What a wonderful find. Place was recommended by a family member. Still can't believe we hadn't heard of it sooner tho. Very nicely decorated "tea shop" that serves brunch. Small and intimate but they do a great business. We ordered the egg, cheese and pastrami sandwich, with Russian dressing, but swapped for the brisket as they ran out of pastrami. It was delicious. Matcha tea was great. The coffee was very good too. I find too often that you can't get a good cup of coffee in many establishments. Also ordered the Challah French toast, with a side of bacon. Butter was melted in the syrup. Absolutely delicious. Service was great. Friendly staff. Bill was reasonable. Under $60, including tip for two and we walked out satisfied without having to be rolled out in wheelbarrows. read more

See all

Cute atmosphere. The food was pretty good. Reservations are taken for groups of 5 or more. Waitress could have been more attentive read more

This place can't decide if it's an English tea cafe or a Jewish deli. I came for brunch and I did not get a brunch menu. I was so excited when I heard about this place. I brought my family for an April 5 2026 Easter brunch. The food quality was mediocre. They even ruined a simple matzoh ball soup. I ordered the "Dill combo" and I got a small 1/2 of a pastrami sandwich it looked like a quarter of a sandwich and the pastrami was over processed and bright red looking and floppy and disgusting it was low quality. I will definitely not go back here. The matzoh ball soup tasted like dish water it was in a "chicken " soup" with no flavor and the matzoh ball was hard and uncooked properly in the middle: very unprofessional. A matzoh ball should be yellow and fluffy and light. This was dark colored and looked old and was hard The pastrami tasted overly processed and I didn't like it Coleslaw was not tasty or salted The salmon was not on point and didn't taste fresh or have capers. They served it on a brioche bun. Seriously? A brioche bun? The challah French toast was tasty and my son appreciated that it was hot and fresh. The water had an actual mint branch in it and it was room temperature. Glasses looked dirty There was no sign for it when we were driving. It's located in a plaza. Every store on the strip has a sign under the plaza sign except this place. There is very limited parking and this place can't decide if it's Jewish or French with the decor of bright yellow wallpaper and small English tea cups. They blare loud music nobody knows why. They have a gigantic TV on the wall blaring . To go to the bathroom there is 1 stall for the whole restaurant. In order to get there you have to pass the kitchen window with the food to be served waiting to be picked up at the counter. Unsanitary! I had to walk past the waitress trying to get to the food that was on the ledge in order reach the stall Owner should pay for a sign so people know where this is Lovely wallpaper P.S. I vomited when I got home Save your hard earned money and go to the Stone House at Clove Lakes Overall I will not return read more

This is not a deli nor does it serve food that u will remember No sign on the road Loud loud music why ? No pastrami Saturday at noon Did u not think people were coming sat for lunch and dinner Wasn't grandma cooking last night Long wait Save your money go across the bridge to Harold's in Edison and pickled herring in nj for real food Oh yeah no egg creams either Big joke Won't be back won't tell anyone this place Owner spend money for a sign read more

Best pastrami south of Katz's. Served warm. Pickle platter was an amazing variety. Meat dumplings starter. Like my grandmother used to make. The place is decorated like an Eastern European home. read more

See all

Wife and I sat down and ordered at 1:19pm. We got our drinks and not once did anyone decided to check on us. We didn't receive our food until 2:23pm we asked for it to go and the orders were still wrong. Pastrami sandwich with no dressing and a side of potato salad and an egg sandwich with well done bacon and cheese. Didn't have potato salad with the order, pastrami was covered in Russian dressing and the bacon looked bad. Would not recommend not come back read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Great spot great pastrami sandwich I have had in awhile ! A must Try ! I live in Bayonne Nj I have no problem going over the Bayonne Bridge to Staten Island to enjoy a Great Sandwich ! read more

Cute little spot, but honestly the service was super slow waited over 45 minutes for our food. The pancakes came out dry and overall the food was just okay, nothing that really stood out. Parking is also pretty limited, which doesn't help. Not terrible, but definitely not a place I'd rush back to. read more

