Single best fish market experience I've ever had. Birthday tequila shots with the owner while our oysters were prepared. Anyone who doesn't appreciate that kind of service is likely a chode and sucks the life out of whatever room they enter. Scallop ceviche was fantastic and the oysters were super fresh and a few were down right huge! read more

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche, sea bass and blue fish paté!

Perhaps you've sampled the rest, but Mike's Amagansett Seafood is clearly the best. Yes there are cheaper... but none I've ever encountered sells fish and seafood as fresh as what Mike offers. His blarney is a hallmark, as are his prepared seafoods, including lobster salad, both a house made coleslaw and potato salad that is light and flavorful plus one of the finest tuna fish salads that's made with just the lightest touch of mayo. It's so good I freeze it for the winter months when Mike is closed. With a couple of hours notice, Mike will also custom prepare steamed lobsters, one of the best lobster rolls on the East End or shellfish platters that are to die for. This is definitely a place to come for seafood and english sports on the telly. read more

Tried this place for the first time a few months ago and when I went back to the area, I had to go back. It is hands down the best lobster roll in the world. So much lobster meat! read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - The roll! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

See all

Knowing Mike since like when he first started in Gansettland I find these reviews hilarious , the tequila shot seems to impress some, others not so much , oh well takes all to make a village ha ha ha. It's Craic though not Crack read more

Mike was amazing! Friendly, funny and knowledgeable! Food was delicious! Still laughing from our twenty minute experience in the shop! Will definitely be back when we're in the area again! read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - Oysters. Shrimp with dill. Ceviche. Octopus salad. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Baring none the best seafood store it all of hamptons. When you walk in the owner, Michael greet you as if your family. It is so clean that it makes you feel that it's worth the experience.. There lobsters are the best in town along with the little neck clams that are always sweet and fresh . Mike will also tell you how to cook the various fish he carries as we know fish is. always very difficult to perfect. But the coolest thing I found out today is forget about those gourmet sandwiches that cost a fortune in the Hamptons run run run for their homemade fresh tuna salad, which is from fresh tuna, so good hardly any mayo also their shrimp salad is the best you'll ever have so run over and get a container and make yourself some sandwiches read more

Very pricey. Lobster tails just a B. Salmon excellent and the cold shrimp small. Owner was three sheets to the wind bombed and a bit of a wanker when i was there. Reminded me of the Soup Nazi. Has the attitude but not the product. Proceed at your own caution. read more

Wow! Everything was so good. I went to grab a piece of salmon to cook at home came out with a full belly of samples plus delish scallop ceviche and soup with a baguette! Limited quantities available so you know it's fresh! read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - Scallop ceviche with a yellow tomato - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

I've had the pleasure of meeting mike who's just a ray of sunshine. We were in the Hamptons and I was catering for a brunch and dinner. I pick up some oysters, lobsters, shrimp and salmon. I must say the quality and freshness of the seafood is unlike anywhere I've shopped before. He was so friendly he walked me to the car with the trays. Excellent customer service. The next day I went back for another order. I'll definitely visit once I'm in the area. read more

See all

called and ordered steamed lobsters was told to pick them up at 5:30 pm. when we picked them up they were still alive. we told the man we ordered steamed. can he please cook them NOW and he refuses? we are renting a room and have no place to COOK them. he Could NOT CARE LESS. I will Never EVER CALL them again. ok and he called my wife Honey and Me BRO WTF. ! Redicilus read more

Really good lobster roll for 24. Came just with coleslaw but lobster chunks with light mayo sauce was great! read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - Lobster roll with tomatoes, lettuce, and red onion. Came with side of cole slaw. 24 bucks - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Amazing lobster roll, clam chowder and all the crack I could handle. I learned that crack is the Gaelic word for FUN. Look for the sign near the door if you don't believe me. Or, just ask Mike. read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - a bicycle parked in front - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

See all

Great lobster clam bake. Upgrade to the 1.5lb lobster. I love the sauce from the clams and mussels which I usually save to make pasta next day with it, so yum. Scallop Ceviche is a must if they have it. Oysters are great when they are available. NE Clam chowder is super yummy too, but a little different than the normal cause I think theirs have dill in it. The fish they sell seems super fresh. They have other stuff on their menu but honestly haven't tried anything else yet. I keep getting the same things each time cause it is so good already. read more

