PIEROGI ARE GREAT!! FOOD IS GOOD, BUT This place is a dive. It was on drive ins diners and dives about 10 years ago. But the Pierogi are the bomb. I will go there again for the Pierogi they are that good. It is hard to really rate a restaurant or bar such as this. The food is good but the place needs remodeled, or is that the CHARM that they want??? 2.5 stars read more

Completely disappointed. Really love their fish sandwich. Sat down to have a drink until our order was ready, but after 20 minutes, the bartender came over . I heard her tell another customer that there was an hour wait for food. Ee paid our bill and left. So did another couple of customers. Such a shame . Lost business. read more

The atmosphere is very old world with the emphasis on old. However, one bite of a pierogi that has been exquisitely fried will make it all worth while. I had the pierogis, haluski and kielbasa platter. It was very filling and very tasty. Barkeep was friendly and helpful. Patrons were all from the neighborhood. I'll return. I'm feeling very Polish now. read more

After having found out this bar was on Diner's, Drive in's, and Dives I felt compelled to at least try it. I've spent my money on worse. Myself and two coworkers searched the internet for hours trying to find an up to date menu or photos from previous users or even from Star lite. We found few reviews and even fewer photos. The common denominator here was the "Polish Platter". Being an avid fan of polish food I decided I would try it. This was the 2nd best decision I made today (the first was deciding I would eat lunch at Starlite Lounge). We called into the lounge and before ordering I had asked if the menu online was up to date. The kind woman on the phone told me it was not but she can help me out if there was something we were stuck on with ordering our lunch. I ordered the Polish Platter which came to about $10.26 after tax. Another co-worker ordered the same and the final order was the Fried Chicken Salad. We were told it was going to be a 30 minute wait. So like natural office employee's we did nothing for 30 minutes before we drove up to Starlite to get our food. When we walked in all three of us noticed that our appearance had changed. I suddenly was wearing JNCO jeans, with a Nirvana T-shirt carrying a Jansport backpack. The lounge hasn't seen an upgrade since the early 90's if we are lucky and it must have transformed us into the appropriate timeline. But seriously, the lounge looks it hasn't been visted by the Allegheny County Health department in years. Not to mention, there were two guys sitting at the bar whom stared us down as if they had just gotten off from a 12 hour shift at the Steel Mill. After having paid and returned to work, I was embraced with one of the best lunches I have ever consumed. The Polish Platter came w/ a 6-8" piece of sweet sauerkraut topped Kielbasa, Gnocchi Haluski, and 2 very large pirogi's (potato & cheddar and Spinach & feta). The Styrofoam dish was weighed down by all of the butter and grease. This by far was on of the best meals I had in a very long time. I couldn't stop eating. Needless to say, I was unable to perform many tasks at work following this meal due to a minor food coma. 5 stars isn't enough. We have agreed to make this a regular lunch location. read more

Go here and eat. Jalapeño and cheddar pierogis, to die for. Guy Fieri is never wrong.

Great food! We were a little worried about the location but it's a calm quiet area and you walk through a very chill bar to a restaurant. Staff was friendly. Food portions were very large and super tasty! We had stuffed banana peppers, pierogis (all 3 flavors), fish sandwich, and haluski. All of it was great! Would definitely go back if we were visiting Pittsburgh again. read more

I would give this 2 1/2 stars but that's not an option. For fun when visiting other cities we like to go to places that is"known" for something, for example we looked up where Diners, Drive Ins, and Dives is and head there. We were greeted with a lecture on calling ahead next time with a party of that size. What?! There was 4 people in this place. One being at the bar. She proceeded to tell me that when busy the kitchen can't handle a party this big. Ok. It was around 3:30 and 4 people where there. Then I asked what Guy ate because really that's what brought me there, the waitress couldn't care less that he was there or that I even asked about what was featured. The cheddar pierogi was good alongside Mott's applesauce. Fetta was just ok, and the glop my husband got was just that, mushy glop (cabbage and gnocchi I think it was) that was to peppery and just a mess. Soda was flat. There's barely any lighting and the ceiling looks like it might cave in on you any moment. Stay away. 2 1/2 stars at best and that's for the store bought applesauce and cheddar perogies and onions. read more

