Slice on Broadway serves up pizza all throughout the city of Pittsburgh. There are several…read morelocations, but this particular spot is in the heart of Carnegie. We have been here several times, and usually stop for a slice when we are in the area. Located right on E Main Street, this pizza shops serves made-to-order pies, pizza by the slice, rolls, hoagies, and much more. There is street parking around the shop, along with a paid parking lot right across the street. The shop is smaller, but is updated and cleanly. There are several tables for dine-in guests, but no large tables. If you have a larger party, you would need to split up into several tables due to layout and size of restaurant. We visited on a Sunday afternoon in July. This was during a Farmer's Marker right on E Main Street, so there were a few customers from that. However, it was not too busy or overwhelming. We only had one person in front of us when we went in to order and had no issue finding a table. You are able to order whole pizzas and customize them like any other pizza place, but what makes Slice on Broadway stand out to me are the slices available at the counter. That concept very much emulates their namesake, and reminds me of shops in NYC in that regard. Since I usually visit here with just my fiancé, we tend to stick to ordering a few slices instead of an entire pizza. This way, we can try different types without spending a fortune/having excessive leftovers. On this visit, we tried four different slices and a roll. We had a Plain Slice, Pepperoni Slice, White Slice with Spinach and Tomato, and a Pepperoni/Cheese/Pepper Slice. All of them were good, but my personal favorite was the Pepperoni/Cheese/Pepper. That is not a combination I would have necessarily ordered for myself in a full pizza, but I loved getting to try it. It opened my eyes to putting the yellow peppers on pizza! Additionally, we ordered a Spinach Roll. This was very good, and came with a marinara sauce for dipping. All of the items that you order at the counter - the slices and rolls - are heated up before being served to you. So, even though the items are on display, they arrive hot and fresh out of the oven. I have found the staff here to always be helpful and friendly. Specifically on this visit, we received great service from the cashier. He informed us on what the different pizza slices were while being friendly and hospitable. Personally, I have never had a negative experience with the staff at this location. The prices are average here. It is nice how you can purchase individual slices that are ready in a few minutes, but ordering several of those will add up quickly. They do accept both cash and card, which is a plus! I would recommend Slice on Broadway if you are thinking about making a stop. They have several locations, and you can try different pies by purchasing a slice available at the counter. The service is quick and friendly. It is a great place for a quick lunch or bite at any time of day. I have always enjoyed coming here, and will definitely be back in the future.

My pal got me this pizza for dog sitting, honestly hit the spot, love a thinner crust, would have…read moreloved it a little more crispy on the bottom. And the garlic knots were actually pretty good.

My boyfriend was really craving a seafood pizza because of lent and with us being gluten free it's…read morehard to find places that'll do it. I googled seafood pizza and called up and asked if we could get it in a gf he was super chill and said yeah. The place was super cute and a little hole in the wall. Im excited to try other pies there too.

Small pizza shop outside downtown Pittsburgh! Honestly, we got in late and it was the only place…read moreopen...(though we did try others that said they were open, but they were already closed when we tried. Even though it was late, staff were helpful and friendly. They helped direct us to try a popular pizza that's a little off the beaten path (chicken Alfredo)! The pizza was fantastic. So much flavor, with just the right amount of spice. Not to mention $1 canned sodas...I haven't had that in ages! Great location if you're in the area!

Man, this place is great. Pizza is better than the previous pizza shop that was at this location…read more Thin crust tasty, kind of NY style. Love the pizza sauce, has a nice flavor. We built our own and it was very good with some nice fresh veggies. The owner was really nice and said to call in our take out order instead of using the app, to save some money. If you are in the neighborhood stop by and have a slice or a whole pizza.

One of the best pizzas in Mt Lebo! This place only has big pizzas and slices. Soooo good. The sauce…read moreis savory and not sweet, fresh ingredients, and super yummy crust! Even my picky kid who loves pizza and HATES crust loves it! When we grabbed the pizza the service was nice however, we did not eat in. But it's a cute little shop in uptown.

