Excellent service and great pizza! If you want a real treat, ask for the pizza fries. They're not on the menu, but they're amazing!

Best pizza in Punxsy for my money. Love the dough and sauce. Others are good, too, but Punxsy pizza has that chewy, crispy pizza oven crust with the air pockets... mmmm. read more

The people here were very nice and patient with us deciding what we wanted to eat. It's a cute little place with a few tables on one side and ordering on the other. I will say that, although we did enjoy our time there, the food was not the best. I had ordered a burger pizza, which I clearly was able to taste. The dough was frozen dough and even the burger. It pieces tasted off. They had a bruschetta option which was far from a traditional bruschetta and it tasted like there was beer in it. The cheese logs were nice, but they tasted subpar. Overall, it's a nice place to get a quick bite to eat, but if you're expecting high-quality food, I wouldn't go to this pizzeria. read more

See all

Pizza was average at best. Shocking to see this hustling business operate, but can only believe it's because there's limited competition in the area. The pizza (when finally received right after a necessary do over) is rubbery, not stiff and the sauce is bland in flavor. Got one regular pie and one GF pie. Very nice to have a gluten-free option, but the staff needs some training on this because they didn't know what they offer or how much it costs. Sadly, an overall dissatisfying meal. Would not recommend this place. read more

Punxsy Pizza - Exterior - Pizza Near Me - Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania

See all

Great menu and food, very clean establishment. Pizza and sandwiches were great. Dined in, staff very friendly.

Great service from the employees. They were very friendly. Pizza was amazing and at a great price as well. Nothing disappointed for my roadside dinners stop. read more

Amazing food and service, delivery service was awesome. Price was great also. Close and convenient

Gluten free pizza that is so good you will ask, "is this really gluten free?" Amazing pizza and service! This is now my go to pizza place for gluten free, the crust is incredible! Thank you!! read more

I live very close to them so I'm always smelling the delicious food they are making. I've had the small pizza half pierogi and half bourbon bbq. It's absolutely amazing. That's why I always get that and nothing else. read more

Pizza was absolutely incredible. We tried two different pizzas (the pierogi and bourbon bbq) and ate all of both of them. My wife ordered a pita that she also absolutely adored. We had never been here and the staff were very patient with us. Definitely check this place out if you are passing through. Very cozy little place with awesome service and some of the best pizza I've ever had. read more

We live a few miles from the restaurant and they won't deliver to our house but they will meet a mile down the road so that's what we did. We get back to our house and see that everything we paid for wasn't there so I called to let them know and see how they would make it right. I figured they'd make the exception and bring it the whole 4 miles to my house seeing as how it was their mistake but nope. I was offered gift certificates instead of my money back and I was kind of disgusted with the whole thing so I said ok and gave them my address. This was a Saturday evening. After the fact, I got to thinking, I'm not really interested in the gift certificates that would cause me to have to order from here again. I've only ordered from here twice in my lifetime and the food wasn't really all that good and the service was pretty horrible so I called and asked if I could just stop in and get my money back. The owner told the girl to tell me that since I agreed to the gift certificates and that they went out in the mail already, (on a Saturday evening or a Sunday?) and that it was yesterday that I am not able to get my money back. It could've been remedied by just bringing me what I ordered and paid for. Instead they took my money and didn't deliver. Not a good look Punxsy pizza. read more

Love this place! First time here, the food was great. Servers were amazing. Can't wait to go back.

Great food. Always order from them, nobody else. They have the best pizza in the area, hands down.

This place is definitely one of the best joints in town to grab pizza. It's cheap, quick, and local! The employees are all very nice and courteous. They all certainly know how to pizza right. The breadsticks are also very enjoyable. A slight word of caution: parking isn't the greatest. If you manage to get a parking spot across the street, consider yourself lucky. If not, you may have to find a spot along the street somewhere. read more

Let's face it. This is Punxsutawney, PA and not New York. I am from New York and struggle to find good pizza outside of NY and NJ. Frankenstein's in Punxsutawney was pretty good but it is long gone. Since they closed, I've tried every other pizza place in this town. Don't get me started on those trials! Last chance: tonight I ordered from Punxsy Pizza--calzone and large pizza ---no fluff, no extra ingredients--straight pizza. Understand this: NY pizza is judged on crust first, sauce second, cheese third. If you need to add other things to make it taste good, the base ingredients probably weren't that good. The pizza and calzone we had were definitely the best we've had in Punxsutawney .... in a very long while. The crust was the first edible crust since Frankenstein's. We will be ordering from here again. Two bonuses: 1. They deliver. 2. Kyle, the order taker and deliverer was excellent. read more

My boyfriend and I were in town for Groundhog Day. I was craving pizza, so we stopped by this place. We're so glad we did. The food was great, the Philsner was great, and the owner was super nice. Can't recommend it more highly! read more

the boss is rude to the female workers and is nice to the male workers. he doesn't care if they're sick, he won't let them go home. they also don't wear gloves or are told to wash their hands regularly. the food isn't too great as well. read more

Just had a beautiful family get together lunch at Punxsy Pizza! Used the private room. It was perfect! There was 16 of us. Perfect for eating and talking. I would recommend for sure! Thanks Scott! read more

Best pizza in town! We moved to Punxsutawney about a year and a half ago. While there isn't a large variety in food options, the one thing that Punxsy isn't lacking is options for pizza. There are a ridiculous amount of pizza joints in town. During the time that we've been here, we be been trying out all the restaurants in town, and this is one of the best, and definitely the best pizza, in my opinion. Great food, friendly staff, and good service. read more

Came here with my mom for lunch on Groundhog's Day weekend. We ordered a small side salad and a small cheese pizza, just enough to share. Clean inside. Salad was great & pizza was similar to a mix between Pizza Hut and Domino's- not bad at all. Food arrived fast and staff was friendly. I would probably return in the future. read more

Punxsy Pizza - Small sized pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania

Right so here's the deal. Scott (the owner) is a freaking artist. His canvas is pizza dough. He has perfected his craft so you can enjoy your pizza and beer. He has thrown down with the best pizza makers in the world. He knows what you want. You don't even know what you want. You can't articulate it. But Scott knows. Trust in Punxsy Pizza. Don't think about it. He's done all that for you. This is the best pizza joint in town, and quite possibly the state. Just keep calm and eat at Punxsy Pizza. read more

Good food the messed up our delivery on new years Eve but they were busy tho they r clean and fast delivery most of the time

Amazing place to eat!!!! Could be bigger, but it is still so good. If I were you try the Italian Wedgie, Perogie Pizza, and their breaded cauliflower. Literally. HEAVEN read more

Ordered a pita for takeout rather than going to a fast food chain in the area. Great service, great prices and delicious!