-30 Food was terrible. We had nachos, pretzel, and wings. Wings were okay, but the other two came with flavorless queso and the nachos just had salad greens on top. The worst part of our entire trip to Put-In-Bay was the Ray Fogg show. He was way too vulgar, and our entire table hated having to sit through his show. We all have a twisted sense of humor, but he was too much. He was also way too loud so it was impossible to enjoy our time without hearing his garbage set the whole time. read more

Our favorite bar at Put in Bay! The atmosphere here is great. Great service, one of the bartender here got best /top bartender in Ohio. The Monea brothers were playing, they are very good and they get everyone involved. They plays music you can sing along with. Now the food, absolutely delicious. Had the bourbon burger, omg so good. Made perfectly. We also had to Brussels sprout taco, surprisingly very delicious as well. Had to try and see. This place will not disappoint. read more

See all

This was our last stop on the island. Loved our bartenders - they were super friendly and chatted with us about the island and its inhabitants. We were there in late September so it was super quiet. I loved the big "pay it forward" board where you can pay for a drink for someone and they can claim in later (within one year). We just got drinks, but the food menu looked really tasty. Nate got the hot honey Manhattan, which was very good! We loved the kick from the hot honey. I got a 1oz pour of Blanton's which was very reasonably priced. They have a pretty extensive bourbon menu for a sports bar. Lots of sports team memorabilia, would be a fun place to watch a game. read more

See all

After spending a weekend on Put in Bay Island our experience at the Reel Bar was the best hands-down of the weekend. Their food was absolutely delicious. They had a comedian performing and the ambience was great. read more

Reel Bar - Chocolate martini - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

I went with a large party and we were split into two tables. The Bloody Mary was excellent. The tacos not so much.... They were tiny, expensive, and unimpressive. The shrimp taco had 3 little shrimp and was nothing special, the pork belly taco was spicy and lacked any sort of texture. The hand cut fries made up for the taco disappointment. read more

Reel Bar - Pork belly and shrimp taco - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

This place was awesome. Came here to see our friends from Key West play and we weren't disappointed in the food, the bartenders and the atmosphere. Very cool inside, clean and hip. If we come back to Put-In-Bay, this is a must stop. read more

See all

We visited here our first night and found it charming. We sat outside and enjoyed the lobster rolls and a local IPA. Our server was friendly and attentive. read more

Reel Bar - Lobster roll - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

This place had great food as well as lovely cocktails. We appreciated that they were open despite it being the off season read more

Reel Bar - Cocktails! - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Great guest service in a high ceiling, open bar setting with a small patio area. They have Vegan options with a couple menu alterations. I got the Sloppy Joe with a lettuce wrap and a side salad. My partner got the grouper sandwich which they loved!! If you are vegan--the staff and cooks were very accommodating and helpful in figuring out what could be arranged. Just gotta ask :) read more

See all

2nd try is the charm. Tried for breakfast that morning and just stood & stood with no acknowledgement from staff as the sign clearly stated wait to be seated.... Tried later in the day for a late lunch ... outdoor seat with N umbrella... great wait staff! Recommend the 1/2 shrimp and it was fantastic!!! Had a pork belly taco and a shrimp taco both very flavorful! Live music was great! Beer selection and the blueberry vodka lemonade with fresh blueberries fabulous! read more

Reel Bar - Entrance - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

QUALITY SERVICE so we all love the reel bar it's a great alternative to roundhouse if ur not feeling it! Fantastic reel burg. Beautiful waitresses. Cheap booze for the island anyway. Funny T-shirt's. It's always a must visit for me anyway, but this time I parked by the police station. Save a trip later I thought HA. So I walk up the stairs & the boss man is telling people to hold up, we shut down for a minute for cleaning around 4. So I walk right by oblivious and sit down the bar. I get a couple rum & cokes & chat up Erica and blah blah blah drink drink drink. Couple wraps up their lunch and leaves. Meantime there's a line out the ass outside waiting to get in. They're cleaning the tables sweeping restocking and there I am. People are looking inside like what's with Gilligan there at the bar?? Well I wrapped up the day drink said my goodbyes to the bartendress and see the man on the way out. He unchains the stair gate, there ya go buddy. I said hey Man whoops u were closing it down and I had my happy hour anyway. Nice guy, WHO CARES HE SEZ, SOMETIME'S ITS ALL ABOUT TIMING. Another memorable trip to the reel bar, where apparently we're all VIPs. 10 stars. read more

See all

Stopped in to the Reel Bar to try the Reel Royal Red Shrimp. We were not disappointed!! These deep water shrimp were amazing. When dipped into the melted butter, they tasted just like lobster. Thumbs up to our waiter Vito too. read more

Reel Bar - Royal Red Shrimp. - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Don't show up and try to drink with a Michigan REAL ID. Whole staff on hand was incompetent. Out dated ID verification book.