It was a great pleasure shopping here! It is the epitome of customer service and customer experience. Once I picked my fish , I was asked how I would be cooking it thereby helping me with actually a lot as the sea bass were so gorgeous, fresh and big. What I saw is an awesome crew caring and willing to go the extra mile and LOVING what they do! Thanks guys! Will be back read more

Damn.... i still dream about these sweet ultra fresh oysters from Amagansett Seafood Store on 517 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930. OMG... the best seafood in the world. Especially the owner Mike he is so friendly kind and entertaining. We love this place. read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - a tray of oysters - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

What a wonderful little store with an amazing assortment of fresh fish. Great staff and the owner is available to help you decide. Don't miss out on the assorted side dishes that are also available. Give them a try! read more

Friendly staff, delicious fresh food, best lobster roll I have ever had can't wait to come back

Mike is special, he knows everything about fish and by choosing Chelsea, nothing about football. Love this guy and the shop. Hidden treasure is salmon curry. read more

I went in right before closing on a holiday weekend and it was quite a scene. The owner was hugging regulars like they were family. Then he excused himself to turn up the stereo when a good Van Morrison song came on. A young man helped me with my order and explained it had been a hectic day. He thanked me for being flexible and gave me some complimentary Mahi Mahi. We had a feast with the great fish and plan to come back. read more

ZERO STARS!! Stay away!! The owner was rushing me off the phone when trying to order steamed lobsters. When i went to pick them up he was drinking beer and doing tequila shots. He gave us LIVE lobsters and refused to cook them for us after HE messed up our order. Terrible business owner. We explained we are renting and don't have the supplies to cook 10 live lobsters and he continued to tell us we ordered wrong. How does he not fix HIS mistake after someone spends so much money?? Terrible business there are many other places to order lobsters from.. stay away from here!!! read more

Love to stop when we drive into town. Mike always has something delicious going on. Today it was dozens of fat juicy oysters on the half shell and to die for crab bisque. Bring a bottle of wine or a six pack, pull up a chair and tune in to the football (soccer) match that is sure to be on. You can get provisions for the house while you're there, but don't buy too much bc you'll want an excuse to come back again and again. read more

Mike the owner is very personable with the freshest fish in town. Had soft shell crab & blackened scallop tacos with a special sauce. Amazing tacos, ceviche, and lobster salad. Jan who took our order was great and accommodating! Very friendly staff and delicious seafood! Must try! read more

BEST seafood ever - mike is the MAN! There is no place on earth that compares to here!

5 star is not enough for this place. Michael was amazing and so accommodating. Me and two of my friends had fresh oysters, raw scallops, lobster roll, scallop taco, seaweed and fried lotus root salad, ceviche and octopus dishes. Omg. They were all heaven. He even made drink with ceviche juice. So fun! Love their fun ambiance and super fresh seafood. They had the best raw scallop sashimi than anywhere else. True 5 star!!!!! read more

Amagansett Seafood Store - Seafood Markets Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Mike is an absolute legend. You'll be smiling ear to ear throughout your experience. Not to mention amazing seafood! 10,000 stars

I love love love Amagansett Seafood Store. Michael is a gas man. A Wexford man too. My sister had me prepared for a visit here, but it was so much more fun and entertaining than I had imagined. After a shot of high end tequila from the freezer, we got our pre-ordered clam bake for two, some fish sauce and the lone of a knife to crack open the lobsters. It was all wonderful. And the most amazing dining experience I've had in years. Eating a clam bake we cooked ourselves on a beach bonfire at sunset. Absolute heaven. I see from a couple of other reviews, some people have taken exception to Michaels personality. I think he's the highlight and I'm glad the majority of Yelp reviewers have embraced this shop and it's proprietor. As the Amagansett Seafood Store by-line says "Get Fresh", it sets the fun tone before you even set foot in the place. Highly recommended if you have an open mind and sense of humour. read more

