I'm from Chicago, born and raised, and am very picky when it comes to pizza. This is SOLID New York…read morestyle pizza. We got an extra large pepperoni for dinner. Went back for lunch the next day. The crust was nice and crunchy, the cheese was real and the sauce was just thick enough. No complaints other than I wish I had found it sooner. Its a small place with a few tables and counter seating. No frills. There were other things on the menu like pasta, wings and desserts, but we just stuck to the pizza. If you are staying in the area, this is a MUST! Especially if you have had too much platano and/or rice and beans lol.

Great pizza the way we grew up eating it here. Do you know Puerto Rico's pizza has been…read moretraditionally New York style... thin and loaded with cheese. Pagan does it in the traditional way shunning the artisanal trends of today. If you want pizza that resembles New York visit Pagan's.

Delicious food and great service. My kids enjoyed the food as much as my husband and I did!read more

Loved this pizza place so much. We came here the night of the Superbowl looking to grab some late…read morenight pizza, and were so impressed with how cute this place is. It's in what looks like an antique house, with lots of vintage decor and really decorative light fixtures. Service here was really top notch -- we were taken care of right away even though we were latecomers. We ordered a pizza to split, the Rosada, which was one of the best vodka pies I've ever had (and I'm from NYC). Food was incredibly well priced also. I would definitely recommend coming here if you're in the area and are in the mood for some excellent pizza.

Service was not that great. Waited a long time while the locals at the bar were served. Pizza is…read moreok, lasagna was more on the dry side. Cheese balls and wings were really good. My biggest complaint was the wait for our food and having to ask the waiter for things such as drinks, forks, sauce that should've been brought with our food. Not a location I would visit unless it's a last resort.

Pizza is huge & the guys are friendly. Great service. The pizza had plenty of sauce & cheese. And…read morecrisp crust.

If you're walking by, this restaurant would be very easy to miss. The entrance looks like a doorway…read moreleading to a stairwell or service entrance, and I honestly didn't even notice a sign. Luckily, there was a gentleman outside directing people in, otherwise we may have walked right past it. Once you climb the two flights of stairs, you're rewarded with a beautiful dining space. The restaurant has a rustic, old-world charm with gorgeous décor and an Italian-inspired atmosphere. It immediately felt warm and inviting. There were four of us dining, and we started with two appetizers: the Setas Rellenas and the Chorizo al Vino. Both were excellent, but the Chorizo al Vino was my absolute favorite--absolutely delicious! For my entrée, I ordered the chicken lasagna. I expected chunks of chicken, but it was made with shredded chicken, and wow--it was incredible. The flavor was outstanding, and it ended up being one of my favorite meals of our trip. My husband ordered the beef lasagna, which was also made with shredded beef rather than traditional ground beef. He absolutely loved it. Our friends ordered the Milanesa de Berenjena and the Milanesa de Pollo with a side of gnocchi, and both raved about their meals as well. Since nearly every table seemed to be ordering pizza, we knew we had to try one. We ordered a small pizza for the table, and each of us had a slice. Now we understand why they're known for their pizza--it was fantastic! A special shoutout to our server, Rouil Rodz, who was attentive, friendly, and provided excellent service throughout the evening. Don't let the unassuming entrance fool you. This restaurant is a hidden gem with a beautiful atmosphere, outstanding food, and excellent service. If you're visiting Old San Juan, I highly recommend adding it to your list.

Killer pizza in an old school Puerto Rican spot. Kids loved…read morethe pizza. Wife smashed a sangria. I enjoyed a couple local beers.

I'm so happy we found this place on our trip. Shamelessly came twice. The margherita is the best…read more If you get the cacio e Pepe definitely add mushrooms. Do not miss out on the Caesar salad! The plates are so cute and everyone is so kind. Keep a can of cat food in your pocket because there are lots of strays around the corner.

This is our regular go-to for great pizza on the island. I think we've tried all their pizzas, all…read moreterrific! We've been numerous times, always a line out the door. They turn tables fairly quickly so you normally don't wait too long. The staff hustles to get drinks and pizzas to your table. Pizzas are a bit in the smallish size so that's a good excuse to try a couple different styles. The more daring among us will even one or two to take for "next morning" cold pizza.

