I ordered a Gyro Platter with Lamb. According to the menu it supposedly comes with a "Greek Salad". In what part of Greece do they use whole chunks of broccoli and diced stalks of string beans? Where are the olives, onions, peppers, & stuffed grape leaf?! Even after removing the offending items, which easily made up 60% of the entire platter, the food still had a lingering taste and odor of broccoli. I'm a city worker who just worked for 17 hours straight with no breaks. All I wanted was a simple and quick, buy-and-go, meal to have during the 5 hours before my next shift and I couldn't have been more disappointed. This place has gone downhill; never again. read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - The supposed "Greek Platter" in question - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Consistently good diner food with a very large menu. Always quick service & friendly staff. The restrooms & tables are always clean & we've never had an issue with our orders. Our go-to diner on Staten Island. read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - Chicken Cordon Blue Panini - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Solid diner. I ordered pick up for 2 wraps. Cheese steak wrap and chicken gyro wrap. Requests were filled to order and all accoutrements were supplied in addition to a little surprise piece of cheesecake! Order was ready quickly and piping hot, even the fries were good read more

There is more Employees then Customers and service is like non existent. My blood line of Coffee Burnt sprite is all Seltzer And the Sauce tastes like fish read more

Sometimes an old-school diner (in this case, Page Plaza Diner in southern Staten Island) hits the spot. On the way back to Long Island from a concert in Sayreville, NJ, I needed some hot food and hot coffee to keep me going for the long drive and Page Plaza succeeded. Deluxe cheeseburger with fries and onion rings was very good (if a touch overdone, more medium well than medium), and the coleslaw was above average. Coffee was very good too. read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - Deluxe cheeseburger and hot coffee! - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Food is consistently excellent. If your meal is a hot entree, it arrives HOT. Owners and managers are always on hand to talk with diners.

I was looking for Halal restaurant in the island to try some new food . Me being silly didn't check before that they were closed on a weekday‍ So I start walking & looking for a place to eat because I was hungry! Finally found this place . It's beautiful, clean & the stuff & the owner were wonderful. They also let me know that their chicken items are halal. So I tried had to try that. When the food came I have realized portion of food was a lot , which I would not be able to finish. The dessert & coffee was great. The price of the food was great considering the amount of food I get. No complaints, I wish it was near my house. Takes me a long time to go there from where I live. Overall I have a wonderful time & made a lot of Tiktok I will definitely come back, hopefully soon .. read more

See all

Love the food I been living in Tottenville since 1980 and it's nice to have a place so close that's consistent with the food I love .

I ordered a pastrami sandwich, it tasted like it was sliced and heated on the flat top. Which made it very dry! It should be kept in a steam table and sliced, which would make it tender and tasty. The service was excellent. read more

We go all the time, Dynamite food service and pricing. Theres not a better dinner on Staten island

It's a very nice diner with nice owners and a great staff. Food is always good and places is very clean. My only complaint is the parking. I highly recommend. read more

I order from here constantly my bill is always over 150 so it's not like I order a little dinner. With one meal I always order a baked potato last night I told the them on the phone they always forget my sour cream, they said I'll personally pack the bag ok so I ordered it again, my other meal I always get extra meat at a extra charge and I knew there wasn't extra meat because the fries were in the same tray usually they are separate because of the extra meat it doesn't fit together. So my delivery comes no sour cream , no extra meat, no orzo soup and the scallops I got weren't fully cooked so I called and I was told I wasn't charged for the meat why not? They read the order back to me before I paid on the phone said I was missing the sour cream that I was told would be there this time their excuse was it was really busy with orders and to remind you I have eaten there for years in take out delivery few times a month . So since they are so busy I will stop eating there so my orders won't be messed up anymore. read more

Sandwiches the size of your head! Chicken parm was very tasty but, for me, the gyro won the night. Just massive, fresh veg, piping hot and a super delicious taziki sauce! The cheese sticks were perfectly fried too! read more

Consistent. Always there. Great Chicken Ceasar salad. Owners and staff are very nice and service is always good. Parking is a horror.

I love coming here. The food is amazing and the portions are large. Service is always on point. A nice family atmosphere.

Food is just okay, feel like recently they changed their food and now it's just whatever. I still come here being it's the only diner in tottenville, but it's very expensive, breakfast easily turns into $40+ for 2 people read more

THE BEST BURGERS ON STATEN ISLAND!!!! I honestly love this diner! I live in Staten Island and I'm formerly from Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. I kind of miss my old Greek Diners and I missed the staff, the owners, and the food especially, my Spanakopita (spinach pie)! Nothing is quite the same as Mamma's cooking but I found the same care and love of cooking at Page Ave Diner! I love everything about the diner. The staff, the owners, and the food. It reminds me of my old Bay Ridge Diner haunts. They really know how to put the entries together. Having said that, just last night I tried the pork chops with portobello mushrooms, which came with vegetables and a baked potato! I have to say it was probably one of the most delicious entrées I have had in quite a while! It was even better than some of the top restaurants I've been to in Brooklyn and Manhattan! I still think about it even to the next day. All I can say is give this Diner a try and you will not forget the experience. Thank you! read more

See all

The gyro deluxe is delicious. The delivery service 100 percent. They. Have other. Great food there

The food is amazing! The prices are decent and the portions are huge. I'll definitely come back and bring others! This is how a diner should be read more

