Today I had lunch in Southhampton Village at Citarella's. The hot and cold buffet was a bargain at…read more$13.99. I purchased some fresh blueberries, ropa vieja, fried tilapia, and chicken with mushrooms. Gisele was my cashier, and I declined her offer to purchase a shopping bag because I was going to stay in the store and eat. I sat on a barstool by the window and people watched--no celebrity sightings though! WARNING: BAD INTERNET SERVICE! I had to check in AFTER I left the premises because I do not use public WiFi!!!

Citerella has good products, but the prices are honestly outrageous. I understand paying more for…read morespecialty items and quality ingredients, but almost everything feels heavily overpriced. It's hard to justify spending that much on basic groceries when there are plenty of other places offering similar (or better) quality for far more reasonable prices.

We got the brie sandwich and the pesto grilled cheese. I would really recommend the Supreme Brie…read moresandwich. Nice vibes, very busy here, and they have a lot of different healthy drinks / sodas. I enjoyed it! The foverpriced / smaller but this is a beach town and it's relatively cheaper than dining in at the nearby restaurants.

Completely overrated. For the prices they're charging, I'd expect much better service, a better…read moreselection, and a more organized shopping experience. Instead, it felt crowded, unimpressive, and catered more to the hype than to quality. Southampton deserves better. I won't be back, and I wouldn't recommend it unless major improvements are made.

Good selection of bagels. Got the "Hobo" breakfast sandwich on Egg Bagel. Fantastic…read more Would definitely recommend / return Nice prompt service even on a busy morning. 5/5

Moments after I placed my order, I noticed the flat bagel sandwiches and started second-guessing my…read morechoice. When I heard another customer order one, that sealed it--I decided to change mine. I asked the woman who took my order if I could switch; she hesitated, likely because my bagel was already toasted, but then quickly agreed and handled it. It felt a bit awkward for a moment, but customer-service-wise it was the right move. This is a legendary bagel shop and worth a stop if you're nearby. The bacon, egg, and cheese I ordered was a bit dry--being toasted without a smear made it come off a little crusty. Next time I'd definitely get a smear, or maybe not have it toasted at all. The highlight, surprisingly, was the heavy-duty sweatshirt I bought as a souvenir--honestly felt even heavier than Carhartt. Tip: Go for the flat bagel version and don't skip the smear.

A classic LI deli. All the chips and drinks you could choose from. The BLT I ordered was packed…read morewith turkey. Would def go back here! Good location in SH

Not too impressive for $14. Not enough meat and innards in my opinion. For $14 I want it to be…read morefull. The coleslaw was fine. Roast beef and turkey in the club house sandwich was good, just not enough. Bread is fine.

Their warm lobster rolls are the best on L I ! Chowder is…read morefull of seafood and delicious. Lines may be long, but it's worth the wait.

First time trying this location but it lives up to the Amagansett location excellence. My bf thinks…read morethis is the BEST LOBSTER ROLL on LI. I got a grilled cheese since there's not the most vegetarian friendly options. Fries are epic and the mozzarella sticks and fish tacos were excellent starters. Nostalgic and delicious.

Tasty food and fun environment! I love the luncheonette vibe and very friendly staff.read more

Decent food, service can be slow but generally friendly. I…read morethink it's a little overrated for the area, it's more a long standing icon for Southampton. Cash only, which given its 2026 is such an inconvenience. Could improve with more tastier food options and upbeat service.

You come here because it's an iconic long island staple. You stay for everything else. They have…read morefantastic ice cream sandwiches. I highly recommend getting a cooler and bringing some home. And they sell so much more than just their iconic chocolate chip cookies...they have pies, cakes, brownies, assorted breads, coffee, candies, merch...the list goes on. There is tons of parking behind the store, so don't be intimidated if you see a busy front. They work fast inside, so there isn't that bad of a wait neither. It's such a cute quaint store that you should stop on by while exploring southhamption.

Thank you for producing such nice cookies. I purchased these cookies from sprouts in Dublin,…read moreCalifornia. I tried both the key lime as well as the blueberry crisp cookies-'outstanding products! Again, thank you very much. P, s, please open a bakery in California.

Pretty decent deli to get a good egg and cheese roll. I…read moreopted for a croissant and was thrilled the eggs were cooked to a nice firm center and the cheese A traditional American yellow slice was ooey gooey melty!!! Didn't need and salt just a Lil' black pepper and hot sauce!

Perfect take out food place in south Hampton. I love my egg wraps with tomatoes and mushrooms very…read moredelicious and the ice coffee is strong and bold great way to start the day. Seans place establishment is very clean and the service is excellent!!!!!!!