The service was prompt and very nice. Mixed reviews on the food. The Waldorf salad was OK. There was too much feta and lettuce. The fish and chips were barely edible. The fish was over cooked and dry. It seemed to be precooked and reheated. The coffee looked like weak tea and had no flavor once cream was added. Even the server said she didn't like the coffee. The Reuben sandwich was good. read more

Met a group tonight for a happy hour meetup and was happy with the selections, service, and spaciousness of the bar area and restaurant. A large selection of Irish beers too. Service and prices are good. The food is delicious and in generous portions. The Shepherd's Pie and Blue Burger were terrific. Onion rings and sweet potato fries were the best! Busy diningroom with private high-back booths made it nice. read more

See all

First time there, went with a friend and would absolutely return! The food was delicious, excellent service and the menu had so many great choices. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - Irishman Burger - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

Nice Saturday evening out enjoying a light meal & live music. Warm lively atmosphere. Service was slow but they were busy. We were seated upon arrival. The prime rib flatbread & garlic parm boneless wings hit the spot. Moved to bar area to finish the evening listening to live music. Good ambiance. Easy off street parking. We'll be back. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - Prime rib flatbread - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Where my wife and I had our second date... And where she had the first (with me) of many bowls of what she describes as the best French Onion (five onion) Soup ever. With an authentic Irish vibe (the owner is an authentic Irishman, cozy fireplaces, comfortable patio and pleasant service MulConnery's is a local favorite for us. read more

See all

Good food, good vibes! Service was great, waitress was kind, patient and attentive. Short wait time on a busy night

Great place to go for good pub food! The fact that they were opened especially after Christmas, when a lot of places were closed, was so much appreciated! We were starving! We were pleased to enjoy such a nice variety of entrees ,and dined by the fireplace was a bonus ! Our server Paige was not only experienced with how the entrees were prepared , but was also most accommodating! I had fish n chips but wanted to swap chips for vegetables and she accommodated this request with no problem! My family ordered the onion soup, soft pretzels, fried mozzarella, brisket sandwiches with sweet potato fries! All was very delicious! We will definitely return! It was too cold to sit outside, but will return when it's warmer to enjoy the patio read more

See all

I just had the best chicken French dinner. I thought Lemoncello's was good this beat it. So moist and flavorful. This place is so Irish!! The potatoes had lumps just like my little grandmas potatoes. Our server was good but the busser was so friendly and helpful. We will be back!! read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - Chicken French. - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

Opened later after senoirs were waiting. The bartender told me customers have no patience. I beat throat cancer and was asking for a menu, she said I heard you the first time. After being told the bar area was reserved for others. I didn't leave a tip. Typical bar food crap read more

Service was ok and and vibe is like a typical bar. I liked the outdoor patio and deck area. The food was so salty and pretty because. The portions are also so big. I had the poutine. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

Food was awesome. Service was excellent. Great addition to Greece. We will definitely return and bring our friends. V

New Greece Location. Pretty pathetic that yet another local business FAILS when it comes to the basics. The look of the place is fine and we have no idea about the food or drinks considering we were straight up ignored for 25 minutes. We stopped in on a Friday at 1:45pm and there were a few people at the high tops and a few people in the back area eating but every seat at the bar was filled. There was one female bartender on duty who had a miserable look on her face and was mad at the world because she was working. Note to the bartender; you picked the WRONG industry to work in if you can't even fake being pleasant. She would not make eye contact with anyone because that meant some would order a drink. We waited and waited, waved our arms, called out, and after several other customers complained about not getting a drink, we left and they left. The owner was there and could not be bothered stepping in an helping. He too ignored everyone and looked miserable. I hope you "regulars" can always make it in because we won't go back to this place EVER. read more

Been going here since they opened, everyone loves Mulconry's. Fish and chips all day long

Terrible service. Food was cold took forever for our food. 3 people in our party. Would not recommend this place.

