I already knew that Dr. Plancher was an exceptionally talented, careful, and comprehensive…read morediagnostician and surgeon because of his excellent work with several members of my family, some of whom had complex cases. (Those stories are worth another 5 stars -- even more if that were possible!) I had never had the need to see him myself until recently when I fell while hiking, landing on my knee. I treated the injury myself with ice and anti-inflammatories, but the healing was slow, and I became concerned that I had damaged it more than I knew. This was an issue because I was training for a 60-mile fundraising walk -- a walk I had been training for for 6 months -- and needed to know that participating in the walk wouldn't do additional damage. Time was of the essence -- I had only two weeks before the event -- so I called the office and asked if they could squeeze me in -- during a week with two holidays no less. They moved heaven and earth to get me in. Dr. Plancher and his team were thorough, spending a great deal of time with me. After an x-ray and MRI we discovered that I had bone contusions and could participate in the walk with a brace, anti-inflammatories as needed, and some common sense. The walk went really well, and my knee felt strong during and following. Thanks so much to Dr. Plancher and his entire team for helping me realize my goal and keep my knee safe at the same time.

Dr. Plancher saved my life. I'm a marathon runner and I totally destroyed my ACL training for…read morelast years NYC marathon. Thanks to Dr Plancher and his amazing surgical techniques, I'm back training 5-10 miles a day. He's a genius.

Excellent experience. Doctor explained everything to me and the course of treatment necessary to…read moremy type of injury.

Extremely happy with the practice. All service providers (reception, x-ray tech, two dr. Assistants…read more& dr. Beldner) were courteous, informative & professional. The office greets you with free coffee & cookies. I was seen before my appt time, & while they X-rayed both my hands, I was in & out in a matter of 35 minutes with a diagnosis & treatment. Also, as I may need follow-up care in 6 to 8 weeks, but will be in FL at that time, the Dr. referred me to 2 potential doctors in FL who could serve me. I WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PRACTICE/Dr. I was very impressed. Hence, why I chose to review them without any prompting, despite me never having done so for a doctor before.

Terrible experience with although she was recently listed in 100 Best Doctors. She operated on my…read moretoes three years ago,and I still have pain and discomfort. Although pleasant, I would not recommend her.

Excellent orthopedic surgeon. She repaired my left toe with a fusion. She is a superb doctor -…read moreknowledgable, skillful surgeon, great communicator who is very clear and informative.

If I could give infinity stars I would! AMAZING surgeon. Had a meniscus tear done yesterday. Been…read morewalking on it since I walked out of the hospital, slept well and did NOT need any meds. Did not fill the prescription ibuprofen, did not fill the oxycodone, did not need extra strength Tylenol. Iced and elevated it. I am doing great post op 24 hours! I even ironed last night! WOW! Its worth mentioning too, he is SUPER thorough when explaining in detail your situation AND has the BEST bedside manner. He follows up with a post op call in the evening, he is the Mercedes of doctors and HIGHLY recommended!! So grateful.

He could not care less about my rehab, only gave me 3 minutes of his time on every appointment, and…read morebasically responded my questions as I was asking them (i.e. did not give a F* what I was telling him). Even his team would tell me they did not agree with his recommendations. In the end I decided to change Dr for the rest of my recovery journey (ACL + meniscus tear)

I have been seeing Doctor Simhaee for almost 10 years. He is an exceptional physician and takes…read moreamazing care of me. He always goes out of his way to make sure I understand all of my options. He has injected me several times in the last 10 years and without his interventions I would be miserable.

