My wife and I stopped by here and we were not disappointed! A very quaint diner with very tasty…read morefood. We both enjoyed watching the proprietor and family run the restaurant. All of the grandkids helping out and doing their job was very impressive! We will definitely return and recommend this restaurant.

Yummy breakfast at New Hall Diner!! Cute and quaint inside. Prompt service and delicious breakfast…read more The bacon was local and thick cut. The homemade bread was outstanding. Would 100% recommend and will come back to visit. They have gluten free toast!!!!!! One note- Apple Maps led us to the wrong town when entering the address. Make sure to use Google maps or confirm you are in Hall!

Stopped for dinner on the way to the lake. Certainly won't go again. Only a few tables of regular…read morecustomers and 1 waitress, also several tables of what appeared to be off duty employees. They wrote up their own orders and took them to the cook while multiple children ran in and out of the kitchen. Their food came out while we waited over 30 minutes for 2 meals and a side salad. Hope the health inspector sees this.

Good food, fair pricing. Very welcoming. We often go on Friday nights for the fish fry. Love their…read moreBLT sandwich. Cozy.

We were in town on our journey around the Finger Lakes area and in need of a place for lunch…read more Thankfully we had Yelp to find a place nearby. With a parking place right out front we entered the bar area, filled with people. We were shown to a table in the rear of the establishment, more of a restaurant vibe than the front. We had simple meals of a grilled chicken sandwich, a grilled chicken wrap and a chicken quesadilla. I guess we all had chicken on the brain! The chicken was nicely marinated and we all enjoyed our meals. We didn't really take advantage of the bar since we had a long day of activity ahead of us, but it looked well-stocked. But we left satisfied and ready for the rest of the day.

Go there at your own peril, andcheck every item on your receipt before leaving. I was charged for…read moreitems I never purchased, and when I caught it, there was no apology, only excuses and defensiveness. On top of the poor service, they mixed up my mother's, auntie's, and father's drinks and were still defensive when we pointed it out. No apology. The manager, seemed more interested in talking back than taking responsibility. Giving this restaurant a negative review is honestly generous.Check your receipt carefully and double-check everything you're served.

Best little diner I have ever been to. Homemade delicious food (especially the fresh homemade…read moreraisin cinnamon toast) and down home feeling! We have been visiting the past 20 years during our summer visits and the staff always remembers us! Good food for exceptionally reasonable prices in a warm inviting atmosphere is what this cafe is!

I was waiting for someone to get out of an appointment, so opted to grab breakfast here one day…read more You know the kind of place that your grandparents might go to because they think it's "a good deal"..? That's what the feel is from this cafe... it's somewhere my grandparents would like. It's convenient and inexpensive. I appreciate the casual nature of being able to seat myself, and the initially prompt attention. I'm not going to complain about having a coffee at my table within 2 minutes of sitting down... ... but was it a great overall experience? No. The food is fine. When I originally ordered my 'garbage omelet' (it includes ham, peppers, onions, sausage, cheese, tomatoes, and mushrooms inside it) and rye toast, I was ALSO going to order a side of bacon... but the server decided my order was done after I said "rye" for the toast on the side of my plate. She left the table before I could even get "and could I get a side of bacon?" out. Next thing you know, I have a receipt on my table for breakfast. (As far as the omelet goes, it was "meh"... a plain 'ol middle of the road omelet.) The one time she came to check on me after already leaving the receipt, I actually said "Could I also please get a side of bacon?" ... and guess what? Never got my bacon. The server completely forgot... and never checked on me again. The only thing I can think is that the server didn't want to interrupt me because I was also reading a book at the table (again, waiting for someone to get out of an appointment - and I didn't want to completely drain the battery on my phone), but I have no idea. Either way, she forgot my bacon... and I would have loved a coffee refill at some point too. :-/ TL;DR Looking for cheap food? This is your place. I paid $15.15 for a coffee, sizeable omelet w. rye toast, and tip. If you're looking for anything especially interesting or memorable though? Not so much. I said it above and I'll say it again: it's convenient if you're around Dundee for something (as opposed to driving to Watkins Glen, Geneva, or other surrounding areas) and inexpensive.

Every aspect of our experience was exceptional. The service was great ( we had 6 people ) the food…read morewas made perfectly, great selection of meals, all our meals were delicious and the staff was very pleasant and accommodating. Would absolutely go back again and tell others it's a great place to dine.

Definitely a locals spot! The staff is awesome, everyone was pleasant and welcoming. The decor…read moregives you that warm and relaxed feel with lots of tchotchkes to keep your attention. Our meals were good with a rustic feel and I would like to return to try something else. Lots of people ordering the prime rib. The Antique inn is worth a try. This could become your local spot.

I really needed some protein for breakfast for my body before we could go to a wine tour. This…read moretiny diner we found on a map was actually open unlike some others listed. It was run by an older couple and they had a sign on the door to announce how service would take a while . We were willing to wait and we enjoyed chatting with the female owner and some of the other patrons at the counter. It was totally worth the wait For our 3 egg omelettes, and great coffee. If you are capable of waiting for them to do their. Job, you will not be disappointed. A great place to know about on the eastern side of Seneca Lake in the Finger Lakes.

Should have known the vibe when the sign on the door says we cook our food to order so things take…read moretime... walked into every table take. but one and every other counter seat taken. Stood in the doorway for a good 4 minutes before getting acknowledged. The lady finally asked the one other worker to clean off the table, took around 5 minutes before getting Sat. As we were waiting for the lady to come over for our drinks and food order we noticed that no one in the place had food. A family of four came in and they were told it'd be about an hour for a seat. Finally we were able to have the lady come over for our order, I ordered home fries and the lady said they just sold out. She's asked if I wanted anything else and I proceeded to say no. She's like oh you don't like breakfast food, I said I just wanted home-fries. She did ask if I wanted lunch instead. I said no thank you. We needed up leaving in awe that a diner would have run out of home-fries by 11am when no one in the restaurant had appeared to have ate. Not sure how this is so highly rated. Very disappointing. Ended up driving 40 mins to another place.

The Wagner is an institution in Penn Yan. We have been coming here since 1992 and the food and the…read moreexperience has not changed. Not one little bit, except our favorite server back then seems to be in management now. The food is good, it is not in the Michelin guide but I don't want it to be. It is reliable and quality diner food. They have lunch and now fish fries on certain days but I've only had breakfast. lots of omlette choices pancakes (buttermilk or a Penn Yan special, buckwheat) and breakfast sandwiches. If you go you won't be disappointed. I think it may have been a bar in its previous life ... it's a little dark inside but you can get all the sun you need at the lake. Servers generally last years there and are top notch and friendly.

We accidentally dropped into Wagner's when we decided we were hungry after attending the Flower…read moreAuction near the Windmill. Boy, am I glad we did! This old-fashioned, no nonsense diner has wonderful breakfast and lunch food. Server was quick, kind, and knew his stuff. The menu is just what you'd expect, with prices that don't slash you. Food was delicious and we will be back again! Would give it a 5 out of 5 if they would put their salad bar back into action ... just saying.

It is an old school mom and pop restaurant. The place is filled with warmth and it is reflected in…read morethe food and the service! The owner is a lady and her two daughters and close friend manage the kitchen and cash register. They mentioned they buy fresh vegetables and do not frozen stuff. We got the avacado toast, french toast, breakfast burrito and egg white omelette. Made fresh, good portion sizes and serves healthy and delicious breakfast.

Great breakfast sandwiches with some variety! The baked goods also looked delicious although I was…read moretoo full to try one. Cute little corner shop along rhe creek with limited indoor seating.