Real local place off the beaten path. Crowded with mostly local seniors when I was there on a Friday night. Great place for Catfish. All you can eat and portions are thick and hot out of the fryer. Good service. Country decor. If you like catfish, this is the place. read more

Simon's Catch - Exterior - Seafood Near Me - Elk City, Oklahoma

See all

We got our fish to go and it was amazing. Can't wait to go back and eat here again. Was a great experience and a good find. read more

If I could assign a ten, I would! Catfish fried to perfection. PERFECT Cole Slaw, hand-cut fries to DIE FOR!!! The hush puppies are AMAZING!!! His ribeye was AMAZING and all I can say is that's the way a steak SHOULD TASTE!!!! Flavourful baked potato - really these two meals were some of thee best food we've had in DECADES!!!!! Great ambience! Thank you to the amazing wait staff and hostess - like clockwork! All I can say is I hope and pray we come back this way, because these meals were just simply delicious! read more

See all

Catfish Was On Point!!!! I didn't care for the Cole slaw, but I'm super picky about that...every else was super tasty & the staff was very friendly. read more

When I back in western Oklahoma visiting my family there is only one place I want to go for dinner. Simon's catch. Bro. It's so good! I always get the all-you-can-eat cath fish and you know what! They give you such big pieces of fish that I usually only get two deep. Sometimes I go for that third, but don't you worry. They aren't skimping on fish size. I am a big fan of coleslaw and they're is definitely in my top 3 favorite. Did I mention the hush puppies!? Shame on me. When I was younger they were stick hush puppies, now they're balls. And you know what. They're still amazing! They also have souvenir cups now! They may have had this for awhile, but I haven't been in awhile. A nice memento to remember my delicious meal. I could tell the waitress was busy, but she was never too busy for us. Very helpful send great service! read more

See all

Man this is a hidden gem in western Oklahoma. It's simple, quaint, and delicious. Seriously if you're looking for great all you can eat catfish and some of the best hush puppies you can find, why wouldn't you start in the boondocks of Oklahoma. It's off the beaten path for sure but man you won't regret it. Plus you get away from the hustle and bustle and into the backwoods to enjoy the peace and quiet and some southern hospitality. read more

See all

Service was excellent. The food was only ok. Fish fillets were very thin. Biggest disappointment for me was the hush puppies. Their version was a cornmeal log with no seasoning. read more

We really wanted to like this place. When they first brought out the hush puppies and slaw, we were excited because these were hush puppies that my husbands father served at his restaurant, The Der Dutchman, years ago in Oklahoma City. We both ordered fish and they brought out three small pieces for both of us after waiting probably 15 minutes are getting our sides. Then there was little to no meat in them. Only batter. They made another batch (2 pieces) which wasn't much better. The people behind us complained about it. Service was good and the restaurant itself is cute, but the catfish was disappointing. read more

Simon's Catch - Hush puppies and slaw. - Seafood Near Me - Elk City, Oklahoma

See all

Amazing food, amazing service, and an amazing ambiance. They even give you plastic cups for free which last a long time incase you happen to need an extra for home. read more

Great food! We try to go every time we are in town for baseball. It gets packed but so worth it!

Great food and service Had the pecan crusted fish with the fabulous sauce and loved every bite. read more

Love Simon's everything is awesome the people the service and the food! Great place to dine in with family...

Had the fish. It was delicious. The sides were also very good. The staff was friendly and efficient. Plan to try a steak next time which I hope is soon. read more

We've been to Simon's Catch a few times while visiting family in Elk City. The food has always been hot and delicious. We've tried the all-you-can-eat catfish and the fried shrimp dinner. Yum. Nice portions. Tasty sides. Good prices. Homey atmosphere. Best restaurant in Elk City! read more

It was a very distracted dinner experience. Me and my husband did not enjoy being here to eat. It was so loud, and waitresses carrying trays all around us. read more

We were on our way to Tulsa and stopped in Elk City for gas. We are so happy to have happened on Simon's Catch! We all ordered the shrimp and baked potato. Loved the light breading and homemade salad dressing. You won't be disappointed! read more

Simon's Catch - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Elk City, Oklahoma

Thinly breaded all you can eat catfish, fresh cut fries, pinto beans, cole slaw, and hush puppies were excellent. They were accompanied by spicy chunked green tomato pickles that were over the top good. We even bought a jar. I had the 8 oz hand cut fillet which had an excellent flavor grill seared on the outside and medium rare on the inside. Baked potato, roll, and salad too. Excellent service, very attentive, got seated quickly. Be aware this place seems like it's out in the middle of nowhere for those of us that aren't local. Well worth the drive. This restaurant serves no beer or alcohol. read more

See all

My wife and I stopped by this gem while we were passing through Oklahoma. I had the ribeye and it was phenomenal! She ordered the catfish and ate like two plates, which is very uncommon for her to do even on holidays. It was fairly inexpensive as far as quality food at a sit down establishment goes. The same meal in California would easily cost a hundred dollars and probably be nowhere near as good. You can tell the people at Simon's love what they do, and they do it great. The staff was nice; although, I will say be prepared for some intense looks from the locals if you're covered in tattoos. We got seated in the middle of the restaurant and all the staring made it a little hard to enjoy my food-- but that's not the restaurant's fault. If you're clearly from out of town, just ask for a table in the corner with your backs to the wall. read more

I've been everywhere in the US and this is some good catfish! Thanks again! I'll be back soon! The shrimp is great too! These people care what their food tastes like! read more

