I'm only leaving a star off because of the experience I had that I'm still not over it yet how…read moreupsetting. But firstly, the food was top notchtheir seafood bisque soup was a perfect consistency, the lobster roll was beyond good and fresh, the fried fish was 10/10 Only 4 stars because we sat at one of the indoor tables and didn't realize until we drove away and got off the car again that all our clothes were stained in bleach! I'm so upset about this I cannot believe it got my sons jacket, my dress and my husbands polo the clothes are ruined and we were humiliated the rest of the day walking around covered in bleach. We also got a parking ticket for not noticing the sign even though we didn't take very long inside, I could take the blame on that but about the clothes I can't believe it happened. Other than that it was a great food experience.

Always fresh & delicious- no matter what you order. Lobster roll is worth the price ($43)- Lots of…read morelobster meat. Wonderful raw options and clam chowder. Minimal searing so takeout may be better. Fun atmosphere- you're definitely by the water. Quick service. Enjoy!

It was fabulous! We got 2 lobster dinners 2 lb each. It came everything! And it was delicious…read more All of the fish looked awesome. We will be back for sure.

The Hamptons are a challenging place to run a business. Seasonal, workers shortages etc . This…read morestore was run so well for a long , long time. Now it has lost its charm and sense of what good quality is. I don't know who bought it but it is no longer clean and delivering what a high quality fish store could. The service is below past standard and just the presentation is less appealing. Please up your game. I miss the old Stuart's.

So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky…read moresalmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally…read moreestablished contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours.

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche,…read moresea bass and blue fish paté!

Perhaps you've sampled the rest, but Mike's Amagansett Seafood is clearly the best. Yes there are…read morecheaper... but none I've ever encountered sells fish and seafood as fresh as what Mike offers. His blarney is a hallmark, as are his prepared seafoods, including lobster salad, both a house made coleslaw and potato salad that is light and flavorful plus one of the finest tuna fish salads that's made with just the lightest touch of mayo. It's so good I freeze it for the winter months when Mike is closed. With a couple of hours notice, Mike will also custom prepare steamed lobsters, one of the best lobster rolls on the East End or shellfish platters that are to die for. This is definitely a place to come for seafood and english sports on the telly.

I've been stopping at this fish market after my North Fork runs for fresh seafood forever, and…read moreevery single time I tell myself, "Next time I'm eating lunch here." I think I did once... but apparently I completely forgot about it. Well, I finally sat down and ordered the lobster roll, and now I'm wondering what took me so long. I can't believe I slept on this lobster roll! If you know, you know ;summer doesn't officially start for me until I've had a great lobster roll. As of Summer 2026, this one is my favorite. The lobster was fresh, the mayo-to-celery ratio was perfect, and every bite was exactly what I want in a lobster roll. Safe to say I won't be waiting this long again. I'll absolutely be back!

Can't rate the food. We called ahead in early afternoon for a takeout order. We were told 45…read moreminute wait. We showed up a few minutes early and were told by the counter person that (a) that our order hadn't been started yet and (b) that we were told it would be an hour when we called and we were early. And there was an edge in her voice. So we went to run an errand and came back 25 minutes later and the order still hadn't been started yet. So it's now more than an hour from the time we ordered and now we are in freefall. So we cancelled the order - with more attitude from a different counter person. It wasn't so much the delay in the order - things happen. But it was the attitude that accompanied it that was most off putting. It felt like a learned behavior.

This used to be the no-brainer place to go for fresh seafood at a market. Since pandemic lobster…read moreprices everywhere have doubled or more so we don't go there for lobster or make you special trip there anymore. Still really good fresh seafood reasonable prices on some things not so much on others anymore. Seems like they're fresh fish isn't turned over as much anymore either.

This is the best sea food market around! Love the homemade soups!!! The service is fantastic and…read morethe selections are perfect!! It is very clean and comfortable.

Never answers their phone. Went out of our way to buy fish here and they were working on catering a…read morewedding with nothing to sell to the public. I wouldn't call this a fish market. More of a fish "maybe".

Alice's fish market is a true Greenport gem. The prices are unbeatable and the quality is…read moreexcellent. Bought our dinner from here for the second time in two days (can you tell we're fans?) Yesterday, we ordered two 2 lb lobsters and 2lbs of Cod. For no extra charge you can get the lobster steamed and partially broken down (made easy for you to crack open and get down to business ty v much) Naturally, we opted for the pre-steamed/broken downfare and passed on the live option. I absolutely love lobster but I don't think I could ever cook (kill) one, myself tbh. This weekend, we were going to go into town for oysters and wine but upon yelping the prices (average price of $3/oyster aka yeah right. No thanks, buddy. When you can get great $1 oysters at many reputable NYC restaurants you find this to be lowkey insulting) we decided we should buy our own bottles and check out Alice's oyster offerings. Jot this down: most liquor stores in Greenport/Southold/Mattituck carry a variety of bottles from various north fork vineyards so wine not stock up. Of course, Alice's did not disappoint! They sell a dozen oysters for $12.50. So basically I could buy three dozen oysters (roughly) for the price of one dozen in town. If you give them an hours notice they'll even shuck them for you free of charge. Hosting an event? Alice's offer a raw bar party option where they'll set up a raw bar table and prepare the oysters/clams etc. in front of you at your event. So to sum up this super long review, Alice's is wonderful, attentive and of the highest quality. Go check them out on your visit to the North Fork