we stopped as we were passing thru after reading the reviews and it did not disappoint. The food was amazing. And at a great price. Very clean inside. There was a sweeter older gal running her ass off. Her service was quick and just the sweetest person ever. well worth the stop read more

The food was good, but there were a couple things I would change. Namely the small portion of curds, the seasoning and the restroom situation. There are no indoor bathrooms. You have to use a porta potty outside. That was not a great experience for me. Service was great and the restaurant was clean. read more

Smitty's Overtime Inn - Yahtzee and curds - Bars Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

Good food at good prices with excellent service. We have never been to this area before and have found some hidden gems. Get there early (5:30 - 6:00pm) if you're wanting to get some walleye on Friday nights. The fried fish is breaded with ritz crackers added to the breading. That's what the waitress told me. It had a unique flavor and the breading was similar to Long John Silver's restaurant. Their lunch specials are something to go there for. The local beer, especially the WI Amber Lager, was delicious and the 34 ounce beer was well priced. read more

Good food, good service, and very clean. Pizza was great and everyone I was with loved the chicken.

One of the best fish fries I've had! Actually, everything was absolutely delicious - appetizers and dinners for our family. The service was friendly and spot on. I wish I lived closer! read more

I ate here on back to back nights (Friday and Saturday) and the service was really great. The staff were friendly and attentive. I ordered burgers both nights and both were wonderfully cooked. My brother ordered the Prime Rib and it looked great (he said it was too!). The 34 oz. tappers are a steal too! I think the thing I liked best was that this was clearly a local favorite, but as someone hunting in the area, I was felt at home and very welcomed. Sure, the food isn't Michelin Star rated, but it is really good - and not just because I was in the woods all day. I will definitely be back (they even gave me a frequent diner card!). read more

Smitty's Overtime Inn - Bars Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

Great place, good food, huge portions, and great service. I liked that they had disposable gloves at the salad bar. read more

Restaurant is very plan lacks in decor. Everything is very basic, there is a jukebox but you most pay to hear music, two songs for a dollar. The menu is ok there are enough items for everyone, salad bar but limited items in it. I got the 12 inch steak which was amazing but had a lot of fat on it. The main issue I had with the restaurant was the amount of flies in the restaurant. There were landing on our food and flying around. The restaurant did not look like they were doing anything to prevent the flies. read more

See all

I'm totally surprised at the good service. Place is off the beaten path and was blown away with the quality and quantity of It's food, and Alexis needs more help-Did an awesome job tending the bar, and the only waitress, hope they pay her double for tonight's turnout. Finally found good fried chicken in the Tomah area. I would like to see WIFi available. read more

It's a good spot for dinner. I had the New York steak, it's certainly not the best steak I've ever had but it's certainly good. The salad bar was good and had good options. Girlfriend had the Prime Rib special and really enjoyed it. read more

Small town hot spot. Locals said this was the spot for fish fry on Friday and Prime Rib on Saturday. They aren't wrong. Food is great. Soup and salad bar also great. Drink selection, beers, cranberry mixes, or some behemoth Bloody Mary on Sundays. If I lived in this area I would be here every night of the week. read more

Best food we've had on our vacation. Soup and salad bar were great and we were there for their fish fry which was good. Friendly staff and prompt service. Highly recommend. read more

Dropped in as I drove across the state. Spectacular country bar, great food and great service!

Laying over, food was Sisco inspired. Server used gloves, never saw a mask. Appetizers came out of the box, beer battered shrimp was actually house made. The lumpy mashed potatoes must have been to show something else was house made the cold peas and carrots where the garnish to the generous amount of pressure cooked roast. read more

We were in the area for the Cranberry Festival in Warrens and looked to Yelp for a place to eat. Overtime Inn sounded good so we gave it a try. It doesn't look like much from the outside, but the inside is warm and friendly and the food is great. The salad bar is small, but fresh. I tried the Spicy Cheese Soup -- OMG, GREAT flavor, but "Spicy" is right! It was too hot for me, but, if you like spicy hot, you must try this soup! We both had the special which was fried or boiled shrimp and we both chose boiled. It is served with melted butter and it was very tasty -- not overcooked which is easy to do when boiling shrimp. They have a good selection of beer, which goes perfect with that spicy soup! They weren't crowded when we got there about 5-ish, but were full when we left. We'll go back if we are in the area again. read more

