I've been stopping at this fish market after my North Fork runs for fresh seafood forever, and every single time I tell myself, "Next time I'm eating lunch here." I think I did once... but apparently I completely forgot about it. Well, I finally sat down and ordered the lobster roll, and now I'm wondering what took me so long. I can't believe I slept on this lobster roll! If you know, you know ;summer doesn't officially start for me until I've had a great lobster roll. As of Summer 2026, this one is my favorite. The lobster was fresh, the mayo-to-celery ratio was perfect, and every bite was exactly what I want in a lobster roll. Safe to say I won't be waiting this long again. I'll absolutely be back! read more

Southold Fish Market - Lobster roll is perfection - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

Been wanting to try this place for a long time and finally got the chance to. They have a great selection of options that are seafood based and the food is really good. I had the big clams and a salad although the salad was a little cold and the shrimp was a bit tough my friend had a lobster roll and that tasted delicious when she gave me some to try. I love the atmosphere and the staff were very friendly and helpful. read more

Southold Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

This is THE fish market of all quaint fish markets in coastal towns. Part restaurant, part seafood market and part gift shop-Southhold offered so many things, I didn't know where to start. I wanted to order food to-go and also items to cook at home. We ended up get shrimp cocktail and I think a dip... Kicking myself for not trying more now that I'm back home in Texas. :/ read more

Southold Fish Market - Front entrance - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

Best lobster roll on the north fork. 10/10. This place never disappoints. Shrimp, fish, fries. Have never had a bad experience! read more

Southold Fish Market - Lobster roll 10/10 - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

Pretty good! Delicious, fresh and warm buttered lobster roll with bountiful lobster and a toasted bun. Loved the delicious side salad that came with it, which is super substantial, with big, juicy beefsteak tomatoes sliced atop. The three-star was the clam chowder, which was all cream and super thick. Not much clam. Would come back for the lobster roll and salad though. read more

See all

We were looking for somewhere to have lunch on a Saturday in the North Fork. I found Southold Fish Market and it looked great. We got here around 1 and when we ordered we were told food would be a 1 hour wait. We figured they were exaggerating but no, it really did take an hour. I must say we were all pretty hungry and it was worth the wait. I ordered the Soft-shell Crab basket (2 crabs, coleslaw, and fries) and my lunch dates ordered a lobster roll with fries and the fish tacos. We all loved our food. It is a fun place to watch people coming and going and buying fish at the counter. Super busy on a Saturday in August. This is your quintessential New England Seafood shack type place with a fish counter and small market. We loved it and we'll be back! read more

See all

We arrived here directly from LGA where we rented a car. We had gotten up at 4 am to make our flight and by the time we got to Southold Fish Market we were on vacation and hungry! We started with two dozen little neck- 1 dozen steamed and 1 dozen raw. They were beyond delicious. Then I had the mahi fish taco and my husband had the ahi tuna over greens. Both were really good. The taco (salad on the side) came with a coleslaw that was wonderful. If we lived here we would be regulars! read more

Southold Fish Market - Fish taco with side salad - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

The food is the freshest. We have enjoyed every meal we have had there, and we frequently drive the hour (each way) to pick up some frozen soups to stock up during the cold months. The staff is always friendly and helpful. Highly recommended. read more

Southhold Fish Market : Amazing Place, the host lead us through the line provided us with a menu, arranged for a seat indoors with our service dog! Wow what an amazing experience, she was very friendly elder lady. Thank you for your kindness, great service and amazing prices, far better than Sag Harbors Over priced Le Bilboquet, a 1 Star dump of a restaurant. Defiantly stay on the North Shore and make this amazing dog friendly South hold Fish Market a stop off on your way to Green Port! ~ Cowboy read more

Southold Fish Market - Do not eat at this dump instead eat at Southhold Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

Fantastic! This place is awesome. Menu is great, lots of options. Staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Outdoor seating is a major plus. Like a few places in the area they have grilled oysters. Until today I have not tried them. Couldn't decide which to get, fresh or grilled so figured just do both. Best decision ever! Fact that they have local oysters at a reasonable price is awesome. Prior to this stopped at a spot just 7min away and they were charging $28 for half dozen grilled. Here price tag was about $16. That's a big difference. Flavors were on point. The shucking of the raw oysters was perfect. Not even a scrap of shell and the meats detached but the juices still in the shell. Grilled oysters no shell but meats still attached but whatever just delicious. Sat outside with the dog in a breezy day but weather was perfect. When placing the order they warned it's about a 25min wait. Wait was close to that but absolutely worth it. Honestly who needs the Hampton and those fancy places when you have something like this! read more