Fallon Melt Awesome I flew down from Florida I've been there twice. We ate in and we ordered take out. Excellent both times. Great atmosphere read more

We went today expecting great service and food given jimmy Fallon loves the place. Our appetizer showed up after our meal when we had already asked to cancel it. Service was slow and not attentive unless you were outside. Server and kitchen seemed overwhelmed. Won't go back. Very disappointed read more

Stopped after an event at a nearby location. It was the day after Christmas. Was surprised I'd never heard of this place as I love a good Irish pub. The menu was very limited. However, was pleasantly surprised with the good pub fare. My entire group said their food was excellent. A must stop if you're in Fairport. read more

See all

Terrible! I ordered the 1.5 boneless wings to go. When I picked up my order there was nothing close to what I ordered. Had to go back into the restaurant to hopefully rectify the situation. The man host was anything but helpful. Then he said he would bring my order (food) back to the kitchen and ask them what went wrong. It was very clear what went wrong, And do you think I would allow my food be handled - once again - to the kitchen so they can spit on it? I requested the manager on duty. She was less helpful than the man host. She never looked at me, never asked what the situation was, never even apologized for the inconvenience. Terrible representation of the business. I requested a refund and had to ask TWICE for proof of the refund. Not a very pleasant experience. Poor service all around! read more

I underestimated this place. We stopped here on a whim because another place was closed. It was 8pm on Tuesday and they were only offering the one page late night menu. Our waitress was quick and very attentive. Everyone in my party enjoyed their food... traditional chicken wings, Beef and Cheddar sandwich, cheeseburgers and Irish Poutine. Nobody left hungry! I would like to come back when the whole menu is in play! read more

See all

Mulconry's is a nice local bar/restaurant that has wonderful staff and a nice inviting atmosphere. Plenty of parking across the street and easy accessibility for all. Also included in the building is a huge upstairs with an available party room type atmosphere with a large outside patio that is beautiful to sit out on during the summer. For dinner, I was in the company of two others, one had a cheeseburger on gluten free bun and she said it was really good. My other companion had the MulConry's burger which was huge and sloppy but in a good way- he said it was " Sooo good!!" And I had the Ruben and Tater tots, the Ruben was ok, but to be honest I was hoping for a much better Ruben sandwich from an Irish pub and restaurant. The meat was small little morsels that got blended in with the sauerkraut and really got lost in the dressing. Staff was super friendly and service was on point! read more

See all

Traditional pub food and comfy location. When we are out in Fairport and just want standard pub food this is our go to. They also have really good Irish options and comfort food. The shepherds pie is great. We recently ordered the corn beef poutine. It was delicious and huge! I did order the beer battered chicken tenders and I think they came out as traditional. They were okay. Definitely make sure to specify which ones you want and not point and say the chicken tenders. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Great food awesome atmosphere, friendly bartenders. We held a 30th birthday party upstairs. We will definitely be back!

French wings? Who ever heard of these? They are unbelievably delicious! Imagine Chicken French in a chicken wing form ... OMG so good! And the thought of them possibly removing them from their menu is appalling. The owner says they aren't selling. Well, that's because they are not located on the menu with the other chicken wings! Promote this deliciousness better and it will be a signature top seller! read more

Bangers and mash were terrible. Potatoes were like mud with the same flavor. The beans were fresh out of a can. The sausage was completely flavorless. Our waitress was amazing and kept apologizing for the kitchen and the fact that they were only seating 1/2 the restaurant because the kitchen was so far behind. Great location and setting in the heart of Fairport. Too bad it can't match the quality of the area around it! read more

If you're at an Irish Pub, then that means you want two things, a pint of Guinness and a Shepard's Pie. Mulconry's pulls both off with expert precision. I'll be honest, I'm always mispronouncing the name of this place, but sometimes the staff remembers my drink order, which is a Guinness. Guinness Country, Let's Ride. read more

This is literally my favorite place. I've been to pubs all across Europe, the US, Canada, and Mexico, and this is easily the one I like the most. The food is always top tier. I think my only complaint would be wanting more of a range for drafts, but that's it. Also, they easily have the best soup (specifically the five onion soup) that I've ever had. Highly recommend. read more

We eat here all the time. My wife loves the chicken boxty. Too much garlic for me. Service is always friendly and fast and we have never had a bad meal. The mulconry burger is great. I always have some to take home for lunch. The chicken tenders are fantastic . This is a very "Fairport" place and always feels like home. We went to several pubs in Ireland and this is close enough for me. read more

I tried giving them another chance. What a mistake. Service was terrible, rude, took way too long. Not sure why they are in the restaurant/bar business? Seems to be not their forte. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - No words. Except dissappointment. - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