See all

Quaint, cozy little place with GREAT door and a wonderful menu! Lots of vegetarian option and gluten free bread too. Food was excellent as was the service . Parking lot is a little small but you can also park on the street. read more

See all

Phone did not eat first bc I was too hungry! This place is super cute with its decoration. We got the Reuben sandwich. It was good but still think Katz is superior . Slow service but overall it was still a great experience read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

"Stepping into this place felt like walking into the cozy living room of a beloved grandmother's home, only she's from another era and has an impeccable eye for décor. The space is quaint and beautiful, a little hidden gem tucked in a small strip mall along a busy main road. We hosted a wedding brunch here, and it could not have been more perfect. The food? Beyond exceptional. Perfectly crisp schnitzel, indulgent hot honey French toast, juicy Reubens, and family-style platters overflowing with handmade knishes and other delicacies. Just when we thought we couldn't take another bite, more dishes magically appeared and abundant doesn't even begin to describe it. Everything tasted fresh, thoughtful, and deeply satisfying, a true upscale Jewish delicatessen experience. The staff were the heart of it all....sweet, attentive, and genuinely kind, making us feel like cherished guests in their home. And for such quality and generosity, the prices were remarkably reasonable. This isn't just a restaurant; it's a place where memories are made. The owner was responsive, easy to work with, accommodating and just so wonderfully professional. read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Wedding brunch setup- we had the entire restaurant for 29 people - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Delicious food, cozy restaurant, quick service! Must try! The plates remind me of my Grandmothers house. I really enjoy the Manhattan sandwich (I believe that's what it's called. And the potato latkes aka potato pancakes! read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Pastrami and poached eggs on top of a waffle with hollandaise sauce - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

awesome spot to check out in staten island. the match was superb- large serving size, earthy strong taste. the sandwich had the most crispy chicken paired with a warm coleslaw that made for a perfect bite. the pancake collection was full of fun toppings: though since they were all kinda on top of one another i didnt necessarily get to try each taste separately. i was truly amazed by the food: the quality, taste, and presentation. also of note, you have to check out the thought to interior design it is absolutely so cute inside. service was quick i went on a weekday afternoon with no wait. there were maybe 15-20 seats inside so i could image weekends and evenings may be busier. read more

See all

Amazing place... fast service.... Warm cozy atmosphere.... Food was delicious... I highly recommend you visit to dine in or take out read more

Good 80s music, delicious food, incredible drinks. I got the lavender lemonade and it was not overly sour and refreshing with the lavender (a good amount of it in there too!). Pastrami sandwich is tender and soft. Love this place immediately. read more

Very cute inside. Very bright. Tight seating area. Came on a Sunday around noon and was seated right away. Only two servers, but works out since not many tables. Food was delish. I ordered the classy lox with no capers. Delish. Bagel was still crunchy and warm. Wish it had more bagel options, but nonetheless--delicious. They only serve the signature cocktails, not a full bar. Will come back to try more of the menu. read more

See all

A little gem.. easy to miss... The ambience is so lovely .. felt like I was lunching in a little Parisian boutique A throwback to a different time. Friendly service ... enjoy the corned beef sandwich! read more

Must have been in this shopping center over 25 times never noticed Sandwich and pickle boy what I was missing great food good service great ambiance ill be back a must try read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The owner was wonderful! You can tell that they take pride in their food. It was fresh and delicious and we were offered some much appreciated recommendations. Service was delightful and so was the food. We sat in the backyard which was warm and inviting. The place was very clean! Do yourself a favor and order the spanakopita which they recommended that we try with the Greek honey. It was a game changer... savory and sweet and delicious. The prices are extremely reasonable and the portions were generous. I will be back! read more

We came across Sandwich and Pickle totally by accident driving through Staten Island. We were pleasantly surprised!! The interior is so cute, very Victorian. The menu has so many good classics to try but we decided on the pancakes and the pastrami sandwich and matzo ball soup. The pancakes were very fluffy and the syrup was amazing! The pastrami was moist and thick cut. Matzoh ball soup was good too! Wish we were local to the area to come back, but highly recommend! Service was quick. read more

