I ordered a delivery of the Big Papi, seafood platter from Puerto Plata maybe two months ago. I was at home, eating through my feelings but even a greedy girl like me wasn't ready for so much food. The Big Papi is enough for plenty of people's feelings. A deep dish aluminum pan filled with shrimp, lobster tails, corn and potatoes was good NOT great. The seafood was a tad bit bland. The shrimps were large but a bit undercooked for my liking. I ordered some sort of side sauce but that was also lacking. It didn't taste like anything- no spice, no buttery flavors. Nothing. Big plus was the amount of food that you get for your money. I would get food from Puerto Plata but in person. I believe that if I'm present to tell the cook just how I want my food seasoned and prepared, I'll have a greater taste experience. read more

Flavorful, well seasoned broiled seafood. Staff is friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating. read more

$37 for a damn lobster roll We ordered what we thought were lobster rolls what we received were potato hot dog buns with a small amount of lobster meat which is unacceptable and a rip off you guys are lucky I ordered off of Grubhub and I was at work because I would of have came back and threw this crap in your face I want my damn $37 back for the damn lobster rolls read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Don't Buy lobster roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love ordering seafood from here! The food is always super fresh and there's such an axing variety of mix and matches. Honestly some of the best lobster I've had in NYC read more

I've been wanting to try this place for a while, so today I did. I had the Salmon dish it was good, my friend had the shrimps and lobster dish, she said it was good. It's a different type of restaurant, it looks like a converted garage. You get your food ready made out of heating units which I thought was cool. There are no tables for seating but you can go next door to sit down if you make a purchase there, so that's what I did. I ordered a spiked fruit punch and it was good read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Mini Salmon - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Friday, November 22, 2024 @ 1 pm Yosuel was very friendly and helpful with the menu and what they had ready to grab and go. We got the Atlantis which was 2 huge salmon pieces, 2 lobster tail split, and a pound of shrimp which were large with some zucchini, corn, and stringbeans. This pan was very well seasoned and enough for a few people. It wasn't as warm as we liked and Yosuel heated it up to our liking. Highly recommend for good food, and service with a warm, welcoming smile. read more

See all

I've only had food from Puerto Plata once and it was to go. I had to wait over 4 hours to eat it because we had it catered for a Poconos outing. That was a year ago and the food remains on my mind. The service is perfect Beverly and the other waitresses came over to check on us often. We drank. We laughed and oh boy did we eat. I had the chicken chunks fried with bone w/ tostones and a side of garlic sauce. I stole a shrimp off one plate and a corn from another, finally a spoon of mash and I was spent. At the end of the night Rey came over with a hookah and it was perfect! We danced in our seats and at the end of the night we made sure to thank everyone for a wonderful evening. The food was delicious. The drinks were boss! If you want seafood you have to go next door and order then bring it to your seat. They call you when it's ready to be picked up. We didn't mind that at all. It was worth it. Every thing is made with love. Please go it really feels like a homely spot. You won't be sorry - promise read more

See all

I feel like this is an addiction. How could some buttery garlic sauce be so delicious? To my surprise; the $50 Apollo is very hefty and beyond filling. Definitely was very worth it since it includes a pound of shrimp, 4 crab clusters, and a piece of salmon at the bottom. The salmon was not over cooked at all. I would pass on the mussels though because it was a bit over cooked and the seasoning was just ok. Ceviche is delicious, pretty pricey for a pint but definitely worth the try. The extra butter garlic sauce on the side was the best price I ever paid for. I even used the left over to cook shrimp and salmon. Remember when I started off as an addiction? I've been thinking about it every night and trying to find time to suck up the hour drive (one way) to this place . It's that good. read more