Food was good. Comedy show was a nice extra. Service was good as well. Price was pretty normal for the island.

The food was great, very fresh! We had a grouper sandwich, shrimp street tacos and a caprese salad. The highlight of our meal was our server, Nate!! He was kind, knowledgeable and lots of fun. He made the meal a pleasure. Look for him when you visit and I hope the restaurant rewards him for his efforts!! read more

It was our first trip to Put-In-Bay and we stopped here for lunch. It's mayfly season (yuck) so we sat Indoors. Ronnie was our server and he was outstanding. He let us know that they were known for their burgers and let us know his favorite. He was quick with the drinks and stayed on top of refills. We ordered the loaded tots and wow! These are not your average Dayton Ohio tots! They seriously should be called something else, these were so much better than tots! Huge potato balls covered with cheese and bacon deliciousness. They were a meal themselves. They seemed expensive when ordering but when they arrived it all made sense. We both ordered the Sweet Bourbon Burger (I know, we just have the same tastes I guess) cooked medium with fries. The burger was cooked perfectly! It was huge and hard for me to finish after those "tots" but it had good flavor, good crunch, and I would get it again. As we wrapped up Ronnie asked what we'd be doing later and filled us in on what would be going on at the bar. He was very personable and proficient and is the type of person I would want working for me of I owned a bar. read more

See all

this was the worst espresso martini I've ever had and will ever have. I'm not sure how something could top how awful it was. Do not waste $14 on it. It's a ploy because they're trendy right now. DO NOT I REPEAT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THE ESPRESSO MARTINI. food was fine. read more

Worst service on PIB. Marginal food can't overcome the lack of passion of Staff. There are a lot better options on the island...

Honesty I had to review due to the outrageous prices we were charged and the bad food we were served. Not cool.

Amazing everything!!! In a place where mostly fried bar food is all you can find, this place has some fresh and healthy menu items that I'll be back for time and time again! read more

The BBQ chicken wrap was very tasty as was the smokehouse burger. They have a nice patio where you can people watch. Our waiter, Vito was very friendly. This is a good place to stop for lunch. read more

See all

Excellent service, atmosphere and music. The food and drinks were supreme! Definitely recommend and look forward to being a patron again!

The food was good especially the chipotle chicken wrap. The servers were kind. I would definitely recommend eating here.

Love this place, we try to come here often. Everyone knows about the shrimp but get the tots, they are delicious. Cassidy is amazing, great server, attentive and fun. Two thumbs up! read more

Highly Recommend!!!! Lobster roll, all their burgers, fries, top drawer! So fresh & delicious! Great staff/service & super clean restaurant. Did I mention fun? Must visit while at PIB read more

Three years ago my family had a terrible experience at Reel Bar. On a recent trip to put in bay (October 2022) my family decided to give Reel Bar another try. All I have to say is WOW in terms of the difference. On the first visit (we went twice...get to that in a minute) the place was slammed. However, we were seated quickly and the hostess made sure the table and chairs were clean and the table properly set for our group of 8. After that the experience only stayed consistently great. The waitress was spot on and wonderful with our table which included 5 kids. From beginning to end the experience was flawless. We even decided to go again during our visit just to see if the experience would be similar. I have to say it was just the same. Great food, great service and great atmosphere. I even made sure to seek out the owner to let him know and to acknowledge what an improvement from that first visit years ago. Do yourself a favor and head to Reel Bar. BEST restaurant on the island by FAR. I strongly recommend the fried pickles, literally best I have ever had anywhere and believe me I get them every where I go. read more

Good food had 2 mini lobster rolls,hamburger special both with hot fries drinks were spot on our server Angela c was very prompt and fun to converse with always make sure to stop at least once a summer read more

Amazing food & service! I highly recommend!!!!! Lobster roll, hamburgers & French fries are so delish!! Add to that talented local entertainers... a must when you visit PIB! read more

Nice surprise on the bay. If you are a shrimp fan you have to try the Red shrimp. Don't be scared by the price-it's worth it. Easily best shrimp I've ever had. So much so I went home to try finding red shrimp. Soooo good. Slap yo momma good! read more

