Coterie Pizza (hwy 327, Garrett, Indiana) - for delicious stone fired pizza and relaxed/casual dining We made a return trip to Coterie after a 3 year absence. Coterie is easy to find. Head north on 327...about 15 minutes north of Dupont Road. They are located in a strip mall, just as you get into town, on the west side of the road. There is plenty of easy-access parking. The restaurant is smaller as it holds about 50 people. It can be busy. There are ample tables for 4 people and some for parties of 8-10 people. The menu is fairly small with only 8 specialty pizzas. Only two items on the appetizer menu - the beer cheese is a MUST try. The pizzas seem pretty reasonable priced for a 12 inch stone fired pizza - $13.45. Coterie has self serve beverage service. You can choose from one of five local beers - and pay by the ounce. Or you can fill up your cup at the soda/tea center. The team here is very friendly and helpful. They all work hard to make sure you have a good customer experience - which we did! Plenty of kitchen help to keep the food rolling..especially at peak diner time! Here is a run down on the items we ordered: -Caprese salad: smaller dish for $5.99. All cherry tomatoes and basil were very fresh and cool to taste. The mozzarella cheese and toppings blended well with the olive oil and balsamic vinegar flavors. Easy to share. -Beer Cheese ($6.99): a layer of pizza dough rolled out thin and baked to a slightly chewy texture. The dough has a slight garlicky flavor and cut into nice sized shareable pieces. The beer cheese is smooth, creamy and dreamy! You get hints of beer amongst the mild cheese flavors. The sauce is a bit thin and simply addicting! -Chicken bruschetta pizza: The golden brown crust is a little tough as it is well baked but still chewable. No special flavors are added to the crust. The bottom was soft and white. The chicken bruschetta is not your typical pizza creation. The tomato sauce was rather thin and only added a mild tomato taste zip. The chicken was tender and picked up the flavors that surrounded it nicely. The cherry tomatoes and basil toppings were very fresh and tasty. They blended really well with the olive oil and balsamic vinegar drizzles. The fresh mozzarella cheese was sprinkled in enough to help hold all the toppings in place. If you liked the Coterie Caprese salad...you would really like the chicken bruschetta pizza! read more

See all

Good ole pizzeria in Garrett... We've seen a lot of press about CP lately, so the ole ball and chain wanted to give it a Go... Good pizza. It's kind of light, fluffy, and crispy all in one. I really liked their red sauce and they load the pizzas up with toppings. Our bill was $60 for two pies (we brought home one of them because those suckers are yuuuuge), a house salad, and two local crafties... That's a win in today's restaurant price gouging world. The restaurant itself is rather plain looking, but it's clean and the service was good... While I don't think CP is on the same level as Oley's, 800 Degrees, or Three Fires, we'll come back because it's respectable pizza. Dave Portnoy 7.7 read more

See all

We got off I-69 in Auburn looking for dinner and were surprised by how many chains were clustered nearby, including McDonald's, Burger King, Wendy's, Taco Bell, KFC, Jimmy John's, Culver's, Texas Roadhouse, Starbucks, and Dutch Bros. With four auto museums in the area, I expected more distinctive local dining options. Someone suggested many visitors drive up from Fort Wayne for the day rather than stay locally, which may explain it. Most nearby restaurants had limited reviews, and while I do not usually choose a restaurant based on photos, the other options did not look especially appealing. Coterie's photos stood out, and that choice paid off. The building is small and looks like a simple metal box from the outside, but the interior is clean and modern. The only open table was dirty, but someone cleaned it within about five seconds of seeing us walk in (they literally ran to the table). We were helped by a young man named Jax who brought us plates, menus, and drink cups. He explained the self-serve beer and fountain drink options, and made sure we understood the menu. Jax was polite, professional, and engaged. The pizza was good and cooked in a stone oven that you can watch from the table. A solid local find when we were looking for something more unique than another chain. Prices were fair, quality was high, and portions were generous. read more

This is some of the best pizza in northeast Indiana. They have a very intriguing menu with some original options and some modern approaches to pizza. The beer cheese appetizer is a must. read more

