Rahway Bagel has the best bagels in town -- always fresh, soft, and made daily. You can really taste the quality in every bite. It's my go-to spot every Sunday after church and such a nice little treat to look forward to. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, even when it's busy. I also like that everything is made fresh early in the day, so you know you're getting something good. They do close early around 3pm, so it's definitely a morning and early afternoon spot -- but it's worth it every time. Highly recommend Rahway Bagel if you want fresh, delicious bagels done right! read more

Ordered 2 dozen bagels. Waited 20 min watched people come after me, order sandwiches and receive their order prior to staff filling an order for PLAIN BAGELS. Customer service is subpar. read more

Great jersey bagel shop. Ample parking. The place is always busy (a good sign) so service is quick and painless as long as you know what you want before you it gets to your turn. Quick turnaround for your food. Had the French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese. This is a take out place only as there is no place to eat inside. read more

Rahway Bagels - French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Must go!! This bagel staple is one of the best shops that epitomizes what you love from a good bagel shop. I will say no matter what you order expect to be blown away. My favorite of course is pork roll egg and cheese but also a big fan of their beef bacon. I will also say don't expect much from an ambiance as this is your traditional deli and is extremely busy at morning time. However they do a great job with service as you can always get a hold of someone to place an order rover the phone which is nice. i advise you order ahead and pickup just to expedite the process. The bagels are always fresh and everything is prepared with love and still hold true to good value pricing. read more

Rahway Bagels - Pork Roll Meat, Egg and Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Woke up starving this morning!! Hoped on DoorDash in search of a bagel sandwich! Bagel was delicious and exactly what I was looking for! Appreciate it. Can't give much of a review of the location, but I might just have to stop by real soon! read more

Rahway Bagels - Everything Bagel with avocado, eggs, bacon and of course cheese! - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Waste of time. I was placing my order but was rushed every moment. Waited 1/2 hr for my order until i saw people that came later got their order first. Turns out they didn't even put my order in despite me ordering in person. I have had their bagels in the past and they were ok, nothing special and definitely not worth the asking pricing. I recommend buying bagels elsewhere read more

Very fresh, soft, delicious bagels!! They always have a long line in the mornings. Very busy establishment I suggest calling ahead! It helps. This is a take out place so don't expect to eat inside. I got an egg and cheese on a everything bagel which is delish. I didn't know they had more options since I used the menu from door dash - so I'm glad I took photos of the menu for my helpers. Prices are decent and worth it! It's a very filling fluffy bagel! Check it out. read more

See all

It was really delayed, and slow to get a simple order, guy that works there is very creepy also.

Omg! If you're ever in Rahway, New Jersey do not pass up this bagel shop. I was just going to get a simple bagel and then I saw this promotion for an egg sandwich that has hashbrowns, avocado, avocados, real bacon, real fried eggs these guys do not like just open up a container and slap an egg in it they make it from scratch. It is the most delicious breakfast egg bagel, avocado hash, brown bacon, cheese bagel I've ever had in my life.! read more

Rahway Bagels - So fresh!!!!!!! - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

I always go here. The sandwiches are great. But every time I order more than twenty bagels, they come out raw and then when I call them to see like what's going on in the most polite way they all they say is I'm sorry I'll give me your number and I'll have my boss call you. This is ridiculous. I will never order from this place again!!!!! read more

Ordered a BEC on everything bagel. Well worth the wait!!! Perfectly toasted, egg was cooked exactly how I asked. Will definitely return when I am in the neighborhood. read more

Read my words over and over. Trust me, with this place you can never go wrong. Never had the wrong order, always fast service, every one with hairnets and gloves. And always a delicious sandwich. read more

See all

Decent bagel. crunchy outside soft inside. too bad no dine in seating. I enjoyed my bagel in my car like a influencer. embarrassingly with strangers walking past me. read more

Rahway Bagels - everything bagel toasted with cream cheese $2.99 - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Looking for yummy fresh bagels?! Well look no further because this is the place to go to in the morning. When you first walk in you feel right at home due to the smell of warm baked goods in the air which makes it the perfect place to start your day. The service is very fast however it gets super busy. It may seem a bit busy when you walk in but the bagels are absolutely worth the wait. With a variety of options, each bagel is perfectly baked and soft in the inside. To avoid any wait time, make sure to place your order over the phone before you head over so it'll be ready and waiting when you arrive. My regular order is any bagel with vegetable cream cheese of the classic sausage, egg, and cheese. All the bagel combinations taste amazing. If you love sweets in the morning then the french toast bagel is highly recommended. Overall you can be the judge of the bagels but I recommend giving them a try and you wont be disappointed! read more