Went here because we saw it on the Food Network Diners Drive-ins and Dives. Their pierogies were the featured food of course. It's just a small bar. We went on a Sunday afternoon and there were a bunch of old guys sitting around the bar smoking and talking about the old days. The bartender was also our waitress. Aside from first-impressions, the service was good and the pierogies were amazing. Three big pierogies for about $7, great for sharing. We also ordered a burger with fries to share and it was good too! And CHEAP! We got stuffed, couldn't even finish everything for $15. If you don't mind the smokey, old-time bar feel, then I highly recommend. On their website, they say to call ahead for the pierogies. read more

I have been going to the Starlite Lounge since I was young and recently took a large part of my family there for dinner between funeral viewings for my mother who had passed away. Due to the family needing to be back at the funeral home, we chose the Starlite Lounge because it was close by and the food had always been great in the past. When we arrived at the restaurant we were rudely told by the waitress that she was the only waitress there at the time and that there was only one cook available and since we had such a large party it may take longer for our food. She also told us that we should not have not come in without calling first. We all let her know that was fine and even offered to write down what items the members of our party wanted but the waitress on duty refused our help stating that it didn't matter, there was no way the cook could have our food ready all at once. She huffed and puffed and rudely went to each table taking drink and food orders, making us feel so unwelcome. We began regretting that we even took our out of town guests there, as it was such an embarrassment. It's a shame that a restaurant known for their good food, and even being on television, now has left a horrible taste in our mouths as we will not be returning to this restaurant. Thank you Billie (waitress) for the most horrible dining experience I have ever received. P.S. The food was good read more

Food is good when the waitress can properly charge you. I get the same meal constantly and pay different prices everytime. Owner is rude & doesn't handle customers well. My job places fairly large orders and they up-charge when there is more people so I advise to place orders separately. They also give smaller portions when you order in a group. Food can be as greasy as the bar is sometimes but i gotta say the pierogies are ok. I will never place an order for me & my coworkers again. read more

The food is pretty good especially if you like perogies but good luck getting it. I've been here a few times to see acoustic performances and every time I'm here the waitress spends more time smoking cigarettes at the bar than attending to her tables. 98% of the time I have to go to the bar to get another beer. But damn the perogies are good. read more

We're visiting from Milford, Ohio. We picked this place because we love eating at places featured on the Food Network, especially on Diners, Dives and Drive Ins. Dive? Ummmm, yea. for sure. I know Guy Fieri says, "if its funky, we'll find it." but I just couldn't imagine him there! talk about a small, tiny, bar. Would NEVER have gone here if we weren't looking for it. The waitress/bar maid was VERY nice. She recommended what was served to Guy; the fish sammy and the perogies. i've never had perogies. From what I understand, perogies are very small. these were huge. I don't know, I'm sure they were awesome........I just don't think they are for me. It was like fried mashed potatoes. I'm thinking Perogies is a cultural/area food. Just not something I'm going to crave. The fish sam was good. Seemed the patrons are regulars. This is not a place I would crave; not a place I would visit again if I were back in town. But thanks for the experience. read more

If you love the traditional pierogies, haluski and kielbasa you'll love this place. My husband had the stuffed pepper soup which was just amazing! We both had the polish platter which gave us each a full meal to take home. Total bill was under $30. Good dinner. Will be back! read more

Thursday night wing night. Great value. Wings were outstanding. Bar keep attentive and friendly. The place is a dive, nothing pretentious. read more

