Coterie Pizza (hwy 327, Garrett, Indiana) - for delicious stone fired pizza and relaxed/casual…read moredining We made a return trip to Coterie after a 3 year absence. Coterie is easy to find. Head north on 327...about 15 minutes north of Dupont Road. They are located in a strip mall, just as you get into town, on the west side of the road. There is plenty of easy-access parking. The restaurant is smaller as it holds about 50 people. It can be busy. There are ample tables for 4 people and some for parties of 8-10 people. The menu is fairly small with only 8 specialty pizzas. Only two items on the appetizer menu - the beer cheese is a MUST try. The pizzas seem pretty reasonable priced for a 12 inch stone fired pizza - $13.45. Coterie has self serve beverage service. You can choose from one of five local beers - and pay by the ounce. Or you can fill up your cup at the soda/tea center. The team here is very friendly and helpful. They all work hard to make sure you have a good customer experience - which we did! Plenty of kitchen help to keep the food rolling..especially at peak diner time! Here is a run down on the items we ordered: -Caprese salad: smaller dish for $5.99. All cherry tomatoes and basil were very fresh and cool to taste. The mozzarella cheese and toppings blended well with the olive oil and balsamic vinegar flavors. Easy to share. -Beer Cheese ($6.99): a layer of pizza dough rolled out thin and baked to a slightly chewy texture. The dough has a slight garlicky flavor and cut into nice sized shareable pieces. The beer cheese is smooth, creamy and dreamy! You get hints of beer amongst the mild cheese flavors. The sauce is a bit thin and simply addicting! -Chicken bruschetta pizza: The golden brown crust is a little tough as it is well baked but still chewable. No special flavors are added to the crust. The bottom was soft and white. The chicken bruschetta is not your typical pizza creation. The tomato sauce was rather thin and only added a mild tomato taste zip. The chicken was tender and picked up the flavors that surrounded it nicely. The cherry tomatoes and basil toppings were very fresh and tasty. They blended really well with the olive oil and balsamic vinegar drizzles. The fresh mozzarella cheese was sprinkled in enough to help hold all the toppings in place. If you liked the Coterie Caprese salad...you would really like the chicken bruschetta pizza!

Good ole pizzeria in Garrett…read more.. We've seen a lot of press about CP lately, so the ole ball and chain wanted to give it a Go... Good pizza. It's kind of light, fluffy, and crispy all in one. I really liked their red sauce and they load the pizzas up with toppings. Our bill was $60 for two pies (we brought home one of them because those suckers are yuuuuge), a house salad, and two local crafties... That's a win in today's restaurant price gouging world. The restaurant itself is rather plain looking, but it's clean and the service was good... While I don't think CP is on the same level as Oley's, 800 Degrees, or Three Fires, we'll come back because it's respectable pizza. Dave Portnoy 7.7

First time Customers and I'm writing this as we eat .... we drove fifteen minutes to try this place…read moreand will not be eating pizza from our hometown ever again. My husband had the calzone ham and pineapple and he said it is awesome .... ( I won't try bc pineapple does not belong on pizza ) I ordered the breadsticks which are better then I have ever had and this so amazingly heavenly awesome chicken bacon ranch ( no tomato those also do not belong on ) ........ all I'm saying is we definitely will be back in the future near near future

We love this place! Great pizza, subs of every type, great salads and even some Mexican food. The…read moreservice is outstanding and the place is locally owned which means they really care about the people and the community here. Butler is small but the Pizza Shack THE place to eat!

Great food, great people. The potato pizza is amazing! Salads are always fresh and deliciousread more

We waited at least 10 minutes for someone to even acknowledge our existence, and when they didn't,…read morewe walked out.

Best pizza place in Indiana. Originating in Muncie, Greek's pizza is the king of Ball State. I…read moredon't know why Greeks hasn't caught on all over. This is my favorite pizza on the planet. The sauce rules. The garlic butter (painted on the BEST breadsticks and frequently the crust of the pizza). A large cheese pizza is amazing alone, but I recommend the gourmet house pizza (which comes with feta). Dang it this place rules! Go here as soon and as often as you can because they're an endangered species!

This evening my husband took our daughter and her friend to Pizza Forum for dinner, it was a win…read morebecause we had coupons to use on Pizza & Bread sticks. It was her friends very first visit. Her words were, "wow this is the nicest restaurant I've ever been to." It was our 2nd visit, actually was better than the first visit. We ended up ordering the girls a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza plus an order of bread sticks. The girls ate a couple bread sticks and 4 slices of pizza each. They loved the pizza. The bread sticks were loaded in butter and garlic sauce. My husband and I ordered an XL pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was so delicious. Yes, we have plenty of leftovers for tomorrow's lunch or dinner. Cold pizza is the best ever. The restaurant was nice and clean. Bathrooms were also clean, that's a plus in my book. Nasty bathrooms make for a bad experience. Our server was great, altho it took her a bit to refill my drink, all is good she got to it. Over all we had a pleasant experience this evening. They played Christmas Music in the background. That was nice for the Holiday. Very enjoyable to listen to. We will definitely be back to Pizza Forum.

