's a local favorite. I understand. Would I come here again? Maybe. I was just somehow in this area but I might prefer Italian pizza more than NY style. It's a good pizza but I'm also venturing into making it at home. It's kind of a fun process and it costs like $3.

Try the Buffalo pizza or the wings. The food is good and the atmosphere is nice with the family.read more

From the owner: Our "Burger Architects" are passionate about providing a…read morechef-driven dining experience with imaginative, great-tasting gourmet burgers alongside our fries and pizza with only the freshest all-natural ingredients including 100% grass fed beef. Relax, Refuel, & Resume. We are located inside Nitro Zone!!

Excellent pizza. Disappointing salad…read more We're Sunday night pizza-and-salad people and usually rotate between Mellow Mushroom and Vero, so we were excited to finally give Vintage a try. We ordered takeout from their cute little brick building in Chamblee. We got a medium pizza, half veggie and half cheese, and requested no olives on the veggie side - which unfortunately got ignored. Aside from that, the pizza was really good! The crust was the perfect thickness: thin, but not too thin. The dough tasted fresh and clean, and the sauce-to-cheese ratio was spot on. The Greek salad, though, was a major letdown. We ordered a large with grilled chicken and feta on the side. The lettuce was the cheap iceberg blend you'd expect from a budget pizza buffet. It could have been a completely different experience with romaine or another sturdier green. The toppings were sparse: three cucumber slices, a couple pieces of red onion and green bell pepper, and three whole cherry tomatoes (which really should've been sliced). Meanwhile, they must've accidentally dumped Kalamata olives into the salad bc there were enough to feed a small village. The grilled chicken had good flavor but tasted like it had been cooked a day or two earlier. On the bright side, both the red wine vinaigrette and house dressing were delicious! Service was incredibly kind when I picked up the order. They honored the $5 first-time customer discount even though the website wasn't working and didn't charge for extra dressings, which was a really nice touch. We'll absolutely be back for the pizza. I'm just genuinely bummed the salad didn't live up to it, because we love having both as part of our Sunday routine.

I will 100% be back to Vintage Pizzeria! First of all, my strawberry margarita was SOOOO good. We…read morealso ordered wings and cheese sticks, and the entire table loved them. The kids enjoyed their cheese pizza, and I devoured the Meat Lovers pizza. Everything was delicious!

First time trying Indian pizza and it's quite yummy! There's a very generous amount of toppings and…read morecheese for a good price ($14 for the small, which has 6 slices). You also get 3 free toppings! Jalapeños with the butter chicken was a good recommendation. The chicken 65 pizza has a nice subtle kick to it. The only thing for me is that the pizza wasn't as flavorful as I had expected and the garlic paneer didn't have noticeable garlic flavoring. Plenty of parking in the front and a very chill, grab-your-own stuff kind of restaurant. The owner is very kind and helpful with helping us order the pizzas and recommending toppings and portions. Overall, I recommend checking out this local restaurant if you've never tried Indian pizza!

I order here all the time and you used to be able to get 3 toppings. Now you only get 1 free and…read morehave to pay for the rest. Consistency is key especially when everywhere raises prices for no reason. Stay unique. SMH.