Great prime rib on Saturday. The price is reasonable, the food is great. The salad bar is ok but with the large king cut of prime rib, I did not eat a lot of salad. Service was also great! read more

Stopped here for Sunday brunch while in town visiting my step daughter. I'm not sure what is happening here, but it appears that the servers really aren't servers, rather friends or regulars who have come to "help", but the service is downright awful. Friendly enough, don't get me wrong, but my kids have already eaten their entire meals and I'm still sitting here waiting on au jus for my French dip (which has been asked for). The food is good (not great, but solidly good), and I think in another circumstance I would likely love this place. It has been over an hour since we have been here and the end is not yet in sight. I suspect when my 2 year old grandson starts screaming then they may pay more attention... Whatever their staffing issue is I hope they get it resolved soon. read more

Everything was great!! Outstanding service along with a really great tasting meal. I ordered the Saturday night Prime Rib dinner Queen size for $18.99. The meal came with soup and salad bar with homemade dinner rolls. They had lasagna soup or bean soup and both were excellent. The salad bar was small but adequate with homemade potato salad, spaghetti salad, cottage cheese, beets and other fresh offerings. I had the baked potato and creamy horseradish sauce on the side with my prime rib and it was the best I have ever had. My spouse had the pork chops with homemade mashed potatoes and gravy which he said tasted excellent. This was a great find and if your passing by Tomah take a ride out here and try to come on a night when they have one of their other specials like the shrimp boil. They also make homemade pizza and the burgers looked great that we saw pass by. read more

The steak tasted amazing. If it wasn't for the fact that a third of it was gristle this would be a five star experience for sure. Dive bar type atmosphere. Family friendly. High chairs seemed like hand downs from the 80s but they were in great condition. Friendly service, even if a little overworked. read more

Great food. Excellent service. Stopped in on new years day. Was a little skeptical due to location being out of town, but was pleasantly surpised. Will definitely be back if going through area again! read more

It's Friday, a bit later... Walleye sold out... heck of a crowd... so no biggie... everything else our party of 6 ordered was FANTASTIC. I had the New York Strip, my wife the filet. The others had salmon, scallops and a pizza. All were, as I said before: FANTASTIC. Been all over parts of the world... this place rates! The service is great too!! Rollie says it's time to go... I'd write more, but time to go. So stop by here and have a great meal!!! read more

The clerk at the Hampton Inn told us about this place. It was a good find. Very friendly people. Good food with a great selection. I had prime rib sandwich and onion rings, husband had 1/2 rack of ribs, and mil had fried shrimp and baked sweet potato plus dinners came with a good salad bar. Very reasonably priced. read more

Wow what a great find!!! The food was wonderful. We were worried maybe not kid friendly but it was. The people were very nice . I would if given a 5 star but it is not anyone's fault but so busy it's hard to get your drinks and waitress to even pay. That is the only thing that we found not perfect. I guess that's not a problem to be so busy read more

The Italian beef was great and the cheese burger was great as well and the costumer service was great and the music was good as well read more

Smitty's Overtime Inn - Bars Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

See all

I came from out of town Ordered their 12 inch pizza and what was brought to me was a frozen 4 inch pizza....it tasted nasty and when i asked waitress if their pizza was frozen she toldmw they made it fresh. The pizza was a kids frozen that tasted horrible and they still charged me $8 for. This left a bad taste in my mouth and i will never go back there again. They did not discount it or give it to me free it was a waste of my time and money read more

Found this place on yelp. Very friendly people neat clean excellent service terrific Pizza ! Highly recommend. Prices are great

I've been to Smitty's 2 years in a row during Cranfest weekend to enjoy their Cranberry Old Fashions and their rib eye dinner. The place is busy but the service is good and the food and beverages are great! read more

