Mark, the new owner has continued right where Feldman left off. They did a great job and go the…read moreextra mile. They replaced the water pump on my Porsche 911 with no issue. Highly recommend them for your foreign or domestic car service needs.

Always honest and genuine about fixing your car. Used them many times over the years.read more

Evans Automotive has truly set the standard for what customer service and professionalism should…read morelook like in this industry. I brought them what turned out to be a bit of a "problem child" vehicle--a rare, numbered Cadillac performance car that I had purchased from a dealership in Jacksonville. Unfortunately, it appears the vehicle had prior damage that never showed up on Carfax, which made diagnosing the issues even more challenging. From the very beginning, the entire team at Evans Automotive has gone above and beyond. Multiple technicians have taken the time to thoroughly inspect the vehicle, the owner himself has been personally involved, and they've even done ride-alongs to better understand the issues firsthand. On top of that, they've graciously dropped me off at home so they could spend additional time digging deeper into the car. That level of care and commitment is rare--especially when dealing with a high-performance vehicle that requires extra attention and expertise. What stands out most is not just their technical ability, but the genuine pride they take in their work. It's clear this isn't just a job to them--they truly care about doing things the right way and taking care of their customers. That kind of passion and integrity is hard to come by these days, and it shows in every interaction. I can't say enough about the experience I've had with this team. Evans Automotive operates with a level of attention, transparency, and dedication that is incredibly refreshing. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a shop that genuinely cares and stands behind their work.

Family Owned and Operated. Recommended by a friend and now I HIGHLY recommend Evans Auto! I wasn't…read moresure of the problem,,,,could only give a description....they found and fixed! Nice to know that this small business is Knowledgeable, Professional and Friendly. Thank you Evans Auto!!!! Rosemarie F

Newfound loyal customer here almost don't want to do this review because they are hands down the…read morebest auto shop and I've been to many in Saint Augustine and as a girl I am always charged too much. I honestly don't wanna share the best kept secret. Why have a million mechanics when you can have two of the best? Price is right and the experience they have is second to none. Tell them the girl with the yellow car sent you!

I trust the mechanic at this shop. He practices with honesty and integrity. I have had only good…read moreexperiences with this shop, I highly recommended them. I know my car is safe and taken care of. Great value. Thank you for such great and honest work!

Had some car trouble while on vacation and they were able to squeeze us in without an appointment…read morefor a same day repair! Really friendly and knowledgeable staff - would recommend!

Car was starting- not starting intermittently figured it might be a loose or corroded battery…read moreterminal. Googled mechanics open on Sunday and called at 1:30. They close at two but David said come on in and we will wait for you. Such a nice guy- fixed it in less than a minute - would not let me pay him. Will be back for normal maintenance or any other future automotive needs and will definitely recommend this business very highly! Thank you!

I know a little about cars and I know a lot about paying to keep them in the road. I also know…read moreabout automotive service and the three things that are important: Honesty, friendliness and timing. I found Sargeant Service Center to have it all. I was driving from Florida to California in my 2016 car and I wanted an oil change. I called and made an appointment. The woman on the phone was FRIENDLY. We scheduled a day and time, because I had to wait for it since I'm on a trip. She quoted me a price for the oil change and it was reasonable. I got there on TIME and they were ready for me. The tech took my car and changed the oil while he checked it over. When it was done, the service writer told me that things looked good and I didn't need the air filter changed, the brakes were ok, etc. That was HONEST, no pushy upsell. I'm not in town regularly to go here, but if you are reading this, then you are and need to take your car to the shop. I recommend this place. Even if you have mechanic phobia like my daughters do, this place is going to be good to you. I promise.

Good Shop! Excellent Services! Always there when you need them, except Sat/Sun! In/Out in 1 hr!read more

Took very great care of my sister and held her car over the weekend since she lives in Titusville…read moreand the car had an issue mid trip home. They took her car immediately and had it rdy to go the wry next business day. Highly recommended! They came with local Tow truck driver approval on the quality mechanic who's not trying to break your pocket book.

Clear & fair pricing. Helped me find battery for my car as…read morewell. Nice & friendly Hope to visit again

I had a very disappointing experience with this business on two separate occasions…read more The first experience was for a scraping noise while accelerating. After inspecting my car, I was told the issue was the motor mounts and was quoted around $1,500 for the repair. Since I knew motor mounts were not worth anywhere near that amount I chose to replace them myself for $50. However, this did not resolve the issue because the diagnosis was incorrect. I later identified the actual problem as a parking brake wire contacting the driveshaft, which was a simple and inexpensive fix. This represents a significant misdiagnosis and a large difference in cost. The second experience involved calling ahead twice to confirm availability for a resonator delete as the shop is about an hour away from me. I adjusted my work schedule and drove out based on that confirmation only to be told upon arrival that they likely would not be able to complete the job. I was advised to wait which I did for about two hours but ultimately the work was not done. This resulted in lost time, money, and other inconveniences. I want to clarify that I did not miss any appointments both visits were made after confirming availability in advance. Clear communication is especially important when customers are traveling long distances and planning around work schedules. While I understand that scheduling problems can happen the combination of being told services were available when they were not along with the earlier misdiagnosis led to a huge lack of confidence in this business. I am sharing my experience so others can make informed decisions.

Don't take a high end car there, they assume you are an idiot, they will tell you it takes 3 days…read morefor exhaust work, translation we want to joy ride your car. If you drive a Toyota you will be fine.

Has an attitude, rude and condescending also will change the price on you plus won't tell about his…read more3% fee. I won't be using again nor recommending services.

I came in with a used 2011 BMW 328i, I purchased for commuting for work. John was very responsive,…read morecommunicated quickly and let me know what was needed now and one thing to think about in the future. I took care of both because he was so reasonable with pricing. The car has been driving like a champ with no issue since... I've put over 18K on it in the first year. John doesn't play any games and is as honest with his work as he is in person. We use him for our Toyota FJ Cruiser as well, both older vehicles and running strong because of John!