Genuinely best pizza i've ever had and the ranch was 10/10! Great service and a homey vibe, definitely recommend and worth every penny!

- stars across the board. - Chicago tavern style pizza. - I recommend getting the Royal Feast and request it well done & crispy. - They have been in business for many years and just recently discovered them which is a bummer. I wish they advertised so I would have discovered them sooner. read more

I'm giving 3 stars just because the pizza is really good. However, I can't say the same for the service. We came on a Friday evening around 10:20p. We were advised we'd have to take it to go because they were closing soon (11pm). We received our food and wanted to take a bite of our pizza hot (we had driven all the way from Doral) and was approached by her again letting us know we needed to leave because they closed at 10:30. It was only 10:36. Everywhere states they close at 11, including their own door. She was rude and just had an extremely nasty attitude. read more

Sir Pizza - Bacon and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

See all

Friendly staff! Family friendly! The pizza is consistent. Everything on the menu is fantastic. The pizza is cut into squares. The ranch is awesome. read more

Definitely a key biscayne staple. I've been coming here since I was a kid. I came on a week night and it was still pretty crowded inside. They will take your order quick and make you fresh pizza. Unfortunately, it takes time for the pizza so you're stuck waiting at your table smelling the deliciousness being cooked. The con is all the kids who come to buy pizza and are super loud and yell inside. read more

The pizza arrived hot and fresh, with a perfectly crispy crust and generous layers of cheese and pepperoni. The garlic bread was buttery, soft inside, and full of flavor. Everything tasted amazing! read more

Horrible Service, first off the girl Myra (old chick with glasses) she's a b*th and liar, first off said my order was taken by an Uber Eats driver, which first isn't true it was a pick up order, and second she couldn't find the footage of them giving ANOTHER PERSON my order without confirming the name first, Get this it was an $80+ order then proceeded to call the cops and kick me out for being "disrespectful", there's a reason why no one gets sir pizza in the key anymore, HORRIBLE SERVICE (thanks to Myra) half a star review if I could read more

I've been coming to this place since I was a kid I used to live in Key Biscayne years ago when I was a kid. I'm glad I came here after 7 PM on a Sunday cause it usually gets crowded before 6 PM I guess because of the kids and the grown-ups coming from the beach. It wasn't that crowded when I went inside I ordered the usual cheese pizza which was less than $20. The pizza was very good nice and hot. If you don't wanna pay more than $15 for pizza and a drink, then this place is not for you but hey, it's Key Biscayne where everything is expensive. I'm used to paying high prices. Other than that, I'm going to give it five stars. I come here about every other month to about every three months. I prefer this one than the one in Palmetto Bay. For some reason, I can't even order online from the one in Palmetto Bay. It takes me to a somewhat foreign language. read more

The pizza is amazing. Love it get the personal pizza wing side of ranch. Ordered ahead and ready when I picked up. read more

Sir Pizza - Half Hawaiian half pepperoni so delicious with a side of ranch for the win! - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

Good pizza after a beach day, i love that they cut it into small squares and their pepperoni is tiny and well spread on the pizza. The prices are fair, restaurant is clean, service is okay. read more

Sir Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

I have been a big fan of Sir Pizza for years, the only issue is that the sole location left is all the way in Key Biscayne. So we decided to make the journey and have some dinner at Sir Pizza. We ordered a large pizza with black olives, Basel, diced garlic, onions, and ham. We also ordered one cheese pizza and a highly recommended sandwich called the Big Sir. The pizza here is famous because they are cut to small squares which makes it easier to enjoy. The pizza here came out hot and fresh bursting with flavor. The Big Sir sandwich consists of ham, salami, provolone and mozzarella cheese toasted in the same oven where they do their pizza. Then it topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, it was delicious warm and crispy. Sir pizza is the perfect reason to go and visit Key Biscayne!! read more

Sir Pizza - Large pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

See all

Loved this pizza ! The sauce was great it was crispy and it came out fairly fast for it being busy too! I definitely will be coming back I love how they cut it into pieces for you so perfect to share with a group read more

i have to say this establishment has some of the worst customer service i've ever seen in my life it's absolutely shameful the way your employees answer the phone and handle orders. complete lack of professionalism. i don't know if they don't train their employees properly or if they think rude, snarky, confused people are the best fit to work here but i for sure will never give my money or the time of day to this place. good luck and good riddance hopefully ! read more

