So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky salmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back. read more

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally established contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours. read more

Excellent seafood at fair prices. Good service and rough-but-clean shop. We return frequently.

I had the absolute best tuna salad I've ever had in my life... And I am a huge tuna salad person. I also had the best lobster bisque soup I've ever had there. It had chunks of the good side of the lobster. Not just the leftover crap... lol ! read more

On our little sojourn to the Hamptons with so many places still shut down for the last of winter, we were fortunate enough to have this place open and available for us to get lunch. Good thing cuz I REALLY wanted to get a lobster roll from HERE !! I had bookmarked it, read the rave reviews, not only from Yelp, but this place is well known and well regarded, and all things pointed to us going HERE for lunch. Naturally, we got lobster rolls, and they were DELICIOUS. A huuuuuge amount of wonderful, tasty lobster, and at $26 a roll, I'm so glad they stuffed it with more than enough lobster. It also came with tasty cole slaw AND French fries. It was a FABULOUS and plentiful lunch!!! This place lives up to the hype. I thought it was just a little place for lobster rolls, but it's really a shop that carries all kinds of fish.... fresh fish, salads, and other things. I would come back here in a heartbeat. I'm just sad that Levain Bakery, 2 doors down, was closed the day we were here. That would have been perfect to have both on the same trip. But I digress..... cuz this Seafood Shop ROCKS !!! read more

See all

The Seafood Shop is a very small shop (only 10 minutes away from Wolffer Estate Vineyard), offering THE BESTTTTT OYSTERS we've everrrrr tasted in a long while! We got half a dozen of their Peconic Bay Oysters for $18. EVERYYYY SINGLE DOLLAR WAS SO WORTH IT! OMG! You guys! Y'all won't understand until y'all try it! We ate the oysters in the car, parked in their driveway! OMG! NEVERRRR had we tasted any oysters thissss oceanly-sweet! HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE! P.S. My husband saw the server threw out some oysters because they didn't look so good. Then he opened up some moreeee to make sure they were all fresh before packing them into our box! Forever grateful because thisssssssss was one of the biggest highlights during our trip in Long Island! It's a must visit evennnnn if you only have a stomach for a few oysters and clams! Hope to return soon! read more

The Seafood Shop - Peconic Bay Osyters ($18 for 6) SO GOOD!!!! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

Whenever hubs and I visit coastal towns, I make it my goal to find Lobster Rolls. Not any mayo-drenched Rolls....only buttered Lobsters Rolls. Seafood Shop came up not far from Sagaponack. Exterior has all the tell-tale signs of finger-licking, buttered Lobster Roll joint, seafood shack-ish, etc. Ummm...no. I may have skipped the fine print on their Lobster Roll ingredients, I phone-ordered one just in case, mixed green salad and a tray full of steamers (tasty- but small in size) and an orange soda. I noticed when one of the employees was prepping a Lobster Roll and asked if that's the only option and she nodded her head with a yes ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. I could've just said to her, "I'm sorry- but I'll leave mine behind"- and wouldn't have been an issue. But hubs was more accepting in trying out the $22.95 mayo Lobster roll....not I. On top of that, the bread itself didn't look like a typical potato roll either. Aside from the prepared seafood mayo salads, there's Ceviche, Shrimp Empanadas, Broiled Salmon and a few other things- plus their seafood market is towards the back. Sat at their picnic table and hubs didn't like the mayo drenched lobster roll- as I thought but steamers were good. Everything looked fresh. Damage? $62 and change. Worth it? No. Steamers were tiny and if having your lobster roll mixed with mayonnaise is your idea of "delicious" and you offer no other option- go ahead. read more

See all

The Seafood Shop is signature and famous for its super fresh ingredients. The exterior decor is humble with simple white and blue colors. During COVID-19, they only allowed 4 customers to shop at one time so there might be a line outside but the wait wasn't too bad. There was a great variety of options from ingredients, uncooked food, prepared food and delicious dishes with reasonable prices. We bought one pound of shrimp & clam and it was amazingly delicious. read more

