This has got to be the hottest and tastiest pizza in Santa Cruz! The pizza crust is both perfectly doughy and crispy, and their menu is brilliant. We got the Magic Carpet and the Mushroom Hunter, and both pizzas were so unique and delicious. It can get busy, but the wait is never too long, and the vibes are nice. Highly recommended!! read more

Pizza was easily 5+ stars and some of the best on the Westside, but as many have mentioned - the wait was still rough. We had the Barking Dog and the Mushroom Hunter and both were spectacular, but after waiting almost a half hour (and seeing other people's orders come out first), I checked with the cooks and was curtly told "we're working on your pizzas" - no explanation or apology as to why they hadn't been working on our pizzas for the half hour before. That being said, we will certainly be back, and if they can get their logistics in order, I will happily make it 5 stars! read more

This pizza is wild, like in a good way, I ordered three pizzas today, the Woodcutters, the Barking dog and a good old cheese pizza. Who knew that pickles on pizza would the greatest thing ever!? I didn't, but now I do. The pickled veggies on the Woodcutters pizza were amazing! The crust is so awesome, thin and crispy, kinda chewy, but not in a bad way. I placed the order online for pickup, it was ready when they said it would be. I haven't been able to sit down in the space yet, but it looks cool from the outside, and they have a nice patio area. I believe you should go here and eat this pizza, it is a wonderful neighborhood pizza spot. I assume this pizza could bring about world peace, you should go and eat it! read more

Very positive experience at Pogonip. You can tell this pizza is high quality, with a really great crust. I was sad they weren't able to do half of one topping and half of another, so we ended up getting what they said was the most popular pizza, the High Street Local. I'm not sure I'd get that same pizza again, it didn't quite do it for me - next time I'd just stick with the plain. But I can tell they're able to make a dang good pizza. read more

Pogonip Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Cruz, California

Pogonip Pizza is a much needed pizza and beer joint walkable to UCSC and the upper west side! Stopped in for the soft opening and I am excited to come back to try more pizzas, beer on tap, and enjoy the laid back atmosphere! The place was super busy, but given that it was the 2nd day that they were open it is to be expected. The tables turned over fast and our party of four found seating very quickly. At the moment they only have cans and bottles of beer (as well as wine and soft drinks), but they have eight taps and the owner said that within a week they will have beer on tap! Pizzas had a thin crisp crust with a great flavor. We got the mushroom hunter and the sweetness. The mushroom hunter had a very tasty savory shroomy medley, though I would have liked more mushrooms on the pizza as a whole! The sweetness was a really unique pistachio, onion, and hot honey combo, but overall I could have done with more toppings and flavor. The vibe inside was very fun, the service was great, and I loved the mountain bike theme. (In addition to local made bikes on the walls, all of the specialty pizzas were named after local bike trails!). Really looking forward to returning to try more affordable pizzas, beers on tap, and their $4 soft pretzels! read more

See all

Chef Ryan is a master a flavor combos. Unique flavor profiles you don't see, but also has tried and true pies classical pies. Service was great. Order at the counter and pizzas are sent out over the counter, where you get a nice view of kitchen action. Ambiance is casual with a local vibe. Bicycles are mounted on the walls which explain the inspiration behind the Pogonip logo. Congrats to the Chef Ryan and team for not just another restaurant, but a gathering place for the community! read more

See all

Pizza was good overall. The dough was excellent. Soft and chewy, charred nicely. The crust was a little too thick compared to the amount of pizza topped section. Having something like some olive oil and seasoning on the crust part would have made that a little more appealing. Got two pizzas - the mushroom was my favorite. Umami and delicious. Also got the Magic Carpet. The jalapeños weren't hot (for me or my fiance) and it didn't taste like hot honey - so it was overly sweet for me. My fiance added some red pepper flakes for another slice and said it made a difference. read more

Pogonip Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Cruz, California

Nice little surprise tucked away on the upper Westside. Pizza has incredible crust and innovative toppings. Add. the great indoor outdoor space, beer and friendly staff, what else can you ask for? read more

The pizza here tastes better than you think. The restaurant owner's heart is very sweet.

Fabulous pizza that I dream about! So far I've had the Barking Dogs, Mushroom Hunter and High Street Local. Such delicious and different flavors, especially the house-made scallion sauce. I have come twice since they opened and had minimal waits for my pizzas. Staff and the two owners are super nice. This is the kind of pizza place that sticks with you. And I love how the names of the pizzas are homages to local Santa Cruz places/events. Already dreaming about my next visit: get the barking dogs again or try the Santa Carla???Maybe both with leftovers to take home! Keep up the great work PP! Now just need a couple of cider options, extended hours and an online ordering system to be pizza perfection. read more

We are locals that live on the upper westside and were super excited when we heard they were opening a pizza place up here. We went in to the restaurant on three separate occasions and tried to place a to go order for a couple of pizzas, only to be told it would be an hour and a half to a two hour wait for a to go order! WHAT???... How can it possibly take two hours to cook a pizza??? Each time we went in the place wasn't even full. The staff is not very friendly or accommodating and the hours are super weird so we finally gave up. After being open for a couple months decided to give them one more shot. I called right when they opened to place an order for pick up. The guy who answered was again not very friendly and told me that they don't except phone orders, he asked how many pizzas I wanted and I told him just two so he agreed to let me order. Then I asked if I could also add two of their pretzels and he grumbled "I guess we can set a couple aside for you". What's even worse is that after he repeated the order back to me and I had to correct him because one of the pizzas were wrong, they still gave us the wrong pizza!!! The pizza itself was okay but nothing special. Even though there are better pizza options in town, I would've been happy to support them because it's convenient having a place so close to home. However, due to the unfriendly staff and lack of customer service we will not be going back. read more

My wife and I loved our experience here at Pogonip! Yes, they are a new restaurant in Santa Cruz, but by no means new to the industry. The pizza dough is very flavorful, chewy, crispy and delicious. Everything tasted very fresh and real. We will be back to sample more. Highly recommended. read more

Thrilled that Pogonip pizza is officially open on the Westside. We live in the neighborhood and have wished a spot like this would open up. We came for the soft opening and had the mushroom hunter and the magic carpet. They were both phenomenal! We learned they'll be serving Woodhouse Beer and slinging a delicious menu of pies. Looking forward to the next slice with friends. The pizza was also endorsed by our 3 year old with a juice box on the side from the friendly staff. read more

Pogonip Pizza - Mushroom Hunter and Magic Carpet - Pizza Near Me - Santa Cruz, California

The pizza was really good, they have authentic cheese as the crust is really soft. Will be coming back.

Customer service was terrible , workers were not welcoming. I was stared at by the staff like I was offending them asking for a to go box. Got weird stares for no reason. Food was good but felt unwelcome and staff seemed hostile. Never felt like this before at a restaurant in my life until I went here. read more

Great spot, very family friendly, really excited to have something walkable on the upper westside!

Absurd!!!!! Hour long wait for them to tell us it would be 45 minutes for a pizza to come out! They didn't open the doors till 5:40 when they are supposed to open at 5:30 and already have the most difficult and annoying hours. Honestly so disappointed there trying to create a good vibe but the vibe is no where to be found. read more

don't bother going here if you're actually hungry and don't want to wait over 2 hours for something you pay for standing