TLDR: 3.5/5, the Sicilian nona pie was pretty good, meat lovers was not much better than dominos. Plenty of meat on the meat lovers but it was very salty and I couldn't really taste the crust or sauce. Meanwhile the Nona pie was better, relatively fluffy in the middle with a nice crust on the bottom. Could taste the sauce more and the bread itself was more flavorful too. Unfortunately it left me wanting more in the amount of sauce and basil. Not bad for a local spot, very friendly service read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Meat lovers Pizza (Large 16") - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This place is always such a treat! Damn good pizza & energy! The owner is so freaking sweet & has a delicious menu! There aren't any seats to eat inside to be sure to get it to go! The flavor is magnificent! Our go to is the eggplant pizza and add broccoli. The prices can most certainly add up but it's very fulfilling! read more

See all

Im so shocked this hidden gem is so close to me. As a born and raised NYer this pizza place is giving back home vibes! Me and my husband has gone multiple times and we can't get enough. I miss getting big individual slices and this place is legit. The cashiers are friendly and provide great customer service. read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Two pepperoni pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

We had the Sicilian Nona Pizza and spaghetti/meatballs for a delivery order. I wasn't expecting much of the pizza and sadly it was a little cold/soggy upon arrival (especially because it was raining and the box got wet en route). The fact that it was still good tells me that it would have been even better if we had it fresh in person. We got a free order of garlic knots with it. I would eat here again but probably not order for delivery. read more

Loved the way my slice came out! It was hot and crispy with a generous amount of pepperoni. I wish the crust itself had a bit more flavor, but otherwise I was perfectly happy with my big, hot slice. The customer service was friendly, and I observed many repeat customers coming in and saying hi to the staff. I noticed a public sign that says that after a certain amount of time, remaining pizza slices must be thrown out. Not that I am a fan of food waste, but it gives me reassurance that my slice for dinner has not been sitting around since opening. There's really not much space to eat here. There's some counter seats, but I have a feeling that it's more for waiting customers since they don't have trash cans around or napkins on the table. There's one picnic table outside but that's about it. If you order from here, plan on taking out. read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Guys from the right place, but the cost per topping is a bit high. No seating, so it's all Togo. The service was good as can be.

SOLID NY STYLE PIZZA IN DUNWOODY | i believe i have yet to experience a bad slice from Piccola. As a sucker for a thin NY slice, Piccola fits the bill, especially with the cheese pizza lunch special (which you can also upgrade with extra toppings) that comes with 2 HUGE cheese pizza slices and a canned soda for $7.50 (it was $6.50 back in 2022 but that's inflation for ya). They also have other pre-made slices like the meat lovers, supreme, etc that you can purchase by the slice. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a quick and cheap lunch or craving a NY slice in the Dunwoody area! read more

See all

wow this pizza was so good! look at my friend juju with his slice! mm mm mmmm looks so yummy! read more

Piccola New York Pizza - amazeballs - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I am so happy that my wife discovered this gem. What an amazing place with delicious pizza and friendly staff. Here is the summary of my experience here; 1) Ambiance 3/5: Well this is not a fine dining restaurant. This is mostly a takeaway place but they still have some seats for people to eat and wait while they cook it fresh. Even then, I love their transparent setting where you can see your pizza being made, cooked, and packed. There is some parking in front but you might have to search for some space during rush hours 2) Service 5/5: The people here are friendly, helpful, cheerful,l and a delight to talk to. They make sure your requests are taken care of. 3) Food 6/5: We ordered a half-and-half cheese and mushroom pizza, and it was absolute heaven. As per my wife, you could close your eyes while eating a slice and feel transported to a New York pizzeria. 4) Value for Money 5/5: The prices are great and you could have a full meal for under $10. This is true value for money with great taste. If you are a New York-style pizza lover who loves great pizza and great prices in and around this place and has not visited this place yet, you are missing a lot! :) What's Good: 1) Freshly cooked amazing new york style pizza 2) The staff Not so Good: 1) Nothing that I can think of read more

See all

Good generic New York style pizza. You can be in and out very quickly with your order, and the price for 2 large slices is very reasonable. It seems to be a mom and pop small business arrangement, where slices are pre made and heated up in the oven. If I'm in another pinch for another quick meal, I'll come back. read more

The. BEST. NY. Pizza. That I've had in GA. A place where the smell matches the taste! Whether you choose a regular thin crust or a Sicilian pizza, you are in for a real treat. Wilton always takes great care of us! A must try!! read more

