Sir Pizza is your basic small town pizza place with a knights & dragon theme played out on murals and decor inside the restaurants. The local chain offers pizza that is quite good - thin crust, balanced tomato sauce, right amount of cheese. On certain nights a pizza buffet feeds a family for a reasonable price. I enjoy the nostalgic feel of the place - it reminds me of being a kid of the 80's eating dinner at the local pizza place with my family. The salad bar is hit or miss, especially the one on Main street. I've seen fruit flies on the lettuce and pudding. One time I asked for the waitress to take the salad bar off my ticket after I saw the look of it. I've had a couple of miserable experiences with Sir Pizza delivery as well. Once the pizza was two hours late and the order not only cold but was incorrect. I had to refuse it (poor driver) and called to have the charge removed from my credit card. I enjoy the pizza enough, though, that I overlook a lot of the issues and just enjoy it for what it is - a family pizza joint with some service kinks, but worth it overall. read more

I am an old school Sir Pizza fan going back to the early 80s. If you are like me, you will love this place. Pizza was great and the ambience is exactly how it should be. Staff is great. read more

We thought this place did not meet the expectations for the price. The other night I accidentally ordered pizza around the same time my wife ordered pizza and we ended up with two pizzas the same night from two different places. Well unfortunate accident but great opportunity to review and compare both places. Our entire family agreed that the overpriced pizza from here did not have the extra cheese that we ordered and cost more and was thinner than the other pizza that was ordered. Oh yeah and Sir pizza cost $6.00 more for the same size pizza. Definitely nothing there worth the extra $6.00. I am sure you have a crowd that is for you, but when we know we can order pizza from somewhere else and get what we ask for, like extra cheese, with great taste and at a lower price we will choose that option. read more

GREAT people, but horrible food. We were hoping for greatness and instead we can't believe it has won awards. It made us question if the people voting have taste buds or if they're the type who think Red Lobster is fine dining. Sorry, it was really just awful. The cheese tasted like rotten feet, the pepperoni looks like a party pizza, and the sausage is horribly small and dry... Not to mention the clumps of flour under the crust. Great idea, love the mom and pop idea, but they're missing the mark on good food. Disappointing. :( read more

I use to work at the warehouse of sir pizza and I feel like people should know how the dough is made, where it was made, and the conditions of things. It is made in a small warehouse in Murfreesboro. The people who makes the dough wears no gloves and there have been plenty of times when I pulled hair out of the dough before having to pack it to be sent to the stores that need them. The workers get a smoke break in the middle but don't wash their hands afterwards when they go back to dealing with the dough. As for working there, it was a horrible experience because they give special treatment to certain people that work there. There was a lady I had to deal with that cursed me out, lied about me looking for her with a knife I carried with me for protection ( because I had to take two buses early in the morning and then walk a few blocks in the dark), and she has a pretty bad history there. No one likes her but the owner and manager keep her because they pity her life and what she has gone though. After a confrontation that ended with them trying to put all the blame on me even though she was the one cursing, throwing things, having attitudes, and more. Then the owner tried to make me apologize to her by telling me to be the bigger person and try to get along with her ( telling me that if i talk with her that it would.make her mood better) after they let her curse me out in front of them but then when I retaliated and cursed back at her, that is when they would try and stop the conversation. There are only two African Americans there which was me and another worker. I have learned that not only did she walk out 3 times and they called her back, but she also threatened to stab someone which made them quiet the job the next day. I wouldn't recommend no one to eat their pizza or work at the warehouse because if you end up having problems with her, the owners and the manager are gonna take her side using her sad home life story as an excuse of the reason she acts mean and rude. I had to deal with this for almost a month before I left and I missed the bus twice on purpose because I didn't feel like taking any more verbal abuse and mean glares from this women and I was nice to her from day one until I realized it would be best that I just didn't talk to her. Her and another ex coworker that came back also started complaining about me leaving early but the thing is that they never truly trained me on what all I had to do.all I knew is that we pack the dough, clean the dough room, do the dishes and then we are done. This was when the women was being nice to me and that is what she told me that is all that we had to do so I didn't know that there was more. I just felt the customers should know what they are consuming and where it is coming from. As for explaing my experience there, I don't want anyone to go though what I went though. I was there to work, not make friends and give a pity party to a person who made bad choices themselves as they grew up and be a human verbal punching bag for them all because they are not having the best life and using it as an excuse to yell at me for no reason and lie about me doing something that I know I would never do. So what every you do, if you see that sir pizza warehouse in Murfreesboro is hiring DONT TAKE IT! read more