See all

Wonderful seafood shop with lots of fresh, local options. The bay scallops are delicious! For the prepared foods, I enjoyed the bacalao and lobster croquettes. Service is friendly and they're limiting the number of people in the shop at once during the pandemic. It's pricy, but you can save a little by paying with cash. Limited parking. read more

Ok food but do not go here if you don't want to run the risk of a very poor experience waiting for your food. Our 2-person order took 50 minutes. Given many other customers got food during this time, they clearly forgot our food for a while. And yet upon a couple politely worded check ins, they continued to assure that food was being prepared and the man behind the counter showed complete disregard for the fact that we waited for so long. As someone in the service industry myself, I would have tried to provide more transparency and apologized for the egregious oversight and poor experience the customer that was waiting politely was having. As a cherry on top, despite having suggested that I order tacos bc they're so good and don't have cilantro on them (because I cannot eat cilantro), they brought out the tacos covered in cilantro. They did offer an alternative wrap to go to make up for this, which was appreciated, but it did exacerbate our lunch experience especially having waited nearly an hour food that I could barely eat. I'm leaving two stars instead of one because the lady behind the counter and the girls working at the register were sweet and kind. We were very excited for our lunch here and had gone out of our way to eat here and were extremely disappointed. I hope our experience is the exception not the norm. read more

So, I've been working in the area on weekends. Decided to stop by this place because I saw a line outside waiting to order. Anyway, I ordered the flounder sandwich. I gave my name and paid for it as I was waiting. The girl at the register called me and packed my food. So I took it and drove to where I was staying/working and only then realized I was given the wrong order. She gave me an order with for someone with my same name. It was 2 salmon burgers. I was a bit disappointed because I really wanted my flounder sandwich. Anyway, I ended up giving a sandwich to a co-worker. The salmon burger was really good. The one I kept had rice and slaw. It was very flavorful and seasoned nicely. My work is about 15mins away from their location otherwise I would of gone back. Still I enjoyed the sandwich even though it's not what I wanted... I'd get it again. Hopefully, next week I'll have time and get the other sandwich. Guess some mistakes are meant to happen :) read more

The Seafood Shop - Salmon burger - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

See all

Well, this was our last time here sadly. The soups r too salty. The wraps r pretty good. We had paella and it was lackluster at best. Nothing tastes as good as it used to and it used to be terrific. Like everywhere, the prices are out of control but mainly considering who is behind the counter, u would think a Tamale would be done well but not even close. It was nothing but one small slice of pork! Nothing else but corn mush. See photo. So much for my husband's dinner. Sad. read more

The Seafood Shop - Pork Tamale w a single bite of pork Otherwise empty. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

This is a solid seafood shop. I've gotten raw fish here that I cooked, and it was of very good quality, tasted great, and seemed pretty fresh. I came back today to try some of their prepared foods, and while it was good, it was nothing outstanding. I tried the caesar salad with seared tuna. The tuna quality was good, but I wasn't a fan of the seasoning that they put on it - it was like a breaded on spice mixture. The salad overall was pretty decent. I also tried a vegetable spring roll which was soggy and not crisp and had okay flavor, but I won't be getting it again. Overall, there are some good options here. UPDATE: I went back here for lunch and got the salmon burger. I was really impressed by it. It was massive and had great flavor. It was served with a sort of yogurt dill sauce on the side which was a great complement. There were also fries (pretty good) and coleslaw on the side. read more

See all

I love going to hole in the wall places and this one did not disappoint. Read the reviews on Yelp and very positive. We drove up and there was parking. Inside, you can either order raw to go or they can cook on the spot for you and there are a few benches and high tables to sit outside. I got the fried cod fish tacos which came in two with a side of my choosing (Spanish rice) with another default of coleslaw. The tacos were wonderful and fish tasted fresh. My wife got the seared scallops while my son ordered the fish and chips. All of them came with coleslaw as a default side and one more of your picking. The pictures speak for themselves and I definitely recommend this place. They also have soups which my son tried white clam chowder and liked. Will recommend for anyone who is visiting Montauk. The folks working there are superb and very friendly. read more

See all

Love this place !! Great soups and food. Always a pleasure to stop here on the way out to Montauk.