Good food, staff was pleasant, place is usually always busy but accommodating since it's a big space. Parking is the only downfall since the lot is small. Been coming here since I'm a kid, moved to New Jersey but still come back for breakfast when I visit! read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - French toast with Bacon - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Place is going downhill. Food is not made nor prepared the same. Everything to me tasted like it was re heated, especially the French onion soup. Waitresses all have attitudes, no one besides the gentleman in the front was nice. I felt that we were rushed out and it was not even crowded. They also upped their prices, but kids chicken fingers with no fries should not be $13.00. I will not be returning. read more

So I walk into the diner at around 9pm. I sniff. The essence of lettuce breezes past my nose. Therefore, I order a cheeseburger with extra lettuce and a side of black olives and coldsaw. Not only was there no lettuce on my buger, I hear a faint echo from the kitchen making fun of me for not being able to hold my burger. I have 3 fingers. read more

One of the best dinner in Staten Island the food quality is great and the taste. Great price, the dinner is clean as the barrooms. The staff is very nice and friendly read more

It's a diner and I don't really eat diner food other then breakfast items like eggs,bacon, and pancakes. If I am every feeling a little crazy I'll have a grilled cheese but that's about all I get from diners.. never a steak or fish etc etc. This place is clean and the staff has been nice every time I have gone. They do deliver also I believe which is a plus. If you are looking for a good, clean diner to go to in the area definitely go here. It is one of the better ones on Staten Island read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This is how a dinner should be!! Great food, very quick service,quiet place awesome prices. Please bring back this type of dinner.. only good things here.. and the complementary carrot cakes..OMG SOOO GOOD!! ever time we will be back to Staten island we will be back!! read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Beligan waffles with ham was enjoyable at $5.95 while my lovely date who inhaled a Western omelette with ham, onions and peppers with home fries at $6.75 for a mid-morning breakfast of several respective times. Page Plaza Diner is one of the better diners I've experience in a long time, albeit in Charleston on Staten Island, NY which is an great distance but well worth the journey for good food, especially for a great presence desired. Page Plaza resides in a complex of shops and local service businesses. Child friendly environment. Price is reasonable, dinning area is clean albeit facilities are minimal of three stalls. Customer service is courteous and friendly who are able to hone their interpersonal skills with professionalism. This diner operates 24/7 @ 365. read more

Food is always fresh. Staff is dedicated and fast service. I had a spinach salad it was fit for a King. The eggs for Breakfast were over easy and cooked perfectly! yes they have my voye read more

This is one of your run of the mill diners. They carry your basic necessities: omelettes, hash browns, wraps, burgers, and et cetera. The prices are a little steep, but the quantity is huge. This is obviously a neighborhood diner that is freqented by locals and truck drivers. You will see everyone greet each other as you are walking down the aisles. I gave it three stars because, personally, I did not find this place spectacular. However, I would say it is not a bad place to stop by. read more

See all

Great! My favorite place for breakfast or brunch. Never had a bad meal there for three years they don't make mistakes... Quick service, not like you wait until you order or get your food. Prices are very reasonable It's an A plus diner.. read more

Just left this place and I am glad it is in my rear view mirror. First, I get eggs adorned with a hair that looked like it came off the tail of a German Shepard. They make me a new dish and the eggs were raw. Not undercooked but raw, clear salmonella egg juice. Needless to say I sent it back After paying 22 dollars for my daughters waffles, they had the nerve to charge me for the coffee I had. So, if you like dog-like hair with your egg juice, this is the place for you. read more

Small little dinner but it's very nice. The staff are great, they are friendly and very professional. They seat us near the door and you can feel the wind coming threw the door and I ask to move. They had no problem and moved us with no problem. The food came out quick and was very good. I have no complaints and we will definitely be coming back here. read more

This place is always good. The staff is always friendly and attentive. Their cheeseburger deluxe is always spot on. Their salads with grilled chicken are all yummy! Italian wedding and cream of Turkey are my favorite soups here. Definitely one of the best diners in the area! read more

Went back to Staten Island this past summer for a wedding and dropped in to the page diner for breakfast . I was very delighted to see my old friends at the diner still keeping things good as I remember Big Mike and Baja . As always the service and food was on point just as I remember . I will be coming in again next summer and page is my go to diner . Derek and Jan P. Tampa Florida read more

Stopped by on our way to an attraction nearby. Everyone was excited given the large menu and great photos here. Did not disappoint! Burgers were great. Sandwiches were great. Even the soup was lovely. Watch out for the generous portions of fries! Also the cole slaw and pickles were a nice treat. read more

It's ok. Food is good. Not very pretty inside. I like the curly fries. They usually give free dessert but it's not that good. I still come though because its open late at night. read more

See all

Always fast delivery, always made perfect. Had the chicken oriental with a side of mushrooms. Mmmmm

Wonderful dinner, super friendly staff. Food came out hot and fast. Large breakfast menu read more

Page Plaza Restaurant - American Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Wondered in tonight while at work was starving came alone, I always knew this was the best diner on the island just don't come here enough. Did a meat lovers omelette and it was huge and overstuffed. Also did a side order of bacon because why not !? I think it was like 9 strips of bacon. Jeez was a lot and cooked just right. Server was great and attentive usually on the overnight hours you can't get great service with a meal. This was different and glad I stopped in. read more

The delivery came quickly and the food was good. Everything was still hot. I had the cheese lover's burger. The bun was not soggy at all like other diner deliveries. The burger tasted as if it came right off the grill. I'll be ordering from here next time. read more

Table service great, food cold and order incorrect, had to send back. I finished my meal while still waiting for my companion's meal.. Wont go back for complex orders go someplace else..... read more