I first visited 58 Main BBQ & Brew (Brockport, NY) in January of this year, and from that very…read morefirst experience, I knew this place was special. The service is outstanding, the food is delicious, and the atmosphere is welcoming and friendly--a combination that keeps me coming back. On my first visit, I ordered the Three Brothers Special, which lets you choose three different meats and two sides. I went with chicken, brisket, and ribs, and let me tell you--every bite was packed with smoky, tender, fall-off-the-bone goodness. It was the kind of meal that makes you sit back and appreciate great barbecue. Since that night, I've returned four or five more times. And here's the thing--I don't live in Brockport. I live in Pittsford, a solid 30-minute drive away. But when you find a place that not only serves amazing food but also makes you feel truly welcomed, it's worth the extra miles. Sue, my server on my first visit, made sure I felt at home, and the rest of the staff has continued that same welcoming energy every time I've returned. I've even made a few friends--regulars who recognize me now, and say hello whenever walk in. This restaurant holds a special place in my heart. After a long, stressful day, when I need to unwind and reset, I don't hesitate--I set my navigation to 58 Main BBQ & Brew and take the trip. Because sometimes, great food is just food. But when it's served with genuine kindness and a sense of belonging, it becomes something more. If you're looking for phenomenal barbecue, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere, this is the spot. Five stars, every time. My Order: 3 Brother's Special: comes with three meats. I chose half a chicken, ribs and brisket. My two sides were macaroni, salad and coleslaw. It also comes with a side of cornbread, which was delicious.

Not really sure what happened throughout the years but it didn't go good for the place. Came here…read morewith family from PA and we told them it was a great place for years, however tonight it wasn't. One member wanted Medium Rare steak and got Medium Well. Another wanted Medium and got Medium Rare. Someone else wanted mac salad and got mac&cheese. Someone got a burger and it was blackened! I ordered medium buffalo wings and the sauce didn't taste right at all. Same for the blue cheese/ranch/i don't even know because taste was so off! Plus wings were also overdone. 1hr wait time and I get they were busy - we were chatting during this time as well. Noise volume was ok and not really has changed throughout the years but definitely might need a new chef. Also saw the kitchen violations - should've checked the seating too. One of us almost got hurt due to a broken chair. Someone else had a wobbly chair as well.

We had an early Father's Day dinner and sat on the outside patio with our dog. It was a perfect…read morespot overlooking the canal. The fried cauliflower appetizer was delicious and so were the Caprese chicken sandwich, Crispy Chicken Mac and Nashville Hot Chicken. A special mention for our server, Taya. She went over and above! Not only was she friendly and on top of her game, she also was wonderful with our dog, Murphy, who is usually shy around new people. We felt lucky to have her as our server. We'll be back next time we're in the area!

I don't like to give more difficult reviews, especially after working in the customer service…read moreindustry for nearly 15 years myself. But this is the third noteworthy experience with this restaurant, and I've never had an experience quite like the one I had a few days ago. When we arrived the host let us know that the outside eating area was busy and asked if we would like to sit inside. We were hopeful to wait and sit outside, but when we asked how long the wait would be for the patio, the host said, "I don't know." Which I registered as an unusual response. Regardless, we opted to stay and sit inside, since it was pretty empty and wouldn't be too hot. This turned out to be beneficial because our server was attentive, while there seemed to be a miscommunication between the two servers outside regarding who was covering which table. Folks kept coming in and saying they hadn't had a server visit their table yet despite being there for 20+ minutes. Which my parents and I were witnessing from watching out the window. When we were able to order, they were out of all of their specials and some of their key dishes which was quite frustrating. Our food took a while, but it was clear at this point that they were understaffed, so it was understandable. However, when our food was delivered, the food runner let us know they were out of silverware?? I ordered a garbage plate and my dad had a salad with his meal... certainly not finger foods. After a few minutes our server realized what happened and told the food runner to wash some silverware and bring it out to us. Such a bizarre situation. The food was good, but didn't make up for the environment of the evening. There was not a manager in sight to assist, coach, or help troubleshoot. And our server had to double as the bartender while also covering all of the tables inside, which filled up throughout the night. This restaurant has so much potential to be successful and the staff was working so hard. Management/ownership need to step up and support them.

Just what we needed for some girlfriend time after going to the coffee shop needed a cocktail and…read moresome good lunch. Thank you Michelle. I don't know how you do it. It was a room full of people and you handled us all.

Friday was our first time there. We were seated right away for some drinks and a late lunch…read more Service was outstanding and I enjoyed was the atmosphere at the bar. Many seemed to know one another and it reminded me of a modern Cheers type feel. We ordered the turkey wrap with waffle fries and the Korean Good For Your Soeul Burger and tater tots. Everything was absolutely delicious and enough for two meals. I would highly recommend the Old Stone Tavern. That extra crisp on my tater tots and melt in your mouth flavor on the burger was on point!

