Fast, reasonably priced, yummy pizza. When we go to Door County, we always have at least one meal…read moreas a take out pizza from Wild Tomato. You can dine in, plenty of seating with outdoor seating views of the beach, but you may have to wait during peak hours. We opt for the convenient takeout counter near the bay and head back to our hotel. We have also grabbed it for an easy meal on the Sister Bay beach, mere steps away, or to have while tailgating before the Door County Drive In double feature. It always hits the spot!

Wild tomato is a great pizza spot in Sister Bay! Conveniently located on the beach for grab and go…read morepizza or they have both indoor and outdoor dining. It's usually pretty busy so we tend to use the pick up option and take it back to our hotel. They have some specialty pizzas that's are fine but I think the classics like pepperoni and cheese are the way to go here! Nothing fancy, just good solid pizza slices to share with friends and family. We always make a stop here while spending time in Sister Bay!

So far, this place had the best Detroit style pizza I've ever had (disclaimer: I've only had…read moreDetroit style at four places in Milwaukee and one place in Denver). The dough was buttery and fluffy, and the edges of the crust had perfectly caramelized cheese to add a crispy texture. The sauce, cheese, and toppings were all delicious! They serve one size and only Detroit style, so that makes your decision easier. Hours vary, so check their social media page (mainly IG) the week you plan to go. Usually open some combination of Wednesday, Thursday, & Friday from 4pm to 8pm. Plan accordingly and trust me, you NEED to eat here if you like pizza!

Food was good, but service was slow! The ambiance was nice but it was small and the pizza took an…read morehour and a half to get.

Stopped back and dined in, having the Taco Pollo again! It came out in less than 20 minutes, was…read morehot, fresh, and tasty. TV's, games, fire pits, and indoor and outdoor seating. Counter service for food and drink.

We stopped to get pizza from Pizza Bros for dinner. A group of 5 women split two pizzas and it was…read moreenough to fill us up with a couple leftover slices. We got the pesto Presto and Pulled Pork BBQ. Both were great! There were a lot more fun pizza flavors on the menu I would like to try next time I'm in the area.

While the Margareta pie makes it worth the drive, the traditional hand tossed pizza is da bomb!…read more This is best wood fired pizza on the Penninsula ! Call & pick up ... the online order seems to shut down by 6p.... Leap frog your effort & just call it in... it's all good!

Shared the green and gold pizza along with a Caesar salad…read more Decidedly underwhelming. First time disappointed with their pizza. Lacked flavor, chicken was blah. Crust still good. Caesar uninspired. Could do better with bag salad from grocery store.

Another place we never miss when coming to Door County. Our…read moreServer was friendly and attentive even though she was VERY busy. Recommend: Brat and side salad with a good blue cheese dressing. Rib eye sandwich. Never had a bad meal. Lively fun place.

I really really wanted to enjoy this place but unfortunately the service fell short. When we came…read morein the bartender came over and half our group ordered drinks while the others were still deciding. The bartender never came back to check in on us again. We sat with our drinks empty on the edge, politely waving to get her attention but she never came back. Hoping to try this place another time and hope for better for better service. The bar itself was cool with what looks like an original wood bar.

Felt like pizza. Went to Della right at 5P. Seated immediately and proceeded to order calamari…read morewhich was delicious, tender and tasty. Followed with salad dressed with a light vinaigrette - salad was only lettuce which was a disappointment. Split to Margarita with prosciutto pizza. Pizza was undercooked and wet in the middle. Cheese was not fresh mozzarella, but rather regular mozzarella and basal was hard to find. Prosciutto serving was generous and only slightly warm. Disappointed to say the least. Place has nice ambience and great staff. Highly recommend without any reservations. Best pizza on the peninsula hands down.

We arrived with a reservation. There were nine of us. We got seated right at our reservation time…read more There was mixed reviews on the food, but I enjoyed mine. Mine was the $39 white fish with broccolini and potatoes. The fish was in parchment paper and it was a giant serving. I definitely recommend this entrée. We all discussed that the chairs are not the most comfortable we've ever sat on. I'm sure some people love them, but for the majority of the people in our group. It was a hard no

We arrived the last hour they were gonna be open and the service was Great!!…read more Bar service and pizza staff were all smiles and helpful. Pizza was delishes!!

Had pizza here before the concert at the Peg Eagan...lots of table space but a few broken umbrellas…read moreso a bit hard to find shade. But I'm sure that will be fixed. Crazy busy night for them due to concert so take the comment with a grain of salt, or a slice of their very good pizza! Also had the Caesar which was yummy! Beer menu is awesome. All in all, a great venue and food is good so we will be back.

The pizza is maybe a 5 on a 1 to 10 scale. The cheese curds were the same. If you want really…read moregreat cheese curds go to Wild Tomato. We ordered the Cherry Bomb which has Volka in it. The menu suggested asking for Titos so we did. The menu or server never mentioned it would be a dollar extra. The service was great besides all that.

Overall- it was a super nice visit. We were able to sit…read moreoutside on the patio. Perfect night to eat outside. Our waiter was super friendly - and attentive. We had a set time for later plans and they were able to accommodate us easily and we didn't feel rushed at all.

I'm normally just a chocolate ice cream kind of girl. My husband wanted to try this place for ice…read morecream and I said I didn't want any. Shocking, I know. He came back with English toffee and deer tracks and oh my goodness shut the front door. The English toffee was fantastic and I don't even like toffee. In fact I really dislike it. But this ice cream was fantastic. What have I been missing my whole life?! The deer tracks filled my typical chocolate craving right to the core. So here was a girl not wanting ice cream to totally enjoying a double scoop.

Ice cream 7/10. Customer service, 1/10. We asked to sample an ice cream flavor and the young woman…read moretaking our order rolled her eyes at us and I really thought she was gonna say no.