I first visited 58 Main BBQ & Brew (Brockport, NY) in January of this year, and from that very…read morefirst experience, I knew this place was special. The service is outstanding, the food is delicious, and the atmosphere is welcoming and friendly--a combination that keeps me coming back. On my first visit, I ordered the Three Brothers Special, which lets you choose three different meats and two sides. I went with chicken, brisket, and ribs, and let me tell you--every bite was packed with smoky, tender, fall-off-the-bone goodness. It was the kind of meal that makes you sit back and appreciate great barbecue. Since that night, I've returned four or five more times. And here's the thing--I don't live in Brockport. I live in Pittsford, a solid 30-minute drive away. But when you find a place that not only serves amazing food but also makes you feel truly welcomed, it's worth the extra miles. Sue, my server on my first visit, made sure I felt at home, and the rest of the staff has continued that same welcoming energy every time I've returned. I've even made a few friends--regulars who recognize me now, and say hello whenever walk in. This restaurant holds a special place in my heart. After a long, stressful day, when I need to unwind and reset, I don't hesitate--I set my navigation to 58 Main BBQ & Brew and take the trip. Because sometimes, great food is just food. But when it's served with genuine kindness and a sense of belonging, it becomes something more. If you're looking for phenomenal barbecue, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere, this is the spot. Five stars, every time. My Order: 3 Brother's Special: comes with three meats. I chose half a chicken, ribs and brisket. My two sides were macaroni, salad and coleslaw. It also comes with a side of cornbread, which was delicious.

Not really sure what happened throughout the years but it didn't go good for the place. Came here…read morewith family from PA and we told them it was a great place for years, however tonight it wasn't. One member wanted Medium Rare steak and got Medium Well. Another wanted Medium and got Medium Rare. Someone else wanted mac salad and got mac&cheese. Someone got a burger and it was blackened! I ordered medium buffalo wings and the sauce didn't taste right at all. Same for the blue cheese/ranch/i don't even know because taste was so off! Plus wings were also overdone. 1hr wait time and I get they were busy - we were chatting during this time as well. Noise volume was ok and not really has changed throughout the years but definitely might need a new chef. Also saw the kitchen violations - should've checked the seating too. One of us almost got hurt due to a broken chair. Someone else had a wobbly chair as well.

I ordered a double bacon cheeseburger combo with fries. The meat was not bad but the pictures I…read moreattached show how greasy it was. The bottom half of the bun was so saturated with grease that I couldn't pick it up and it was soggy, floppy and I couldn't eat it. I ate the meat with a knife and fork. The fries were crinkle cut, the kind you buy in the freezer section at any grocery store, and had no seasoning, no flavor, nothing special at all. I could have done better at home. Overall, very disappointing and gross. It's a shame. I wanted to support a local business, but burgers don't need to saturate the bun to taste good. When I go to a restaurant, I expect the food to be better than what I could make myself at home.

Long wait Overpriced…read moreBurger was not that great for all the hype Stay home and save to our money

This was my first occasion to go to Custom House under the new ownership and management. Fantastic…read morelunch. I brought my wife and two daughters. The food was delicious and prepared with love and care. The menu is outstanding with really thoughtful choices that I now cannot wait to try. Something for everyone. Definitely elevated Pub Food. Every one of us was excited about our meal. I will definitely return soon. My highest recommendation. P.s. The service was also great

I'm in brockport at lest one's a week and have been meaning to check this place out, it's a…read morebeautiful tavern Lake restaurant with a basement bar overlooking the Erie Canal. Service was amazing and amazing recommendations. It was a Friday so I asked about the fish fry and I talked about how I liked it. Nice and crispy. When it came out, it was perfectly cooked and excellent crispy. You could definitely tell the server pay attention to me talking and had the food cooked to my liking!! Amazing place 100% would go again and would recommend to anyone else !! Ps. You need to get the French onion it was to die for

I was really excited to try this place out with some friends and had such a good experience I left…read moreready to come back again soon! The place is super cute! They have a great covered patio, in addition to another small patio with a pergola. Unfortunately it was raining during our visit, so we opted to sit inside, but the patio along with the nice weather we have been having made us plan our next visit already! When we arrived the bartender told us that they were having a Community Day and had a complimentary lunch buffet, so needless to say I didn't end up ordering a meal from the menu. Really enjoyed the food, pulled pork, watermelon, a salad with a lot of good toppings, salt potatoes, and brownies! Wow! What a neat event! The menu did look good, so i'll update my review when we stop back at the end of June! They have a variety of their own wines and beer for sale, in addition to some hard ciders. However, after the bartender recommended the mango wine slushie I just couldn't go with anything else. It was the perfect refreshing drink to enjoy. I am already looking forward to my next visit and encourage everyone to stop out for some good food and drinks!

Amazing service and great food. Burgers, chili, fries and coffee were the best. Would definitely…read morecome back. 10/10

This is always a more of a nostalgic review more than anything... the place has not changed in 35…read moreyears... same old stale smell.... Great beers on tap. The cooks are college kids who are not trained chef but they do a great job. Epic sandwich, the balboa, and sports on 24/7. The copper ceiling can date back over 100 years... I come every-time I get into town. Mackenzie was my bartender who was great....

The rub bal is sandwich is one of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time! Perfect balance of…read moreflavors and the roll is perfect. Love this little dive bar in Brockport that serves food until 1:00 am!!!

Everything was delicious! You MUST get the mac and cheese. My husband loved the pretzels. The…read moreburger was so flavorful. Service was so friendly and made us feel like family. The restaurant is beautifully appointed. We enjoyed dining on the deck overlooking the course. To top it off pricing was so reasonable. We can't wait to come back!

Our food was decent, burger was cooked well done when I ordered medium but it was edible so I…read moredidn't complain, the scallops weren't seared very well and were somewhat rubbery, the spicy rigatoni was good and it was indeed spicy, and the coconut grouper was very good. Our service overall was hit or miss with a rocky start, when we asked for a minute to look at the menu to decide on an appetizer we lost our server for about 20 minutes, after we ordered our drinks we were brought IPA's instead of Kolsch but that was rectified right away, and the rest of the service went smoothly. Overall I would return and give it another chance, though it did get extremely loud in the dining room and the later it got the louder it got to the point where I could barely hear the person sitting next to me.