Greatly limited choices recently on beverages & menu. Food quality seems to have degraded altho…read morestaff continues to be pleasant & attentive. Hopefully this is just a bump in the road for Robbie & things return to the way it's been there for a long time

All around great experience, food, drinks, service. Friday and Saturday entertainment is always…read moregood. One of my favorites is their grilled garlic parm wings

I am updating my review because the food quality has gone into the toilet since new management took…read moreover. I have eaten here several times in the past and ordered the exact same thing every time. I always order the Philli Cheese Steak Sandwich. This is the first time eating here since the new management took over. It appears that besides turning the hotel into a one star hotel, they have really messed up the food in this restaurants. If you look at my original photo of the sandwich, envision the sandwich with a reduction of the meat of about 40%, hardly any peppers abd onions and the cheese sauce is now like watery cheese soup and there is 50% less than it used to be. With the food and hotel are really bad now and the minimum bets on the penny machines jacked up to 80 cents from 40 cents, this is the last time I will ever go to Batavia Downs for the food, gaming or hotel.

Service was excellent with Shannon as our bartender. She was fast and friendly. Food was ok. Nachos…read morewere soggy.

Bru is a bit of a divvy location but oriented toward a sports bar. Staff was friendly. Plenty of…read moreparking. The menu item was vast and we ordered the pizza which was good. Restroom was a bit of a wreck and floors/tables sticky. We were here for a team event. Plenty of space for a large crowd.

I came here with my mommy and papa on a Saturday afternoon. I got an expresso martini and fried…read morepickles . mama got a peanut butter milkshake, and Papa got 7 different IPAs because Mama Bear and Baby Bear (me) have been a handful all week! They have a great selection of IPAs. Great restaurant for family celebrations (we celebrated my new job as a planned parenthood patient recruiter)!!!!! Highly recommend!!!

ZERO STARS!!! Waited…read more25 minutes for a table. Sat for 20 minutes and no one even came over to ask for our drink order. Two tables that were seated after us got their drinks and ordered their food. We walked out.

Recently visited for the first time for trivia night. I punched the address into my GPS, and it had…read moreme park behind a building next door. Because this place is tucked back, I couldn't find it to save my life. You actually want to park and enter through the Batavia bootery. This info is just to help other YELPERS. Once I found this place, we were immediately seated, and were waiting on a 4th person. We were sat, and probably waited 30-40 minutes for someone to swing by and take our drink order. If we weren't there for trivia, I'm confident that we would've left. All of our drinks (lemonade and soda products) tasted off, and we all sent our drinks back. My lemonade was WAYYYYY TOOOOO sweet. We got water, and ordered food. Food was okay. I ordered loaded fries. They were okay, but those tasted off too like they were fried in old oil maybe? Waitress was nice and apologetic. I don't fault her for anything and felt a little bad for her. Not sure if I'll be back outside of trivia

After adventuring at Holley Canal Falls, we stopped by Back Porch 585 Tavern for some grub. We've…read morechosen to sit outside where we were served by a very kind waitress. Starting off with one of their house-made soups, the New England Clam Chowder was scrumptious. A nice thick and well-seasoned soup. For mains, I opted in for their Fish Fry which is offered every Friday and Saturday. I inquired whether the fish was fresh or frozen and was informed fresh. This was one of the best fish fries I've had anywhere. Crispy batter, and moist and flaky fish. For sides, I asked for coleslaw and mac salad. The coleslaw was nothing to write home about and I felt was a bit bland. As for the mac salad, one of the better mac salads I've had. Normally it tastes like the fridge, but this one was nicely seasoned. This restaurant took me by surprise and I'm glad to have stopped by and had one of the best fish fries ever.

Great food And good vibes…read more Service was ok Worth the trip And left a good tip Haven't heard any complaints that really mattered

Outstanding service our waitress's were outstanding they checked on us and informed us that our…read moreorder was going to be 15 minutes cause we had a special order added to the chicken wings. You have to try there blueberry mojitos bbq wings outstanding my wife and I also ordered the French onion prime rib sandwich really good flavor. The decor of the restaurant was dark but pub style decor which made it feel friendly and relaxed which allowed us to enjoy each other's company we also found out that they make everything from scratch including the dressing great job

For a celebratory dinner, four of us sat near the kitchen door. Servers was trying to move us along…read morelike it was a Friday night, inappropriately fast. The place was half seated. From the get-go small bugs flew around us all at the table. Possible fruit flies problem. I was able to kill one. I presented it on a napkin to the young man who was cleaning tables. I asked him to give this to the manager stating there was a bug problem that annoyed our dinner. Crickets! Spaghetti sauce is too thick like a paste. Not good. The stuffed mushrooms appetizer was drop dead delicious. I wouldn't be bothered writing this if not for the bug problem with no managerial comment.

Their garbage plates are very delicious! Friendly service and they sincerely care about their…read morecustomers.

Great little spot right on Main. Food is great and service is fast. Got the Muck plate, it was…read moregreat.