See all

The place has great ambience! The decor is very interesting--like a family dining room. Eclectic plates too. The menu had a great variety of choices however the prices were high and portions were on the smaller side. I had thought of it more of a sandwich shop but it was trying to be finer dining. $45 for eggs Benedict and avocado toast and tip --no drinks--I would estimate they are closed in a year with those Prices. read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This place is special. As Kitch and quaint as the decor inside is this this Polish sit down delicatessen packs a big flavor punch. We have been here a few times everything is tasty. The matzoh ball soup is the best that we've ever had. And although we aren't Jewish, we've lived in New York and had many a fabulous diner matzoh ball soup. But this one takes the Cake. the service is really good as well. Everyone is friendly and helpful. The sandwiches are great and the french fries are so crispy perfect crinkle cut fries. read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Best matzoh ball soup ever, potato salad and pastrami 1/2 Sando - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

We were visiting my grandma every weekend for a month and kept coming back here again and again. They pay attention to every detail with such love and care, like your own bubbe would. Their matzoh ball soup is a dream! It wafts with such rich chicken broth deliciousness, and the half-sandwich combo is everything you could ever want: half a brisket with their potato salad. Also a big fan of their waffle-meets-eggs Benedict dish that's sweet and savory. And I still crave their pillowy, foamy cappuccino, generously sprinkled with cinnamon if you ask. 5 stars!!!! read more

See all

Wow, I'm amazed! This place is delicious and is so nicely decorated! The staff members are so warm and welcoming! It is decorated almost like a traditional grandmas home. It make you feel so calm and relaxed. The food is super yummy, reasonably priced, and comes very quickly. Would recommend this small yet charming place! read more

I had a disappointing experience at Sandwich & Pickle. About an hour before arriving, I called to ask for a table for two and was told there was no need to make a reservation and that they could seat us about 30 minutes later. When we arrived, however, we were told they couldn't seat us because there were reservations coming in 40 minutes, even though there were three empty tables available. We tried to explain what we were told on the phone, but the staff didn't seem interested in hearing us out. They told us we can be on a wait list but we ultimately left. Very frustrating and poorly handled. read more

A cute brunch spot tucked in a small plaza. The vibes are immaculate and perfect for families or small groups. The chicken on French toast (you could also get on waffle) is delicious with crispy white meat chicken. The breakfast fries are two sunny side eggs with pastrami and Russian dressing on a mound of crinkle fries. The pastrami is tender and slightly salty. I recommend that you go early because it does get crowded for Sunday brunch! read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Chicken on French toast with honey - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Visiting NYC for the Holidays we were staying on Staten Island and ground this little out of the way sandwich shop. What a treat. Serving up some Jewish Deli style fare we started with the Latkes and Pierogi, yummmmm! We had the Manhattan (pastrami, corned beef, slaw and Russian Dressing), Matzoh Ball soup and egg salad on a bagel. Washed it down with Dr. Brown's Creme Soda. Great meal! read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Matzoh Ball soup, 1/2 a pastrami sandwich and Cole slaw and a Creme Soda - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I think this place was super adorable! Literally 10/10 service, everybody was so nice & patient; I would recommend anybody to come here! Oh yes and my sandwich was delicious 9/10 read more

This little cute spot is very petite and very pretty, perfect brunch spot for a relaxing Sunday! This place is aesthetically pleasing with many pictures and cute decors. The salmon Benedict was delicious, the pancakes were fluffy, and the potato salad was very flavorful. The fancy tuna melt was nothing special, but despite that everything else was very pleasant and enjoyable! The latte was very mild in flavor, so I do not recommend it. However, their fresh orange juice was delicious and not too expensive! Please give them a try and I hope you have a good time! They have such a wide variety of dishes! Thanks for reading and good luck! read more