See all

This is a very nice fish market where you can purchase fresh fish or prepared meals . On the day I came it was very busy and we had to wait for a table as there is limited seating inside . There are several picnic tables outside which is great when the weather is nice . Everyone was polite and welcoming. Everything we ordered for lunch was so delicious and fresh . We shared the Sesame Seared Tuna Tacos and the Bay Scallop basket both with a choice of fries or salad . We got the salad and replaced fries with onion rings . The tacos were so good and tasty with the seaweed , shredded cabbage and a delicious sesame ginger sauce . The Bay Scallops were sweet and tender and not at all oily , as were the delicious crispy onion rings. This is definitely a great place to stop in for a delicious meal ! read more

See all

This unique combination of restaurant and fresh fish market is an absolute gem on the tip of Long Island. From the absolute freshest fish available locally, to an amazing selection of chowder and prepared dishes, this is a not-to-be-missed stop for the local fish lover. Highly recommend. read more

Freshly battered corn fritters. Large lobster portions, meaty lobster rolls. Not your table service type of place since it's both a market and restaurant, you get a buzzer for when your food is ready for pick up. Cute place with indoor and outdoor dining like you're enjoying a lobster roll in Maine. You can grab fresh seafood for dinner while having lunch there earlier in the day. Will definitely be back to try other items from the menu and seafood to grill. read more

Southold Fish Market - Corn fritters and warm lobster rolls one with salad as the side, one with fries - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

I loved my visit to the Southold Fish Market today! It was a beautiful day so we grabbed a quick bite and sat outside. I got mozzarella sticks and fries and was awed at all the fresh fish they had for sale inside! The woman at the counter was so sweet and I can tell why this spot is so popular among the locals. Wish this spot was closer, I'd come way more often! read more

See all

Get fish and chips - you won't be disappointed. Fish is fresh, batter is thick, a perfect blend of chewy and crunchy, and comes out piping hot. Comes with delicious tartar sauce not pictured too. Just don't eat too fast or you'll burn your mouth like me! Place is clearly a local favorite - was packed and half of it is a seafood market. Kinda weird to have that near prepared food but it didn't bother us. Super casual, pay at the counter. We also ordered a dozen oysters on the half shell, nothing wrong but forgettable. read more

Southold Fish Market - Fish & Chips - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

A restaurant and fish market in the same building. Was ok though, place was clean. Menu was behind the counter where we ordered and then was given a buzzer. Very casual. The lady who took our order was very friendly. She mentioned the hour-wait for food (bec so many people that Saturday) and the food did come in an hour. Bisque and raw oysters came out faster though. Raw oysters are $20/dozen - fresh. Some local options up to $34/dozen. Seafood bisque was a bit thick for me, reminded me more of a pasta sauce. Fish and chips $16 were very lightly tempura-battered which I liked (another option for $1 more is breaded fish). Fries were a little soggy. Warm lobster roll with fries was delicious but we've had similar or better at other places. Fried oyster po boy had a lot of oysters but oyster taste is not for me. Each order came with coleslaw. Ample parking and outdoor seating, under umbrellas. Some tables inside. A small thing but the ice in a small cooler was very much appreciated since we went at lunchtime and weather was warm. read more

See all

Everything fresh and delicious! They close early so don't wait until the last minute.

