The food is fresh and locally sourced. Fries are homemade and don't forget to have some of their…read morepickles, they make those as well. Friendly service. Yum. I will be back

It was our first time passing through Hot Springs on our way to Mount Rushmore and we decided to…read morespend the day at Evans Plunge Mineral Springs. Out of all the options we saw online, this one did not disappoint. We spent a long relaxing day there and had a great experience, and the staff was exceptional and very welcoming. The burger was amazing and the patty was so juicy it practically melted in my mouth. The ice cream was also delicious. The fries were well seasoned and the flavors overall really hit the spot. Definitely a great stop if you are in the area.

Solid beer choices and excellent burgers! There aren't a lot of places to eat in Edgemont so I'm…read moreglad that The New Hat Creek Grill has good food. Friendly service makes it a great choice.

We were recommended here by a friend who is local.. oh gosh the food is so good! We enjoyed pulled…read morepork, along with hand cut fries, home made coleslaw... absolutely delicious! It's super cozy, rustic and just perfect...

There are limited options in Custer. We would choose here to eat again and again…read more The food was great and the prices were too. The wait staff were local and all friends. This added a great vibe. Highly recommend.

Be wary of the service here. Our server, a blonde, middle age woman, was noticeably cold to my wife…read moreand I when comparing how she treated us compared to other tables. Frequently coming back to other tables to check if anything was needed, striking up conversation, mentioning the specials of the day (which i would've gotten if i had been offered them and hadn't heard after already ordering). We got none of that. As for the food, it's okay. Nothing to write home about for $50 dollars between a drink, an appetizer, and two mid size entrees. I'm assuming the issue is that my partner and I are both in our mid 20s and have the stereotype of not tipping, which is understandable. This dining experience we definitely did hold up the stereotype based on the complete lack of decent service. If you're anywhere below mid 30s, I'd take your money elsewhere. There's a Pizza Hut a block away that's tasty, friendly, and 1/5 of the price.

We waited just a few minutes at the bar for a table and enjoyed some local craft beers. Service was…read morequick and the food was very good. Chicken pot pie and elk bolognese were our choices. The salads were also terrific. We were too full to enjoy dessert but the selections sure looked good.

Food was amazing! Service was fantastic- highly recommend!…read more We had the pear salad, pork tenderloin in a yummy sauce & bison burger. All was great.

An amazing small restaurant with the right size menu and friendly staff. We got there just before…read morethey closed and that didn't matter at all as they served us and those that came in after us. The food was delicious and refreshing. I would highly recommend going and we'll be back if we're ever in this area again.

Cute little restaurant with nice service and delicious food! I loved my fresh tasty Buddha Bowl…read more(quinoa, avocado, hummus, chickpeas, cucumbers, lemon, red peppers, etc.) with a nice avocado-ranch dressing. My husband got their creamy pasta dish with steak on top, which was also lovely - how was the young lady who served us. She was charming and kind! I loved being able to get something so incredibly fresh and light for dinner. We will definitely be back!

Excellent food and costumer service. The atmosphere was so pleasant, and the place is clean and…read morecomfortable. The burgers were perfect. It was enjoyable talking to the owners and hearing about all they have done to create such a good environment from an old historic building in Hill City. Eve W.

5 starts because our last experience was simply amazing. The…read morestaff has always been very friendly and helpful (I went there maybe 5 times total over the past 5 years). Place is cleaned and nicely decorated (renovated historic building) but this year the food really stepped up. We were a table of 4 and everybody was so happy with their order. I must say this is probably the best steak I had since I live in the US. It was cooked, seasoned to perfection. The meat was the best quality (locally sourced), the accompaniments, sides and sauce were on point, and my place was nicely dressed. It was a delight (huge plus for the green beans...not sure how they were seasoned but I still dream of that side!). My friend's Elk medallion was to die for. Highly recommended.

Such good food. Recommend doing the hot springs too in the same building. Small intimate restaurant…read morewith a wonderful chef. Recommend the steak. Our server was very knowledgeable.

I've eaten here 3 times at the time of writing this review and each time has been amazing. It helps…read morethat it's inside the hot springs spa, so combined with a hot springs soak it makes for a relaxing lunch! While it can be a little slow, especially if there's a line of people, the staff ensures everything is cooked to perfection and care is taken with top quality fresh ingredients (reflected in the taste!). I know people have complained about it being an 18+ age requirement due to the spa, and I can tell you as someone that's interrupted many times by screaming children whose parents are anything BUT attentive, interrupting an otherwise glorious meal, I'm GRATEFUL for this rule! I agree with other reviewers that it should be disclosed on their website, but people need to realize this is INSIDE a "Quiet voices required" spa environment (a simple Google search will reveal this fact) and children are typically anything but quiet... They're KIDS, and I honestly don't know why anyone would bring kids here anyway since the food is quite pricey (worth it!) and they have no children's menu. Overall this has become one of my favorite local restaurant and I aim to eat here a few more times before we leave the area for our next destination.

Always great service ..... Food is always consistent …read more..... Always busy during tourist season

My friend got the soup of the day a cheddar potato soup and she said it was tasty! I got a burger,…read morethe bull, and it was perfectly cooked and they had everything out super fast! The fries were hot and seasoned with a sprinkle of kick, but not spicy. Our server was attentive - he hustled! We didn't go to the bar, but it looked busy too. They have some beautiful prints on the walls. Gotta love the cowboy life!

The food was Outstanding! Very cozy and friendly atmosphere. Our server Tiegan was amazing This…read moreplace was highly recommended by a local so we decided to try it out and we were totally impressed/satisfied!!

Fabulous restaurant! Food was so excellent it could be in any city. Quaint and very popular with…read morelocals as well as people like us traveling through Custer. Our server Travis gave us great service, he was attentive and answered all our questions. Can't wait to return!

Great beer and amazing service. We loved enjoying a couple beers on the patio. Large beer menu with…read moreall types of options. Food menu looked pretty good too.

Just off the Main Street of downtown Custer, this hidden gem is not just the great brewery on the…read morelower floor, but the dining room upstairs is amazing. Open only later in the day, the dining room offers a very sophisticated menu that's not readily available in the downstairs brewery. The dining room has a full bar, and of course all their wonderful beers, and a menu that will just blow your mind! An extensive selection of appetizers, entrées, and sides to satisfy any taste and diet. The salads are phenomenal and the staff will accommodate just about any request, including shared salads, substitutions, etc. This was such a hit that we tried it twice in one week. Entrées like bison, Oso Buco, Cornish Hen, Quail, an array of beef selection, as well as vegetarian options that includes pastas, etc. Yum! The service is just outstanding! Super friendly, eager to please, and really professional. Touting itself as the "pounding father's brewery", the names does not necessarily portray the sophistication of the dining room experience. This is a must stop! Check out the mount Rushmore brewing company, and in particular their dining room upstairs