The Nona gets better and better every time we order it! This is a great pie - best thick crust in Georgia. read more

See all

I grew up in New York City. Pizza is one of those things that everyone tries to take every possible shortcut to make it look good. At this place, the owner obviously cares about all the little details, the dough tastes delicious and is obviously an actual 1-2 day fermented product. The cheese and sauce is just perfect and their basic New York pie is probably the absolute best New York style pizza you'll find anywhere in the Atlanta area. This place is truly a hidden gem and owned by a real NYC, old world, Italian dude. read more

This is a small place with a couple of bar seats which is clearly geared towards takeout. It took a minute for me to be greeted resulting in some good-natured ribbing (I think) between the staff. I'm always skeptical of places that say "New York Style"; of course you'd want to associate yourself with the pinnacle of the cuisine you're doing, but it's often just a cheap marketing trick. My Sicilian pizza, however, was quite impressive. A distinctively textured crust was browned deliciously at the edges while being soft and relatively light inside, making for a satisfying crunch. Mushrooms and peppers were helpful toppings, and while it is a $30 pizza, it is also enormous and will be good for multiple meals. They didn't have much besides bread and cheese, but the picture of a salad they had up kind of made me wish I'd gotten one. Regardless, you'll be hard pressed to find a better pizza of this sort in the region. read more

Piccola New York Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

So this is a very Small shop, only about 4 to 5 seats on the inside and a couple of picnic tables on the inside. No signage but there are small menu's to look at (I tried to take a pic for y'all lol). The service was good. One of the chefs hooked me up with a slice just because. He didn't know me so that was mad cool of him! Fries were pretty good. It was odd because the seasoning on the fries or if there was any legit seasoning it was only on the top, they didn't actually shake the fries in the seasoning so I noticed that. So you would get fries that have something on them and then you get fries that are pretty bare so that was something I noticed. Meat lovers slice was Good. Didn't have as much sauce that I would have liked to have, but it had a lot of meat and it was placed with plenty of flavor. It was kind of like a calzone situation because the bottom and the top of the pizza had crust. I guess they said they were going to do that so they would have to worry about something falling off while you're eating it. We'll just cover it lol. White slice was actually really good. Didn't have meat on it, but it had a very mild but pretty good flavor profile to it. So if you dont eat meat, this may be for you. Lemon pepper wings were Good and flavor but my only grip was the fact that they were very small. Comes with carrots and celery and your choice of ranch and blue cheese dressing. You get about 10 wings, well I did, but again, they weren't the biggest wings. This could be a decent go to pizza spot for me. It didn't miss on flavor. I wish that everyone back there had on gloves, which was my only thing. Is that going to be something that stops me from trying it again, no, but I would have liked to see all employees doing it. read more

See all

Been going here for a few years. Still the best slice in the game for my money. I moved, so I can't go as often as I used to, but when I'm in the area, I go back. Service: friendly, fast, and never gets the order wrong! Pizza usually takes 15-20 minutes if you order for carry out. They also deliver, but I've always just picked up on site. Quality: You can taste the freshness and quality in the sauce, cheese, toppings, and dough. Pizza is never floppy. Dough/crust is crispy and holds up well. Price: I've always gotten pepperoni or pepperoni & basil, so I can't say for sure the pricing on more than 1-2 toppings. They may not charge for basil either. The pizza is always 24 bucks or so if I remember correctly. Well worth it if you like a nice NY style pizza. Location: easy to access off winters chapel in Norcross/Dunwoody area. Plenty of parking. They also make a mean meatball sub. It's more of a carry out spot. There's a small seating setup but it's more of a "sit here while you wait" setup than an actual "sit down and eat here" setup. I think there are some benches outside though. read more

See all

BELIEVE THE HYPE!!!! This place is AMAZING!!! We've been twice and the second time sealed the deal! The service is fast and easy! Call-in, ready in 15-20mins. Boom! It's a real deal pizza shop and the accent of whom I assume maybe the owner is real deal NY style of Italian. There are soda cans for sale that are apart of a deal which is two slices with a soda; take about super nostalgic! First time we ordered a medium white pizza with mushrooms, black olives, and bacon added to half the pizza. The original pizza made was wrong so they made us another right on the spot and sold our pizza by the slice because they sell slices of pizza which is rare but awesome. Long story short, the pizza was piping hot and ABSOLUTELY delicious!!! Oh em gee! We finished it in one night and didn't leave leftovers. Fast forward to the second visit which prompted this review, it was pizza night and we wanted to try this place again since it's not far from us. We ordered the veggie with half having pepperoni. I also ordered A Sicilian Nona slice because I love deep dish pizza and wanted to test it out for next time. When I picked the pizza it was super hot! There was steam coming from the box. The Sicilian slice came in a brown bag with a paper plate and I couldn't wait to eat it so I ate it right on the spot in the parking lot lol! It was soooooo flavorful and cheesy and bigger than I anticipated. Definitely will be ordering a whole pizza next time. I saved the rest for my partner so he can try it. The pizza was everything and we finished it in one swoop! So flavorful, so hot, and nice sized slices. This place is a 10 out of 10. read more

