Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Plantation Realty & Management

    3.9 (8 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    Services - Plantation Realty & Management

    Property management

    Plantation Realty & Management Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Plantation Realty & Management

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 months ago

    Great People Great Company- Myles and Darrell will go out of their way to help their customers out!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 7
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dani F.
    25
    17
    3

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Plantation Realty & Management

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Property Management 357 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Avalon Property Management - Dedicated team serving Atlanta since 1991 in Residential Sales and Property Management.

    Avalon Property Management

    (20 reviews)

    Avalon took over management of a lease that we originally signed with the homeowners. During the…read morefollowing month after Avalon took over the lease, we were told that Avalon was terminating our lease, and we would either have to sign a new lease with different terms or vacate the property. After carefully reviewing the terms, we were not comfortable agreeing to them. Based on both the lease terms and our interactions with Avalon, we decided that moving out was the better option. The time, effort, and expense required to move was worth it to us to avoid continuing to deal with Avalon. If Avalon had honored our original lease terms and simply raised the rent a reasonable amount, we would have been happy to stay longer. We were responsible tenants that received our entire deposit back. However, we did not feel valued or respected as tenants during our experience with Avalon. Our deposit was also held for the full 30 days after we moved out, the maximum period allowed under Georgia law. I am glad that we no longer have anything to do with this company. Avalon represents the exact type of management company I try to avoid when renting a home, and I cannot recommend them to anyone.

    Avalon took over our existing lease and shortly afterward required us to either accept…read moresignificantly different lease terms or vacate the property. We ultimately chose to move rather than agree to terms we were not comfortable with, and although we were responsible tenants who received our full deposit back, our experience with Avalon was disappointing and we cannot recommend them.

    McCreary Realty Management - Our Office

    McCreary Realty Management

    (40 reviews)

    This information is at the bottom of all of their properties "All residents are enrolled in the…read moreResident Benefits Package (RBP) which includes HVAC air filter delivery, our best-in-class resident rewards program, identity protection, and much more! More details upon application. This is a "JUNK FEE" Fee REQUIREMENT and is paid to a third party. There is a monthly cost for this of $39.00 or $27.00 depending on the package chosen by the resident. If you go to their website to see the requirements to view the property, you will read that you have to provide LINKED bank information. In other words give them open access to review your account. "AVAILABLE NOW | SHOW: LOCKBOX VIEWING INSTRUCTIONS: Home is available to view, visit our website to schedule your viewing TODAY!" You are expected to pay $250 just to have your application reviewed in addition to $75.00 for submitting the application itself. "All Applicants MUST meet our BASIC QUALIFICATIONS $250 admin fee per lease, once accepted Application Fee is $75 / Applicant (all occupants 18+ Must Apply) Application fees are non-refundable;" Pets: For some of their properties if you have a pet you have to register your pet with a third party pet screening company that will require you to pay an annual fee for this screening as long as you rent the residence. Keep in mind that you would NOT be the only one applying for this residence. You may be among several others who have paid the $250.00 admin fees as well as the $75.00 application fee; who do not get chosen to rent this residence.

    Family owned and operated for decades, McCreary Realty Management is currently under the leadership…read moreand direction of Michael McCreary. Michael is passionate about mentoring and instructing others in the industry and dedicated to taking care of both tenants' and owners' needs and concerns. McCreary RM handles over 300 residential properties and manages 30+ HOA's. A firm that doesn't provide exceptional customer service in today's competitive markets cannot survive, let alone thrive and grow as McCreary has over these decades.

    Property Services Of Atlanta

    Property Services Of Atlanta

    (29 reviews)