My husband bought a container of frozen clams to add to a pasta sauce. When he opened them and poured them into the sauce, he realized they were all covered in muddy sand. They were not clean and the sauce was ruined and had to be thrown away. So disappointing. Bad quality control and a waste of time and money. read more

Good Food, just not the best I have had, and I have eaten seafood extensively up and down the East Coast. Food: Our adventure off-season spared us the agony of long queues, which was a relief. The Warm Lobster Roll was brimming with succulent lobster, albeit a tad steeply priced at $33. The coleslaw was a pleasant surprise with its delightful hint of pineapple. However, the fresh-cut French Fries missed the mark - if you're going fresh, make 'em crispy! And yes it is possible with the right potatoes and process. The Local Clam Basket delivered on freshness, though some clams were a bit gummy from the breading, and yes, those fries again! The Onion Rings were tasty, but $12 for a side? Pricing puzzled me a bit, despite understanding the rising costs. Service: Efficient, yes. Memorable? Not particularly. Counter service kept things moving, but there were no standout moments--positive or negative. Vibe: Picture a laid-back coastal spot, clean and comfy but lacking that extra oomph. It's not exactly a destination in itself, but it serves its purpose without any major hiccups. So there you have it--a culinary escapade with highs, lows, and everything in between. If I were invited to go, I wouldn't turn it down, just not sure I would make a special trip. read more

See all

The food was priced fairly, there was a good amount of seating, the food was FRESH, but my only complaint was that they gave less clams that I expected on the po sandwich. read more

Southold Fish Market - My burnt friend eating some fish n chips - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

I don't give 5 stars often, but the quality, value, happy atmosphere, and quantity was wonderful. This is a dying type of restaurant because it's also a great fish store. No beer, brown paper table 'cloths', sturdy paper plates, no built in service tip (so bring cash and be generous! We're both soft-shell pisser clams and oyster lovers, driven from our passion, passers elsewhere at $1 each, NO. Well, we ordered steamers and I'm guessing they were maybe 50¢ each, smaller, which means also sweeter. My wife had shrimp tacos, fine, huge salad and good coleslaw. I lucked out on a special 8 oz Swordfish (grilled pink interior at my request)) ciabatta sandwich with lettuce and excellent tomato, and a huge mound of hand cut french fries, some of which came home. So good, I can add some wishes. I assume you're BYOB, as a beer would be nice? Your pissers should be soaked longer, as they were quite sandy. I love drinking the broth, particularly since your butter is seasoned. Not possible in the small plastic cups. Check out what Sophies does! Bigger plastic is needed. We kept catching you on Tuesdays when you're closed, now we know better! read more

Incredible selections of fresh fish, shellfish, prepared foods and soups. Zach is always super helpful with service. We feel so lucky to have such a top-notch fish monger so close to Greenport. read more

Great market and prepared food. Tried the oyster basket and fish and chips. The batter on the fish and chips was light but less crispy. The fish was very fresh. The oysters were also lightly breaded and fried and the salad was very fresh. The hard cider they served was also very smooth and light. Would come back and recommend to anyone visiting the north fork! read more

Southold Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

The best fresh seafood especially from their kitchen. Lovely, delicious platters, sandwiches, wraps etc. all freshly made.

Away from the village along 25 you'll find a gem of a market/restaurant. The fresh fish looked stunning We ordered a variety of local Oysters and clams. Honestly the best raw clams we have ever had. You know they came right out of the water. They were sweet and firm. Fairly reasonable for the area, 6 for $8 (without being a happy hour price). The Manhattan clam chowder was freshly made with chunks of veggies and potatoes. If we ever get back to the North Fork we will for sure visit again. read more

Southold Fish Market - Clam chowder - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

Large selection of various seafood entrees. Very fresh! Will definitely be returning. read more

Southold Fish Market - Dozen wild oysters - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

Terrific spot for off the boat, right out of the ocean, fresh seafood to eat on site or take home to prepare later. Picnic tables outside on the grounds to enjoy your feast. You can have your feast made there eat, or they have many items in the freezers to take home for later. There is a bar inside and seating for when the Covid restrictions are finally over. Menu of items offered on the chalkboards including daily specials. Affordable prices for seafood. Ice bins with loads of the catch of the day and prices listed. Put in your order and they give you a buzzer to notify you when it's ready. Everything we had was delicious. Some of the freshest shrimp I ever ate! read more

See all

Seafood market and restaurant in Southold, NY We had lobster roll with salad ($32) and fried oysters ($16) with french fries. We ordered the food and waited about 20minutes for buzzer to ring to pick up our food. The lobster roll was good without too much mayo and salad was fresh but it was on a regular hot dog bun. The fried oyster and french fries were little soggy and not much oysters. read more

See all

Absolutely worth the drive for this delicious seafood shack! Fried fish and chips and the broiled oysters are the best!

