The reviews are true. Sabrina's has the best pizza! The Sabrina's Special is so good and the garlic crust adds a nice touch. I'm one of those that usually doesn't eat the crust but not this time. The Margherita pizza and Pepperoni pizza are also really good. My family loved everything we ordered. The staff is friendly and the ambiance gives old school pizza parlor vibes. Definitely a gem in Oakley. Forgot to take pics. **Not open on Tuesdays. read more

First time here. Very average at best . Margarita pizza ok . Ambiance zero sorry. It's like stepping back to the 70's. No table service. read more

I really wanted to love this place. The community seems to rally around Sabrina's, and I was genuinely excited to give it a try. On the positive side, the service was quick and everyone we interacted with was very friendly. No complaints there at all. The staff was welcoming and the food came out fast. Unfortunately, the food itself just didn't live up to expectations. The pizza had skimpy toppings and the sauce wasn't really my favorite. Overall, it just wasn't very good. It was cut unevenly with random-sized slices, and there were even spots where a slice had no cheese at all, just bare bread in the middle. That was pretty disappointing. We also tried the garlic cheese bread, which was very dry and bland. The mozzarella sticks were honestly inedible. We ended up throwing them away. I'd describe the food as more mediocre bar food than something you'd specifically go out of your way to order when sober. I was hoping for a standout local pizza spot, but it just didn't deliver this time. read more

I really like their Pizza, but, they don't Bake it Long enough!! We have ordered from them multiple times, and Every time, it's not baked enough! I don't know if I have to quit ordering from them or give them another. I even called with specific instructions, Xtra Sauce, and Bake an Extra 3-5 minutes. Really Sad! read more

This was such a good experience it was good but the pizza was little to saucy for me but the arcade machines and the service were excellent I can't wait to come back. read more

Sabrina's Pizzeria - My plate - Pizza Near Me - Oakley, California

This was my first time trying this place out and I was pleasantly surprised. Called it in for pickup and it was ready in a timely manner. The restaurant looked pretty busy but we were attended to pretty quickly and the food was ready to go right away. My family and I ordered 1 large supreme, 1 small cheese and an order of cannolis. I liked how it wasn't piled with toppings. The last thing I want is all of my toppings falling off my pizza. I also enjoyed the New York style pizza, dough wasn't too much and it was a nice bite. Cannolis were DELICIOUS! It's hard to find good cannolis in the area. Chocolate may be a little too much but the filling was nice and creamy. One of the top places to try out when in Oakley. read more

See all

Service was a little slow and restaurant could use a nice deep clean but the vibes where nice and the pizza is good.

Let's get straight to the point.. It's good pizza! I have nothing to complain about, the dough is a good consistency, the crust has flavor, is not dry, is not hard, the cheese is given in an ample amount, and so are the toppings! The service is also great. They are quick and attentive, and also informative on the questions that were asked. The Large pizza is also a pretty big serving, compared to other "larges" around the area for a similar price. The inside of the restaurant has a nice, older, sports bar feel to it, with a little arcade. As a sports fan myself, I appreciated it. The bathrooms are also clean. The only reason why I gave Sabrina's 4 stars instead of 5 stars is because of 2 reasons. Their pizza is good, but nothing crazy to rave about, but still good enough for me too come back to, periodically. The second reason is that the place itself is outdated. Oakley is growing, so this place isn't the only outdated building, but I feel like they should at least upgrade the bathroom a bit; like i said earlier, the bathroom was clean, but old enough to where even when it is clean, may look "dirty". read more

If you love watching sports, while eating good pizza this place is it!! They have tvs everywhere. The crest was very thick and they pile on a lot of meat and vegetables is very tasty. The ambience is totally chill laid-back and sporting and the service was great. When in this area, I will definitely be back for some pizza. read more

See all

3 years later and it's still a great place in the middle of a plaza where they have the best pizza in Oakley, CA. GREAT service, attentive staff and YES they've upped their draft beer in house menu. If you haven't been here before, I don't know what you're waiting for. Get in here read more

Sabrina's Pizzeria - View from the bar. Duh! - Pizza Near Me - Oakley, California

Agree! BEST pizza and wings in the area!!!! Love you guys! Love the thin crust that is always cooked to perfection.