I've enjoyed your tuna half wraps for years but it seems that they've changed recently, there's much less tuna now and also they've become a little sweet. Please return to the old recipe, they were perfect, thanks. read more

Seafood Shop is one of those rare places that does everything that they do perfectly - both the prepared and raw food are of the highest quality, the selection is surprisingly good for a tiny store and the lobster salad roll with onion rings is quite possibly the meal I would request if I were to find myself in a position where I needed to choose my last meal! Yes, it's that good, and everyone who works there is incredibly nice to boot. Get's very busy around lunchtime, so come a little before or after the rush. Keep doing what you're doing! read more

In Sag Harbor for the weekend and was craving lobster rolls. These were so delicious. Lobster was fresh and just the right amount of dressing. Only wish they had toasted the bun! So many other available seafood options here. Highly recommend ! read more

Always excellent! Especially the tuna and the soups. Bay scallops when in season. Friendly staff. read more

We came here on the Monday after Thanksgiving. We were on the way to Montauk. First time in over three years. We usually stop here because we come later in the day and don't want to start shopping when we get to Montauk. Today we decided to get clam chowder too. The chowder in the past has been good, not great Usually, the my main complaint with the take out chowder is that it's not really hot. This time is was piping hot. Yippee! We continued on our drive to Montauk. I opened the lid and the smell hit me right away. Oh no... Needless to stay a few miles away we tossed it. I sent an email to their website. Perhaps they didn't receive it? In any case, one bad clam can spoil a soup. The clams we bought for the clam sauce were good. I hated writing this review. read more

I know this is the place to come for the best selection and freshest seafood on the South Fork! Also takeout and prepared lunches to go. The other day I was picking up lunches for my colleagues at work, as I was waiting for them to put everything together I ordered a small ( coffee cup ) of Lobster Bisque! OMG! Usually have this when I'm on vacation on the Cape or New Orleans or Maryland shore but this was spectacular! Not only the best Bisque but the best soup I've ever had! Large chunks of lobster ( knuckle, claw and tail), a touch of cream and hint of sherry! I went back a few days later to see if possibly I had just hit them on a good day, no way, just as good! Very special, my compliments to the chef!!! read more

This seafood market/ready to order take-out spot is fantastic. Everything looks super fresh, its busy, has a ton of staff, lots going on. Seafood is moving in and out of here for sure. They know what they're doing. Stopped for a lobster roll and some seafood salads which were all good, but wish I could go back for some fresh seafood! read more

I love this lobster bisque soup!!!! The soup is the BEST EVER!!!!!! Please sell it by online!!!! read more

The Seafood Shop - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

My family and I happened upon this place one rainy day and it is the happiest coincidence ever. If you're a lobster bisque fan you NEED to go here. Their lobster bisque is not too rich but flavorful and has full chunks of fresh lobster in it. The lobster roll was amazing, their chicken sandwich was amazing, waffle fries were amazing... everything was amazing. I love this place. It is a must-visit on your way IN and OUT of Montauk and the surrounding areas. read more

Wandered in after hitting up Levain Bakery. Thought they had a ton of different types of seafood & choices but heavily overpriced!! The service wasn't overly friendly. Decided on trying a Duck Quesadilla & a Lobster Empanada, 2 things I've definitely never had before! Wanted them heated...was super disappointed when I saw a worker pop my order into the microwave and nuke the mess out of them! I absolutely hate microwaved goods. As for the taste- the Duck Quesadilla didn't live up to my expectations. It tasted very much like a standard quesadilla, the cheese overpowered the duck. I really enjoyed the Lobster Empanada! The Empanada Dough probably wasn't Homemade but had a nice amount of lobster stuffed in it. Unfortunately corn was also stuffed into the Empanada which I would have rather done without. Overall I am glad that I tried both items and would probably get another Empanada from this place if I ever wander into Wainscott. read more