Carrie was an excellent server, friendly environment. Great Wisconsin Fish Fry. The Broiled Cod was perfectly done. Good salad bar. A Haven for Wisconsin Sports fans. Will visit again with friends. read more

No frills pretty much sums it up, just great food. It's in the middle of nowhere. We recently moved from the Chicago area and pretty much said goodbye to great restaurants, so when we saw this on yelp it was worth a try. Place was packed, all seats taken on a Friday night. The seating is nothing to write home about, thus 4 not 5 stars, pretty much your typical roadside diner decor. However the place has its own kind of pub style class. Had the ribeye which was fantastic. Wife had steak and shrimp. Beer selection is awesome. Server was on the ball. We will be regulars. read more

The ambiance was set by kitchen smoke and flies, as we enjoyed our slimy flavorless Italian beef on plastic folding tables.

So so delicious, a hidden gem! The only bad thing is that we just found it after coming to Tomah for years. Very casual, great food! Steak was amazing so was the Friday fish fry! Staff was great! read more

Smitty's Overtime Inn - Yummy steak! - Bars Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

See all

Best fish fry in the area and excellent Prime Rib. Soups are always good. Atmosphere is not the best but wait staff is always pleasant and prompt. We are frequent diners. read more

Wonderful staff!!! We stopped there on our way home to Minneapolis from Chicago, our server was fantastic! And the food was outstanding! Totally worth the detour off the interstate! We had a picky eater with us and even he was thoroughly impressed next time we make the drive we will make it a point to stop again read more

Good food, good service, fun times. The owners are quite often there and very friendly. Love the lobster I had and husband said steak was good. Very enjoyable experience. read more

Saw Smitty's ad in a visitor's guide at our hotel in Tomah. Saturday evening we decided to drive the short distance from the hotel to have dinner. We wanted to do a local restaurant vs one of the chains right off of the freeway. The place was really busy but looked like a great place and seemed very friendly. We were standing by the hostess area and the girl came over to seat us. She directed us to a booth, gave us menus and said someone would be with us soon. We were looking over the menus when some lady comes over and says "You can't sit here. Why are you sitting here?" I explained to her that the hostess had seated us when she said she was the hostess. I told her that it was the girl with the braid, who turned out to be a waitress. We got up and walked out! I have never, ever been treated that rudely in a restaurant! Ever! If one of your staff makes a seating error, you don't yell at the customer for it. It wasn't like there were any other people waiting to be seated at that time. Sorry way to present your restaurant to someone from out of state that came to your establishment based on a visitor guide ad. Ended up at one of the chains after all. read more

My husband and I often come to Smitty's on Friday nights for the fish fry, and I always get the broiled cod. So often broiled fish is rather tasteless, but Smitty's is consitently the best-seasoned fish I think I have ever had. read more

Smitty's seems to be a local bar with not typical bar food. There is the soup and salad bar, perhaps not big but very good. Saturday night's special is prime rib, no it's GREAT prime rib. We've only been to Smitty's on Saturdays and we always get the prime rib. read more

The food was great, but I wish I would have kniw that they take reservations. I think they might have been under staffed, but the hostess and the wait staff were moving trying to get people served. Worth the wait. read more

Had the shrimp boil on Thursday at the Overtime Inn, great food, nice salad bar. Nice local place.

We use to go to Smitty's almost every Friday night for their fish fry. The best in the area and anytime we had friends in town, we would take them out there for fish. Unfortunately, the new owners felt it was necessary, for whatever reason, to change many items on the once, delicious Friday night fish menu. The fish is different, the salad bar has many items taken off or replaced by their own recipes. Example: the coleslaw, potato salad, and soup I had was terrible! We asked the waitress about it and she said they make their own instead of ordering from the company they use to purchase from. What I don't understand is... why would you change so many things in a thriving business. A business that was so crowded if you arrived after 5 on a Friday night. Now, you can just walk in and sit down, so evidently the word is getting around. It's too bad because they had the best fish fry in town for such a long time. read more