Grabbed takeout for lunch and got the AYO Syd!! sandwich. The cola braised short rib was so flavorful and tender. As if the sandwich wasn't already enough to feed two people, it comes with Garlic Parm French Fries, which had the perfect level of seasoning to really elevate them. Had I known the portions sized ahead of time, I would've split it with my wife instead of getting one for each of us. Otherwise, I'd love to see a half size option for lunch time. read more

Scungilli's - AYO Syd - Italian Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

Over priced for what you get. Ordered the gavone, very thin layer of dry roast beef. Could barely tell there was any garlic mayo on it- which is one of the reasons I ordered it. Also ordered the clunky luciano. The vodka sauce has no flavor. We ate half of our meals, took the rest home and ended up throwing them out because we had no desire to eat it. And I hate wasting food. Not going back. read more

I enjoy Italian Beef and theirs is amazing. The bun is good, the meat juicy and tender. I crave this sandwich! Service is very friendly, hometown type of friendly. read more

Scungilli's never disappoints. I had the Italian Beef today and it was absolutely delicious! I spotted the Italian Wedding Cookies while ordering. I saw the owner come out and offer coffee refills to the couple at the table next to me. I didn't realuze they had coffee. Then, I ordered a coffee and a couple of those tasty looking, homemade Italian Wedding cookies. Scungilli's hit the spot! read more

See all

Always puts a smile on my face and everything I've tried is fantastic. Toasted Raviolis and the AYO SYD! are my personal favorites read more

Cute. Good music. Friendly staff. Prompt service. Delicious brewed iced tea. Good turkey panini and chicken soup.

Amazing sandwiches!! We love this place so much - everything is great. They also have great catering options!

The food was very good. We ordered several different sandwiches, ravioli, and flatbread. The only reason I did not rate this 5 stars is because the initial table service was very slow. The 9 of us even debated walking out. Once we were served though, the service continued at a good pace. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

All I can say is you've got to stop in and taste for yourself!! Family owned & you feel the love in the food. 11/10 read more

Scungilli's - Toasted ravioli with vodka sauce - Italian Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

Their new Waterford location is perfect. We dined in at their outdoor seating area and had several staff checking up to make sure the service was good and we had everything. Every food and drink item was made with care and had great presentation and taste. Perfect for a lunch or dinner date! read more

See all

This place is fairly new. Heard good things about it from my sister, so I thought I'd give it a try. It's a quaint little shop located in the small village of Rochester. Their specialty is Italian sandwiches. I had the turkey Panini with a side of chips. So crispy and delicious! I saw the meatball sandwich on the menu, and I believe that will be my next choice when I stop here again. You won't be disappointed. All choices are reasonably priced. The staff is very friendly, and it has a family atmosphere. Plenty of street parking. read more

See all

Very good food and atmosphere. Very friendly staff. Prices are fair and menu there is a good variety of Italian dishes.

Took me way too long to finally stop by this family owned gem. BEST beef sandwich with sweet peppers!! Yes, I said BEST. And I grew up in the suburb next to Melrose Park. I can't wait to go back and try all the other wonderful menu items. What are YOU waiting for?! read more

The service was good and the food was delicious. The seasoned french fries were good. read more

Ordered an antipasto salad and some olives with gluten free bread, to go. Both were amazing, and large portions for the price. The employees were all so friendly and welcoming. The restaurant itself was welcoming, clean and very cute. Overall so happy they moved into the Waterford area!!! read more

Scungilli's - Antipasto salad to go - Italian Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

See all

Great food! Had the Italian beef today. So happy they opened up in Waterford. Very delicious. Can't wait to try the rest of the menu!

I went to Scungill's based on other Yelp reviews, and I was not disappointed! This is a gem. Husband and wife owned and run (with the help of a few others) sandwich shop in the small town of Rochester. I was eyeing up the "Don" but two people recommended the Turkey panini so I gave that a shot (pictured). It was spot on. Great bread warm Turkey, thin sliced tomatoes and bacon with a good amount of sauce. Paul, one of the owners heard my dog was in the car and let me know about their dog friendly patio out back. The only problem I have with a place like this is that when I come back I'll want to try something different on the menu, but I'll probably order the turkey panini again cause it was that good. Give this place a try, you'll be glad you did. read more

See all

Has the Italian beef, best I've ever had besides my grandmothers secret recipe! Will be having it again!

One of the best local restaurants in Waterford. They're made from scratch soups are amazing. Will be on our regular rotation.

Ordered their Italian beef to bring over to a new Mom and Dad . It was top 3 I have ever had !! The staff greeted me as soon as I walked in - packaged perfectly for the road trip . Simply delicious- will be back read more

Wonderful place with GREAT customer service! Our party walked in at 8:30 p.m. (closing time was 9 p.m.) and we were warmly welcomed. Waterford has needed a nice restaurant for a long time and this fits the bill perfectly. Delicious Italian food, beer and wine. Had fun chatting with Dagostino family members who own/run Scungilli's, and ordered desserts to go. I highly recommend this place! Open till 9 p.m. Thursday, Friday and Saturday. Cute decor, too! read more

Great addition to the area! Friendly family owned shop that makes delicious food. We have been here multiple times, and not a single thing we have tried yet has been less than excellent. All the ingredients are just so fresh, and you can tell that they truly care about their food and customers. Just make sure to get a cannoli or three, they are probably the best I have ever had. The minestrone soup and eclair cake are must gets too! read more

Scungilli's - Pistachio Cannoli and Eclair Cake - Italian Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

The salute salad and pasta salad is delicious. You can tell it's all homemade and fresh! Staff are friendly. A great addition to downtown Waterford! read more

all the food is so fresh not to mention absolutely delicious. You really feel like they made it with u in mind for every detail.

