I ordered a taco sub on wheat bread, the bread felt like it was homemade being soft and warm. It was a very good meal. For a treat I got a toasted butter pecan mixer with extra pecans. Sub was brought to the table quickly, I ordered the yogurt mixer with my sub to pick up later. Outstanding yogurt mixer. This place has a great ambiance both inside and outside. read more

Millhollow Frozen Yogurt - Yogurt mixer - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

I love the pastrami sandwich and any of the tart yogurts--tart raspberry most of all. There's often a long line and a short wait. It has a country feel with artwork with a mill theme; benches and tables. A fun place to take groups or go by yourself. read more

I live in Utah, my grandparents live down here. And every time I come I get around 4 grilled cheeses. They're the most delicious things I've ever tasted in my life and I get extra to keep in my fridge at home. read more

Millhollow is so cute!!!! I had the turkey sandwich with a bunch of fix ins which were all fresh and delicious. The sour dough bread is different than what I'm used to at sandwich shops but I'd recommend it. The employees will let you order a yogurt with your meal, but pick it up AFTER you eat so it doesn't melt while you're eating your food! It is INSANELY busy inside, but the employees still get the food out quickly and accurately. The yogurt is also delicious! :) read more

Millhollow Frozen Yogurt - Build your own sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Great sandwiches and service! I haven't had their frozen yogurt yet but plan to in the future.

Mill hallo. Always has really good sandwiches and I like their frozen yogurt as well. When you order your food they give you a number and they bring it to you which is nice to have a restaurant that's not quite a full-blown sit down restaurant but isn't fast food that gives you the service of a full-blown sit down restaurant. I have the pastrami sandwich which was very good and I also have had the turkey BLT previously and that is a very good choice as well. read more

Great food and service. Nice relaxing atmosphere. Staff friendly! I'll be returning to this restaurant.

Great service and food! I particularly love hot sandwiches and the sourdough bread. Beautiful place to eat the landscaping outside is beautiful! read more

Good food, friendly staff. Showing a Military ID gets you 50% off, which is great for the college students in the area if they want a cheap, but healthy, food option. read more

Best sandwiches in Rexburg! Everything in the Turkey BLT was amazing, especially the bacon. Great customer service and nice, clean restaurant. Definitely recommend. read more

This is the best sandwich shop in town. Hands down. I love it. You build your own sandwich, and i get the same thing every time. Good amount of food too. I can get a whole sandwich and be full after just eating half, and save the rest to eat for lunch the next day. Their frozen yogurt is also delicious, super creamy and great flavors. 10/10 recommend!! read more

Favorite sandwich shop in rexburg. Their sourdough bread is amazing, same with their frozen yogurt.

So yummy!!! First time was actually last week . My husband and I ordered the pastrami sandwich and the bbq chicken. For dessert?? I had the chocolate yogurt, and my husband orders a mix of strawberry cheesecake and vanilla. We were really surprised how yummy everything is. We wished we had ordered full rather than half sandwiches, but they were still very tasty. A little more expensive than others, but they were super satisfying. And the place itself is very unique. I'm surprised there weren't too many people the evening we tried it out. read more

Millhollow Frozen Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

We have always loved Millhollow. My wife went there when she was at college in Rexburg and we introduced our daughter to it when we took her to college. This past Friday we were camping in Island Park and when we came to get our daughter at BYUI we stopped there for lunch. Unfortunately this was not the Millhallow any of us remembered and could be the last time we go. We were shocked at how little they put in their sandwich. I got the club and asked to put more ham and turkey and leave off the roast beef. I also asked for extra lettuce. My sandwich had ONE piece of meat (turkey) and very little lettuce, tomato or other ingredients except plenty of Mayo (which I do like). The bread is good, but this sandwich was basically all bread. So disappointed as this is NOT how Millhallow sandwiches have been in the past when they were full of meat and toppings. So disappointed, especially when I was so hungry and craving their sandwiches. Both my wife and daughter felt the same about their sandwiches but loved their ice cream. read more

I have never been treated with such kindness and respect not only by the employees, but personally by Aaron the owner as well. The genuinely incredible experience we had, along with the unbelievably delicious food, will keep us loyal customers for life!! Thank you :) read more

Millhollow Frozen Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Really good icecream at pretty reasonable prices and really nice portioning sizes. Their sandwiches are great and they it was no problem to get extra ranch. Would go again read more

Love there sour dough sandwiches and yogurt with all the toppings they offer for one low price

This place has bomb sandwiches. Also, they carry Jackson Hole Sodas and the huckleberry one is amazing

Wonder! Inexpensive and delicious. Had some hot sandwiches and milkshakes. Definitely worth it!

Turkey BLT double meat on sourdough is heavenly. I've been to sandwich shops around the world and this place is a gem. Chef salad with pulled pork, hot Italian sandwich with jalapeños also killer. read more

I love you. I love your spongey bread, I love your satisfyingly flat, UFO-looking sandwiches. The hot Italian & the BLT bring a happy tear to my eye. I love the simplicity of your grilled-cheese & root beer float. YOUR SMOOTHIES. All of them. Those strangely addictive white-chocolate macadamia nut cookies that are so slyly placed next to the cash register, just within arm's reach. Your sweet little grandma decorations that are probably a few decades old but still change festively each season. You feel like home. You are Rexburg's best kept secret- but you shouldn't be. read more

This place is great they have awesome sandwiches! It's a pretty big serving so you don't need to order a ton of food.