Always great thin crust pizza! 3.45 for a soda, No Refils.. at that price maybe 1 refill??? Short chef

Very good quality just a cheese pizza will do. First tried them back in high school since they have a location in coral gables

Terrible. Check your orders. We ordered half pepperoni and there was noting, we asked them and she (rude) said it was there. No resolution. We've been living here for 40 years and it's the first and last time. WHAT A SHAME. read more

My family grew up on the island and Sir Pizza is still the absolute best in town. I recommend getting hamburger or pepperoni pizza (or both) with ranch. It's has its own unique style and flavors. read more

This is a casual pizza spot. I had actually never ventured inside, we had always ordered in. Yesterday however, I experienced the full Sir Pizza experience. As I said, casual. There are booths inside. You order at the window and grab your food once your order is called. The inside is clean and simple. Service was fast and attentive, which is easy because all you're doing is going to a window and ordering. There is something addictive about their pizza. After one bite, I am left wanting more, and more. They have thinner crust and square cut pieces. The addictive nature of their pizza can probably be attributed to their ranch. I like to order EXTRA and dip my pizza in the ranch. It is the most wonderful compliment that pizza could ever ask for. Regardless of what you order, be certain to ask for some ranch to accompany it. You will not be disappointed. read more

Sir Pizza - Half cheese, half pepperoni. And RANCH!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

See all

Best pizza in town..... Grew up in this island and still go back just for some pepperoni pie and a side order of ranch. I literally just drive in to pick up and go back home. read more

Sir Pizza - a large pizza on a white plate - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

This has been on Key Biscayne for quite a few years now, and I have never tried it before. My BF said he had when it first opened and it is like any other chain (think Little Caesars / Hungry Howie's ) - mediocre pizza at best. Since we have been going to Casola's Pizza on 17th street in Miami for years and love it (see my previous review) , we had no reason to try Sir Pizza. When we had to move my mother in law out of the apartment on the Key, we had 6 guys in to take out the furniture and box things up and so we looked on line to see what would be the easiest to do. Sir Pizza seemed to be the place to go and have lunch brought in. They had a variety of food and they delivered . They opened at 10:30 am, and I called to place the order. Somehow we had looked at an old menu online and so they did not have many of things we wanted to order. So I had to hang up and look at the current menu and ask everyone again what they wanted. After I placed 1/2 the order, I was told that they did not offer delivery during the day - only at night. It would have been really helpful to have put that on the website or put that somewhere. We would have ordered from another restaurant in that case. We ordered a large cheese pizza, a large sausage and cheese pizza, 3 chicken breast sandwiches, a Philly cheese steak sub, tuna sub, and 1/2 lb hamburger. The pizza was a bit overcooked, so dry on the edges, and so not very flavorful. The sausage had a bit more flavor, but I didn't like that it was crumbled sausage, not chunks or slices. And again, it was a bit overcooked. The guys all said their subs/sandwiches were ok. Fine to fill up on, but they liked the subs made at the Winn Dixie much better. That says something right there. The woman on the phone was pleasant and our order was ready when they said it would be. But based on our mediocre pizza and food, I would not go there again. Even if I were trapped on the Key without a car. read more

Sir Pizza - Slice of cheese and cheese and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

Amazing i don't know why it doesn't have 5 stars. At least should be a 4.6. One flaw is they don't re fill drinks for free.