I knew Sabrina's Pizzeria is good when once, I had two pies for carryout. Now I know its even better when we ate in the restaurant and the kids had a ball. The whole family went to Sabrina's after my daughter's successful theatre performance for a victory late lunch. My son's eyes lit up when he saw a couple of arcade games inside the restaurant. Sabrina's is large enough to host our party of ten. We ordered a large of each: Peperoni, Sabrina's Special, Meat Lovers, and Hawaiian. The person in the register doubles as our server and she was very friendly and helpful. After a few minutes later, our pizzas came one after another. All of them tasted really good. The crust just have the perfect thinness a la NY style. The big surprise was Sabrina's Special. It has a garlic crust with some unique twists like jalapeno's and black olives. A couple in our party commented that they like the uniqueness if this pizza and was that highlight of their meal. And as aforementioned, the kids had a ball with their arcade games. The fact the all of their arcades guarantees a reward on every play makes the kids smile of miles. read more

See all

I was leaving from work and I know I wanted to try this place out. I am always a fan of Ma and Pa pizza places, so I was glad to give it a whirl. Ordering was easy online, since they use DoorDash as a store front. Cheesy Garlic Bread: This was not as impressive as I imagined. It tasted more cheesy with barely any notes of garlic at all. The marinara sauce was good, but for the price I paid for this, I would pass on this. Supreme Pizza: This was pretty good. It was flavorful and had a bunch of toppings, expected for a surprise pizza. But it was just that to me. Nothing really came to me that made it stand out from other pizza restaurants that I have tried. The thin crust was nice for their style, but that was the only thing I liked about it. Overall, I may consider coming back here again. read more

Sabrina's Pizzeria - Large Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oakley, California

See all

I'm updating my review because we've ordered pizza here a few times since my last post, and I have to say, it's been fantastic. The pizza and wings we've tried have both been delicious. read more

We love Sabrina's Pizza! Always hot & yummy. We normally pick up ours and take home. Cashiers are always very nice and friendly. We are addicted to the Sabrina's Special pizza with garlic crust and jalapenos + ranch. read more

Loved it. Wish it was open later, but the pizza was amazing. We ordered a pepperoni and a special. Both were great

I just don't like their pizza. I wish I did they are a local business I would like to support. I have tried it twice.

Food is always good and hot!! Service is always given with a smile. Owners are so accommodating and personable. Sabrina's is my favorite pizza spot!! read more

Best pizza in the area hands down. Half supreme, half chicken pesto bacon is the one bro

New to town so have been looking for a local pizza shop. Was excited to try this but it disappointed. Tasted almost identical to Costco pizza. Like all the ingredients are frozen and bought from the same major companies. Was hoping for a unique taste and presentation. Employees were super nice which was nice. I probably won't be back. read more

Very strange pizza. First of all, it was way overbaked and the cheese had a weirdly tough/dehydrated texture, not at all stretchy like mozzarella. And despite the fact that I asked for and paid for extra cheese, there wasn't much cheese to speak of on my PLAIN CHEESE pizza. Additionally, the pizza from this establishment is advertised as New York style, which it most definitely is not. NY pizza is thin crust and oily; this pie was almost too thin and DRY as a bone. I won't go so far as to say it was inedible, but it wasn't at all satisfying. read more

My family and I have been going to this pizza joint since 2017. This place never fails us. Hands down to Sabrina's Pizzeria. My kids and I are really picky when it comes to eating pizza. It's really hard to please us. But this place does its job. Satisfying us with each and every bite. Our go to pizza is the Sabrina's special and their regular pepperoni pizza. Best pizza in oakley!! Delicious and scrumptious!!!! This place is a must!!!! read more

Off first impression this place is definitely worth a visit! Menu has a lot of options including a wide range of beverages, including tap beers, for all persons. Service was friendly and the vibe was what you should expect of a Sports Pub Pizza establishment. read more

If you like some heat, Sabrina's special is the winner here! We loved the hot jalapeños paired with the sweet pineapple, savory ham and crispy bacon bits. The garlic crust was awesome too! I'd go for this any day! The Margherita fell short (didn't taste like much) and the Caesar salad was way overdressed. By the time I got to it, it was wilted. read more

See all

The salads and pizza are always fresh. The garlic sauce spread on the crest is fantastic. We love to stop in for an early dinner, and a glass of wine. read more

A nice cozy local pizza joint with a limited but decent selection of beers that I frequent occasionally.

Outstanding pizzas and calzones. Very friendly staff and a clean comfortable dining room with plenty of space. It's not cheap, but it's well worth the money. read more

Must try, best pizza in town. locally owned Staff are super helpful. They provide an atmosphere welcoming and sense of belonging.