Always get their fresh made-in-house sourdough (and get it it toasted!) Otherwise it's just kinda up to your sandwich preferences. My husband and I really like the spicy pepperoni and bacon sandwich (my brother comes from slc to visit us just to eat the sandwich, haha). Sometimes I just get a grilled cheese (the bread is *that* good). read more

Always very busy, but the food is pretty good and pricing is okay. A fun environment to meet up with old friends!

Food is super good! There are only female employees though, which I think is a little odd considering that the manager is an old white guy

Millhollow is one of those places that has been in Rexburg FOREVER! Although overpriced, there are definitely lots of sandwich options that are quite amazing. Their combos that have several types of meat and pretty descent since they're priced about the same. Another thing, the size of the sandwiches are pretty big. I get a half and am totally fine. Their ice cream is also super yummy. Worth a trip just by itself. Give if a try! read more

Really good sandwiches on interesting but good bread. Not the best sandwich in the world the best in rexburg. The smoothies and frozen yogurt are great too. Get either the peach smoothie or vanilla froyo with cookie dough chunks on top. Prices are a little steep in my opinion but that doesn't stop us from going here. Plus there is a drive-thru which is nice. Update -- Went from 4 stars to 2. I found a HAIR in my sandwich. Wow. Talk about appetite killer. read more

The sandwiches are very mediocre. Clearly the people who gave this place a high rating have never left Rexburg.

The sandwiches are amazing! I highly recommend! The help is amIng and the food equals it

Amazing little gem that hidden in Rexburg. Don't know why more people don't go. Frozen yogurt is cheap, and you get a lot for how much it is! and the sandwiches are out of this world. Some on here have said that the sandwiches are overpriced, but if they really were that over priced and not worth the money, would they still be in business? They're definitely worth what you pay for in my opinion. When people ask me about any places to go eat, I always recommend Mill Hollow read more

Millhollow is the oldest and best frozen yogurt spot in Rexburg. It's owned and operated by a local family that really prides itself on quality and service. Located near the college, the building is like a little log cabin or mill, and it is decorated accordingly. It is a perfect spot for a date or family treat. This is so much more than just a yogurt place, but I'll start there. The yogurt is always very cold, and never watery or melty like other places. They have so many varieties to choose from, many of which are very unique. Their Strawberry Cheesecake is always a good option. I'm not a big mint fan, but Irish Mint is a very popular selection among the locals. They also have low fat and sugar free options. Millhollow also features many different sandwich options in sub or hoagie style with a plethora of toppings to choose from. They wrap their hot sandwiches tightly in foil, and the resulting steamy, cheesy, and gooey product is mouth-wateringly good. One of their best options is to get the hot sourdough bread--perhaps the best sourdough east of San Francisco. If you want a hot sandwich and a cold yogurt to wash it down with, Millhollow should be your first choice. read more

Millhollow Frozen Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Our favorite frozen yogurt in the world. Fresh cookie dough topping is soooo amazing! Best sandwiches ever too. We are frequent flyers here! read more

By far my favorite sandwich I've ever had. I recommend the turkey BLT, with peppered bacon, double meat, with all the fixings you'd like. Can't go wrong with Millhollow. read more

Used to love this place but after ordering 10 sandwiches they got the order right maybe 5 times. I'm not paying, and in my opinion overpriced, for a 50% chance of you getting my order right. If you were going skydiving and someone said 50% of parachutes don't open would you go...? It is also weird only females work here. Don't know what the manager is trying to due....? Lure in the football team? Just seems weird in 2020. I'm not saying that it's not okay that all women work there but if I can't make a joke about my wife making me a sandwich without all the "social justice warriors" calling me sexiest and a bigot then why is it okay for a room full of women to make me a sandwich and no one bat an eye? Anyway, pricey place for the quality. Go to Gator Jacks. read more

I was pleasantly surprised with our visit to Millhollow. I was a little skeptical at first because of its location in a cheap college town in the middle of Idaho. However, I consider this one of my "Top 10" sandwiches I've had. Why is it so good. #1 The bread was so good. Thin and moist. It had a great crisp from the toast center though that gave variety to the texture #2 Great topping variety (I loaded mine) #3 Quality meats. My pastrami was favorable but not overly salty like some places serve #4 Small town feel #5 Great frozen yogurt. I got the coconut which was very tasty. One negative- who serves Diet CAFFEINE FREE Pepsi? Especially when regular Diet Pepsi was offered? Weird :) read more

I love their sour dough bread. They're usually pretty quick and the servers are always very friendly.

We always take opportunity to go to Millhollow when we're in Rexburg. It's this town's restaurant gem! I'm not really a sandwichy person but I am when I go there! (+ who doesn't like their froyo?). I've never had any sandwich there that I didn't find delectable. **SO YUMMILICIOUS!!!** read more

A little on the pricy side for the sandwiches, but the food and frozen yogurt was great.

Had a lot of sub sandwiches from here and they're always really fresh. Recommended. The veggies and meats are always freshly sliced so far as I can tell and the sandwiches are big enough for anyone's appetite. read more

Sandwiches and ice cream are amazing! Great customer service. Highly recommend to anyone