We were in the mood for lunch out today and wanted something a bit out of the ordinary but special, so ventured to Rochester to visit Scungilli's. To our surprise, we noted that Scungilli's had a Muffaletta listed as a special. We decided to give into the temptation and were very glad we did. We lived in New Orleans for 16 years and have enjoyed all the wonderful (and unusual) foods the city has to offer. Of course we had our share of Mufaletta from Napoleon House to Central Grocery. We have to say that the Mufaletta made at Scungill's was the best we have had outside New Orleans. The lightly toasted Italian bread was delicious - lightly crusted top with a tender interior. The ham, cheese and roasted red pepper slices were generous and wonderful. But oh, the home made olive salad, generously provided, was the best. The sandwich is very large so sharing one makes for a satisfying lunch. So if you want a true New Orleans creation served locally, we highly recommend enjoying a Muffaletta beautifully crafted at Scungilli's. You won't be disappointed! read more

Our first time here. It is a cute little deli. Have driven passed a few times but it wasn't open. This place is worth the trip!! We live about 40 minutes away. We had the minestrone soup and turkey panini. Both were great! We add a little mild giardiniera. The person next to us got the mushroom bisque soup and sandwich that looks tasty also!! This is a definite stop any time your close!! The staff was friendly and helpful. read more

Scungilli's - Italian Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

Had an amazing lunch meatball sandwich, sauce and meatballs great flavor super fresh bread and nice hot giardiniera. My wife lover her turkey panini. Paul the owner was a great host. We'll be back to try more of the menu! read more

The turkey is delicious! The grilled cheese is large so if you have littles you might want to split it. The eclair cake is yummy but different than expected. It's graham crackers as the cake. But don't let that stop you! Yum! The family is very attentive and friendly. read more

Scungilli's has to be my most favorite restaurant. Theres not a single thing on their menu I haven't loved! My top favorites are the Gavone, Ham Sando, Big Fella and the Turkey Panini, all of which have generous portions. The Ham Sando is unique because it's topped with a honey mustard based Coleslaw that is divine. Not to mention the chocolate Eclair cake that is heavenly! The take and bake family meals, like the lasagna, are also a great option to consider and well worth the bang for your buck. You cannot go wrong with the Stromboli, and they run out fast! Consider them for their catering options; it's always a hit when I bring their sub trays. This a family run business, and they are the sweetest people who really pride themselves in providing the best innovative sandwiches that you can't find anywhere else, which is why they've been voted best in the county! As soon as you step in the door, you will be welcomed into their second home, and I cannot recommend this business enough! Come in and enjoy the pleasant cafe-style dining area, or enjoy the quaint back patio in the summer. Don't forget to say hi to Paul & Dana! read more

See all

The best sandwich I've ever had. Incredible food, great service, and everyone who works there is good people. A place you have to try and guaranteed to go back. read more

The sub here was so good I cannot wait to come back. Happy to have found this place on my drive to Minnesota!

Such a cute family owned Italian restaurant. A great experience from start to finish. We had a large family order. Was greeted kindly and they definitely made you feel welcomed. The meatball sandwich was incredible. Highly recommend this great little spot! read more

Scungilli's - Meatball sandwich - Italian Near Me - Waterford, Wisconsin

I've been here a few times now, and each time is as good as the last. These sandwiches are first rate. Do yourself a favor and dine in to enjoy the food hot and crispy. The decor is fun to look at while you wait, and even when busy you won't wait too long. Deserts are fantastic also. read more

We had them catering part of our daughter's baby shower and everything was delicious! Deli sandwiches and mini cannolis! Couldn't have had had better food! I also have to share that their grilled cheese is one of my favorite sandwiches ever! Thank you! EPIC! read more

Family owned sandwich shop in Rochester. First time we went today. Blown away with quality and authentic Italian food. The staff is courteous and on the ball.I'm telling everyone about this place! It's nice to find a gem line this in our own neck of the woods. I recommend the Don sandwich. Just packed with flavor ! Can't wait to experience the rest of the menu read more

Delicious food! I had the Turkey panini and minestrone. Can't wait to come back here. Great service and family owned.

Amazing food ...... everything is so fresh and tastes delish love the fact that it's family owned and operated . Super sweet family and very good food and service . A must try read more

We stopped in and had the meatball sub and Italian cookies and all was terrific! Cute little patio in back to dine on. We will definitely be back to try other items as the menu has a lot to offer! read more

Great food, great atmosphere. The turkey sandwich was amazing. Definitely check this place out

food was tasty but only 3 slises of meats on the italian stromboli the don and paison way over priced for what you get unless you just want bread read more