See all

Holy king crab legs, Batman! If you don't have that reaction, after opening a platter package from Puerto Plata Seafood Market, you probably didn't order king crab legs. BUT, you'll still be amazed by all of the wondrous seafood that will be glistening in their own flavourful juices, waiting to be devoured. I used to see my niece post these ridiculous pictures seafood feasts, for every special occasion, and it prompted me to ask here where she acquired all of those crustaceans! She put me on to PPSM, and I went searching to see if we could buy a feast for my MIL, who's birthday was fast-approaching. She LOVES seafood, and I was sure this would be a taste of home, and include all of her favourite things. Unfortunately, they're closed on Tuesdays, which was the day her birthday fell on. My son and I, still very intrigued by the seafood platters that they offer, decided to get one for ourselves to share, so that we might try out the goods. You know, for next time when we try and order for the MIL *wink wink* After stalking their IG account @puertoplataseafood, I found out that they are based in Brooklyn, with their brick and mortar, but they have a food truck that travels uptown, to Dyckman, Wednesdays through Sundays, until 1p! You can order just about any of their seafood trays, and pick them up from the food truck. The food truck even has its own IG account, @puertoplataonthego. You can order through either account, depending upon whether you want to pick up from the food truck at Dyckman, their BK location, or have them deliver to your home. The trays can get pricey but you're getting A LOT of quality seafood, cooked to perfection, along with veggies like, corn, red potatoes, broccoli, string beans, zucchini, and carrots. The prices range from $40, to over $200, depending upon the amount and type of seafood you're getting. They also offer smaller versions of their suped up platters, for around $30. They cook everything really well, too. They're your regular fish market that offers steamed seafood, but on steroids, and the way they handle every ingredient, is with the respect it deserves. Let's be honest....how many of us have had that steam bag of seafood from the neighborhood fish market spot, only to have all the veggie sides, turn to mush? Not with Puerto Plata. Every item is cooked well, and seasoned perfectly. Some of their other items include Sopa Revive Muertos, an awesome looking seafood soup that I'm dying to try, different flavours of flan, steamed mussels, ceviche, and even rawbar oysters! The oysters are only available from their BK location. Let's say you can't get out the house to pick up your sea creatures? Well, they'll deliver! Again, this is an added cost, based upon travel distance from BK, so it would probably serve you to just go ahead, and pick up your order, yourself. My delivery tacked on an additional $38, and while I probably won't have them deliver again, I was still really happy with the food. My son and I ordered the Oceanus, which includes, 1.5 lb king crab legs, 2 snow crab clusters (we counted 3...score!), 2 lb shrimp, 2 pieces of salmon, 2 lobster tails, potatoes, corn, and mixed veggies. We even shared with hubbs and my daughter, and they both enjoyed the seafood, as well. It was outstanding. They pre-cut the lobster tails and king crab legs, so eating them was a lot more fun, without having to wrestle with the shells. I also ordered their hot sauce and garlic herb butter (the truth!), because just about EVERY one of their customers told me to do so, in their reviews. I'm glad we were able to try them out first, because I was going to order one of the huge trays for my MIL, but she would be much better off with one of their smaller versions. Quality seafood, done very well. Period. Go get you some. Thank me later. read more

See all

I didn't really enjoy this tray of crab legs. The crab tasted like it was frozen for too long. I could get the same quality in my local grocery store. It could be because of the restaurant closings due to COVID19. But, I'm not ready to throw in the towel, I'd like to go back and try their lobster and let ya'll know my final verdict. Happy Yelping. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - 5 mins pick up $120 - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love puerto plata seafood. I started off with getting platters from this location. It's a pick up location only. Then I went to the seafood location in Nautical Mile. At this location I bought the Poseidon wish I had the pics to show y'all. It was so good & the presentation was top tier even as a pick up order. Picking it up wasn't a hassle. read more

Went with my Girlfriends to pick up some food. We all ordered the Fulton Tray $60 each with Butter $7, my other Friend also ordered the Seafood Salad $8 and another ordered the Mussels $8. You can not dine in here. Its only pickup and pay. The place is open with ovens against the wall to keep your food warm. Plenty of social distance was enforced as you enter through one door and exit another. There was not a line when we went, so we ordered and paid right away. They accept debit and cash. After our order we proceeded to walk 2 doors down in an enclosed heated Tent that belonged to Puerto Plata Restaurant for drinks. The heated tent was empty so only our group sat to enjoy some drinks. We all ordered Frozen Alcoholic Beverages for $12 bucks a pop. They were pretty strong. The tables were pretty uncomfortable because they're small and round and only literally fit 1 tray and and a drink. They need to fix that. You can not eat seafood with a bunch of butter dripping on a tiny table. I was afraid that I was going to spill something. The flavor of the food is legit and flavorful. The butter garlic is delicious. Their complimentary hot sauce is super spicy but tasty. The Lobster Tails were a little small but you get full with the rest. So its fine. I didn't like the potatoes at all. They were hard. The corn was nice and sweet. I tasted the mussels and they were delicious. The Seafood salad was on point. My friend bought the Seafood Soup Prior and said it was delicious. The waitress Carmen at Puerto Plata Restaurant was super nice and attentive. She made the experience memorable even more so. I highly recommend this place. I cant wait to go back to try different options. The Seafood is fresh here and wrapped nicely and clean. Definitely worth it! read more