Stopped by this bagel shop to grab breakfast and was impressed. The inside of the shop is smaller and older. The bagels are large, fresh, and baked in true New York style--crispy on the outside and soft, chewy on the inside. I tried the Lox Special on an Everything Bagel, and it was delicious, delivering the perfect balance of flavors and everything I want in a lox bagel. Be prepared for a bit of a wait during peak times, but the quality of the bagels makes it well worth it. If you're in the area and craving a classic New York bagel, Rahway Bagels is worth a visit. read more

The two stars is for the freshness of the bagel bc truly the bagels are fresh and good. New owners since my last review. Same complaints though. I hate going in there. So many people packed up in the store like sardines that you may get a bagel and Covid or a cold as a constellation prize. Everyone is on top of each other which brings me to the fact that you can never win here. If you order online and pick it up, you will receive a text saying it's ready and get to the store and wait forever bc it's so busy there. Waste of people's precious time. If you order from uber eats, you get to pay an extra twelve bucks for the same thing. However, given the fact that they can't read the order here - you hardly ever get what you actually order, so don't get excited. Ever. It's not cheap so to consistently get the wrong order is annoying and at times (like when you order from uber eats) - infuriating. I love when they tell you to come pick up the correct order after you just paid exorbitant uber eats fees. Insulting to me and my wallet. When they run out of bagels- they will give you a different bagel- of their choice instead of having the courtesy to call and ask you. This happened this week. Last week I went to pick up and they gave Lox slices instead of pic spread and it grossed me out. The time before that they toasted my bagel when I always get it un toasted. The breakfast sandwich sometimes thru forget the egg or the cheese melted when they cooked it and there is no cheese left. The only reason to go here is bc it's the only open bagel shop in Rahway. Kinda like how Comcast has us by the balls if we want cable - this place does the same if you want bagels. Just always something here. There's zero point and going to the trouble to put what you want. read more

Stilll no actual menu Also I'm disappointed I was charged extra to replace bacon for spinach in a bagel. Spinach is cheaper??!?! I never been somewhere they charge extra to replace an ingredient. Not add replace Since there is no menu the price is a surprise Surprise you will be paying $5-$8 for a bagel read more

The bagels were OK! Not great and not bad but Ok. I got the bacon egg and cheese, and they were very skimpy on the bacon. Honestly, for the price, they could've gave extra extra bacon and it would've been a better sandwich. Also to order and pick up your food was a bit chaotic. They should have more structure within the store. read more

Best bagels in the area. Our go to when we have guest. The bagels are so fresh and I love the vegetable cream cheese!

This place sets the gold standard for bagels. Delicious bagels and awesome breakfast sandwiches. Love the extra cream cheese they put on the bagels. The Rahway Bomb is the Bomb!! read more

Rahway Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Picked up a bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. It was really good. I was scared because of all the negative reviews, but im glad i gave them a try and will totally be coming back. The guy behind the counter couldnt have been sweeter to us. read more

Super friendly, and attentive staff. It was a bit of a rush when we came around lunch time, and they got through everyone quickly and prepared the food quickly! I ordered a ham, egg, and cheese on everything bagel. The egg was a fried egg, which is crucial and was cooked well! Cheese tasted like a kraft single, which isn't my favorite. The bagel was a dense dough bagel which I loved! Great size and value for the money. read more

Rahway Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Gave it another go today. Ordered a Taylor ham and cream cheese on a poppy bagel, and some items to go, and it was good. It was before lunch rush, so the line wasn't long and was in/out fairly quick. My sandwich was nicely done and tasty. Highly recommend. read more

Rahway Bagels - Taylor ham and cream cheese on a poppy bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

As someone from the west coast, I had no idea what a "Taylor Ham" was until a recent work trip with a native who lived in Rahway and loves this place. She pre-ordered, one morning for us so I could have the real NJ experience and inhale one of these bad boys. The place was pretty dang busy at 8:15 in the morning, but they were quite efficient in getting folks in and out. Not the friendliest bunch behind the counter (like nobody smiles in NJ?) but I would excuse that after sinking my teeth into this breakfast sandwich. The everything bagel was on point, like I could have eaten a dozen of them by myself. I got mine with scrambled egg since a running egg freaks me out along with pepper and American cheese. I wanted this thing as close to traditional as I could get. I passed on the ketchup... but if I ever come back will try it that way. Taylor Ham reminds me of a cross between bacon and ham. It was super good, and I am happy I can now say I have had one of these things from a place that makes kick ass bagels. read more