Jibarita: 5 stars. I was skeptical since I was not sure of her mix of ingredients (ground beef and…read moresweet plantains). I was so wrong. It is VERY good. I am supper happy with this pizza. Service: 5 stars. Our server was very nice and helpful. Ambience: 5 stars. The place has an inviting atmosphere.

Caprese salad was a portion for a doll. This is ridiculous and for the price $11!?! Is not even…read moretasteful. It feels warm. Sams club salads are better. Safe your time and money and go somewhere else. I even spoke w the manager and she said that's how it is.

Dorado's pizza place is probably the best in town. Their calzones are also delicious, with a tasty…read moregarlic oil coating. The service is quick and consistent, making it a great place to eat. I have to eat there every time I'm visiting the area. I highly recommend it.

Perfect takeout for our little family…read more Pasta w butter for my 5 yo Burger w fries for the 8 yo Pizza and salad for mommy and daddy Ordered delivery on door dash to our hotel. Very accommodating! Give them a try.

Fast service, but they can be busy. You can call in an order, or just walk up and place one. Our…read morepizzas were delicious, best we've had since moving to PR. No jalapeños available, sadly. My husband ordered extra cheese, which was amazing and super cheesy, but my regular one had plenty.

I really liked this place! The food came out quite fast tbh especially since we were a huge group,…read more16 people! The pizza is delicious - OMG! The pizza was made on the spot! This place is very GENEROUS with their toppings and portion. Wow! The meat lovers one should've came out first because it was A LOT, like A LOT! We ordered the pizza at the same time but they came out at 10 minute intervals. Regardless, the pizzas were delicious! Even the ones that did not want the veggie pizza, it was actutthe best! The Alfredo pizza was ok, not as "Alfredo" as I anticipated. I absolutely loved the concept of this place - great family environment or if just with a date or after work, they have a bar! I am a coffee person and was VERY HAPPY that they served coffee! The coffee was on the lighter side but it was still delicious and not old or stale. The menu is ample and has various options to choose from! So why three stars? Well, it says they're good for groups but we ended up splitting our tables but at least we were in the same area. I think our waiter was new or relatively new to the serving business because he seemed very well but was very nice don't get me wrong. I tried to help him as he had other tables but when I would ask him or his peers for extra napkins, utensils, plates, more water or refills, the reaction was as if we are to be compliant with what we had. Pizza is greasy and the paper plates will immediately disintegrate so plates were much needed as well as napkins but it seems they didn't want to give extra and it was a hassle to get extra too. Also, parking is a hassle! Anticipate to wait for parking to avoid stress. Overall, the pizza is amazing! The alcohol menu reasonably price and great made and fresh coffee! I wouldn't order anything other than pizza because the Mac and cheese was not good and neither was the sampler.

IF YOU'RE THINKING OF COMING HERE.DON'T.IF could, I'd give…read morethis place 0 stars. This is the second time we've received bad service at this pizzeria. Unfortunately, they repeated the same behavior: they made us feel uncomfortable and even told us to "hurry up and leave" while our group was still eating. This isn't the first time it's happened, so it's clearly not a misunderstanding - it's a lack of respect towards customers. Very disappointing, especially when you go out to enjoy time with friends and end up feeling rushed and poorly treated TO THE OWNER: This is NOT how you run a BUSINESS. Good customer service is the most important thing, and allowing vour staff to treat people badly or make customers feel uncomfortable shows a total lack of management and professionalism. This is the second time it's happened, so there's no excuse. I WoN'T BE COMING BACK

What a great place. I have one of the stuffed burgers, it was stuffed sausage and bacon. Topped…read morewith grilled onions. I was skeptical but, I like to try new things. Well I was not disappointed at all. The flavors blended well and the sweetness of the grilled onions was the icing on the cake. The wait staff was great, friendly and tentative. Highly recommend trying the burgers here.

Horrible experience. Took the family there, 6 in total, and waiting over an hour and a half to get…read moreour food. If the place was busy I could understand, but it was empty. Servers never came to ask if we wanted more drinks, we needed to ask for more. When the food came out, most of it was way overcooked. They never asked how everything was (not a language issue because we speak spanish). They came over cleaned the plates, two of which were not touched because they burgers and onion rings were burnt. Overall bad experience with everything.