See all

Delicious seafood with cool staff. A bit confusing but you place your order on one side( owned by the son) and then you go 1 door down ( owned by the dad) and grab your drinks and sides if you want any. Nothing fancy.. no frills.. just some good seafood. Ceviche was awesome too . I even found the restaurant to be a bit intimate. Glad I was able to finally get this off my list. read more

See all

We ordered a couple seafood trays for pick up. Food was packed very well for travel and unwrapping. It was very easy to put everything out and then clean up. We had a platter with lobster and shrimp and another platter with red snapper and clams. We also got an order of mussels and ceviche. Food was flavorful and the seasoning was not overwhelming. read more

My awesome friend dropped a tray off the seafood platter for my birthday. I've never been here before but oh boy, i will definitely be there as soon as I can! The tray came with a variety of seafood, potatoes and corn. It definitely put a new meaning to finger licking good. It tasted fresh and the garlic butter it came in, it was overwhelmingly delicious. Unfortunately I can't comment on the service not line etc as it was dropped off to me by a friend but he definitely speaks highly of this place; and I can see why!! read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been back to Puerto Plata Seafood at least 3 more times since my original review and enjoyed it each time. I've ordered the Olympus which includes 4 King Crab Legs, Peeled Jumbo Shrimp, Potatoes and Corn. They recently began offering "mini" sized trays which is almost half the size of a full tray for half the price of a full tray. I love this option because I am usually buying for myself and as I have mentioned before Puerto Plata trays can easily feed 2-3 people..so mini trays are perfect for one person! The only downside to the mini tray is you don't get much potato and corn but it is still a good deal. This first time a tried Puerto Plata I was disappointed with the Lobster as it was over-cooked and dry. Didn't have that issue on my next order. My Mini Atlantis' lobster was juicy and hot this time.. The Salmon Mini Dish is a deal for $10 you get a piece of salmon and mixed veggies The only downside is the size of their Snow Crab Legs.. super small..However, I believe that you can request the larger Snow Crabs of course at a price adjustment. Love Puerto Plata seafood and glad that returned to try them again! read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Fulton Street - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is a great find ! Went this evening and picked up the Fulton tray. The line was around the corner but don't let it scare you away. The line moves quickly and orderly. They have a great system in place to pay and pick up food. The owner was out greeting everyone and security was around to keep things moving . The food was excellent . It tasted great not too salty. Get the butter ! The food was an excellent value as well. I had the Fulton tray, soup and flan. All were amazing ! I will be back ! read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Did a pick up order from this spot, and I'm sure glad I placed an order in advance. The seafood they serve here is outstanding. Well worth the trip. Did the Crab Leg Madness and Atlantic Ave platters. And they are not stingy with the food. Everything was perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. Crab legs, lobster tails, the nice sized shrimp and the salmon was all delicious. The veggies and potatoes that came in the platters complimented the seafood very well. Seeing line outside to pick up food tells me the food is excellent. Staff were very friendly and helpful and were great in following the social distancing requirements. Need some good seafood to chow on or bring to a gathering, this is the spot to come to. Heads up, those platters are heavy so unless you have a vehicle or shopping cart handy, bring additional arms to help carry especially when getting multiple platters. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Crab Leg Madness Platter - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Finally decided to make my way over from Astoria with anticipation to wait on a long line. The line was around the block but we made our way over to the front in no time. Me and my friend had two drinks and caught up while waiting. The owner made his way up and down the line numerous times having small talk with people which was refreshingly nice on his part, not to mention how sweet the staff was as well. The food was worth the travel and wait! Delicious, fresh seafood and the price is what really got me. I made the same plate a few week prior for 3x the price. I'll definitely be back here, the Fulton street THANK YOU! Flan was on point too read more

So delicious. I was too late with the pre order as it was Father's Day and I called two days before. While I chose to get there at 1115 when opening time was at 12. I got a good spot on the line right around the beginning of the block. The line sure did not stop behind me, I lost track it looked like it trailed down all of Hale Avenue. Well once the line started moving, it moved. They we're quick and efficient. The music was pumping nothing like some good utz utz in the morning. They accept credit cards and Apple Pay. The owner was there to talk to the people waiting and ultimately I got my food and was in my car by 110pm. The food delicious. I also picked up ceviche, la sopa revive muerte, 4 Fulton street specials and 1 Apollo. Just don't think about it and trust me and get your seafood on. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Fulton st special and Apollo - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We received quality but 3-5x they make the famous fulton tray or etc with Less Less less food than then they started it sucks bc for Example a fulton st was such a wonderful Tray for additional items and now u get 2 tails cut in half, smalller amount of shrimp.. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Poseidon platter - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I went during the summer and the line wasn't very long. I purchased the salmon with cabbage salad It was fresh and tasty This place also sell ceviche and soup I haven't been back but I plan to go back for a really big order..that is what they specialize in read more