Rahway Bagels - the front of the store - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

I had a toasted everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese and it was delicious! The place was pretty packed so I was prepared to have to wait 10+ minutes for my order but it was ready in a matter of 5 or less. A lot of bagel places I go to puts a pound of cream cheese on my bagel and I find myself taking some off a lot of the time. This place put an adequate/perfect amount. I will be back and I highly recommend. read more

Rahway Bagels - Toasted everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Love this place! Cheap and delicious, fresh bagels Everything made to order Just a solid place to grab a classic bacon, egg & cheese & a coffee for $5 It gets busy so call ahead of time read more

This ladys always forget something in my orde, plus I paid for thing that I don't gey worst place to get a begal

Absolutely love this place!!! The bagels are always fresh and super delicious! The owner is absolutely amazing and assures that you are all set and satisfied. I was so happy to find this gem when my husband and I moved to the area and would give it more than 5 stars if p read more

Having grown up in NYC where bagels are made in a more traditional manner, I tend to know a bit about them. Although there is almost always a long wait in the morning at any bagel establishment, today was no exception and my first time visit to Rahway Bagels off of St Georges Avenue. There's a variety of fresh bagels & spreads. I went for my go-to whole wheat bagel with veggie cream cheese. The bagel was huge, so soft and freshly made. They didn't skimp on the cream cheese as it's overflowing and tasty. Price is comparable to any bagel shop in the area as anything good isn't cheap. Definitely worth the wait even if there's a line as it goes quickly and merit a repeat performance. read more

See all

Walk in asked for menu there were 3 or 4 workers no one acknowledged me or my granddaughters, there were no other customers. I had ask for assistance which they took their time so by time they ready to take the order, me and grand children left I felt like they were being very disrespectful because we're BLACK I'm Very disappointed read more

Foods great. Down fall is ordering. Theres lines all over and it looks chaotic. Theres call orders, then online orders, and store orders. I always see angry faces lol read more

Great local spot for all your breakfast wants and desires, plus their own take on a loaded breakfast sandwich! The price point is excellent for anyone on a budget, but wanted a belly full. Wall lined with various flavors of bagels, and simple selection of breakfast drinks. You can't go wrong. read more

We found Rahway Bagels on Yelp while traveling through Jersey. We stopped in for a dozen and a half bagels to bring to my family for brunch plus. They had a great assortment of bagels available for a late Sunday morning. The bagels were fat, with the perfect chewy outer crust. Every flavor I tried was perfect. I could overdose on carbs from these amazing bagels. The staff was amazing, fast and dealt with my indecision and newbie-ness with ease. The price for what we got was low. I felt like we were ripping them off. This place is HIGHLY recommended. You should go there. Right away. I wish we lived closer. read more

Tastes great when they get your order right! I do like this place, I mean it's thirty minutes away and I still order here (on my way to the beach, not like, randomly and without strategy). But they really need to work on getting the line out quick and simple logistics. If you order ahead you should be out the door 10x faster than those who haven't ordered yet. Those are the only negatives...wrong orders and long wait times despite ordering ahead. If you have tons of free time on your hands, nothing to do, little self-worth, etc., then yeah, order and wait for some good food. The French toast bagel is the best in the world... ...if you don't have to cancel your GrubHub order because they don't have it for you 25 minutes later. read more

Stopped in on a Saturday morning for a bagel sandwich and was beyond impressed with my experience. The owner was there so I was able to place my order and have a good conversation with him. He recommended the sausage, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich add hash brown to the sandwich on an everything bagel. The sandwich was everything I needed to get my morning going. read more

See all

Never disappointed with this spot. Lines can be super long, but they move quick enough. Best bagels

Good bagels. Absolutely horrible service. One of the most disorganized places I've ever been to. Not out of the ordinary to wait over half an hour for a plain bagel with cream cheese. They seem to prioritize food courier services instead of walk in customers. Owner also always seems to belittle staff. Have been there numerous times. read more

Horrible - !!! Organization!! Everyone runs around discombobulated- You order 30mins before coming and your still waiting!! I'm going to circulate this message until they get it right!! read more

Don't ever EVER!! Order Grubhub delivery from Rahway bagels. Customer service was awful! Will be my last time ever ordering! What a shame poor customer care and services. Especially from there pick up drivers for Grubhub lost in the sauce for sure! read more

There's a reason that this place is always packed. Bagels are of generous size, and always fresh and tasty. Never a complaint.