If nostalgia had a smell, it would be the second you open the door at Wertz Candies…read more This place is pure hometown magic. The kind of shop that's clearly been doing things right for decades because they don't need to shout about it. You walk in and immediately get hit with the warm, buttery aroma of their homemade caramel corn, and honestly? Game over. Your willpower never stood a chance. They make so much in-house, and you can tell it's done with care. The candy cases are packed with classics, handmade treats, and those "oh wow, I haven't seen that since I was a kid" finds. On top of that, they carry other great local goodies, which just makes the whole experience feel even more special and community-rooted. And the chocolate-covered strawberries? Absolutely delicious. Fresh, juicy berries with a smooth, rich chocolate coating that's not overly sweet just perfectly balanced. Simple. Classic. Nailed it. Wertz Candies isn't trying to be trendy. It doesn't need to be. It's cozy, charming, and exactly what a local candy shop should be. If you're nearby and don't stop in... frankly, that's on you. A forever favorite. Classic for a reason.

The friendly staff are always willing to help you pick out many kinds of candy based on your…read morerequests. Their home-made chocolates, caramels and other special items are always ready and available for purchase. And every candy I have tried tastes great. Sign up for their rewards program. It's free and gives credit at a high level.

Great variety, excellent ice cream, very reasonably priced. We will definitely come back. My…read morefavorite was the coconut chocolate chip

If you have a sweet tooth, pop into this shop. The first room is filled with all kinds of…read morechocolates and their famous Stroopies, waffle cookies with caramel in the middle. The back room is an ice cream shop with a little cafe to sit and enjoy dessert.

Discovered this place in 1992. When driving thru the small village of Port Clinton one could smell…read morefreshly roasting peanuts. Filled with nuts, chocolates and candy it is a great place to shop! Back in the day every place had a business like this. However they are more and more rare so you must support them!

Make a point to stop here if you're going to Hawk Mtn or nearby Appalachian Trail. Get snacks of…read moreall kinds new and old. Get different roasts of peanuts for a great price. Peanut butter better than Jiffy! All types of candy!

Living for six months in Lititz as a little boy, I loved walking to the original factory to watch…read morethem make Wilber buds. Returning decades later, the original factory is now a Hilton. (To their credit, the restoration of the building is impressive.) The only place you can go inside to see them make chocolate is the retail store across the street. It's a large store with lots to buy, but start with the milk chocolate Wilbur buds. They have free samples to try it before you commit.

Great store for chocoholics. Had to FaceTime the husband who is the chocolate connoisseur in the…read morefamily. He chose carefully and gave everything a thumbs up. Staff was so friendly and helpful with recommendations.

I recently participated in Georgie Lou's Retro Candy's 6th Annual Sweetheart Stroll, and while this…read moremay have been their sixth time hosting it, it was my first time even hearing about it. I immediately corrected that mistake by buying a ticket the moment I saw the event posted--and then started counting down the days. The concept alone sold me: a ticketed, adults-focused stroll through downtown Carlisle, with participating small businesses offering tastings, experiences, treats, and deals. Sweethearts of all kinds were welcome--couples, besties, gal pals--and dressing in red and pink for Valentine's vibes was strongly encouraged. Say less. Ticketing was super easy, and Georgie Lou's did a fantastic job with pre-event communication, especially via social media. One post in particular deserves a shout-out: a reminder to bring a bag to carry your treats. This is something I absolutely would not have thought about until I was awkwardly shoving sweet treats into my coat pockets. I came prepared with a small reusable shopping bag (pink, obviously), and by the end of the stroll it was completely full of sweets, trinkets, and purchases. Meanwhile, others were struggling with overflowing pockets alongside gloves, hats, maps, and life regrets. Lesson learned. Excellent advice! I found parking around 1pm and headed to Georgie Lou's to check in and grab my materials. The staff were incredibly friendly, checked my name off the list, and sent me on my way with a Map of Hearts, a button identifying me as an official 2026 Sweetheart Stroller, and a small sweet treat to kick things off. I also took some time to explore the shop itself--my first visit--and wow! They have managed to pack an impressive amount of nostalgic goodness into a small space. Total blasts from the past, plus candies I'd never seen before. Super fun shop! From there, the stroll itself was a delight. Georgie Lou's clearly put a lot of care into coordinating participating businesses, and it showed. Most spots offered sweet treats, discounts, or special offerings, but every single business was warm, welcoming, and happy to have folks stopping in. Even though I've done a few downtown Carlisle walk-style events before, I still discovered shops I'd never been in--and every purchase I made that day was from a place I was visiting for the first time. That alone feels like a win. Overall, this was a fantastic way to spend a few hours on a very chilly January Saturday. It got me out of the house, walking downtown, supporting local businesses, and discovering gems I usually zoom past while driving from Point A to Point B. I had such a great time that I jokingly asked if I could pre-register for next year... apparently that's "not a thing yet." Fine. I'll wait. :) This has officially been added to my annual tradition list. Great event, great execution, great vibes. Well done, Georgie Lou's!

Great nostalgic candy shop...lots of unique inventory! Definitely a great gift spot for people of…read moreall ages.

Bring your kids here and get them a super shake. It's very good. The people are nice, the place is…read morenice. The candy is great.

A little pricey for the amount of popcorn. Do not get the white cheddar. All I could taste was…read moresalt! The other popcorn was good but $7 for a bucket.

They have all of the candies and the weird sodas. It's a great candy store…read more But the most important thing (to me) is that they have jelly bellies where you can buy individual flavors by weight. Much like former president Jimmy Carter, I love jelly bellies so much... but actually only about 14 out of the 49 standard flavors. So I hate buying bags of jelly bellies from the store, especially since the company is charging for them like they're gold bars. I went to Macy's the other day and they were selling the 2lb bag for $30! Like maybe we should start setting the U.S. dollar on the jelly belly standard. But I digress. The point is that you can buy jelly bellies here, but only the ones that you want.

It's just the best! Great service and a fantastic assortment of sodas! Grandpa Joe's is always…read moreworth the trip!

Pete Matangos has the best candy in the area! He is so nice,…read morefunny, and the perfect person to deal with the public!! Whenever I travel to see my family I always try to stop in for some Venetian Mints to bring to Seattle. They are a big hit! Thank you, Pete for your wonderful store! Louise Bianco

Chocolate Perfection…read more This chocolate is pure bliss. The texture is smooth, and the flavor was rich and deeply satisfying, with a perfect balance of sweetness. You can taste the love and care in every bite--simple, pure, and absolutely delightful. Their chocolate covered cherries are incredible!!

This store was really awesome and had a large variety of candy and sodas. They have shekeves and…read morefridges full of sodas to try.

The bulk candy aisle is just one of the attractions. They also seem to have every bottled soda…read moreimaginable! A fun place for kids of all ages.