Can't remember the last time I didn't have turkey on Thanksgiving. But after tonight's dinner from Puerto Plata ... I don't know if I'm gonna ever want turkey on Thanksgiving ever again!!! Food was unbelievable. Flavorful, fresh and freakin' delicious!!! Ordered 4 trays of Fulton Street, butter sauces and the ceviche. Fulton Street tray is $60 and consists of four crab leg clusters, a pound of shrimp, 2 lobster tails and potatoes and corn. If you like old bay .. you won't be disappointed!! Can't wait to come back!! read more

See all

*QUARANTINE PICKUP* / COVID PICKUP Although I've been dying to come here, I was NEVER willing to get on the line. Way too impatient. They now have a new system where they mass produce. They have these warmer things where the trays are placed. I was in and out in about 7 minutes. This was our three year anniversary dinner so we got the Fulton street and the crab madness and went to town! The crabs were decent size clusters. Some smaller than others but that's ok. Was delicious. The shrimp in the Fulton street were pretty frickin big and so so delicious. I wasn't craaaaazy about the soup but it was pretty good. Will always return. read more

See all

Let's just start by saying this is the Best Seafood in NYC, reasonable pricing, friendly owner and staff , fresh and very clean food and establishment. Tip: Don't bother calling or Dming them on IG, just as everyone in NYC, NJ and LI, gotta stand on line at the store. Remember when you arrive there, the far left line is to order and the right line is to pick up. Typically, if your ordering one of their signature trays, they have those ready to go. If you need further information, feel free and Check out my IG @Kurryeats. read more

See all

Definitely worth every penny spent . Called and put my order in on a Thursday evening for Friday dinner; Got to the fish market and my food was hot,done and wrapped in a foil pan protected by Saran Wrap. I got two whole lobsters, a small salad ,potatoes and corn; then paid extra for a pound of shrimp and four cluster of crab Total to $65 and again worth it !! The food was neither spicy or over seasoned but just right & served us for two meals, dinner Friday night and brunch the following morning . I'll definitely will be making future orders . read more

Go try this place. You won't be disappointed. My de-shelled plate of lobster tails says it all. The entire pan of food was seasoned to perfection. read more

See all

Puerto Plata is my go to when I want to throw down on some seafood.I've been a loyal customer for years. I would recommend this place to all seafood lovers.The service is very good as well. read more

Pulled up to their original BK location today and the Fish god himself was there. Nice guy, friendly staff, and the food is always on point. I've been getting their seafood trays since before they expanded from the fish market next door, and they never disappoint. Today I got the regular size Fulton Street, butter sauce, and the Sopa Revive Muertos . Called ahead and everything was ready when I got there. We already have their hot sauce at home, which is always a go. We went in on the tray so fast, didn't get a chance to take a pic. Everything was delicious. Uploaded pics of their recent menu from their IG, since I couldn't really find an updated menu of theirs on Yelp. Their IG page is always up to date and definitely the spot to check for the latest info on their other locations like the trucks uptown or their spot on the Nautical Mile in Long Island. Whether you flying solo, hosting a feast, or pulling up as a guest somewhere, you can't go wrong with something from here. I'd suggest calling ahead to make sure they have what you need and whether or not there will be a wait. Always appreciate their consistent quality, service & food. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Menu from their IG, 1/9/22 - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I am in love , the seafood was great had it twice back to back in yesterday and Friday. The ceviche is on point , worth the price and so fresh . Butter sauce is definitely delicious omg so happy I found this place I waited in like for an hour but it was worth it . Will be back Wednesday Ceviche med $18 Apollo dish $50 shrimp , crab legs n salmon ,corn , potatoes seasoned perfectly feeds 2-3 Soup $5 Butter sauce $5 Flan $20 Alllll great , next door they have the adult drinks and well worth it ! Most importantly the staff is super nice !!! Great business to supp read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - The Apollo - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Don't believe the hype due to Instagram. Go there for yourself, blow your money, then be tight at the quality and quantity you get . That's the problem with people now a days because the place is a hype spot for now y'all run with it smh. I ordered here twice . First time was when the platters first started Poppin off mother's day 2020. Great quality and quantity. Then I ordered again November 2020 and shit was fucked from there. I ordered the midas platter you must reserve this platter. I made my reservation 3 days Prior got there on the pick up date had to wait over an hour because they didn't make my order and the place was packed. And let's not get into customer service it was bad they need to spend less time idling and get people's order correct and on time. I tip my hat to the owner for being an entrepreneur with this place but I'm not spending another fucking dime in that place read more