As we enter the restaurant a member of the staff was taking trash out through the front door, super tacky. The pizza tasted like it had been bought from the frozen case at the Kroger down the street. There was precious little toppings. Ambiance was dry and lacking. At least they have beer. read more

We have ordered delivery from this location more than 3 times. Always make sure to ask how long delivery wait is before placing your order. Sometimes they can get really busy and it could take over an hour. Their pizzas, wings and breadsticks are delicious. Prices are reasonable. read more

Very small toppings. Including crumbled sausage and very small pieces of pepperoni. Taste like those $1 frozen pizzas. Tastes very cheap and dry. read more

Great twist on pizza...great sandwiches and best BBQ bacon cheeseburger pizza I have ever had.

I hate to do this but it's necessary. We ordered dinner, take-out to be specific. I got the Chicken Chefs Salad and 5 wings - bbq (with bleu cheese). I DO NOT RECOMMEND. 1. I ordered Italian dressing with the salad, 2 containers of dressing came with the salad - one was Italian (1/2 full), the other was thousand island 2. The chicken on the salad was DRY as can be - like couldn't even eat it, it was like chicken jerky 3. It's supposed to be garlic chicken - it had zero flavor to it 4. The wings weren't very saucy (though admittedly this could have been my fault for not asking for it) 5. The bleu cheese tastes like it has mayo mixed with it or some other non-flavorful, fatty substance (side note: Im from Buffalo and bleu cheese is absolutely better there) 6. The egg in the salad was also overcooked, the chopped yolk was spongey and suspicious - I'm giving one star because my husband liked the small pizza he got (bbq double cheese), he said it was "okay" Don't waste your money - there are definitely better pizza and wing places read more

Its a poor excuse for pizza instead of wasting 30 bucks at this shit hole buy a frozen tostitos pizza what a joke can't believe people around here make such a big deal about it and the inside is very tacky dark and ran down looks like a place that should be on Dave Ramseys chopped show...sorry meant this fot the one on main street still shitty pizza though if it has sir pizza name on it read more

We were looking for our new pizza place and thought that a local chain that had been around since 1965 would have to have something going for it. We arrived as a large party was leaving and the buffet bar contained remnants that looked like they'd been there a while. We ordered the buffet thinking that they would soon be restocking fresh pizzas. Twenty minutes went by and we had long finished our salads but there were no new pizzas and the old ones hadn't been touched. I asked the server how often they rotated the pizzas and she said that they didn't; pizzas would stay until they were gone. When she saw my shocked expression she back peddled and said that new pizzas would be out soon. Fifteen minutes later she said it would be up soon. Five minutes later they consolidated the nasty dry slices into one pan and added ONE new pizza. We ate a couple of slices and then went to pay. The manager wouldn't acknowledge our presence until another employee told her to. She said nothing to us and was very rude. Mind you, we had not been rude to our server and never spoke to the manager. I'm shocked to see the rave reviews, because our experience was horrible. read more

Best pizza in town! Very tasty and not greasy. Tuesday night is 2 for 1.

I don't like the pizza its nasty and not worth the price. There are other places that are less expensive and pizza taste better!! I don't recommend it. read more

We ordered 2 pizza's and cheesebread. First off it was over cooked the cheese/bread was stiff as a board. And secondly it was 50 bucks. Really people 50 dollars for 2 pizza's. They were 3 toppings each and were 20 dollars each. I was baffled. Do not go here. Over cooked and way over priced. read more

On July 17 I ordered pizza to be delivered a large pepperoni pizza, I have not had sir pizza in forever and it was wonderful! It was delivered to me in under 30 minutes and the people on the phone which were two guys and I'm sorry I did not get their namesThey were so nice and I was so impressed. I will order from them again and again! I wanted them to know how happy I was I even figured out how to download the Yelp app. I am not a computer person or phone person but I had to let it be known that they were awesome! Thank you for a wonderful evening. read more

Yep! Looks and tastes just like it came out of the frozen food section. Awful pizza. My wife took one bite, i on the other hand crammed down a few squares because I was starving. read more