Best pizza in the world and has been so for over 40 years. The one thing that hasn't changed in KB. Ambiance is totally chill, service is totally whatever. But the pepperoni pizza has no equal! read more

Sir Pizza - Pepperoni pizza with extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

Been going here for decades. Favorite pizza after a trip to the beach. Consistently good and always is delicious. Highly recommend a side of their infamous ranch. Trust me try it and you'll understand the hype of pizza with ranch read more

See all

It honestly pains me to write this because I hadn't had Sir Pizza in roughly close to 5 years. I remember it being a bomb ass pizza. I used to go to the one in the gables quite often. My boyfriend raved about this one and said it's the original one so we drove way out of the way to pick up an order. I honestly was highly disappointed. The pizza recipe must have been completely revamped because this is not the pizza I remember. I remember the pepperoni pizza being loaded with the signature minced pepperoni, which our pizza severely lacked. The bbq chicken pizza was extremely dry. Chicken was over cooked. I'm not necessarily a huge fan of greasy pizza, but there was something about Sir Pizzas greasy pizza that was so delicious. This pizza had zero, I mean zero grease. I've never seen a pizza box I was able to recycle! LOL. I vote to bring back the old recipe! The cheese bread was okay. Nothing to rave about. We also had their chocolate chip cookies, which are the size my hand and they are pretty good. Not your typical cookie, but oddly addicting. read more

Absolutely loved this pizza spot. The pepperoni was diced like the inside of a pizza pocket. The pizza almost has no crust just crispy burnt ends. Highly recommend trying them out for a unique pizza experience in Key Biscayne. The large was perfect to feed 2-3. read more

Sir Pizza - Hal pepperoni half cheese large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

You walk in here and you would think you've entered a time warp, back to 1980. The place just feels yucky, with very poor lighting, especially in the left dining room. The old curved booths were very uncomfortable. To order, you walk up to the front counter--I barely got an acknowlegement of my presence, let alone a smile. I told them it was my first time there and it was dead silence. I settled on the royal feast pizza, removing mushrooms and adding bacon, and they charged me extra for that move--how nice. They made the pizza pretty quick and threw it on their conveyor belt pizza oven (Little Caesar's style). When it was done, they call your name and you pick it up. It was nice and hot with toppings all the way to the edge. Not sure why they cut it into squares, it creates very tiny pieces at the edge. Perhaps they could ask how I would like my pizza cut? These clowns covercooked the pizza, so the cheese was brown and dry, the crust underneath was thin and almost black. The sauce had far too much sugar in it making it overly sweet. Despite the number of toppings, the taste of the pizza was poor due to it being overcooked. I also didn't see any pepperoni on it; perhaps it's ground up? At any rate, the whole pizza was pretty tasteless. Also bought one of their chocolate chip cookies which also lacked flavor--I just tasted oily plain dough and some chocolate chips. What a waste of time; we won't be back. read more

See all

Menu loaded sir pizza has been in business 52 years!! We were at the beach and after we left I decided to show my daughter this place last time I visited was 20 years ago! So we ordered a small cheese , a lasagna. Cheese bread & a small salad! The food was phenomenal still after all these years! Great quality food and great staff this place remains opened all these years because it's the best! My daughter absolutely loved it! read more

See all

Always a favorite!!!! Their salad is always fresh, their pizza is freshly baked and beyond delicious, and then their cookies if made correctly are heaven on earth! Only reason I am giving a 4/5 this time is because I did not appreciate the staff that was working and they burned my cookies. read more

Sir Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

I haven't been here in over seven or eight years. I only come to Key Biscayne for work so I decided to come back and see if the pizza is still as good as I remember well I'm happy to report the quality is still the same and my pizza that I had for lunch was outstanding! Cooked just right. The sauce had great flavor. Perfect amount of cheese nice crispy crust. It was a very satisfying pizza. I'll definitely be back when I'm in the area. To Check out some other pizzas and some of their hot sandwiches. I've also heard people also like to get the ranch dressing and dip their pizza into it. Never tried that before but hey, you only live once!!! read more

See all

When my kids were younger, I always used to take them to Sir Pizza in kendall after their drs visits. We were all very sad when they closed. They also closed the one by merrick Park; we were devastated. I assumed all of them had closed, but as I was on Tik-Tok the other day, I saw someone at the original Sir Pizza in Key Biscayne, and my son immediately said, "Let's go". All I have to say is when I smelled that Pizza and my son, who is now 23 years old, it literally transformed me back in time when I use to take him. This time, he drove me, and he paid If you didn't know, now you know... read more