Great local place with the freshest ingredients. Service is VERY friendly. Atmosphere is modern and cool. Beer Cheese - $6.99 - Very good and very filling. It may cause you to have leftovers of your pizza. 5/5 stars. Chicken Bruschetta Pizza - $13.35 - I thought the balsamic vinegar would be overpowering, but it was not. Good balance and good amount of toppings. 5/5 stars. Mushroom Medley - $13.35 - Love this pizza, but I'm also partial to mushroom pizzas. 5/5 stars. Cheese - $11.25 - This one is just fine. Not a whole lot of cheese pull and it's boring to me, but hey, people seem to like that. 4/5 stars. They get their cheesecakes from Pixie Pies: Neapolitan Cheesecake - $7 - Very good cheesecake. Similar to an In-and-Out Neapolitan milkshake. 5/5 stars. My only complaint about this place is that sometimes the dough has a nice fluffy crust and sometimes it's flat. I do prefer the fluffy crust. Not sure why that consistency is overlooked. Highly recommend this place. read more

See all

This place is amazing! The pizza is definitely one of our favorites in the area! Made a little side trip when coming home from Ft Wayne tonight and it's oh, so worth it! The service is great and the pizza is even better! Get the Mexican Street Corn Pizza while it's available for the next 3 months or so! Go get some! read more

Coterie Pizza - Mexican Street Corn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garrett, Indiana

See all

Walked in with 8 people not realizing they closed in 12 minutes and was greeted with "can we help you?" Yes we came to eat like everyone else in the restaurant and the employee very sarcastically says " at 850, yeah sure let's do it" So we asked if they had any other recommendations and she says "sorry not from here but go ahead and sit down." I let her know she was very rude so we wouldn't be sitting down and went somewhere else that was very eager to take a table of 8 and a 200 dollar check! read more

Super! I read the reviews and had to try it on my way to Ft. Wayne. I ordered the beer cheese appetizer, hot honey, chicken & bacon, Margarita, and brisket pizzas with the idea of tasting and then taking most of it home. The beer cheese is amazing! It also re-heated ok. Favorite was the chicken & bacon with BBQ sauce. I don't usually like pizza without red sauce, but these pizzas were an exception. Ironically, my least favorite was the margarita. They were all great, though, and some of the best pizza I've had in Indiana. Excellent crust! Good, friendly service, too. Highly recommended. read more

Coterie Pizza - Marguerita pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Garrett, Indiana

My wife and I decided to venture up to Garrett and try out Coterie strictly based on the beer options. They're located on the south side of town in an unassuming little strip mall. We were warmly greeted and were given a layout of the menu and beer sampling taps. The beer cheese appetizer was spot on. In addition, the pizza arrived hot, fresh-tasting and delicious. We'll be returning soon just based on the service (the owner swung by to check on us), fresh tasting pizza and beer options, all for an affordable price. read more

See all

The best pizza we have had in the area. The Caesar salad made with kale, bacon,tomatoes was amazing! The service was also great. Everyone seemed to enjoy being there. Will definitely be back!! read more

My wife thinks they have THE BEST Pizza in the US. She says It's worth the drive to Garrett, IN just for the Pizza! read more

Coterie Pizza - Pepperoni, Sausage and Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garrett, Indiana

See all

Excellent brick oven pizza in an unassuming strip center. It would rival pizza shops in any larger city. We got the brisket pizza, which was pretty good, but felt like it was missing some cheesiness, the hot honey with pepperoni was tasty with some fluffy ricotta. Asked for the crushed red pepper on the side so we could control the spice. The Greek goddess salad was fresh and jam-packed with yellow peppers, artichokes, chickpeas, Kalamata olives and feta. The beer cheese was delicious. Bread was perfectly chewy like a Parmesan pizza crust. If we weren't tracking we might have taken home leftover cheese! Prices were also very reasonable for the quality. You order at the counter and they bring it to your table. Plenty of seating inside. Two pizzas, a salad, and beer cheese was more than enough for 4 people. read more

See all

Gluten-free pizza was pretty good that's for sure. The regular pizza was also pretty good. Open floor plan and the service was fine. Wish they had paper plates to go. read more