Stop in on Thursdays. Staff is very pleasant and the food is good. Plus they have live music most Thursdays and on the weekends. Nice local pub. read more

I love this location because it is near the canal. There is some outside seating & they also sometimes have live music. We did not come at an extremely busy time but service was very slow. I think it took about 10 mins for someone to come to our table. I have the Shepherds Boxty. The potato part of it was not what I was expecting at all. It was more like a pancake then potato. Another person in our party had the beef on wick. This sandwich was not on the correct roll, nor did it come with dipping sauce. The meat was dry & there was very little of it. Staff was friendly when they did come to the table & food was ok. I don't think we will go back here since there are some better places in the area read more

Walked here for lunch and was ready to take a burger down. Sadly, I left with heartburn and disappointed. Our waitress was great, but the food was sub par. Also, my wine glass had lipstick stains and floaters that made me gag. Brioche bun was stale and couldn't eat. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - Special burger. Looks good but was not at all. - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Was in town visiting in-laws when I was refused service at the bar due to not being a New York resident. Great ambiance with a great selection. Would be worthwhile to have bartenders learn how to read out of state IDs rather than outright refusing service. Will visit in the future if the owners adjust their policy. read more

Update: we went for the fish fry! SO SO good. You're served a Giant piece of cod or haddock (depending n the special), that has been beer battered and comes with a lemon. You will leave very full, but clean your plate. The fries are yummy and potato-y. The coleslaw is vinegar based - in case you care, like I do - but still well made. Our service this time was very slow and disjointed, but everyone was still very friendly. Glad we were able to stop in one more time! read more

I've eaten a few dinners here, each time a different plate, and have come away consistently unimpressed. Very average quality.

Visited from California to meet old friends, have some drinks and have a nice meal. There was a table available that we took to wait for friends and start our drink order. The waitress was very rude and showed NO customer service. She abruptly said we could not sit there for longer than 2 hours and that full meals had to be ordered and would not let us order appetizers while the other two people showed up (total of 6). We politely went upstairs to finish our drinks that had already been ordered and to get away from that waitress. They made it easy for us. We went and had a much better meal elsewhere and we just finished. They lost out on what would have been a good serve/sale/great tip. read more

Food took over a hour after we ordered. Came out cold to say the least . It was freezing inside . We would never go back for any reason. read more

I've been to this restaurant a few times and considered it a nice place to eat/drink. Last night I had one of the worst experiences I've had at a bar with one of the staff members. I will no longer be giving them my business or recommending them to anyone in the future. read more

It's always a great meal here. This is our go-to for a great takeout meal or a nice dine in experience. Looking forward to the live music this year. read more

I want to give 2.5 stars or change my first review to 4 so I can drop it to 3. Nothing was really wrong with our meal and experience. I had the Reuben as I did the first time I came here, but they have changed their bread from the amazing seed crusted bread I first had to regular ho hum rye bread. The meat was tender though. We also tried the boxty special of the day. I didn't really know what to expect but I was hoping for a shredded potato pancake stuffed with love like an Irish arancini. Alas it was a pancake, maybe made with potato flour, topped with a pseudo chicken/artichoke French, topped with another pancake. Flavorful French rendition but dull, odd pancake. read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - Sad regular rye bread reuben, bring back the seeded crust! - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Came here during canal days mid day on a Saturday. Actually wasn't that busy that I thought was going to be. They do have an upstairs but the bottom floor had a ton of tables open. They have outdoor seating as well so of course that was full and only allowed people to sit out there if they were eating. We decided to split a sandwich or burger. The cons: decided to get the chicken wing Sammie. Mistake cause it was so small and not worth 9 bucks We Asked for blue cheese on the side but it came smothered in it And the waitress didn't come to refill the water. Oh and we did ask for extra fries. I told the waitress before the food came out that we changed our mind and didn't want the extra. The problem was the food came with one plate of fries on a separate dish. The bill came with an extra charge but we didn't have extra fries. I paid anyway Pros: it tasted good and came already split for us, how nice! I don't think I'll come again mostly cause I just don't live close by and I don't want to risk another bad experience read more

Mulconry's Irish Pub - Chicken wing Sammie - New American Near Me - Fairport, New York