See all

WOAAAHHH THE CALZONE IS HUGE! I got the cheese calzone, garlic knots, and a cannoli the shop it's self is small and intimate I loved it. if I knew the calzone was going to be this huge I would of not gotten the garlic knots but all in all food is good my dad approved and he's picky(he's only ever had pizza h*t and li**le c*asers) thank you for this amazing food read more

Piccola New York Pizza - cheese calzone, garlic knots* and Jumbo Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

This place is another hidden gem in Dunwoody. Their New York style pizza and Sicilian are really good. It's been awhile since I was there but their Sicilian and white slices are my favorite. I just wish they were in the Marietta area. Sorry I don't have a pic. read more

Stopped in for a takeout large pie for lunch. The Good: The pizza was very good. 7.9. Nice and thin and the way I remember from home. They are putting out a nice product. Super nice people too. The Challenges: There were none with my experience except if the pizza stayed in the oven another minute it gets into the 8's. I'll be back. Good pizza in GA. Thank you! read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Cheese pie. Slightly underdone. - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Highly recommend. Best pizza around for sure. I recommend asking them to make it crispy/well done for that good crunch personally cause sometimes it's a little floppy. read more

I can't believe I haven't written about this place yet. This is a pizzeria of any NYC kid's life pre-2000s. The only thing missing are the percolating tank fountains of purple and red drink. This is the kind of pizza I grew up with and thank god it's close to where I live because I get homesick a lot and this helps during those days. We've had almost everything on the menu and besides really good pizza, I love the philly chicken cheesesteak and my wife loves the baked ziti and the regular philly cheesesteak. The cheesesteaks are one of the best that I've had and definitely the best in GA. I also really like the chicken roll, but I do wish it was more like the chicken rolls back in Brooklyn; smaller and no cheesy butter topping. Again, it's a great chicken roll, just sometimes I crave the more simple version of it. This isn't a place where you sit down and eat. It's just a counter and a few stools next to the window bar. There is a table or two outside when the weather is nicer, but ultimately, expect this to be a place where you place and order and pick it up. read more

I have placed to go orders from here twice in the last two weeks and both were very good. First time we ordered a white pizza with pepperoni and a supreme pizza. The garlic knots were amazing. The second time we called and ordered a Sicilian Nona Deep Dish pizza. Highly recommend. Cannot wait to try other offerings. read more

Pizza is pretty good and the meatball sub is ok .. AVOID the house Salad !! Lots of Lettuce nice size , BUT !they used the outside leaves from the head of lettuce ( you know the ones you usually throw out !! ) there browning and yellowing to the lettuce ( that's why you throw it out ) one thin slice of Cucumber , two small slices of Tamato and a couple of little onion slices and a sprinkle of Mozzarella cheese ! Worst $6 I spent !! I also asked for extra dressing and paid for it and sis not get it ! read more

You gotta get your NY Pizza on - wow wow wow! The owner is right outta the Bronx And every thing is made fresh - like right there on the spot! I asked him about his chicken Parmesan and his eggplant Parmesan and he brought out the chicken and basically it was freshly pounded thin. So he also he fried up some samples of the eggplant which was literally out of this world. Being that I grew up in the restaurant business I was able to spot that he was using literally some of the finest ingredients available. Wilton, takes his time and cooks his sauce and prepares everything so fresh. I wish I he had a sitdown restaurant near my house. Naturally, he treats every customer like you are a longtime family member, even though I just walked in the door, and we shared the common background I was instantly made to feel special ! So if you're in the area, you gotta stop by and pick up a pie and some other yumminess! read more

Piccola New York Pizza - The freshest eggplant made by the owner in front of me! - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

If you're from upstate don't come here...... I checked the reviews before I came here that's the reason I came and sorry to say the food wasn't good I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a Philly cheesesteak combo the food had no flavor (seasoning) $24 wasted...... great customer service though read more

I use to live next to this place and NEVER even knew it existed and now that I'm far away, I'm so sad lol. But I decided to go the other day and omg! *I got 2 slices of cheese pizza cause I'm a plain girl and they were so good! One slice was probably the size of my head. I reheated the second one in the air fryer the next day and it was still so good. I definitely will be going back. *I also got my mom some lemon pepper wings and they looked like they were bout to be so good too! I have to try it next time. Covid friendly read more

See all

Only ordered once since it opened but the pizza was good. It's thick slices so be prepared for heavy crust.

