Best shrimp on the island. Outside dining is delightful. To go orders always an option if you're on…read morethe run!

Stone crab was exceptional and they have the large ones. Spiny lobster and lobster roll were just…read moreokay. It's in a nice neighborhood but we wouldn't go out of our way to come back.

I'm not sure who cleaned the yellowtail fish , but I bought two & they were Full of bones, are…read morewhole meal was a waste of time and money, thanks for a terrible night

Gross, not fresh fish or seafood. If you enjoy seafood not…read morekept at the right temperature and sitting in the sun for hours outside... this place will suit you.

I come here every year. Always have what I'm looking for…read more Great fresh food & service

Stop here if you want the best tasting, freshest fish dip you will ever have!…read more Driving by heading towards Key West it is located on your left just past Big Pine Key. The man working behind the counter was super friendly, helpful and efficient. They smoke a variety of fish.

Prices are high but that's the price of fresh seafood and fish everywhere unless you buy crap…read morecaught in China Red Grouper definitely great Stone crab claws delicious Friendly service!

Super fresh local seafood at great price! Service was prompt and asked us if we had any questions!read more

So we had our first stone crab claws in November during our honeymoon and we've been wanting some…read moremore ever since. I looked around online for awhile hoping to find a place in Key West to ship them to Philly as an Xmas surprise. Lo and behold, I found Key West Shellfish Co. I read the glowing review on here and checked out the website. The prices seemed reasonable compared to other sites, and when I emailed them with some questions, they responded right away and were extremely friendly and helpful. So I placed an order to be shipped Wed, 12/30, thinking I'd surprise the old man on New Years's. Markham McGill was kind enough to not only email me when they went out, but advised me they'd arrive 12/31, so they'd be at their freshest. Oh, they were fresh alright. And damn tasty. Got the Key West Pinks too - very tasty as well. We had all the proper condiments, key lime mustard, butter, spicy cocktail sauce - barely used them. These were best nekkid... We sat in the floor with a box of wine and some mallets, and went to town. Good stuff - we will be ordering again!

Key west shellfish CO, is a fantastic set-up, they send you shellfish and fish all the way to…read moreCalifornia where I live and everything is just as pristine as you get it out of the water! The price is right and Markham McGill, can even help you out with recipes. My husband Sam,and I bought 5 Lbs.of large Stone Crab and 3 lbs. of jumbo shrimp. We enjoyed a shrimp cocktail and cracked crab with our favorite sauce and were able to eat enough to finally satisfy us for 2 weeks. Ha! Ha! Not like "Joe's Stone Crab" were you are teased with a small amount. here the centerpiece is the crab, not the sides!

I bypassed the Lobster Ruben, had the conch ceviche and a fried hogfish sandwich, it was one of the…read morebest seafood meals of my life. Bonus points for the bar next door, and having the tartar/cocktail sauce readily available. Their prices are incredibly low for the freshness and quality they serve up. I can't wait to return to the Florida Keys again to eat here.

Looking at the food it truly looked like hospital food quality, and for the prices I was expecting…read moresomething a little jazzier on the presentation- but truly seeing around this area everything is $$$$. Which is fine. But still... Service is an order behind the counter, find a seat & listen for your name called over the intercom (you can't hear anything- so just go ahead & stand over by the counter). Food itself is okay- maybe we should have tried their famous lobster Reuben .. the seating area is surrounding the pier which is nice and there was a constant breeze coming through making it enjoyable to eat at. Have crew members standing by for boats pulling in to eat their catch & ensure no one is feeding the bird/fish. Would stop again and try something different but I'm sure there's other places to go for fish.