The black sea bass I bought at the market today was full of scales and bones -- pretty much inedible and a real disappointment.. I won't go back. read more

Love this a lot always good atmosphere, flavors are good , fresh seafood , prices aren't that bad . Parents and sister loved it . Alcohol and bar is a plus , ans the fresh seafood . read more

See all

Our food took 40 minutes to come out which was 4 different meals. However it was a busy day so I don't blame the restaurant. As I sat down a random cat came up to me looking for someone to get pets from. I'm guessing it is there for rodent control but either way it made me happy. They have local papers available as well as fish, fish products, and ingredients to purchase. The food was not too great but it wasn't bad. We fed some leftover fish to the cat. The outside seating area is nice and there are many parking spaces available. It's also right next to the ferry to shelter island so you can get it and go! We also got lobster which was great and tons leftovers for different recipes. read more

Southold Fish Market - A very friendly cat that came up for pets. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

Came here specifically for their lobster roll, which was listed as one of the best on LI on a recent 2020 news article. They have both hot and cold, and I got the cold. The wait is a little lengthy, but come prepared and it goes by quick. There are tons of outdoor picnic tables on either side of the driveway. Place your order, wait outside and they will announce your name on their outdoor speaker system. The lobster roll comes with lettuce tomato, coleslaw, and your choice of salad or fries. The bun should have been toasted/buttered. But the lobster was very good and very fresh, with big chunks and not chopped up. My husband had the fried oyster platter, which I thought was great. The breading was seasoned perfectly and each oyster was juicy and tender. Pass on the baked clams. I would come back and try the hot lobster roll and definitely get the oysters again. read more

See all

The place is very authentic with items are super fresh! The cashier was super friendly and helpful. The warm lobster roll was a bit dry and overpriced. I expected better. The fries believe it or not were the best item ordered, fresh, crisp and delicious! Outside sitting is the way to go. read more

Outrageously good food! Fresh and varied. The owner is incredibly accessible and helpful. The take out is truly amazing - fresh tuna salad not to be missed! read more

Quality control has slipped and customer service/care is lacking. This has been a goto for me for years but this season my last two visits i wound up with a spoiled piece of $20 swordfish and now i get home and 4 of my 18 little necks were broken yesterday. I'll drive the extra 10 mins to Brauns from now on. read more

Great spot to grab a beer and some amazing fresh seafood. Nice seating outside and quite spacious and less busy towards the back. Fish and chips, tuna steak with ginger sauce and the lobster roll are a hit. Also really good to get fish to go and cook at home. Great prices. read more

This lively spot is a Home Run -- crushing all bases: Fresh and Delicious, Fair and Reasonable, Friendly and Cheerful, Consistent and Comprehensive. I've purchased fish at the market to grill at home (always a winner!), and I've enjoyed the dine-in experience thoroughly every visit, including oysters / clams on the half-shell, the fish tacos, shrimp tacos, bay scallops -- you name it -- and of course the Grand Slam selection of cold beers. The prevailing vibe is casual, lively, clean. I can say truly I have never tasted seafood as fresh nor as perfectly prepared and presented to Focus On The Fish! The staff clearly love their jobs, whether in the market section of the business, at the bar, or at the food order/cashier station. Always enthusiastic and delighted to please. Thank you Southold Fish Market. read more

Southold Fish Market - Nothing like Southold Fish Market Fish Tacos and Little Necks on the halfshell at one of the picnic tables. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

The food here is DELICIOUS! Every time I come to the north fork, I try to eat somewhere new, but then I always end up at Southold Fish Market. The seafood here is incredibly fresh, which makes it taste amazing! I recommend the scallops! Both the bay and sea scallops are so yummy with fries with garlic aioli, tarter, and their cocktail sauce. YUMMY! My family has also tried the fish platter, the fish Reuben and the stuffed fish, which they have all reported as delicious but every time I go there I'm getting my scallops because I haven't tasted scallops this good anywhere else! There's a seating area outside and inside as well as a very clean bathroom. Enjoy! read more

Best fresh fish on Long Island. Friendly staff. They always took special care of my stepdad John PONTINO who was a regular customer. I was also until I moved upstate New York but whenever I'm in town SOUTHOLD fish market is first on list. read more