Great Pizza, this business has served up pizza for 30 years now. Still the same great taste. They have a good buffet at lunch and offer pasta and wings if your not into pizza. The deliver too. read more

Sir Pizza is addictive. There's none other like it anywhere in the world. The Main Street location seems to produce a much better pizza than the other locations and that says a lot considering that the other locations still serve great pizza. The quality of their employees oftentimes has the potential to ruin the experience. There are some excellent employees at this location, but I have also encountered employees who I wouldn't hire to walk my dog. It has been this way for years. Recently, one failed to turn in my take-out order and rather than apologizing and embracing accountability, he lied, became rude, and perpetuated the stereotype of an incompetent, ratty, & dishonest stoner-type pizza-guy. I wish the owners would spend a little more hiring employees that don't make me second guess the delicious pizza that's been a favorite for generations of Boro families. All that being said, any condescending college drop-out with questionable hygiene could make my Sir Pizza and I'd eat it. It is also worth mentioning that, for a pizza place, it's quite expensive. To me, it's worth paying more for a pizza that tastes so good. However, I can imagine there are many families with chunky, gadget-using, kids unable to justify springing for Sir Pizza. Unusually interesting to me is that the decor remains dark, dingy, and ratty but somehow it undoubtedly adds to the Sir Pizza experience. I wouldn't have it any other way. In fact, when I've dined in other locations, I feel let down. This place is definitely one-of-a-kind! read more

Bad food, worse service. Dirty inside, and grease tank was overflowing by back parking lot. Only 4 tables occupied, at noon. Ate buffet, and waitress never came by to take plates or fill drinks. Too busy talking to another table. Had eaten at Pizza Kings in Indiana and had a good experience, both food and service. This location was a disappointment. read more

I've passed this pizza place plenty times on the way home and decided to stop and give it a try. I had high hopes for this pizza especially since they claim to be the best pizza in town. I WAS DISAPPOINTED at the quality of the pizza seeing that THEY ARE EXPENSIVE. The pizza was luke warm at best and reminded me of a frozen Tostitos pizza. Honestly, you'd be better off going to a pizza chain than there. read more

Sir pizza graciously came to the rescue and provided food for my Vanderbilt Children's Hospital fundraiser last night when our food sponsor fell through. We had 250 students to feed and they absolutely loved Sir Pizza. Great food & great people! read more

Uniquely tasty pizzas made memorable by a sweetly seasoned tomato sauce on a crispy, crunchy crust. Dine-in area is simply that, but the pizza makes up for it. read more

It has come to my attention that there are many mixed reviews on Sir Pizza. I'm here to set the record straight: this is my favorite pizza place. If you're looking for big-chain, corporate-based, market-dominating pizza, then Sir Pizza is not for you. If you'd like inexpensive, frozen-from-the-start, cookie-cutter pizza, then move along. I'm telling you right now that as a kid, there was nothing I looked forward to more than Friday nights with my family, ordering a few Sir Pizza pies, and watching a movie. Born and raised in the great state of Tennessee, I can say with complete honesty that the disappearance of these establishments has been nothing short of criminal. Do not listen to the naysayers who claim that they had a bad experience at this establishment; has your steak never come out under- or over-cooked at Logan's Roadhouse? Has Chili's never disappointed you with their lackluster service? Get a grip folks, and hold onto your chairs because I'm about to learn you a thing about Sir Pizza. Not only is this pizza place a staple in my fondest childhood memories; it is an establishment that recently celebrated 50 YEARS of serving Murfreesboro and its citizens. If you read certain reviews that say the decorum is "played out" or "hackneyed"; guess what? This building has been around longer than most of the idiots negatively reviewing this restaurant have been alive. Is it the 'hippest' or 'most happening' place in the boro? No. If you sit in a few select booths will you find 50 years of inscriptions carved into the benches and paneling? Absolutely. But all of your doubts will drop away when that first sweet bite of pizza passes over your lips. Please do not allow this establishment to fail due to a few bad reviews. Give Sir Pizza a try, and if you don't enjoy it, feel free to contact me and I will gladly offer you a free pie to convince you otherwise. My name is Jordan Chandler Fly, and I approve this message. read more

Best thin crust in town. Always consistent. Try double ground beef. Add their sprinkle cheese and a touch of salt.