Really solid food, great costumer service, and a fun atmosphere. I don't think it's the best seafood I've had on the island, but it does the job. The food and drinks are a little pricey. Expect to pay $10 for all your drinks and $8 for a taco but both will be very good. read more

Two stars because the food was very good but extremely overpriced for the portion sizes. We paid $179 for 3 apps and drinks for a party of nine. $20 for the smallest nacho ive ever seen in my life. Very disappointed. When I asked for more chips for the nacho the waitress charged us $6 for a small plate of chips. I complained about the sIze of the nachos and the waitress pretty much just walked away. read more

Older crowd which I like. Good food and the best servers on the Island (most of them are worthless). They get bands all summer. We saw Crooked. They are great. Place is owned by a dude names Ray. Mix Don Knotts, Dice Clay and Jimmy Buffet and you got this dude. Hes a trip. Come check this place out to get away from the roofie, bro and hen parties at the other bars... read more

Reel Bar - Crooked sangin' - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

The atmosphere is very nice, and it appears that the locals dine here often as the servers were falling all over themselves to keep them happy. We started with the tater tot appetizer, but were disappointed. These are home made tater tots, and lack flavor. The presentation is nice, but they are missing something like onions. I had the buffalo chicken flatbread, which had a wonderful taste, but lacked actual chicken. There were only five small pieces of chicken on the whole flatbread, which was disappointing. My husband had a cheeseburger and fries and they were great. Burger was cooked perfectly and the fries were hot and fresh. Service was spotty, which was annoying as there were only 3 tables of customers. We had to ask for everything. The menu has a lot of odd choices, and even for a resort town, the prices are high. In particular, the grilled cheese sandwich for 10.95 is a bit extreme. They offer music at night and there is a nice bar. read more

South Bass Island, Ohio --- I kinda thought the "Reel Bar" being off the main street (Delaware Avenue) would have better bartenders, nicer atmosphere, better prices, or something that would make me leave wanting more ... I was wrong on everything! The Walleye fish sandwich was like eating a grease sandwich, the fries were limp, the bartender was young & inexperienced (spent all her time working on bar restocking, rather than customers), definitely nothing inexpensive, and the atmosphere is too sterile ... REEL bad food / REEL bad service / REEL expensive "Run-A-Way Bill" was here! 06.17.16 p.s. Someone complained to Yelp after my initial "honest" review and had some of my pics I posted removed. Since the owner called me personally about my review, I am jumping to conclusions and "assuming" it was someone from the "REEL" bad restaurant "Run-A-Way Bill" was here! 07.07.16 read more

See all

Stopped by on a Wednesday for lunch. Awesome spot. Great beer selection, walleye sandwich was great and substantial, delicious fries and outstanding service. Probably won't return to Put- In-Bay, but if I do we'll definitely get back to this spot. read more

We stopped here for dinner on a Thursday night and it was pretty dead. We sat outside on the patio and there is a decent amount of space. Drinks were decent but a little pricey. That applies for the food menu as well. The prices are a little steep, but the food was good. The onion rings were great, and the chicken wings/chunks were good as well. Our server was somewhat inattentive, but since they were slow I'm sure she was working on side work/ chatting which is understandable. Good place to stop for a bite to eat! read more

Darn near impossible to find vegan options in PIB, so when I called and they said the Veggie Sloppy Joe AND the Black Bean Burger were BOTH vegan my stomach fluttered! I can attest to the deliciousness of the Sloppy Joe. And my whole fam went nuts for the fries. I'll be back to have the burger by the time we depart. Our server (wish I caught her name!) was absolutely lovely and totally on top of her game. Highly recommend!! read more

Reel Bar - Veggie Sloppy Joe - American Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

I thought the food was horrible and ate 1 bite and said it sucked and they gave me 10% off wouldn't recommend at all

Came in for drinks it was a Monday night and the staff here was so friendly we told them we ordered a pizza and we're going to go eat it shortly, the bartender told us we could bring it back and eat there if we liked. The drinks were good and the patio area was nice. Definitely come back here again. read more

We always stop in for breakfast when we are on the island. They have great biscuits and gravy! Top em with some over medium eggs...yes please!! My only qualm is sometimes the service is spotty. But usually always a great breakfast! And you can have a drink from their bar with your breakfast! It's overall my fav breakfast place on the island! read more