Simon's Catch - Catfish - Seafood Near Me - Elk City, Oklahoma

We hadn't eaten here in years but we were hungry for fish. Our waitress, Carly, was exceptional! So friendly and attentive! The catfish was good although we both thought it could have been seasoned more. It wasn't over breaded; and was hot and crispy. Cole slaw is very good as are the fries and hush puppies. We'll be back. read more

Fire! I always stop here when I can. I wish they were open more often! Plenty of food and at a decent price. The beans are delicious! Beat hush puppies around. read more

I ordered the fillet with a salad, baked potato for an appetizer I had the boiled shrimp, cocktail sauce was perfectly spicy, everything was delicious , service was great and the people were pleasant. read more

Best dinner of our whole vacation! Our server, Amanda was a delight! We ordered the RibEye steaks, they were perfectly cooked and absolutely delicious!!! This is a place not to miss when in Elk City, Oklahoma read more

Consistently good! After our experience with the "catfish" restaurant in TX, it was great to have ACTUAL catfish! read more

See all

Wow! I found this place by browsing Yelp for the Elk City area. It was a little off the beaten path. When we pulled into the driveway we knew we made the right decision!! The parking lot was full! We were seated and waited on right away. Taylor was a wonderful server who was attentive snd sweet even though she was busy with another very large party. The menu isn't extensive which I like because it is much easier to make a decision. They specialize in all you can eat catfish. They also have shrimp and steaks. We ordered shrimp for an appetizer and the "all you can"eat catfish family meal. So so good!! Best catfish we have eaten in a very long time. We ended up getting two plates of fish. I really enjoyed the green tomato relish and bought a jar to take home. My husband loved the coleslaw. Very country style atmosphere. If you are traveling through this part of Oklahoma, stop in and enjoy this gem of a restaurant. (Not a good place for vegans.) read more

See all

One of the best places I've eaten at. We had the all you can eat fried catfish served family style. It's hard to find catfish properly cleaned but these folks do it right! Lots of sides.. beans, homemade fries, hush puppies, great coleslaw and outstanding small pickled tomatoes. On top of that we had one of the best waitresses we have had anywhere from California to Maine at a reasonable price. We will definitely be back. Well worth the 200 mile round trip! read more

This place was great!!! Passing through, I like to look for places the locals eat.... this place popped up and pics looked good. Following the directions I thought we were lost and then this oasis came into view and the parking lot was full on a Sunday night. I think everyone here knows each other but I don't feel like a stranger. If you are anywhere in the area, you should drive the extra hours to stop by... oh yeah... come hungry! read more

My husband and I found this restaurant while on a road trip. A little off the beaten path for someone traveling the I-40, but nice people, good food and a welcome change from corporate roadside offerings. We will definitely stop again next trip if timing allows. read more

We have been here few times, and always had great food and outstanding service! The all you can eat catfish is the way to go

Delicious food and super friendly service! Thank you Destiny and team for keeping your doors open and making me feel right at home. read more

Simon's Catch - Ribeye cooked to perfection :) - Seafood Near Me - Elk City, Oklahoma

The catfish was good, and the pinto beans were well prepared. The hush puppies may not have come out of a bag, but they lacked the strong onion flavor I expect in my hush puppies. The service was friendly and consistent, and the price was fair. I do not care for such sweet coleslaw, though -- make mine far less sweet, please. This place is way out in the middle of, well, nowhere. Be prepared for that. (It's probably no big deal for locals, though. I'll give you that much.) read more

Dang good fried catfish, generally hit this place when visiting family in the area, hush puppies, home cut fries and the steaks are good as well read more

Came here for a surprise birthday with a lot of people. The servers were very helpful and nice. Restaurant was clean. The catfish was the best I've had in years. Fried just right and seasoned perfectly. Clean fresh catfish taste. You can tell they really pride themselves on freshness. I will be coming back here anytime someone says they want catfish. read more

The all-you-can-eat catfish dinner was superb. I went there the next day and had the shrimp dinner which was likewise delicious. It is worth going out of the away to dine there. read more

Outstanding! Great fish, hush puppies, beans, etc.. Great place to go with family and friends.

This is one of the best places ever to eat! The catfish is amazing, homemade French fries, shrimp, and my ALL TIME FAVORITE.... the Ribeye steak!! We have eaten at a lot of steak houses in many parts of the state and other states and this is by far in the top 2 places. The service is always excellent and the workers are friendly. We will always make the drive from Yukon, OK to eat here!! read more

The catfish here is so tasty. Not overly breaded. Cooked just right. Great service. Great place. One of these days I'll try the ribeye which looks amazing!Have always enjoyed eating there and will continue! read more

Not much choice in Elk City but Simon's is a decent change from a fast food place. All you can eat fish, thurs-sat, is a bargain and a half, attentive wait staff, ample portions and variety. No beer... but soda drinks and ice tea are bottomless. Truth be told, not a fan of corn meal coating... too dry... Look forward to trying the steaks next visit... read more

Crispy fresh catfish that joyfully fills the Oklahoma section of my tummy! Delicious slaw, pinto beans, and green tomatoes as well!

Wow! Wow! Just had dinner at Simon's Catch in Elk City! So delicious. The catfish was so tasty and the variety of sides that come with the all you can eat is amazing: coleslaw, hush puppies, relish dish of pickles, seasoned pickles, red onion, seasoned pinto beans, French fries. Well worth the short trip out of Elk City. And our server, Carly, was a true gem. Encourage anyone on their way out of the state to stop & be amazed! read more