Man this place is a dump. If you're not a local or regular good luck feeling comfortable there. It is obviously a local bar first and restaurant second. Certainly not for the ladies or kids. The pierogies were indeed delish and the fish sammo was okay. It was cooked nicely but the fish wasn't all that fresh and you could tell. Btw, I did not pre-order pierogies and I got mine no problem. But it wasn't during peak hours. As noted by other posters the waitress was the bartender. A bit gruff, but I've had worse. Music was BLASTING non-stop during my hour there. A Nickelback fan's dream com true. Smoky, but not horribly so. If you're a local rummy barfly then this place is for you! But if you're a DDD fan you might want to move on to another DDD spot in Pittsburgh. Not sure why it would be featured on the show. Nadine's was better and they made you feel welcome. read more

Been going here for a year now. The pierogies are the best in the business! As others have mentioned, if you need catered to and fancy surroundings, this isn't the place for you! However, if you're looking for great food and feeling like you're with family, this is your place! Every time we go, we have a great time! And it's clean. Even the bathroom! I'll continue to travel 40 min to go here! read more

Good italian hoagies, great jumbo wings. Very affordable. Will get something polish next time

Husband and I have been here several times and while the food is ok, the slow service makes each experience worse than the one before. We have been here for 40 minutes and still waiting for our soup, there's only one other table....ridiculous...the hype of triple D will only last so long. read more

I suspect that folks who rate this establishment as "poor" probably were expecting a pizazzy hyped up version of eat n park. Marc C is so right: dont gho there if you arent prepared to enjoy good "bar-food" along with the quintessential "bar-flies." However, we've been there twice, both times for pierogies, and they've been wonderful both times. I had the grilled chicken salad this time and it really isnt anything to write home about. The Starlight has made its reputation on wings which are the biggest I've ever seen, and O'course the pierogies. The hoagies are also an amazing feat of sandwich-artistry. Dont go if you want ambiance or culture. Take yourself to the Cafe at the Frick instead. However, if you want a family - business where grandma makes the spinach-feta pierogies - give it a try and post your thoughts! read more

We ordered subs for take out because of this place being on Food network. The food is terrible. Very cheaply made. Definitely won't be going back and wouldn't recommend anyone else go there either. read more

Authentic neighborhood dive bar with friendly patrons and nice bartenders and waitresses. Excellent wings and cheap beer. Check it out before hitting moon dogs for live music! read more

Ok, this place is my absolute favorite place to come and play bluegrass music on a Tuesday nite. I fly here from TN just to be part of it - when I can :) read more

Wing night is the best! Have yet to try the rest of the menu items which all look amazing. The bar is a bit smokey but hey, it's worth the food. read more

a dump! don't understand the fuss, looks terrible, bartender terrible, wings terrible, people there terrible,

This is the second time I have come for lunch and I have the place to myself-- which is ok for me, but too bad for you! The soups are homemade excellent- just had the chicken and dumpling. So good. Now on to the famous pierogis which are tops. Ok, Starlight isn't trendy/swank but that's just another plus in its appeal column. I consider a place like Starlight a treasure where more and more, places like it are being replaced by chain crap. Do yourself a favor - come here, get some real food done well at an awesome price, and ditch the fast food and the not-so fast food places that make the food in Omaha or somewhere, freeze it (last year) so it can be fresh-microwaved today. read more

I don't even know how to rate this place. So we too saw it on food network. Being from a small down in PA, I can attest, this place is a DIVE. It is like the kind of dive where a couple of people from the neighborhood surely spend every day in here at the bar smoking and drinking. You have to KNOW what you are getting into before you go here, and if that makes you uncomfortable, better not go. Me on the other hand, if they have something delicious, I will go. The pierogies were 5 stars. Best I have ever eaten and obviously homemade and HUGE! The rest of the food was reasonably cheap and pretty tasty. The wings were pretty great too. I normally wouldn't even walk into, let alone eat at a place like this, but all of their other food was surprisingly good. I know darn well when I walked in with my family and kids everyone in the entire bar and the staff looked at us like, there are some city slickers coming in because they saw us on D,D, & D. Yup. Damn straight. Yuns gimme dem dar pierogies up dar over dar. read more