See all

We came here for brunch and ordered a couple items. It's a nice little spot with a couple of tables. Service was good. I got the pastrami eggs benedict on a waffle. The waffle was a little dry but the pastrami was 10/10!!! I would definitely come back just for that. The bananas and nuts waffle was good but gets a little sweet for me after awhile. read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Awesome place with an eclectic menu. Definitely eastern European but very homemade and bold flavors. Would absolutely come back to try so many other items. We had: Shakshuka: delicious! And paired with toasted Challah to mop up all the goodness. Hot Honey Chicken: very rich and tasty. Menu says its a must try and it absolutely is. Pastrami sandwich and soup combo: tasted very homemade and delicious. read more

See all

Amazing food, the atmosphere is wonderful, great service They have so many interesting positions The best pastrami on island I had so delicious triple decker with turkey and pastrami Highly recommend. read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

My family and I have visited this restaurant several times. Ambience is cozy and charming and the wait staff is excellent. The food is amazing. There is a lot of variety all delicious. You can have soup and sandwich, breakfast and brunch. Highly recommend! You will not be disappointed. read more

Went here for the first time today after we've been talking about it for 2 weeks at work. We ordered the "grille special", coworkers ordered Pasrtami on rye & a knish. Food was ready when we got there. The set up is like a little old lady tea shop. Doilies all over, lacey curtains. That type of look. Everyone loved the Pastrami on rye. The grille special said 2 grilled knockwurst sausages, with "steak" fries, sauerkraut, pickles, and mustard. It was just 2 large hot dogs, cut fancy & probably microwaved. They also forgot the pickles and mustard. Definitely not worth $18 for 2 hot dogs, kraut, and regular krinkle cut fries. Oh, and they charge $3 for a CAN of soda. A can......1 CAN. read more

Nice ambience but waitresses lacked in personal attentiveness. Also very overpriced for the amount of food received. Coffee delicious but will not purchase again because it was extra $2 to add a flavor! read more

Decided to check this place out on a friend's recommendation. The menu reads like a Russian delicatessen. The interior looks like my grandmother decorated but in a good way. It's adorable but unless you want to book the place out I don't suggest large crowds. It was late lunchtime and I chose the half sammich and soup option. This comes with a potato salad or cole slaw as well. They have a generous drinks menu including coffee drinks. They were "out of corned beef for the day" but the brisket on the sandwich was moist and delicious. The potato salad is actually a Salad Olivier; classic to me. The soup I had the next day; nice matzoh ball and some white meat chicken in there. I'd love to be back for brunch. read more

Super small place but the intimacy is what makes it special. It feels like you're at bubby's house for dinner or an elevated Seder. The decor is so unique here and the food is another level of flavor when it comes to traditional Jewish delicacies. For instance, you can get your pierogies truffled! read more

See all

The Chicken was overcooked, service was slow, and no one seemed to care. So many better places to spend your money at.

I've been wanting to come here cos this is like the only place with good ratings for brunch on SI! Its a bit hidden, i've drove past this small lot so many times but never noticed it ! They have a tiny lot, white laced curtains at the door. Inside is a small and cozy restaurant. Think floral wallpapers, chandeliers and vintage shelves, baby breaths on the table. Such a cute decor! So many things to choose from their menu but we were sticking to our plan of getting brunch items. The food was very good and service was great. I am so happy i visited! Will definitely recommend and come back to try more items! read more

Sandwich And Pickle - Latkas benedict (middle), salmon bennie (top left), smashed avocado (top right) - Sandwiches Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I've eaten here twice so far. As far as menu goes it's an updated Jewish deli menu with extras. It's a genre of food that is most sorely needed on Staten Island. I've had the latkes, matzah ball soup, corn beef, pastrami, palmeni, and Israeli salad. All very good. Food is served on china and the interior of the restaurant is adorable. I think a needle point similar to what was in my grandmothers house was hanging on the wall. Service is friendly but the second time around not as attentive as my first time there. One dish was never out in and server never checked in on us until I mentioned the one dish didn't come out. I attribute this to the place becoming more popular. It seems as if there are quite a number of returning customers which is great. read more

See all