Super good pizza! The wood fire here is great. They have a state of the art oven and it makes for some of my favorite pizza crust. They have their own styles but you can customize your pizza pie. We got the Cajun and I really liked it. Fresh chicken and good veggies. My family also tried the sausage and I really like how this is made. It cools so well. They also have a beer wall. They had some very rare and super local beers. The inside was very comfortable. Clean and an easy place for our family of 4 to enjoy a meal. I would go back! read more

Coterie Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garrett, Indiana

See all

they gave us our food and never came back sat there for over 1hr before anyone came to check on us don't recommend

We have been various times and will continue to go! It would be 5/5 if the owner were the one making the pizzas each time. Unfortunately some of the crew doesn't put in as much care -- folding the pizzas over into themselves because they stuck to the shovel has happened more than once when he isn't around. Great place! read more

What a nice restaurant! Seat yourself on walking in, large clean dining area! Great service and the best pizza we've had in ages! We went with a pepperoni, beef sausage & red onion. We've never had beef sausage but it's excellent!!! Our pizza was out to the table quickly and looked and tasted great! Will definitely be back when in the area, if it wasn't a 200 mile drive we would be back more often! read more

See all

Great food, reasonable pricing!!! The margherita is a must have, such a fresh and tasty pizza!

For our small town, we have one of the best pizza places in the area. The staff is always friendly and the pizza is always delicious. The only downside is that they only have a medium size pizza with the exception of Sunday and Wednesday (I believe). Then you can get a large sized pizza as well if you don't want to have to purchase two. Overall for the price and quality of Coterie Pizza, it's pretty hard to beat. read more

What a cute little pizza restaurant. This was our first time trying it out and we were really impressed! The cheese bread was very good! We also tried the Margherita Pizza and a cheese pizza. Both were really good! They were cooked well. Love the stone fire taste. The self-pour beer wall was fun. They had a good selection of beers. read more

Well worth the drive from SW Fort Wayne. Prior to our visit we had considered Beer Barrel pizza our favorite despite numerous bad service experiences. Coterie Pizza is better than anything I have had in Fort Wayne. The crust is very good and so are the ingredients. We will be back for the pizza. I wish they were closer to Southwest Fort Wayne. The need to open a second location on Illinois road west for I-69. The also gave a self pour beer wall with 7 Fortlandia beers on tap (as of the time of this review) plus a mead. I really like the beer wall experience. Congrats to Fortlandia for getting so many beers on tap. read more

Absolutely the best pizza in Northeastern Indiana. 10x better than 800° Highly recommend the hot honey pizza, and the beer cheese! read more

Hey Auburn! Hey Angola! Hell, even... Hey Fort Wayne!! Why does Garrett have a beer wall and none of you?? Literally take my Power Band up and pour your own beer!! So awesome! Fantastic fire oven pizza!! 10 taps! And you pour your own! Very awesome place in small town Garrett. We had the Beer Cheese, the Cajun Pizza, and the Honey Drip! Absolutely awesome place! read more

Excellent, fast,attentive service. Best pizza I've ever had in my 85 years. Love the "build your own" choice for getting exactly what you want at that moment. I was nervous about trying one of specialty pizzas, since "hot honey" sounded weird to me. But I risked it. FANTASTIC! Everyone should try it once. read more

Had dinner at Coterie last night. We were a party or four and shared 3 pizzas which are medium sized - we had a Spinach Artichoke pizza, a Brisket pizza and the Hot Honey. We had almost a full pizza box of left-overs. The spinach artichoke was utterly without flavor. We each had a piece and left the rest. The Brisket pizza had a nice zesty bbq sauce and we ate most of that one and we liked the hot honey fairly well. That disappeared too. All cooked appropriately and they came out fast. Reasonably priced I thought. Everything was clean and modern. They have an innovative pour your own beer service. That was convenient since we didn't see our waitress very often. The service was pretty slow and although we had made a reservation our table was not available. I doubt we'll be back - its a 25 minute drive for us and its not 25-minute-drive pizza. Certainly if you're close or in the area its worth trying. read more

