I have tried quite a few lobster rolls around the hamptons over the years but this is still my…read morefavorite. This place gets pretty busy on the weekends and I wish they did ordering through the website because sometimes its hard to get an order on the phone during peak hours. Limited seating, but very cute and on the water. Tried the clam chowder as they won the contest in Sag Harbor and it did not disappoint.

I've now been here twice. Sag's town is by far my favorite and I think this is a wonderful…read morecomponent to it. The location is right on the dock down the water. There is minimal seating but it is easy to take their stuff to go. It's super casual but delicious. The lobster roll is one of the best I've had out in the Hamptons, a classic cold lobster roll. The fries are also great. I've tried the clam strips, they are good but nothing to run to. I don't know if I would get again I would definitely rather try something new. I've sent other people here off recommendation and would continue to.

There are still a few things that remain as good as before, but my favorite award winning Stuart's…read moreNew England Clam Chowder is NOT one of them. It is tasteless and watery. No creamy lusciousness. No herby clammy umami. They sell clam juice. They should use it. I bought it, tasted it, added everything I could think of to make it taste like something but nada. Didn't mention It's watery? Zero clam taste? There are clams for sure, but I doubt they are fresh. Ps I hate potatoes in my soup. It's a cheap lazy way to add bulk, but red potatoes??? After tasting it, I was so mad that I thought to go back and nicely tell them to stop cutting corners as this will only lead to the closure of yet another failed biz, but instead I threw it out. These owners own a few places out here. Why would u mess with tried and true recipes? You have to spend money to make money. Sell less junk! Keep the good stuff we loyal patrons come back for over and again! Hey guys, read the room! We r a beach community filled with local fisherman and seafood lovers. Don't mess with perfection. It won't end well!

Friends wanted to have a clam bake experience and being a novice, I got a great recommendation to…read moreuse Stuart. Krystal was great! She helped me navigate how much we would need and the best part- they cook we eat! The lobsters were delicate and not overcooked and the clams; I'm not a big clam person but I devoured more than my fair share for sure. We also got a container of their garlic butter OMG. By the end of the meal we were all doing butter shots! Thank you Stuart's for a fab experience.

So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky…read moresalmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally…read moreestablished contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours.

Single best fish market experience I've ever had. Birthday tequila shots with the owner while our…read moreoysters were prepared. Anyone who doesn't appreciate that kind of service is likely a chode and sucks the life out of whatever room they enter. Scallop ceviche was fantastic and the oysters were super fresh and a few were down right huge!

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche,…read moresea bass and blue fish paté!

This unique combination of restaurant and fresh fish market is an absolute gem on the tip of Long…read moreIsland. From the absolute freshest fish available locally, to an amazing selection of chowder and prepared dishes, this is a not-to-be-missed stop for the local fish lover. Highly recommend.

Best lobster roll on the north fork. 10/10. This place never disappoints. Shrimp, fish, fries. Have…read morenever had a bad experience!

This used to be the no-brainer place to go for fresh seafood at a market. Since pandemic lobster…read moreprices everywhere have doubled or more so we don't go there for lobster or make you special trip there anymore. Still really good fresh seafood reasonable prices on some things not so much on others anymore. Seems like they're fresh fish isn't turned over as much anymore either.

This is the best sea food market around! Love the homemade soups!!! The service is fantastic and…read morethe selections are perfect!! It is very clean and comfortable.

Never answers their phone. Went out of our way to buy fish here and they were working on catering a…read morewedding with nothing to sell to the public. I wouldn't call this a fish market. More of a fish "maybe".

Alice's fish market is a true Greenport gem. The prices are unbeatable and the quality is…read moreexcellent. Bought our dinner from here for the second time in two days (can you tell we're fans?) Yesterday, we ordered two 2 lb lobsters and 2lbs of Cod. For no extra charge you can get the lobster steamed and partially broken down (made easy for you to crack open and get down to business ty v much) Naturally, we opted for the pre-steamed/broken downfare and passed on the live option. I absolutely love lobster but I don't think I could ever cook (kill) one, myself tbh. This weekend, we were going to go into town for oysters and wine but upon yelping the prices (average price of $3/oyster aka yeah right. No thanks, buddy. When you can get great $1 oysters at many reputable NYC restaurants you find this to be lowkey insulting) we decided we should buy our own bottles and check out Alice's oyster offerings. Jot this down: most liquor stores in Greenport/Southold/Mattituck carry a variety of bottles from various north fork vineyards so wine not stock up. Of course, Alice's did not disappoint! They sell a dozen oysters for $12.50. So basically I could buy three dozen oysters (roughly) for the price of one dozen in town. If you give them an hours notice they'll even shuck them for you free of charge. Hosting an event? Alice's offer a raw bar party option where they'll set up a raw bar table and prepare the oysters/clams etc. in front of you at your event. So to sum up this super long review, Alice's is wonderful, attentive and of the highest quality. Go check them out on your visit to the North Fork