Fantastic Special Pizza. Great cheese too. We got a cheese pizza, a special and a pepperoni. All were very delicious Sausage was delicious. Well done. read more

Excellent food. The lasagna is very good. Service was also very good. Not a lot of seating but seems they do mostly take out anyway. Solid choice! read more

Asked for well done with banana peppers and got doughy not crispy with bell peppers Ugh read more

See all

Great food and great people. The family that own and run the restaurant are super nice. The food is top shelf !

Best Grandma pie! This is so fresh and good. It's worth the 20 minute trip to pick this up. read more

yikes a little tough guys, you wanna do a little better, way too greasy, what is good with that? read more

Sicily Pizza & Restaurant - Yukes - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Friendly staff and a clean newly remodeled inside. Got 2 slices and they where on the better side of pizza you can get in the Lehigh Valley. read more

Sicily Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Very disappointed in this pizzeria restaurant.. meatball Parm hero was overcooked . mussels marina tasted like it came from a can. Calamari came with no sauce. Greek salad was no Greek salad. But the pizza was good. That's why I gave it one star. read more

Always has amazing food. The staff is very nice. One of the best pizza places in Nazareth.

I ordered baked ziti and I got baked noodles , the lady on the phone could hardly speak English, what a joke.

One star for being open on Sunday when other places are closed. Plus another star because the sticks are decent. Unfortunately the pizza is just not good. I wouldn't normally take the time to post a negative review but this was the third strike. The first two times I gave the benefit of doubt since my son would go after school and tell me the slices are good. I then realized he is getting the ziti slice. Which how can you mess that up, it's pasta on dough. You can't just dump cheese and sauce on dough and call it pizza. Look at the pictures... it's just horrible. No pie should look like that. It's all sloppy cheese with no taste/ To the owners and workers Please take some time off and go visit a good pizza place in north jersey or even New York and learn the art of making a good pie. ***ive since ordered here many times since this review. Maybe it was a bad day but I will say I've not received a sloppy pizza or bad meal lately. In fact I order from here more times then not. They have great dinners and sandwiches. I don't always get pizza but so far has been pretty good. I'd say they should throw in a soda or app if you spend more then 30 like other do. Nice job! read more

Sicily Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

See all

Delicious food! Love the Granma pie! But everything is great! Staff is friendly & helpful. Clean environment.

Average pizza. I personally haven't had a bad experience yet, but nothing to write home about. It probably wont make Dave Portnoy's 7+ list, but its good quality pizza, and I think the best in Nazareth, PA. read more

Mussels entree was very good but the salad included in the online menu was missing. When asked, they just replied we don,t include that anymore. Maybe take it off the menu because the price I saw and paid included one. read more

5 stars for their calamari and pasta dishes! 5 stars for their Sicilian pie! 3 stars for their classic pizza. 3 stars for dine-in experience. read more

My wife and stop by for an early dinner and we had the whole place to ourselves. Christmas music, good food and friendly staff......doesn't get any better! read more

Sicily Pizza & Restaurant - a christmas tree in the dining room - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Went here twice and we had some appetizers and grandma pizza...the grandma pizza is so different and the sauce is so delicious. When the pizza comes out it looks too beautiful to eat. The owners are so professional and go out of their way to accommodate requests in person and on the phone. They have a nice size dining room too however due to lack of staff, they have not been able to open their dining room in two years due to Covid. Such a shame as their dishes look great too. A must try if your in the neighborhood. read more

My family and I went here after shopping by the bridal shop next door. The food was AMAZING and the service was so great! The staff was so friendly! I would definitely recommend and will be going back! Update: The second time I went the waitress was much less attentive (maybe she was just new and learning?). The dining area was very chilly and the waitress said (politely) she could not fix it. Food was still awesome, service was just a little less than what we were expecting based of the first visit. read more

Ordered a pizza with sausage a week or so ago. Asked for extra crispy because in past pizza is soggy. So, i took home a soggy pizza once again.with not so good sausage and or cheese because it made me ill. Don't care much for this place. Hope they clean up their act and stop serving bacteria. read more

Dining Date January 23, 2015 for lunch. Gigantic buffalo chicken pizza slice was very good. I have ordered takeout pizza here many times and am always happy with the pies. Their prices are good. Take out service is always fast and accurate. read more

