Talk about a family business! With multiple locations around the area run by various family members we appreciate being able to find our local favorites like Stromboli and I love to get a salad with Italian and crumbly bleu cheese. Have a large crowd or event they have a nice space to accommodate that too. Family run businesses where they know your regular order without saying a word. read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

See all

We stopped in on our way home and was pleasantly surprised. The staff was pleasant, the place was clean, and we all really enjoyed our food. If you're gluten-free, I highly recommend their gluten-free pizza. It's one of the best I've had. read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Gluten-free Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

I would give no stars if I could. I called in an order and arrived to find they had no order. It happens, but when the owner treats you like you are lying and did not place an order, asks to see your caller ID which clearly shows you called them and then says, you couldn't order a pizza in 39 seconds. What does he think I was talking about for that amount of time with his employee? There were 3 of us in the car when I called, so 3 of us are lying? Then I said it might have been someone named Chris I spoke to. They don't have a Chris, so because I said that might be their name you accuse a customer of lying?! NEVER AGAIN. read more

ordered chicken Riggies online for pick up. Might have been good except when I got home I found out it was just Ziti??? because there was NO chicken! I mean if I wanted Ziti it was okay, but I REALLY wanTed Riggies.... And the house dressing for side salad was bland. read more

9/7/25 ordered Baked Ziti- Small Tossed Salad. Ziti noodles were way under cooked. No way could it be eaten.. I tossed it in the fridge. Too upset to call them that night I waited till next day. Called They said nothing they could do about it. No refund. Besides they said I wouldn't have the food any more. I told them that I still have it that it was in the refrigerator. Still said nothing they could do. I said so I just waisted my money for uncooked food. Then he said ok we can give you 20% off your next order. Really !!!! A WHOLE 20% ! BAD CUSTOMER... SERVICE BAD FOOD... read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Ziti... I still have it... - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

I really love this place. They have delicious food, friendly staff and it's always my son's choice if he wants pizza, pasta or a delicious calzone. Easy parking up front and back. However tables are usually sticky. I saw a young girl cleaning seats where ppl sit and table with same rag. Also this has never happened before last time I was there I waited over an hour for our food. Maybe it was my lasagna I ordered. I still do and would always pick this place over other pizza place in town. read more

I ordered 2 calzones and ordered extra sauce. A large pizza with mushrooms and extra cheese. I had them delivered. The calzones had hardly anything in it. They cook it with the sauce baked inside the calzone it was barely edible! The pizza was ok but they don't go to the edge with the sauce and cheese so it has 3 inches of crust so it is like ordering a small pizza. The taste was good. But it was expensive for what I got. I know it's busy but that is not an excuse for a making mediocre food. Go to the edge with the sauce and cheese ! And don't put my sauce inside my calzone. I wanted extra sauce and all the sauce was baked inside with the cheese and ham ? read more

Solid pizza and subs in Pulaski. Easy parking out front and decent service. Turkey sub was a pretty large and they even have gluten free pizza. Pizza was good! Ambiance is classic CNY pizza chic. read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Catering - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

I got a medium mushroom pizza. It didn't taste horrible but it completely fell apart. The middle of the pizza was just a soggy flopfest. The crust was too thick and the inside didn't have enough dough to support the weight of sauce and cheese. Multiple slices were picked up and had the toppings immediately just slide off into the box. read more

Friendly staff, quick service and simple menu. I wish they had cheddar or munster cheese as options for the sub sandwiches but they have a typical cheese selection for a CNY sub shop. Fried ravioli are solid here as are the chicken caesar wraps. read more

Food was OK service was a stone cold young lady who should do something new for a job. I asked her what she liked on the menu, she replied"I don't know" with a cound not care less. She took my order and while eating my salad she plopped my dinner on the table. I guess service with a smile and courtesy is not what she is about. Sad, I will not be going back. read more

I will start this as I always do by saying that I don't give out five stars unless I am really blown away. So this is one of those special reviews where five stars is needed. I have been here three times now and every time I come through Pulaski from now on I am getting a pizza to take home and some marinara to go. I wish we had a pizza place close to our house like this The pizza is awesome every time and the staff is always pleasant and on the top of their game. This time we were here with my daughter and the owner came over and said hello to us and we talked to him about how good the food was he offered our daughter more food to go. Again the staff was also top notch and that 3 cheese garlic pizza was the bomb. If you are in the area don't bother going anywhere else to eat just come here. I will be back here soon I hope you do too! read more

See all

Ordered a large pizza and crispy chicken salad for pick up (they use doordash). Upon arrival, the salad was ready but pizza wasn't. The owner said, "the doordash order for the pizza just came through a minute ago, we are making it now. There's something wrong with doordash." ...Even though the order receipt sitting on the salad container had the pizza listed, and there was deep fried chicken on the salad . After 15 minutes, two pizza boxes were set on the counter and a server said "you're all set." Everyone disappeared. We were confused, so we checked the boxes. They were both our pizza order, but it was one large and one small. No explanation was given, so we left with our order. After getting home, we realized why - The large pizza had a huge hole in the middle. No crust, just wet sloppy toppings - it had apparently stuck or was too thin and ripped. It's obvious now, that was the reason for the delay. We would've been understanding if it was communicated that the pizza had to be remade. Instead, we received a ripped messy large and a small. (Neither of which were thin crust or crispy, as requested). Most bizarre take on "customer service" ever experienced. Happy they have green olives as a topping though! read more