This is one of those places everyone seems to love--and now I get why. Pro tip: definitely make…read morereservations. We didn't, but somehow got lucky snagging seats at the bar... which honestly turned out to be a perfect spot to eat too! The beet salad was SO good I could've easily ordered a second without hesitation. I had a self-proclaimed Reuben connoisseur with me, and he declared it the best Reuben he's ever had (second only to his own, of course ). It's not your typical version either--no standard Thousand Island overload. The corned beef was perfectly peppered and packed with flavor, and even the bread stood out. Fish tacos? Absolutely a yes. Fresh, flavorful, and just done right. We split sides--tater tots for one dish and the homemade chips for the other. Always go for the homemade chips here. WOW! They had this subtle sweetness that made them seriously addictive. Friendly service, great atmosphere, and food that lives up to the hype. Totally worth it! One quick heads up: there's a 3% fee if you use a credit card, so plan accordingly.

My daughter and I went here for the first time recently. It was intended to be a mini celebration…read morebecause it was her last day of school. We arrived around 4:30pm, we had to park on the street, but there were several spots available. The restaurant is small with a casual interior. We were greeted and seated immediately. The food was good with hearty portions, but our waitress rushed us the entire time. We said we needed a few minutes, because this was our first time here, so she stood there and just... waited. She didn't offer to make any suggestions or ask whether we had any questions, she was just standing inches from the table looking at us. Finally I had to say, "oh, you don't have to wait right here, it'll be at least 5 minutes." Then she left. We ordered an appetizer, two entrees, two non-alcoholic drinks, and two desserts. She never asked whether we wanted dessert, and reached to present the bill while asking if we needed any takeout boxes. I had to interject and ask if we could see a menu for dessert options. The check was placed on our table before dessert arrived, which has never happened to us before at any restaurant we've ever been to. Then, when the desserts were brought to the table, she grabbed the bill presenter and said, "are we good?" I replied, "no, I'll pay when we're done eating." It was odd because we went very early and there were only a few other tables occupied so, I had no idea why we were being rushed the entire time. They also brought my daughter's entree with the wrong side, but they fixed it right away with no fuss. I left a generous tip and didn't report our experience. She was never outright rude to us, but rushing guests at every interaction is uncomfortable and made us feel unwelcome. Overall, this place is good, but if I ever go back, I would insist on a different waitress.

The atmosphere was charming Italian! The staff was friendly and welcoming the made you feel like…read moreyou were at home and mom or grandma was asking if everything was good! The owner stop by each table several times and refilled drinks and brought food! This level of customer service was amazing and and beyond compare! Now for the food when trying a new restaurant that serves pizza and wings! You start with the basics pepperoni pizza Sicilian style and mild "buffalo " wings ( as a Buffalo WNY guy I hesitate to call them Buffalo wings) The pizza was doughy and the cheese pull was great ! The wings were sauced and tossed perfectly with a house made mild sauce that had a tang but not too much served with house made ranch that wasn't even needed because the sauce was perfect! I am sad only to the fact I passed by this place over a 1000 times in the last 12 years and I just discovered it! This place is exceptional!

This place is so good I am writing my review while I am still at the table. I wish I could give…read morethis treasure of a restaurant 10 stars. Everything about it is charming. My lovely server Linda has been with the company for 21 yrs and is well versed with the menu. I went with her suggestion of Chicken Ala Nico and it was ahhhmazing!! Don't let me forget to call out the Wedding soup that came with the entree melted in your mouth. I could go on and on but you need to see it for yourself!!