HORRIBLE service. For a dive bar, you can get past the not so great decor and slim menu, but awful and rude wait staff is NEVER acceptable. Save your cash for one of the million other places that service the same food - but better -and dont have the rude and awful waitresses that Starlite has. read more

This place is one of the burghs hidden Gems!Wings, Fish Sandwich, and Pierogis are my favorites. There is a bar in the front, and a dining room in the back for families to eat. Non smoking untill the kitchen closes. They have a Juice Box, haha and Golden Tee as well. read more

Friendly homey atmosphere (loved the Christmas tree and fire place) great comfort food esp loved the stuffed peppers, fish sandwiches, "Pittsburgh" salad and burgers all at amazing prices. A really fun night out. Loved being able to hear talented live music all at the same time! A must on our list of Pittsburgh institutions! read more

Poorly managed - advertising take out on a Friday evening in Lent -then takes over an hour to get order - while waiting there at the bar. Eat there - get your food a little faster - want it to go - forget about it. Can't comment on the food - after an hour being told it would be another hour we left angry and hungry. I guess we should have ordered to eat there then put in take out boxes ourselves. Would have maybe gotten the food then. read more

My husband and I went with high expectations after seeing DDD's on the Food Network. We were truly disappointed. First of all the waitress and barmaid were rude and acted like we were bothering them. There was only 1 other table with 7 people. The waitress was curt and snippy to the one woman who asked for extra napkins. The man wanted another beer and we could hear her sigh at our table. We looked at each other and said wow. Made us wonder about our decision, but we did have a coupon....................ah so we thought. When we went to pay the bill we were informed that they were no longer accepting them. It was a Groupon. There was no sign or notice anywhere in the place. Not on the door, wall or on the front of the menu. Bad business and unfair to unsuspecting customers. We still would have eaten there but we would not have ordered $40.00 worth of food for 2 in order to use the coupon. Called about it and owner,(Ron, I think was his name) was just as rude as his employees. I was requesting a refund as they had no notices posted. I really feel people should know up front if a program is discontinued. How many other patrons got caught up in this? Now about the food. Chicken soup was excellent as were the fries but the pierogies were mushy, soggy and swimming in grease with a couple of specks of onion. Poppers tasted like freezer and chicken sand was wet and tasteless. The place is very dark and dingy. I have no problem going into so called dives, but this place had my eyes looking everywhere to make sure nothing was crawling or moving!! This was truly a bad experience starting with the staff on duty. Thank heavens our waitress never came back to check on us, only just to give us our bill. She acted like the only 2 tables were really putting her out. Put a knot in my stomach. We worked all day and just wanted to relax not be on edge. We also got charged twice for a beverage. Waitress said barmaid was at fault and was very frustrated because bill was rung in already. This was a big deal to her. Did not make her happy. Won't ever go back or recommend this place to anyone. Save your money, go elsewhere, especially if you have a coupon!!!! read more

I heard this place makes some fab food so I decided to give it a shot after work. I walk in past the huge bar in the front of the place and into the restaurant in the back. The have a fireplace going and the other tables are full of other patrons enjoying their dinner. There is a sign which says please seat yourself, so I took off my jacket and grabbed a table by the wall. I sat there as other people were getting to order and the waitress cleared the table off next to me, after sitting and not even being greeted, let alone given silver ware or asked what to drink, I turned on the timer on my watch, and waited an additional 10 minutes by the timer. I then picked up my jacket and walked outside and left. After 20 minutes of waiting you can't even acknowledge my existence it's quite obvious you don't want my business. So the Starlite Lounge may have the greatest food on the planet, I'll never know, because after the way I was disrespected, I will never set foot in the establishment again, and I will discourage others from doing so as well. read more