We have been coming here for over 20 yrs. This past year has been the worse cold food, over cooked hard chicken. Pizza under cook bread to doughy 7:00pm went to order a slice and waitress said all slices are sold out so from 7-9pm no pizza (smh) read more

We've always had excellent service and great food here. This evening we were a party of 8 (4 couples). I ordered a medium pizza with 3 toppings. When it was delivered there were two toppings only one of which was what I ordered. I told the server it was incorrect. Our server seemed flustered and in over her head. Another server asked what was wrong & offered to remake the pizza. But didn't want to wait as everyone else was digging in to their food. I suggested that if they would take 50% off, I'd be willing to eat what was delivered rather than making a new one. She said that if you want to keep it that they would just comp the item. I was impressed that she offered more than I asked for. Our server continued to be disorganized often having to correct items she brought or having to be asked multiple times for things like drink refills. A manager came over and asked about the order and I told him one of the servers said they would comp the pizza. The others at the table heard what she said. But the manager said, "We don't do that." I said, but your employee stated it would be comped. The manager walked away & then left the restaurant (which I didn't realize right away). When the bill came there was 10% off the pizza. I objected, but since the manager had left some poor young guy who seemed to be functioning as an asst manager said there was nothing else he could do. He even texted his manager who just confirmed the 10% off. I told this poor guy that I understood that his hands were tied, that he didn't have the authority to adjust anything, and I was not mad at him. But that when an employee tells me that an item will be comped, I expect the business to stand by that. So I paid the bill, NOT happily!! Meanwhile the server was having trouble getting appropriate containers for our leftovers. She had to be asked multiple times for containers. I left a small tip, much smaller than my usual 30+%. Again, we've always had very positive experiences here, but this evening was terrible on two fronts: very poor service from our server AND a manager who would not acknowledge or stand by what his employee said about comping an incorrect item. I'm hoping this is an isolated incident. read more

Small menu but the pizza is very good and excellent crust. The Buffalo chicken sub was ok. Wasn't my favorite but not bad just a lot of bread. Service- can tell they're operating short staffed but they were pleasant and got everything right. I would recommend them if in town. read more

Stefano's Pulaski - "The meat" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

See all

One of the best places for pizza and wings! Ordered for an event at my store for the employees, and WOW! Chicken wings were crisp on the outside moist in the middle, and fantastic flavor.....I ordered medium. The pizza was amazing, crisp edges tons of cheese (didn't even order extra cheese), and the buffalo chicken pizza was soooooo flavorful. I plan on ordering from here every time I'm in Pulaski, and would ride the bike for a quick day trip just to have it again! read more

Staff was friendly and helpful, even offered to separate the pasta dish we shared. The dish was short on sauce (alfredo) and the kitchen refused our server's ask for more, even after we said we don't have an issue paying for it. Found that odd and unhelpful, so we can't recommend an Italian restaurant that won't sell extra sauce. Just not a customer-friendly atmosphere. read more

The food is mediocre at best, but the way the owner treats its staff is inexcusable I know a lot of people like food there but again, just not for me I guess read more

Family owned business with predictably delicious Italian food and solid service. I've had 2 meals here and they were great tasting and reasonably priced. Pasta carbonara was served in a large bowl with a plethora of bacon. Creamy, full of flavor, bacon in every bite with fresh pasta, boom sauce! They serve a side salad that is typical and plain. I liked the dressing and the salad was not bad, just simple. A huge Highlite to the meal is they have Peroni on tap. $4 for a pint. Great meal. The other meal I ordered was Chicken Parm with ziti. It comes out with two breaded fried breasts with a layer of melted cheese. On the side you get red gravy on ziti. This meal also comes with fresh baked roles with butter and a side salad, I went with Caesar. I think this is the better choice. The dinning area is family style, comfortable booths with big tables. They have a couple of TVs with sports on. Parking is all around the building and it is easy to get in and out. I look forward to eating here again. read more

Went salmon fishing with family and needed lunch been craving pizza so I tried this place out getting the family meal deal $38 and change with tax) came with large cheese 20 wings and large antipasto. Cheese pizza I really enjoyed despite the crust being not crispy and tad soft/flimsy but the flavor was there and the sauce spot on. Would def get the cheese pizza again Wings were mild and soggy drowning in sauce which I didn't care for to be honest but the sauce was ok. (Love a crispy wing) Antipasto was LOADED with meat and over all alright. The pizza was the star it was a hit between the 6 of us who ate it. Next time I'm fishing I'd def get a slice or two read more

The food is always hot and delish. Anthony is the best hostess I've ever had and so polite and kind and it's just a cozy place to eat.