So my friend ordered from here during a game night around 11 pm on a Sunday since this is one of…read morethe few pizza places nearby open until midnight. We got the large buffalo chicken pizza. When it arrived, there wasn't a phone call, only a text saying it had been delivered. My friend felt bad because they weren't able to leave a tip after the driver came all that way late at night, and when they called, they were told not to worry about it. So my recommendation is to keep checking your phone because they may not call once it's delivered. I also think calling customers would help so people can leave a tip and so the pizza stays hot instead of sitting on the porch. If my friend hadn't checked the phone, we wouldn't have even known it arrived. Although the pizza was smaller than we expected, it was absolutely delicious and honestly crave-worthy because I'm still thinking about it. At first I felt a little disappointed because there was no tomato sauce and I had really been craving tomato sauce, but the buffalo sauce had this weirdly addictive quality to it and worked so well with the cheese. I can definitely understand why they don't combine it with tomato sauce because the buffalo flavor would probably overpower it, but I still secretly wanted the tomato sauce too. One thing that impressed me more than expected was the quality of the chicken on the pizza. It was sooo good. I don't know if it was grilled or what, but it was excellent chicken -- juicy, flavorful, and not even slightly hard or rubbery. The chicken honestly made me want to try their chicken bacon cheddar ranch and chicken broccoli Alfredo pizzas too. I just wish every slice had the same amount of chicken because I think the chicken was what I was looking forward to the most. I also still want to try their regular pizza with tomato sauce and will update this review when I do. Even though buffalo chicken pizza normally wouldn't have been my personal first choice, I somehow ended up eating 8 slices because it was that delicious and easy to eat. Definitely more pizza than I planned on eating, but something about it kept making me want another slice. Looking forward to ordering from here again.

The pizza order was 20 minutes late. By then it was cold …read more Still good though after heating it up.

Great Pizza, have been looking for a good pizza place for about 1 year since the dive I use to go…read moreto closed due to poor service and not to friendly owner but had good pizza and wings. Have found it! Had a New York style. Manager said they have homemade sauce. They also have Napolitana style pizza and bianca pizza. Also tried the hot chili pepper sauce wings, WOW! HOT! and good! For those that do not like hot (they have a milder sauce did not try it) or make sure you have some blue cheese or ranch dressing to go with it. I hear the the spagehettata and some of the meals are good (from a friend, that is how I found out about this place). Will definitely return for many more! This is take out only, but they do have a room connected, not sure if they plan on opening up so you can eat in or not (sometime in the furture).

What's not to love about this Pittsburgh staple? This is our household's favorite pizza, and we're…read morealways willing to drive 35 minutes one way to pick it up. The location is terrible. It's on a dilapidated brick road that you essentially have to drive up at a crawl speed to prevent your car from rattling a part, and there's rarely parking. HOWEVER, somehow, this adds to the charm. The journey makes the reward that much better, I suppose. When you enter the pizzeria, it feels like how a pizzeria should. It's small and noisy, and the smells are overpowering. The staff is too busy for small talk. They're making dough (see what I did there?). I love it. The sauce is sweet, which isn't how I typically want a pizza sauce to taste, but it's also what makes their pizza so unique. You won't find another pizza that tastes like this. A plain cheese pizza from here is worth its weight in gold. I cannot recommend them enough.

We visited on a Saturday and the place was packed, which was a great sign that this is one of the…read moremore popular pizza spots in the area. We were told there would be a wait, but our pizza was ready right when they said it would be. The staff was also extremely friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Parking was a little tricky because of the location, but it was definitely worth it! The standout feature of this pizza for me was the flavor of the cheese (especially when paired with onions) that combination was easily my favorite part. They use a very generous, thick layer of cheese, which creates a rich and indulgent pizza. The cheese is quite oily and can slide off the crust, so personally the amount of cheese and oil was a little heavier than my usual preference. However, the chewy crust holds up well to the toppings, and there was still something really addictive about the overall flavor and texture of that cheese. One thing that surprised me was how good it was the next day when eaten cold. I actually prefer this pizza cold. The cheese and onions complemented each other even more, and the pizza felt a little less oily while allowing the flavors to shine even more. Overall, this is definitely a top-tier pizza place in the area. If you enjoy a flavorful, cheesy pizza with a great chewy crust, I would absolutely recommend giving it a try!