We love this restaurant and we have been eating here since 2001. I have never had anything that was not delicious. We don't get there often enough just because it is not near where we live. Every time we go to Wegmans on rt. #248 we go to Sicily for dinner. The owner of this place is a nice guy and he has his entire family also working there. Fantastic food and great prices. You will not be disappointed. read more

im always disappointed when i go here....then i say im going to joes pizza...then im disappointed again...when i spend 50 dollars on pizza i expect my dog wanting to eat it at the very least. This food absolutely sucks. My whole life i have gotten pizza from sicily's and it absolutely sucks read more

Good, but not great pizza. Sicily's has built its reputation on it's location, it is one of the most popular walkable destinations from Nazareth Middle School (or whatever they are calling it now) and as a result all the Middle Schoolers flock there on half days, exam days, or pretty much any time they are turned loose like a pack for rabid dogs. Sicily's counts on Schaffer kids to convince us Lower Nazareth and Bushkill kids, who know better. read more

When the guy at the counter decides to ridicule you and make fun of you then maybe it's time to pick a different place to eat. I'm not saying this place isn't clean or there's something going on behind the scenes, but they do clean their windows with windex while the pizza sits below it. If you're around here, just pass. read more

I've always enjoyed this restaurant, but recently their quality and service is suffering. Apparently they raised their prices, everything up $1. However their menus (both paper and online) do not reflect this. Very disappointed. read more

I grew up eating Sicily's Pizza, so I may be a little biased here. But, ever since I moved away the one thing I need to have when I come home is Sicily's. The pizza here is so unique that I have yet to find another pizzeria that comes close. Although the pizza is rather greasy they combine the right portion of sauce to cheese along with a soft crust. I don't know how they do it. If you are a fan of pizza though, you owe it to yourself to give Sicily's a try! read more

We've never had a disappointing meal here. The bruschetta is so good and the pizza is always so fresh! Love this place!

We had three different pizzas and all of them were great. They had a great crust and the perfect amount of toppings. Very few places can do veggie and Hawaiian without it getting soggy but they do it great. The service was friendly and just the right amount. read more

Best pizza in Nazareth. They have a fine dining room but are mainly a local pizza shop. And they have 6 packs.

Love their food. Their sauces are delicious and fresh. My favorite Italian food around. The Granma pizza and baked gnocchi are two of my top favs. Their bread is also really good. Service is great - owner always goes around and checks on every single table every time I'm there. read more

Decent pie with good taste. A solid top 5 joint in the area. Tip. Love eating slices in. Taste so much better reheated. Tip. Use the drive through window for quick pay and go. read more

Best pizza spot in PA. Best place to eat. Food is awesome. If you want good Italian food, eat here.

Hands down my go-to Italian restaurant. Food is always delicious and consistent. Wait staff are friendly and attentive. Prices are more than fair. Must try the rigatoni vodka --my entire family LOVES it! read more

Promised delivery to a corporate event and backed out at the last minute and we had to drive to get the order and carry many pizzas, etc into the event that started late because POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE ! Never going there ever again. read more

I have never had a bad experience here whether it be for take out or dining. The staff is very friendly & the pizza has been my favorite for years. I'm sure its the same pizza dough recipe, but I prefer the Nazareth Sicilys pizza over the one in Forks for some reason. read more

We have not eaten at Sicily, we have only ordered for take out. That being said, I really wonder what took us so long to try Sicily considering we live less than 1/2 mile away from the restaurant. In the last week we have had takeout from Sicily 2 times, both times everything was very good. We did not call orders in ahead of time but did not wait more than 20 minutes for our order to be ready. Based on the quality of our 2 takeout orders we plan on visiting in the near future. Very good value for the price paid on the items we have had. read more

I was very surprised to hear that this place didnt get better reviews. I've never had the pizza and can only speak of my experience in the dinning room, but the food was great for the price and the serving sizes were more than generous. The waitresses are always pleasant and friendly. read more

I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, but when I was eating it, all the chicken fell off. Not worth it in my mind.

The pizza was the only reason that this isn't a 1 start review. Walking in to Sicily Pizza never having been there before my friend and I were almost intimidated by the entire staff perking up when we entered the empty pizza parlor. We hoped that would've been a sign of good service ahead, sadly it wasn't. Apparently we were unaware that there were was an additional dining room that had dedicated servers. We figured that out when we were being called over by an obviously frustrated employee. Takeout is the way to go here, you get what you get. read more

The fact that consistently their food has been, eh, and they will give you a time of 20 minutes until ready, even if it's an hour, should say enough. But I ordered cheese fries this evening, and behind my back, my husband is adding cheese and sticking it in the toaster oven, because there is barely any cheese on them (which is an extra $1.50 btw) says even more. Done. So done. read more