Eat pizza all over USA, this is great pizza. Thin, tasty, plenty of toppings, fresh! Stefano's Italian dinners with salad and garlic toast, also direct hit! read more

Little did we know this stop along the road would yield such a fabulous meal. Nice homey family atmosphere, and excellent service. Definitely a place to watch sports. You could tell that it was family owned by all the baby pictures on the wall but it didn't distract from the amazing Italian food. It's not every time you eat an Italian restaurant you get to have garlic knots soaked in garlic butter. They were flavorful and delicious. Huge menu options but we went with the pasta. Bolognese angel hair, and rigatoni vodka, just like grandma used to make. The music wasn't too loud, the atmosphere was a delight, and it was clear that all ages were welcome. As far as Pulaski eating goes, take out or dine in, you can't do better than Stefano's. read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Delicious homemade garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

We love to dine at Stefano's. We have always had good food and service there. We love their sauce, chicken riggies and their pizzas.

This pizzeria is terrible always mess up the orders send it at the wrong time the owner was very rude they sent me the wrong pizza when I ordered a deep dish pizza they sent me a round pizza meat supreme it was terrible tasted like cardboard I will never ever ever ever go back to his place I wish I can give it a zero rating read more

One of our favorite restaurants!! The food is always good. The staff is helpful, cheerful and knowledgeable about their products. Don't hesitate to stop in. And please support local businesses during this unusual time. Local places need our support much more than chain businesses! read more

Simply said, I just love this place! It is certainly a local, family run establishment which I tend to like over chain locations. The pizza and wings here are outstanding! It is that simple. The the large pizzas are good sized (we only get large... that is how good they are) and always come with plenty of toppings! No, refrozen stuff here! Now, if you're a health nut, you may not like this aspect, but in my book, "one" of the characteristics of a great pizza is that a small pool of grease will form in the center of the pizza... if you've never seen this, then you've not had great pizza and you can do so by coming right here. The wings here are also outstanding. They don't fool around with undersized chicken parts where the wing is about the size of your pinkey or thumb.... no way... here they are much larger. These wings have a ton of meat on them. They also offer several degrees of heat, so most likely they'll accommodate the various desires of any group or family coming here wanting to share some wings. This place can get packed, so you need to time it right. We've found getting here on the tad early size works well! Oh yea... and I can't forget about the staff. They are friendly and get the job done and most important, they make sure your glasses don't go empty! read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

Another great meal from this place... delivered to me at camp & did not disappoint! Thanks y'all at Stefano's! read more

Awesome pizza and wings this summer! We were camping at Selkirk Shores state parks and they deliver there. Good to know!

Second time here. Pizza is good. Ceasar salad w grilled chicken also good. Raspberry tea perfect. Portions are generous. read more

See all

Love it!!!! They had great music playing and their Sicilian pizza tasted absolutely fantastic! They also had very efficient and kind staff. All in all, this restaurant was wonderful and I definitely recommend eating here if you're ever in Pulaski! read more

This place was always great but the last two times I've visited the food was terrible. I ordered Egg Plant Pharm one of my favorites but it was terrible. I contacted the management they took the information and never got back to me. I won't go back! read more

My husband and I have made the trip to Pulaski a few times in the last 6ish months, and Stefano's is always our go-to place. Yummy food, great service and people, with easy ordering and delivery. A definite go-to for a visit in Pulaski! read more

These folks know how to make pizza! The garlic knots are yummy! Friendly staff and restaurant setting was warm and welcoming.

My idea of a good "family run" Pizzeria & Restaurant! The ambiance is great "Italian Soccer Teams Theme", Plenty of seating,My family and I have ordered just about everything that is on the menu over the years and have been happy with just about all the dishes (I'm picky, so there are some things that sound good that I end up not eating a second bite of).I am a HUGE fan of their thin crust pizza, stuffed shells, calzone, and calamari. I didn't give it 5 because I think the prices are a little too high for the amount of food you get in each order. The wait staff also becomes "forgetful" sometimes. read more

Stefano's Pulaski - Pizza Near Me - Pulaski, New York

This is a nice small italian restraunt in Pulaski. We stop by for a few slices of pizza and a drink from time to time. Lets be honest.... we are like about 50% of the population in Pulaski around the sept-oct timeframe. We are there to catch some fish and small places like this are easy to get in and out. This trip we had a few pizza slices and a drink each for the two of us. It is a deal for a lunch only costing about 14 dollars. Filling and good quality. We have tried the hot subs as well and were pleased. This place does have the tendency to get very busy around lunch. So, if you are expecting to get in and out make sure you order ahead. read more

All of the food came out super quick and the service was friendly. Easy going environment. And the cannolis are AMAZING!!

Really terrible food. Got food delivered: calzone with mushrooms, sausage, and hot peppers, spaghetti marina with meatballs, garlic knots, and cinna knots. Every single thing ordered was pretty disgusting. The calzone was limp with grease leaking out. The spaghetti was bland and the knots were just balls of oil and butter. Never getting anything here again. read more

Food is great. Hometown vibe is strong. Be prepared to wait during tourist and fishing seasons. Service can be somewhat uneven. Conserve your beverage. If they offer you a table for two in the corner, decline. You need a tea set to accommodate. read more