See all

I always pass by here when I drive out to the Hamptons/Montauk. Finally decided to stop by one day for lunch with a couple of gal friends. They have daily lunch/dinner specials so that's what we went with. The food comes freshly prepared, in a good portion, and packed in styrofoam boxes. The meal comes with a salad, specialty sauce, and a side of rice/fries/onion rings, about $9-15 depending on what seafood you choose. We had the herb crusted filet of cod, fried filet of cod, and the sauteed rock shrimp. Everything was super fresh, you definitely get what you paid for. The favorite was the fried cod. The meat was flakey, tender, and moist...great with the side of tartar sauce. The herb crusted cod is a bit overcooked (just a bit dry), as well as the rock shrimp (a bit chewy), but overall well seasoned and tasty. Besides the meals to go, they have a fresh seafood counter and another with prepared salads and spreads. There are soups of the day, as well as some market produce and a grocery section. Definitely a nice place to stop by to pick up some to-go meals to bring to the beach or sit outside at the picnic tables they've set up next to the storefront. They also offer some great deals on live lobsters/crabs, buy some and bring a little of the Hamptons home with you. read more

See all

Spectacular Seafood...Exceptional Staff...Tremendous Value!!! The Seafood Shop is a MUST for those who live in the Hamptons (although you probably know this already) and especially those like us who visit the Hamptons periodically and want to get the highest quality meal for a tremendous value served up by a super accommodating staff! There honestly isn't the need to go out to fancy restaurants because The Seafood Shop prepares out of this world made to order meals that are both plentiful but most importantly SUPER DELICIOUS! We had grilled Halibut with two sides the past two days that was cooked to perfection! Our compliments to the chef as it was honestly THE BEST Halibut we have EVER had...light and white and flaky delectable! Onion rings, waffle cut fries(extra crispy) and grilled veggies as the sides garnished with lettuce leaf, huge tomato slice and a wedge of lemon...we couldn't finish it all as the halibut portion and sides were so plentiful! And what's incredible is that for two meals it costs only $47 including tax! We challenge anyone to find this kind of quality and value anywhere! Thanks to owner Colin and our new friend, Andrew, who made sure our orders were perfect we will continue to plan our meals around The Seafood Shop each and every day we are in the Hamptons. Once you try it we're sure you will agree. Bon Appetit! read more

We ordered a takeout order of 2 lb lobsters and asked for them to be steamed and cracked. The lobsters were perfectly prepared and tasted like they were out of this world. The worlds magical and heavenly come to mind. Best lobsters that I've ever eaten. We will happily come back again and again. read more

9/17/2020 nasty service Today I Ordered a lobster roll which was very good although skimpy. The woman preparing the lobster roll never used gloves, for me or customer before me. When I commented to her about gloves she ignored me and the man at register said "she did wear them and You didn't wear gloves to hand me your credit card Go home and quarantine yourself" Very rude, nasty poor attitude by staff and unclean service. read more

I have been meaning to write this for almost 2 years! If I could give more stars, I would. We rented a house in Sagaponack for our small family wedding in October 2020. We had originally gone with a private chef but it ultimately did not work out/wasn't what we wanted. A few short weeks before the wedding, we were scrambling a bit to find someone. By miracle, we stumbled upon the Seafood Shop and it was the best decision we could have made. Not only did they save us pretty last minute, but it was easy and not stressful at all. Alex Fausto came the day before our wedding to check out the house and to make sure everything was organized/we had everything we needed - he wanted to make sure it was perfect. The day of our wedding, Alex and his team came on time, prepared and were absolutely wonderful. The private chef we were originally going to use had told me that there wouldn't be time for us to go to the beach to take our sunset photos (something I really wanted!). Alex was the complete opposite - he told me he would work around whatever we wanted. Alex is extremely warm, always has a smile on his face and was so easy to work with. Alex and his team made our wedding so special and last but not least, the food was absolutely INCREDIBLE. We still talk about how amazing everything was and we go back to the Seafood Shop every summer now! read more