This is the best pizza ever! Once you have it you will never get any other again! Excellent customer service and amazing pizza

For $30 for a large pepperoni pizza you're better off getting it from costco. The dough is pretty good, not too thick but could really use more sauce. The cheese doesn't stick to the bread so everything just falls off. Flavorwise, it's ok. I shall continue my search for good pizza in the area. read more

Normally I would give them 5 stars. Customer service and ambiance is always on point. However, the pizza last time we were there was disappointing. The crust was paper thin & soggy. The sauce was watery and not flavorful like usual. Still giving 4 stars because I want to believe this is a one off. Other times we've been there it's delicious! read more

We ordered our pizza via DoorDash. The pizzas were delicious! We had a custom one with sausage, olives, mushrooms and onions, a cheese one and a spicy Hawaiian. First time ordering. It will definitely not be our last! read more

My go to pizza is pesto sauce, bacon & pepperoni.......the pesto is perfectly garlicky, bacon pieces are big and the pepperoni is crispy & spicy. It's so good I can't stop at a few slices! Paul, the owner is the nicest guy and he keeps a good hardworking staff. The restaurant has an old feel (good thing).....reminds me of pizzerias I went to as a kid. Games are always on the TV & there is a small bar for locals to hang & share a beer. read more

Just moved close by so I'm still tying everything by around here. I've had skippolinis but wanted something new so I looked up Sabrina's pizza and it's only a 5min walk for me. Ordered the pepperoni and mango habanero wings and it was fireeee. Will definitely be coming back (and have) whenever I'm craving that combo. Dining in seems quiet I haven't ate in yet but it's chill has a nice bar area. The staff at the front are very nice. I would recommend this place to anyone as the pizza was delicious. read more

Headed back from an all day track meet, we found ourselves hungry & in search of a pizzeria. We enjoy "other" pizza franchises however we have an even greater appreciation for smaller businesses. I can't describe it but if you enjoy pizza you know when you've struck gold and distinguish the difference between commercial and "mom and pop". Here you'll find a spacious dining room equipped with a small game area for you or your kiddos. Decked out in sports paraphernalia you'll find jerseys of all the professional teams located in the Bay Area. Of course they are playing sports on all 5 flat screens. I'm sure on a a game night you'll find Sabrina's Pizzeria packed and lively although that was not the case of his mid Sunday afternoon. We were appreciative of how quiet it was fruiting our brief stop. Ordering two 18" pepperoni pizzas along with 6 buffalo wings, 2 pitchers of water and 1 pitcher of Sprite totaling $65.25 well worth every penny. I would suggest purchasing pitchers if you're a larger family as a cup per person will be more expensive. The wings were good and if you prefer baked wings this would be your best bet. The pizza gave what it was supposed to give. The pizza arrived picture perfect, hot, and ready for a good cheese-pull! The reasons are beyond obvious why their window at the entrance is full of award stickers. How badly do we wish a place like this existed closer to our place of residence. The establishment was clean, staff was friendly and the patrons were even friendlier. You're in good company when visiting. I could go on and on but I've recorded videos and pictures to assist with visualizing this review. read more

See all

My favorite pizza in the area! Sabrina's special pizza is sooo good! Love adding mushrooms (+$1 extra topping) Service is always quick and pizza is ready for pick up on time. The inside has a few arcades and has a bar area with tvs around. Ps. Don't forget the ranch for your pizza, so good! read more

I just found out about Sabrina's recently, came in today and grabbed a small pepperoni pizza. New favorite pizza spot is now Sabrina's to say the least. I'm a Round Table fan, they're overpriced. The service was quick and friendly, the pizzeria is in a very unassuming parking lot. Pricing was reasonable, will definitely be scooping up something again soon. Fairly authentic Italian options including cannolis. read more

Sabrina's Pizzeria - Delicious pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Oakley, California

So I am a skipolini fan, it's been my place since I can remember. But I wanted pizza and wanted to try a different spot. Based on the reviews I had to try Sabrina's . Never knew it was there and I have been in this shopping center many times. I walked in ordered an all meat and they allowed my to substitute an item Which was cool. The customer service was decent very personable and nice . The pizza had just enough toppings sometimes pizzas can have so much toppings that everything will hit the floor before it reaches your mouth. Everything was just right. The quality was decent and I devoured a whole large pizza within 2 days it was better the next day after reheating. The restaurant itself was a local spot where everyone knows each other it's a pizza joint . I will be back to try some other items. Ohh also the crust was delicious and reheated well and was not soggy . read more

I have been here a few times, very good food! I went with my family and it was quite packed but we didn't mind. We went up to order and the lady was extremely rude. My mom wanted a minute to see what we should get, I asked the lady for a minute and she throw her note pad down on the counter and told her co worker "go they aren't ready anyways". I have never experienced this here and i was shocked. But over all the food was great, just don't ask for a minute to look at the menu oh my! read more

The photos here on Yelp look amazing, especially that crust. Unfortunately what was delivered did not match what we were thinking was going to show up. It's just another flat crust from your chain-style pizza restaurants. I was disappointed because I thought I found a new favorite. read more