If I could post 0 stars- I would…read more I have often taken the time to write a positive review and publicly thank someone, I have never written a negative review, until now. I had an 11:45AM appointment yesterday to see Dr. Jonathan Simhaee in the Englewood office. I arrived at 11:40AM and checked in. 45-minutes later at 12:30PM I asked the receptionist when the doctor might be ready to see me (as I watched 8-9 other patients called, some of them coming in after me). Her response was "he will see you soon," and then went back to chatting with colleagues. At 12:45PM, I again asked and was told "there are two people ahead of you..." What??? How? No emotion and no sense of concern. I realized then I was just a number in the system, which was so surprising because the doctor who referred me goes out of his way to make his patients feel like they really matter. Finally, at 1:15PM, I approached to remind her I had been waiting 1 1/2hours. A puzzled look came over her face: What was happening!!! After she checked her computer screen for a couple of minutes (not sure for what), she went in the back and next thing I knew someone called my name. I went into Dr. Simhaee's office and he entered shortly after me, and without even looking up, or making any reference or apology for running so late, (we're not talking 15-30-minutes, but 1 1/2 hours!) he just launched into "so what's the problem, even though the referring doctor had sent him a full report and MRI results which he hadn't bothered to read. It also hit me at that moment that when I last saw this doctor, 5-years ago, I had a similar negative experience. Unfortunately, my memory kicked in too late. I knew at this point that there was no way I was going to stay, even if it meant spiting myself. This place is a factory. I also knew at this point for my own sanity, I had to ask Dr. Simhaee what happened, hoping his response might evidence some concern or understanding. Instead, I got.... "I'm slammed; it's the holidays; I had an emergency." There was no apology or sense of concern." besides throwing the receptionist under the bus and saying he would talk to her later. I am the first to acknowledge that emergencies happen and appointments can run over time. That said, there's a way this should have been handled and it starts in the waiting room with the receptionist or whoever expressing some concern or acknowledgment of the situation. That didn't happen, ZILCH! So, I couldn't really be surprised when there was no acknowledgment from Jonathan SImhaee. This holier than thou culture flows from the top. Keeping patients waiting is "business as usual here." There's no other reasonable conclusion in the absence of someone from management "owning," acknowledging and attempting to ameliorate the situation. Here, the doctor-patient relationship is purely transactional. I am in the process of securing a new appointment with a new doctor.

Denies medically necessary tests and treatments for insurance companies. He is in the pocket of…read moreinsurance companies and patients suffer as a result. I am baffled he is associated with Mt. Sinai, I would have had high expectations of their physicians. Dr. Arsht did not even read my notes when he denied treatments for my patient. I would hope this review would motivate him to be a more ethical physician.

Suddenly stopped taking marketplace insurance and won't even accept self-paying patients. This…read moredoesn't mean you can't make an appointment through MyMountSinai - you can, but someone will just unilaterally cancel it without providing a proper explanation. Time to find an orthopedist who cares about helping patients more than maximizing profits. The whole Mount Sinai system is a nightmare, but I'm told this is this doctor's individual decision. So gross.

EXCEPTIONAL in every single aspect. There's A LOT of people claiming to be skilled enough to help…read moreyou, yet to leave you feeling hopeless. This isn't the case with Dr Tim Canty. His academic achievements speak for themselves. What sets him apart from other physicians is his drive to actually make a difference and provide relief from pain, which many of us have been told is in our minds, or we have to just deal with because everything's been tried. That isn't always the case. Dr Canty has gone out of his way, cancelled his personal plans to accommodate my own schedule to treat a chronic condition that I thought would never go away. I am a physician and I can assure you that you're in the best hands with Dr Canty. There's so many different types of treatments that many doctors don't know about. Dr Canty & his staff are by far at the TOP of their game. Definitely 5*****

I don't know if this doctor is any good or not because I never managed to have a consultation with…read morehim, but his staff, I had plenty of interaction with them and on a scale of 0-10 they rate a stellar -10! It took an entire week of me calling daily asking to make an appointment and being put on hold for so long the line would eventually hang up. Countless times the call would go straight to voicemail where I left messages to please call me back, but no one ever did. Finally, on my last attempt a week later, I let out my frustration on the woman who actually did answer the phone managed to make an appointment. I gave her all my information as a new patient and all my insurance details. I received a text confirmation regarding my appointment for a few days later. On the day of, and after a costly Uber ride into the city I walked into the doctors office feeling a sense relief to finally put this saga behind me and finally get the medical attention I so desperately needed for my pain. I filled out all the necessary pages of paperwork, gave my insurance details yet again although they already had them on file only to be asked fifteen minutes later by one of receptionists who made this appointment for me because the doctor does not work with this insurance and if I wanted to see Dr. Canty, I would have to pay $500 out of pocket. It was a feat to contain my composure and not lunge at them. Never have I ever experienced such incompetence and lack of professionalism in what is supposed to be a reputable doctors office.

Checking for pain management today. Dr Rosen is friendly and the office is clean and most of the…read morestaff are really nice

People can always tell you what to do. When you see a person who looks healthy and present…read morethemselves professionally, that is when you listen. Dr. Andrew Rosen is a Gem in Orthopedics. He is a highly valued person with the look of hope that things will get better. The clinic is very welcoming. It clean and well kept. The x-ray room is comfortable. Service is quick, professional and caring. The Paperwork is done efficiently to make sure you get what you need to complete your examination. No questions unanswered. Everything is explained. When you leave you feel this is a place I want to come back to because I am getting great care.