Sir Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

See all

This place is definitely the best pizza place in miami The family and I drive about 30 minutes just to come here. You have to try it with their ranch sauce ! read more

Sir Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

The best of the best this was the place for me since child hood I love it the pizza is out of this world my favorite they have all type of sauces you could pick from . If you are in the area stop by and check t read more

See all

Love this place! Went there a lot when a was growing up and have not been there approx a little more than 20 years! Pizza is still as good as I remembered and the chocolate chip cookies are still excellent! It is so nice to see that good thing with time have not changed! read more

See all

This layback and unpretentious pizza place has been one of my Summer fav eating spots for years and stopping by this Summer was no exception except there was... Service - Unfortunately, it was ok at best and felt as if they couldn't be bother to take my order much less prepare my food. There were plenty of people behind the counter so it wasn't due to being overwhelmed by servicing all its customers. Place - it lacked cleanliness...again, there was plenty of personnel for the restaurant not to be picked up. Food Ordered - *Original Pizza w: Pepperoni ($19.15) - this famous crustless pizza was very saucy & runny. Unlike previous occasions, the pizza would have been devoured; but this time, it was best to cut our losses. *Chef salad ($4.05) - it was fresh, tasty & worth eating. But when the salad that comes from a bag is better than the pizza I came for, it makes me shake my head... This fav place, unfortunately, fell from grace with me. I hope the owner(s) turn their personnel around & take charge of their food quality...can't wish you a Bon Appétit this time..! read more

Sir Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

See all

My boyfriend have been wanting to bring to this place for over a month, cuz he was here before and said was amazing, well, we are here and he is so upset, the "new" sauce that they are using for the pizza is really bad, doesn't taste the same and he is really disappointed, I am too read more

Locals tell me this place is good. Their pizza reminded me of Elios frozen pizza. This does not appear to be hand tossed Neopolitan style pizza like is available in the North east. The pizza dough was not very good, and the cheese was flavorless. The wife and I were very hungry after a long day at the beach and this was on the way home. Sorry, not a fan. read more

I grew up eating, sir pizza as a child and even though I moved off the island as an adult going back, it's still just as good literally my first stop as soon as I get back to Biscayne from Los Angeles. I look forward to it every single trip and I am so gratefulthat they are still going strong after all these years so please everybody them by eating their delicious amazing pizza and spread the word read more

Sir! This pizza is too saucy. The cheese isn't cheesing for me. Tbh I kind of liked the pizza and it's good after a long day at the beach but.... I wish it was more. It needs more cheese or better cheese and less sauce for sure. read more

I grew up in Key Biscayne and although they have Domino's on the island, it didn't surpass Sir Pizza. The ingredients are fresh!! I've never had a bad experience. I recall my younger days being spent on the beach with a nice delicious lunch from Sir Pizza!! Sir Pizza expanded their locations in Kendall, but it doesn't compare to Sir Pizza in Key Biscayne. Now I get to bring my boys where I grew up and the places on the island I enjoyed. Although I've read other reviews on the decor not being updated since 1980, I am happy it is still the same. I'm so happy Sir Pizza is still around! read more

Sir Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key Biscayne, Florida

Sir Pizza, you have a pizza my heart (see what I did there?). Whenever I leave Miami, Sir Pizza will most certainly be a place I miss. My love started over ten years ago while in college at the U. Back then, there were more locations, making it easy to order after long nights out on the town. Nowadays, there are only a couple of locations left including this one. I recently found myself nearby and couldn't leave the Key without bringing a pie home to go. My husband and I shared a large pepperoni pizza with a side of ranch (about $20) which fed us for both dinner and lunch the next day (but we had to show a lot of restraint to not eat the whole thing in one sitting). NO WHERE else do I order pizza with ranch but here it's just tradition. The pepperoni is also not in round slices like most pizza places, but rather, minced into small pieces. Again, not something I'd go for anywhere else but here. Part nostalgia and part pure deliciousness makes this pizza a win in my book. We called in our order for pickup and it was ready pretty quickly. We paid upon arrival. They seemed to be following COVID safety protocols, although it was really hard to hear in there between masks and the sound of the kitchen. There are some tables outside which people were taking advantage of. read more