Update after 7 months: enjoying even better. 1. Authentic NY pizza made by a former New Yorker. Crust, oil, cheese sauce. Perfect cheese pizza. My Son and his roommates find their pepperoni the best in Atlanta . Lots of pepperoni. 2. Until here we were not fans of white pizza. We have it plain or with artichoke . Sometimes just a few slices, sometimes half pizza with cheese the other half. Very accommodating Oh yeah they always have selection by the slice. 3. Sandwiches great. My favorites are meatball parm and ny cheesesteak. 4. Daughter eats the pizza but prefers their baked ziti. Its good! Comes with garlic twists. 5. Wilton (the owner) is really cool and accommodating. Forgive him for being a Mets fan ( that happens to new yorkers) Located across the street from Walmart on Winters Chapel at peeler . Call ahead, they usually have it ready 15-20 minutes read more

Best NY style pizza in Atlanta! Pizzas by the slice and whole pies. Don't sleep in the white pizza, it's awesome.

Im a NYer and my parents owned a Pizza place in the Hudson Valley- l love this pizza place. The crust is light but holds up the ingredients i usually get 1/2 pepperoni and sausage and 1/2 plain. The sauce is not sweet like other places. I have watched them make my pizza once and it looked like there was lots of care being put into it. It is only Take out- which i love as well. All in all my favorite pizza place near me. read more

I tried the Buffalo chicken pizza. That was super fantastic. I liked it a lot. The margarita pizza wasn't good; I've had way better margarita pizza. read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza- very good! - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

OMG. The food is delicious. I'm originally from New Jersey and it's really difficult to find New York style pizza in Georgia. Piccola's has changed my view. Their food is amazing. Great attitude too. read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Great pizza predominately take out. Staff is friendly and pricing is fair. Garlic knots are a hit Calzones are a must try. Will be back read more

Way over priced for what you get , how see we this the best pizza in Ga, just get the $60.00 for (2) pizzas . I am from NYC and this is is the best. If they can get the order correct, add the cheese they charged me for, I would be a very happy cusotmer. Charging me for it but not adding is is frustrating. Give me what I pay for. I give them 5 starts because of the pizza is so good , so , so good! Reminds me of home read more

See all

Great pizza!!! We always order mushroom pizza slices. It's reasonable and delicious! After Piccola, we stopped ordering chains.

My favorite spot for Buffalo Chicken pizza closed and the pizza place that replaced it, their chicken just doesn't taste good. Piccola's is my new spot for it. Their chicken was nicely seasoned and the sauce was just right - not too much or too little. I finished my slice and thought I should have bought two. Also, their garlic knots weren't the best I've had, but still were good enough that me and my daughter tore them up. It's a pick up and go place. Not for dining there - just in case that's not clear from pictures they have been posted by others. read more

Their pizza reminds me of being back home in NJ and NY. The pizza is the truth -- right amount of sauce, right amount of cheese, very large slices and perfectly baked! read more

A quality pizza place in an unassuming lil plaza. Called on a Saturday evening for pick up and ordered the Sicilian artichoke and chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pricing is decent for the level of quality gone into the pizza. I wish the slices were a bit thicker than they were but they were still yummy. The Sicilian had pesto, peppers, and artichokes. The chicken bacon ranch was pretty straightforward with no tomato sauce. Overall, would come back to try their well priced lunch special! read more

Piccola New York Pizza - Sicilian artichoke pizza Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Stopped here for lunch after a serious craving for buffalo chicken pizza. I saw that the previous reviews were looking pretty good for this spot. I placed my order online and they have some decently priced lunch specials that I will be back for. They sell by the slice and whole pies. I got one buffalo chicken pizza slice and a supreme slice. It took about 10 minutes and my order was piping hot and fresh when I picked it up. The owner is very nice, as everyone has mentioned before. He's very friendly and ensures that your order is correct, hot and fresh! The pizza was delicious! I like my buffalo chicken pizza a little more saucy but all the flavors were there and the supreme was *chef's kiss*! I highly recommend this pizza spot for anyone on that side of town. It will not disappoint. read more