This place was incredibly delicious and the customer service is on point! We phoned in an order and was quoted a 30 minute wait time. Not only were they on time, they call you to let you know! Our food was expertly wrapped, perfectly seasoned, and was packed with butter which I was skeptical was too little but turned out being the PERFECT amount! read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Steamed seafood - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered an Atlantic tray, a lobster roll and of course the butter sauce today from this establishment and I must say the food was DELICIOUS!!!! and customer service was exceptional, & food quality the best!!!!. It was definitely worth the travels from NJ and the money. I must definitely will be ordering again from this place. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I placed a delivery for the first time from this place because I saw all the great reviews and even saw friends who have come here. What a major FAIL! I ordered food for my dad's birthday because he loves seafood and I could not be with him due to being sick with covid. The food arrived an hour after their scheduled delivery window, it arrived COLD, and the driver said he had the wrong number. But they had the right number when it was time to take my payment. My biggest gripe with this restaurant is the fact that you cannot call them. I understand they are busy and figure avoiding phone calls is easier but it is bad for business when I am expecting an order and can't get in contact with you. This business practice doesn't work for people who place delivery orders and need to get in contact with someone when something has gone wrong. It took over 30 minutes to get a response via direct message to get anyone to respond to my many messages asking for help. By the time the food arrived, it was 9pm and my parents were upset, hungry, and didn't even want to eat the food anymore. Safe to say my father's special birthday dinner was ruined. Thank you sooooo much Puerto Plata! read more

The trays of seafood is outstanding. Cannot Be beat. I bought a tray for a birthday party and the ladies loved it read more

This is the most amazing fish market/restaurant I have ever eaten from. The fish is always on point the seafood is amazing. There is not one stench. I love that they have trees that are ready for pick up at any time and they now have food trucks. They do deliver but you need to reserve prior. It's definitely an amazing entertainment tray I paid $190 for the specific tray because I added Jonah claws . The the owner even threw in a free flan and soup for me since we do some work together and know each other. Everything tasted absolutely delicious and on point I always order here especially for Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve. If you love seafood this is definitely the place for you read more

See all

Yes good seafood and fish very busy long wait time but worth it. The soup is delicious also the octopus salad and ceviche. Fresh fresh is all i can say the bandejas exquisite. read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - Bandeja corn shrimp potatoes lobster tails - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious food and drinks. Amazing staff very friendly and attentive. Service was extremely fast for my drinks. It get extremely pack on Friday and Saturday. read more

I don't even know where to begin with this place... First and foremost I had been wanting to come here for WEEKS before actually getting Puerto Plata Seafood but the lines were literally wrapping around the block. I was hearing horror stories of people waiting 6-8 hours for seafood!!! People were arriving 2 hours before this place even opened and yet still spending hours here. I was absolutely not down to do that no matter how good the food was so I waited for a better solution to be made, which it finally did. The owner decided to put the trays of food into warmers where the food is pre-made and ready to go. Prior to this it was your typical walk up and order spot. Having things pre-made and ready to grab eliminates the hassle of waiting for individual orders. Each tray has a specific name and you'll already know exactly what you are getting in it. I would imagine that if you want something special you can still do that but at that point I have no idea how long you would have to wait. We ordered the Poseidon, a side of ceviche and butter sauce. YOU MUST get the butter sauce. It is an additional cost but you don't want to order all of that yummy seafood without this butter sauce that will take it to the next level. The Poseidon is $175 bucks and will get you; 8 snow crab clusters, 8 lobster tails, colossal shrimp, potatoes & corn. We ordered this for two people and had plenty of food left over. This dish can easily feed up to four people leaving no one hungry. Would I have recommended this place before the warmers? No. There are plenty of great seafood spots on Astoria but now that they have a system running I would absolutely recommend! read more

Puerto Plata Fish Market - The Poseidon - Seafood Markets Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The seafood at Puerto Plata is so fresh and mouthwatering! Everything that I have ordered has simply been so delicious and tasty since the first time I ordered. You must try the ceviche and salmon they are awesome! The food is flavorful and keeps you wanting for more. I think I've tried and tasted all the seafood on the menu and they never disappoint! read more