Have to love the small town independent restaurant. Food was amazing and great service. Plus pricing was very good for today's high prices. Definitely coming back again. read more

I'm a pretty fussy pizza person, but this place surely checked all my boxes. I could "build my own", great cheese to toppings ratio and perfect crust. The jackpot was whole Kalamata olives. The veggies ( green peppers,onions, mushrooms) were fresh and pepperoni thinly sliced. read more

Great salad, pizza, and baked sandwiches. The crust here is crispy , light and has a good chew. Ingredients all taste fresh and good quality. A real hidden gem. read more

Pizza was very good!! They were very skimpy on the toppings. Don't know about the service inside. We picked it up ourselves.

We have eaten here multiple times. The location & atmosphere are pretty mediocre. However the pizza is the best I have ever had. The bread & beer cheese is also incredible. We drive 45 minutes just for this food. Try the hot honey pizza, you won't regret it. read more

Impressive flavor profile on their various pie options, and the restaurant boasts a clean open kitchen aesthetic. High tech beer and wine wall will please all palates; offering stouts, lagers, seltzers and more. The interior is equally impressive to the food and beverage offerings, with a beautiful hardwood ceiling, and a fresh bright color scheme throughout. We look forward to returning in the near future. read more

See all

A really fun, different place to check out. Within our group we had several different items including pizzas, salads, pasta and sandwiches. Everyone was happy. The serve your own beer/wine wall was cool too. Just a quick drive from Ft. Wayne. Well definitely be back. read more

Brand new pizza shop in Garrett! They have a brick oven and the pizza is delicious. They have a really cool pour your own beer wall that you pay by the ounce with a special bracelet that you scan. Service was very fast. They have a variety of indoor seating, including high top tables and traditional tables. They also have high chairs and booster seats for children. Couldn't find a menu online and didn't take a picture of it, but search on Facebook and you'll find it! Brisket pizza was very good! Definitely unique. read more

See all

Long wait times. Even for take out. Food is ok. The place is packed and can't hear the people at your table talking. Tables are close together. read more

A wonderful dining experience overall! The restaurant has a nice atmosphere that doesn't feel crowded or packed even when all the tables are filled. The addition of the self serve beer bar and soda fountain makes it more inviting and enjoyable. The pizzas were very well made and full of flavor, and the prices were very reasonable for what you get. An amazing experience overall 10/10. read more

This is the margherita pizza that was brought to us, I said "Where's the basil and there's not much cheese?" the server said "that's how we make them!" Judge for yourself. Bread sticks were good thou read more

Coterie Pizza - So called Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garrett, Indiana

We had their pizza at Sylvan Cellars so stopped by to experience it more and we'll be back! Picked up carry out in the way to the lake. Hot Honey Pepperoni and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizzas plus the beer cheese and bread were excellent. Service was friendly, guided me in what to order and very timely. Also ordered the Greek salad and very fresh! Thank you! read more

Yum! Pizza was hot. Sauce was delicious and the crust just as great! I had the Pepperoni n Sausage pizza. Friendly service. I'll be back.

Great smells as I parked in the clean, and fairly new parking lot. Walked in and was greeted in a friendly manner. Told I could sit anywhere we choose, and was follow by waiter. She asked for drink orders and explained the beer wall (awesome idea, I have seen only one other, Kennedy Space Center). The place looks brand new inside and was spotless. Plenty of pie choices and salad was ordered first. Kids gobbled up the salad as it had plenty of meats and red peppers. Beer wall was cool, able to try a few different really great local beers, had Pachanga from Sun King! All beers were super fresh. Then to the pies, came out fresh, hot, and delicious. Had the margherita, hot honey, and brisket. All of them had prefect crust, good flop, and cheese melted perfectly. Would I go again, I got carry out the next day, and drank a beer while I waited. The in-law were very impressed, Pizza, family, Sunday Football, go Colts! read more

The Italian sandwich was delicious and we added lettuce, tomatoes and Mayo on the side. Got there when they opened and seated ourselves. Waitress greeted us upon arrival, friendly and explained the self serve beer and wine. What doesn't everybody have a beer and wine wall? read more