    If this company was a person, in my opinion and experience, it would have malignant narcissistic…read morepersonality disorder. I'm still in shock over our experience. At 42 years old, I have rented multiple homes in Los Angeles and Atlanta. My husband has rented multiple places all over GA AND has owned and sold houses, land, etc. He has also owned his own very successful business for 25 years, paying high rent for his business in the heart of Atlanta. Not once have we ever missed ANY payments. Not once have we been evicted, filed bankruptcy, etc. We are ideal tenets. We are mature, responsible, clean, reliable, and because my husband gets up so early for work, we rarely make a peep of noise. We take very good care of any place we live and have had amazing relationships with past landlords (some of whom we are still in touch with years after leaving their property). We found the cutest little house in Marietta. We have lived in midtown for 8 years and decided that we wanted to relocated to the suburbs. This house was absolutely perfect for us. So, we contacted the rental company. This company. When we started the application process, we immediately knew that something was not right. They wanted every single account we have, including different savings accounts. This has NEVER been asked of us before. Normally, companies want ONE account and your SSN for a background check. NOT ONCE from LA to Atlanta have we been asked for this much information. It made us very uncomfortable. It felt like a HUGE invasion of privacy. At that point, we decided to take a look at some of the reviews. I was gobsmacked at the amount of negative reviews this company has, with a lot of the complaints saying some of the same things we were experiencing in real time. At that point, we contacted three separate attorneys in Atlanta to have them look at the application. All three attorneys gave us the same advice. First, this company was stretching the law in GA and in their opinions what was happening could be shut down and investigated if turned into the authorities. Second, all three attorneys told us to only give them ONE account. We were told that it is common for shady companies to try to spy on all your accounts in order to see where they can add on fees. Under no circumstances were we to give them more than one account. Under GA Law, you're only required to give one. We were told if we really wanted the house, we had to be very careful this company and keep our cards close. I sent an email expressing my concerns. I was very nice in the email but what I got in return was pretty nasty- a messages confirming that they did in fact need access to a checking account we use only for groceries, on top of all our savings account, and on top of the account we mainly use to pay rent, bills, etc. Oh, and they also needed credit card information. So, I called them. I explained that I wanted to talk to them human to human. After all, they're in a human based industry. When you're dealing with someone's home, you're dealing with vulnerability. You're finding someone a place that is their security and safety from the world. It needs to be handled with care. I thought surely if I speak to them, they will be understand where they're crossing some line legally and see it's an invasion of privacy to ask for ALL your information. When I got on the phone, I immediately said that I wanted to express my concerns with some of the yahoo and yelp reviews that I was seeing. Before I was able to get out the content in the reviews I was told that none of them are true, these people were slandering them, and the company was going to be suing the people writing the reviews for slander. First of all, you cant sue someone for slander if what the person is saying is true. Second of all, if you're trying to censor someone for telling their honest experience with your company, that's HUGE problem and truly speaks to YOUR dishonesty. If you don't want bad reviews getting out of hand, then don't do shady things to people that prompt them to take time out their day to warn others about their experience. And thirdly, I was being told that none of these reviews were true WHILE what these people were complaining about was actively happening to us in real time. This, dear reader, is the actual definition of gaslighting. Needless to say, we know they called our landlord to check out our history with them, they took our $150 application fee, but we have not heard anything for a week. My boyfriend emailed them, called them, text them, and we still have not gotten any communication on if we're approved or not. They are not doing the job they have been paid to do. Shame. BE CAREFUL. I wish we could just rent this house from the owner directly. Please do not give these people access to your private information. Protect yourself.

    If you're looking for a property management company in Atlanta, DO NOT hire PSA…read more I've managed over 30+ rental properties across the U.S. and have taught thousands how to invest in real estate--so I don't say this lightly: PSA has been the worst experience I've had with any property management company in my entire career. They are not proactive, strategic, or partnership-minded. They collect fees and respond to tenant requests, but that's the bare minimum--and even that is done poorly. No preventative maintenance. No property visits. No accountability. I had properties that sat vacant for over six months with no leasing strategy, no feedback, and no urgency. These were homes that had never been difficult to lease--yet PSA made zero progress. The moment I took back control, those same properties were leased immediately. Even worse, they charged me monthly per-door fees on vacant units they couldn't lease--giving them zero incentive to do their job. It felt like a scam. Their negligence caused me to fail a housing voucher inspection, and they refused to take ownership. We had to step in ourselves, hire our own contractors, and clean up their mess--time and money lost. The final straw? Despite my direct request not to use self-showing lockboxes (especially with the rise in squatting issues in Atlanta), they went against my instructions and we ended up with squatters in two separate units. Not only did they fail to take accountability, they gave me the runaround about basic showing records and required attorney involvement to resolve the issue. On the customer service side, working with their team was equally frustrating. Myself, my husband, and my CFO were spoken to in an unprofessional, condescending tone repeatedly--especially by their operations manager, Michael. Instead of owning mistakes, he doubled down with arrogance. I had to escalate issues to the owner, David, just to remind them of their fiduciary responsibility. The property manager, Sonja, was consistently disorganized--losing keys, missing walkthroughs, and making excuses instead of offering solutions. If you're an investor who values professionalism, communication, and results--take your business elsewhere.

    Plantation Realty & Management - propertymgmt - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...