The old time service / bar is awesome. Food is cooked to order and always tastes good. The price is…read moreright

They sold the business 2 yrs ago. And took out the café.. so you will be very disappointed if you…read morego in hungry only to find a sporting goods store

Loved the ice cream! It was so good. Had to stop to see what the square ice cream was about.read more

Been going there since a kid-now retired Always a must to stop for a square ice cream. Tasty ice…read morecream selections and polite servers.

I had a chocolate malt milkshake. It was delicious…read more Service was fast the two young ladies who served me were very nice. Seems like they have a nice election of eggs and cheese and some different things and there as well so it's a beautiful little shop!

I had a truly bizarre experience at this ice cream shop after it was highly recommended to me. I…read morewas in the mood for a thick milkshake, so I specifically asked for an extra thick one. After waiting 10 minutes (despite being the only customers there), what I got was basically chocolate milk. I pointed it out, and they remade it--but after another 10-minute wait, it was only slightly thicker. As we drove away, things got even worse. While sipping my shake, I suddenly felt something unusual in my mouth--pieces of plastic coming through the straw! Whether this was a careless mistake or just a lack of attention to detail, I can't say, but it completely ruined the experience. So I after waiting almost 20 minutes for two shakes and having pieces of plastic in my shake and having to discard it. This is one of the worst customer service experiences. I've had in a long time. Safe to say, this is one visit I won't remember fondly. I shared this experience with someone right after and they say had a very similar experience. That is a very uneven place.

This is a great hometown burger joint. They have some good…read morefood for equally good prices. The meal deals are a good value. The kids meal too. My son even got a small toy in his kids meal! The service was friendly and helpful and there is a nice comfy seating area. A few down sides-- the space between the counter where you order and the entrance and the wall is tight. It's also where you get/refill your drinks. It gets crowded. In some ways it adds to the make-what-you've-got-work charm. In other ways it's hard to work around. The fries were not quite as good as the tots. But they had plentiful fry sauce and ranch. I would eat here again for sure!

They unhook their phone when they don't want to take orders. Employ young rude highschoolers. Run…read moreshifts with no manager. If you try to go there and order they try to make you call it in even if the phones are unhooked... AWFUL hospitality and service ( unless they know you personally) won't be supporting this small business as they support their workers bullying customers! Hoped this helps

My absolute favorite sandwich on earth!! The turkey blt & bbq chicken sandwiches are the best…read more Blessed that they have miss vickies chips because it completes the meal. The toppings are always good and they have the best ranch. They take their time but it's always worth the wait. I love going inside and eating but I also love taking my millhollow sandwich with me on the go!!! The best in rexburg!

We are in town for a softball game and were looking for recommendations on a good place to eat. A…read morelocal gal recommended this sandwich shop. It's a quant place, pretty busy but a lot of employees and quick service. The food was ok, not too much flavor and my turkey BLT only had one slice of turkey so couldn't even taste it. I was disappointed for such a large sandwich with yummy fluffy bread to only have 1 slice of turkey. My husband ordered the chicken BLT salad, again he said he was ok, nothing special, not much flavor. I also tried a chocolate chip cookie and it was yummy! So if you are looking for simple, fresh tasting food, and are ok with it tasting kind of bland, I'd recommend. I'm def more of a Jersey mikes lover when it comes to a good hearty sandwich!

The best ice cream I have ever had! They also make their own sodas, pastries and candies.Server was…read moreso friendly and let us try any or all flavors. The shop is so cute and has an olde fashion vibe. It was fun. Watching them make ice cream! Highly recommend.

The decorations are super quaint--absolutely loved the cozy, charming vibe. The staff were…read morewelcoming and super friendly, which made us feel right at home. We stopped in for lunch but didn't try the ice cream (and we really should have! I suspect I might have given one more star if we had--I really want to). Unfortunately, the sandwiches were a bit overwhelming. The croissants were over-baked, and the chicken salad and pulled pork fillings were over-salted and over-peppered for our taste.

We love stopping by The Freezer for a soft serve! They use Reeds dairy which we all know is the…read moresuperior dairy. :) It really is so creamy! My kids love that they have a few toppings to choose from. They are .50 cents to add a topping. Sprinkles, mini M&M's, gummy bears, etc.

Great quick ice cream stop near the place I was staying on vacation! Loved the topping optionsread more

Stopped by after seeing all of the positive reviews. Ordered the bacon. cheeseburger basket with…read moreonion rings instead of fries. The burger was good, but the bun was a little dry. Onion rings were good.

Fast and friendly service. Quaint little place with booth, table, counter, and outdoor seating…read more Good food and ice cream with generous portions and fair prices. Kudos to opening at 10am for those of us just passing through and needing to eat before we hit the road.

Delicious ice cream, thought the service was great, and had a really fun atmosphere!!! Would…read morerecommend, had a really fun time with my family.

Farm fresh homemade ice cream!…read more Two of us split a single group anchor almost not finish it. Mint chocolate chip Oreo caramel. What a great combination!

Crispy Cones is a sweet treat! BYU Idaho students are lucky to have this gem in their backyard!…read moreShark Tank's Barbara Corcoran knew what a great dessert this was when she invested in 2023! I went into the Rexburg location with a friend on a weeknight for a couple cones of ice cream. We settled on the monthly special, mint, plus a traditional chocolate. With chocolate, we got a traditional cone with Nutella filling and strawberries to top it off. With mint, we opted for a traditional cone without filling, and definitely splurged on Oreos topping. No doubt, this is a great spot for a casual date night or a catch up with a bestie. The atmosphere is super chill, and the staff is super friendly. Although you order from a kiosk, the staff will check in with you to make sure you understand everything. In my experience, our orders came out within five minutes and they were made to perfection. I don't like a ton of ice cream, so the staff even entertained my extra request to make a smaller cone. Perfect! This month's special cone was Nutter butter, which should pair amazingly with the chocolate or vanilla ice cream! Now, to plan my return...

Nice service. Over priced. The soft serve was good. This was our first time. I thought the cone was…read morenot great. It just seems like this concept is trying to hard to be different and not hitting the mark. Mushy. Difficult to eat. Super sweet. After ice cream, maybe having something a little less, not more sweet. Shark tank, really? Hmmmmmm....