The Seafood Shop - Mini quesadillas and Mini Lobster Rolls - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

This tiny seafood shop (as the name suggests) is a roadside hole in the wall, but worth a visit for all of your raw seafood needs and more importantly great lobster rolls. After grabbing a lobster roll, you can top it off with some amazing cookies from Levain Bakery next door. read more

The Seafood Shop - Lobster Roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

This was the most disappointing lobster roll. It was $19 and came with lobster salad on a bun. The bun was straight out of a refrigerator- somewhat moist and cold. There was not toasting of the bun or butter or side of chips or fries. It was served in a plastic bag. The lobster salad Israel's was decent but better off buying by the lb on the salad. Skip the roll. read more

The seafood shop has quickly become our favorite go to spot in the Hamptons! They have the best selection of fresh seafood and to go menu. Favorites include the clam chowder and lobster rolls! read more

Excellent selection of seafood for take out and to make at home. We had the fresh local tuna and stripe bass. The stripe bass was flaky and tender after we grilled it! read more

Literally the best lobster bisque I've ever had in my life. Huge chunks of lobster, great flavors and reasonably priced. They also have great lobster rolls and lobster salad wraps(also highly recommend). I would recommend stopping in here anytime you are leaving Montauk or the Hamptons... definitely worth it. If you really want to treat yourself there is a Levaines bakery right next door for desert read more

Traveling down the Montauk Highway and hungry for some awesome seafood? Especially during fall when all other roadside seafood destinations are closed for the season? Welcome to The Seafood Shop. I'm guessing it's open all year long, as there's a cascade of locals popping in for lunch. Many of these locals are on a first name basis with the store's employees. They have everything from sandwiches to a small selection of groceries to fresh seafood by the pound. They also have a selection of hot soups for immediate consumption. That's what I sauntered through the doors for. The clam chowder is among some of the best I've had in Montauk. The lobster bisque is also totally worth getting your mitts on. But I'm sure that can be said for just about any stew that comes out of The Seafood Shop's tiny kitchen. There's no seating to speak of, but you can rest your comestibles on top of an old surfboard outside the front door. It's perfect. read more

The Seafood shop is my favorite store in the area. They have unbelievable food that you can order or get from the cold bar by the registers. A hidden gem here is the dumplings. They usually always have a variety of seafood dumplings for $2 a piece which are a perfect snack. Another hidden gem is the seared tuna sesame noodle wraps, for only $7.50. If you need fresh seafood to cook at home, they have everything. Located right next to Levain and a bagel shop, don't pass on the Seafood Shop! read more

Super fresh seafood. I stopped here on the way home from east Hampton and got 1.5 lb of tuna belly which came out to $35 ($23/lb) and a lobster wrap ($12). The lobster wrap was really good and had a lot of lobster for the price that it was. The tuna belly was super fresh and I made tartare with it for dinner. Everything looked really good here and the price was reasonable. They also have a deal of live lobsters, 4 for $56 read more

The Seafood Shop - Toro tartare with the tuna belly I bought - Seafood Markets Near Me - Wainscott, New York

See all

The Seafood Shop is the best place in the East End to pick up fresh seafood to barbeque. Each time I have gotten my fish or shellfish there, it has been the freshest, most flavorful cuts. The Chilean sea bass filets are pricey, but perfection. Always a large assortment of mussels, clams and recently steamers. Always plenty of live lobsters. And don't hesitate to ask the guys behind the counter some cooking tips! They are so knowledgeable and helpful! The shop also has some lovely prepared foods. I haven't had one yet, but I often see on my stops people stopping in for a lobster roll. I'll have to grab one on my way out next time! read more

Very good very fresh seafood. Stopped for lunch and enjoyed oysters, lobster roll, and salad with salmon on top. Outdoor seating is nice and convenient. Service could be a little more friendly but they do let you sample the soups and salads which was nice. read more