Ordered carry out tonight. Ordered a Royal Feast pizza with BBQ sauce, Jr. Chef salad with 1000…read moreisland, and an order of cauliflower with Ranch dressing. Total bill $49 and change. Got home and found they gave me Ranch dressing instead of the 1000 Island that I ordered. The pizza was good but not worth what they charged. On the positive side my wife enjoyed her cauliflower and Ranch dressing. They have changed hands a couple of times now. They were my favorite go to place for pizza, but the quality has went downhill and they have priced themselves out of my budget for pizza.

Girl at the front counter was extremely flirty with my husband and it was absolutely disgusting and…read moredisrespectful to do that right in front of me WHILE I was holding his hand. He got refills on his drink and I didn't, I didn't even get acknowledged even when we ordered food. This is absolutely disgusting behavior coming from an employee. I did not feel welcome there and I just got talked about by the girls in the back

By far the best pizza around! Fresh mozzarella and toppings…read morewith a homemade sauce that is really good. I love the deep fried pickles with ranch dressing. I highly recommend the Everything Pizza or the signature Red Angel! We live in Georgia and came across this gem. We loved it so much, we actually ordered some pizzas and had them shipped to us!!

Pizza sauce is very tart like vinegar is added to the sauce. While this is a proprietary recipe,…read moreit's not for my family. Broasted chicken is usually great but the last order tasted reheated. Cole slaw was warm after it was placed in the box with chicken. Pizza crust taste like a hint of chlorine. Probably from water added. Service is great!

We were coming into town and needed to order food to pickup for dinner. We have a grandson who…read morelikes less cheese on his pizza and they were very nice about making the change for us. We also had a custom made pizza. Everything was delicious and we highly recommend them.

I was traveling through the area and looking for a Pizza place for dinner. My first option was…read moreclosed to I decided to take a chance on Rugiono's. First impressions were that this is a Mom and Pop place that I am guessing has been around for quite awhile and known to the locals. There were not many people in the establishment on this Sunday evening. The waitress was friendly and invited us to sit wherever we wanted. Rugiono's appears to need a bit of a face lift. There was a Pepsi fridge in the dining area and it was we could see cheese being stored in there. The decor was dated and there was a pile of boxes that could be seen at the end of the restaurant. We ordered a few personal pizza's, a Grinder (or sub) and some breadsticks to start out meal. I have to admit when the breadsticks came out I was confused. They looked more like pizza triangles with cheese on them. However, when I took a bite, I was pleasantly surprised the cheese was fantastic, and the dough was on point. It made me excited to get my pizza. Once the pizza came, I was very pleased. I did takeoff the jalapeños because it was too spicy for me, but everything else was fantastic on the menu. It says that they make their dough fresh every day and you could really taste that they do. I was not as impressed with the grinder and the potato wedges that came with it tasted like they've been in the freezer too long. I still have to give this place four stars though, because I loved the pizza! I would love to see Rugiono's get a makeover, but for Pizza I would definitely go again if I am in the area.

The first thing you notice when walking in to the restaurant is it's nice and clean. It's on the…read moresmall side but big enough to handle most get togethers. I was met by the owner of the restaurant and he was extremely polite and friendly. I ordered a Hawaii pizza. with bell peppers. The pizza looked delicious and let me tell you it came with a nice amount of cheese. Now this restaurant puts the toppings under the cheese. At first glance I thought where's my toppings, then I could see them in the cheese. I have to say it was a very tasty pizza. Cooked perfectly and it was delicious! I highly recommend this pizza place! Great food clean restaurant and friendly staff. I'm sorry I didn't have any photos as my phone had died at the time.

Had delivered from DoorDash twice. Great both times. Wings also excellent. One of the better pizzas…read moreof the surrounding area.

Small town Pizza place from St. Joe, has found a new home in Butler, and I am one happy guy!…read more Finally another sitdown option is available, and I don't have to order pizza from a gas station! Rumor is there may be a possible beer/wine option in the future! BONUS!! Ordered carryout, but when I walked in to pick it up, I saw lots of seating options. They even put in a small stage? Possible future events are in the works? The menu is full of school/football themed names. Absolutely love it! The staff was very friendly and the service was spot on. Order was ready when I arrived 5-minutes early. I ordered a small The Hot Route; chicken, hot sauce, and banana peppers. Delicious. Wife had their Cavatini. Awesome. Order of bread sticks with cheese was the perfect appetizer. And their beer cheese was absolutely great!! This is their first review and I want to get this new to Butler place started strong! Very happy with everything! I will definitely be back! Just imagine when they have an ice cold beer to offer as well. Great job Cheesy Does It!

Definitely worth trying if you haven't. Sausage roll was better than Oleys and Redwood Inn in Fort…read moreWayne which they say is the best in town.

YUCK, YUCK, YUCK. This is hands down the nastiest pizza I've ever tried. The taste is absolutely…read morehorrible. It's insanely SPICY, has basically NO SAUCE, and is EXTREMELY DRY. I honestly can't believe how bad it is. What a complete waste of money. So gross!!

We were staying with family for Thanksgiving and the night before we ordered pizza. Good crust,…read moreexcellent cheese, amazing sauce.