Thanks Mike - Sunday 10/21/2012... Just stuffed myself full of Sea Scallops - cooked as per your simple and easy to folow directions ! De Lish !! Best Birthday Meal I've ever prepared myself ! Greg read more

Not to be missed if in the east Hampton/Amagansette area. Simply the best seafood if you're looking to cook at home and the most delicious prepared seafoods if you want to grab lunch to take to the beach or create an easy meal at home and impress your guests, I just feasted on soft shell crab tacos in a mango alioli sauce and the best crab cakes outside of Baltimore-all crab, hardly any breading. The atmosphere is a draw as much as the food. Mike creates a warm familial atmosphere where everyone is welcome -- locals and international visitors alike. A hamptons classic if you want locally caught fish and shellfish. So grateful there are places like this still left in a community getting more and more overtaken by national chain stores. read more

This is THE place to buy seafood in Hamptons. It can be a bit pricey, but you definitely get what you pay for. Make sure to try the scallop ceviche. It's the best ceviche I've ever had and I eat it every time I'm out there. Also be sure to chat up the friendly owner and you may get a free shot of tequila ;) read more

They have absolutely the freshest fish in the area. Mike goes out of his way to buy natural ocean fish, very little if any farmed fish.. I have never been disappointed In anything I have bought there. Delicious... read more

If you like a store run by a guy who values his booze more than your time this place is for you. Maybe if you get there before noon he'll still be sober but I wouldn't count on it. On the other hand, if you're looking to drink with some locals and Wolfie's is too far, stop by for a shot and maybe you can buy some fish eventually. read more

Awesome seafood!! Freshest ever! great company! And best place to watch soccer.. And don't forget to try the scallop ceviche! Mikes secret recipe.. read more

The freshest seafood and the best salads make this THE place on the east end. Mike the owner/proprietor is friendly, knowledgable, and an all around great guy! When the season ends this is the local "hangout" on Saturdays, where good people, good company, and fresh seafood all come together. read more

Great seafood, good food and outstanding experience! Mike is entertaining to say the least. This place will always be on the list of stops when in the Hamptons. read more

Amagansett's Seafood is by far the best on the East End. Over the years, I've shopped at virtually every other fishmonger in the area, and I don't shop at those guys anymore. Freshest Scallops, Swordfish, Striped Bass, and Lobsters, as well as many other kinds of fish and shellfish that can be had. Prices are very reasonable for the excellent quality, and the prepared foods are to die for! Lobster Rolls, Spicy Bass Dip, Fish Tacos, Lotus Root and Seaweed Salad (!), Lobster Mac and Cheese, are just a few of their delectable delights for snacking in-store or bringing home to the house! I have it on good authority that they will have the World Cup on this summer for all of you soccer fans. This place is simply the best. read more

The owner of this place was drunk when I visited the store. He made many inappropriate comments and had everyone in the store feeling uncomfortable. He berated an employee in front of all of us. On top of it all, several items we purchased were not good at all, including the tuna salad and lobster bisque. With so many good options for fresh seafood in the area, there's no reason to come here, read more

Amazing staff and experience, great to have a good laugh while picking up some great fish for the Barbie. Oh and don't forget the scallop ceviche it's out of this world. read more

It is true that the owner was on his way to drunk when we stopped in, but he was actually friendly and charming, let us taste stuff, gave us excellent advice (I like to think of myself as pretty knowledgeable when it comes to seafood, and I still learned a few things from him). With respect to the drinking, it was early in the day, so I could see him getting out of hand later in the day as some of the people below report. We went back into town later that day looking for an oyster shucker, couldn't find one, and he let us borrow one from his store, which we promised to return later. Very nice of him. But most of all, the product is excellent. We tried their oysters, clams, scallops, scallop ceviche, octopus salad, Mahi Mahi, smoked Bluefish dip. All of it was excellent, and I'm pretty picky (some might use much less flattering words) when it comes to seafood. Definitely worth going just for the product. read more

This is my favorite seafood shop! Michael and his team are just the best. Seafood is always delicious and they have never let me down, small and large orders, perfect each time! read more