My wife and I stopped here for lunch after a train ride in from NYC, it was our first time at Reruns but won't be our last.
It is a small, but friendly establishment - as the only non-regulars in the place it could have been uncomfortable, but Karen the bartender treated us like old friends. The owner/chef (didn't catch his name) was friendly, and a great guy.
They told us (most of) the food is homemade. We had the French onion soup made by the owners wife (incredible), a buffalo chicken wrap with tots (very good sauce), a $19 lobster grilled cheese that tasted better than a $40 one elsewhere, and finally the clams over linguini (a special, I think). All of the food was delicious, they clearly take pride in their work.
We had a couple beers (not sure the price) and finished off with an Irish coffee and a spiked hot chocolate - both were perfect.
What an unexpected but 5 star experience. Amazing food, friendly staff, and friendly regulars (they had us cracking up the whole time).
Don't let the small space, or divey vibes throw you off - Reruns is a gem and we can't wait to go back! read more