While the Margareta pie makes it worth the drive, the traditional hand tossed pizza is da bomb!…read more This is best wood fired pizza on the Penninsula ! Call & pick up ... the online order seems to shut down by 6p.... Leap frog your effort & just call it in... it's all good!

Wild Tomatoes in Fish Creek is one of those places where you immediately understand why the parking…read morelot looks like a Black Friday event at lunchtime. We went around lunch and it was PACKED with of course limited indoor seating, crowded parking, people everywhere but honestly the food made it worth squeezing in. The tomato mozzarella salad was SO fresh and delicious, and the pizza absolutely lived up to the hype. We got the goat cheese & spinach pizza with hot honey and wow... whoever decided hot honey belonged on pizza deserves a raise. Sweet, spicy, cheesy perfection. Even my four year old loved a kick on the pizza. Now for the reason this isn't a 5-star review: the service. Our waiter seemed like he'd rather be literally anywhere else on earth. We had to ask multiple times for refills, and the overall vibe felt like we personally ruined his afternoon simply by existing. I totally understand places get busy, especially during tourist season, and we also had a four year old that was starving and was quiet about it with us so we weren't expecting royal treatment, but good service and a friendly attitude really do change the whole experience. The food? 10/10. The atmosphere? Cozy chaos. The waiter? Needed a snack, a nap, or maybe both. Would absolutely come back for the pizza alone. Just hoping next time our server likes people a little more. Solid 4/5.

Our first time there and we'll definitely be back. Beautiful decor and even though we didn't order…read moreany, the bakery/desserts in their display case looked amazing! Even though it was barely 11am, they let us order a pizza. Oh man! A new favorite! Order at the counter and they bring it to your table. Give it a try!

This place I randomly stumbled upon when I was taking a walk with my friend! We ended up getting a…read morecoffee and desert! I'm a huge fan of iced mochas, so I decided to try it and it was alright. Something tasted a little off! 6/10 For desert I decided to have a piece of chocolate cake which is my FAVORITE!!!! It was a tad bit dry, but I still ate the whole thing! 6.5/10 Overall setting is pretty, it's spacious they have a big menu. Staff was super nice!

Oh wow, 7 years since my last review? Definitely time for an update. Please see my original…read morereview as well. We decided to aim for a late lunch here since they tend to fill up during traditional lunch hours and then ramp up again for an early dinner crowd. 2:30pm on a weekday was perfect. Only a few tables were filled inside with more people outside on the patio, but it looked like there was still room there too. They have great beer selections including local draft choices. I had a local hazy IPA that was excellent. We shared a cherry, goat cheese and walnut salad which was delicious and definitely plenty for two. We went with a 16 inch sausage and pesto pizza which was excellent and the housemade sausage didn't disappoint. Leftovers were delicious cold the next day. Service was good and the atmosphere is relaxed and casual. The kitchen is open so you can watch the team tossing dough to make the pizzas. Parking is usually not too hard to find along the main street through town.

Wild Tomato Pizza is 100% worth the hype, guys. The service is quick, the staff is friendly and the…read morelocation is super cute. With so many tasty sounding choices to choose from, we were happy to learn you can do half and half pizzas -- we tried half "El Fuego" and half "Hot Honey." The crust was so good and the pizza was generous in flavor and toppings.

I've been coming to Door County for over 25 years and to Sonny's for at least 10. The place is…read moregetting run down and at 5:00 they took almost 5 minutes to even greet us. Then their "famous" pizza was loaded with salt and tasted horrible. I also had a piece of lasagna that obviously was just thrown in the microwave and re-heated. It was super hot on the top and cold in the middle. I didn't want to even mention how bad the food was because the server was a new hire and I didn't want to discourage the lady. If I'm not mistaken Sonny was from Chicago and if so he needs to go back to visit and rediscover why he got into the business. Otherwise close the place. Much better choices for pizza in town. I'm never going back.

What a great start to our girls trip! When I say we got bar food we got probably exactly what you…read moreare thinking. Heres our line up: chicken tenders hot dog bacon cheeseburger chili (served on spaghetti noodles like skyline chili) fish n chips What can I say? Everything was great and up to par. Service was good! The place was packed, too!

I really really wanted to enjoy this place but unfortunately the service fell short. When we came…read morein the bartender came over and half our group ordered drinks while the others were still deciding. The bartender never came back to check in on us again. We sat with our drinks empty on the edge, politely waving to get her attention but she never came back. Hoping to try this place another time and hope for better for better service. The bar itself was cool with what looks like an original wood bar.

Great spot in the heart of Sister Bay with a large and fun patio. We sat on the upper patio, which…read moreserves the whole menu. The waitstaff was so kind and accommodating, and didn't mind pulling over extra chairs for our large party on a busy Saturday. The Garage below serves a variety of frozen drinks- you can grab one and bring it to your table, or take one for the road! Food was pretty solid!

Such a fun bar! The music, drinks, and ambiance was set for a great time. The bartenders were…read morefriendly and quick with their service. I definitely would come back for a fun time! I enjoyed the outside area during the day!

Delicious ice cream made on premises. So many flavors and sundaes. We loved it so much we're…read morecoming back to try more flavors. The original inside with wooden booths is cute. Butter pecan, peanut butter and coconut were very good. Door county cherry was good but I'd prefer more tartness. The ice cream was creamy and not at all icy. It's so much better than Wilson's, both service and ice cream. The Lick custard was also good but we prefer door county ice cream

The ice cream was good. The staff was friendly and they have some good choices. The building was…read morecool also. We sat outside and enjoyed the night. A delicious treat after sun set I like the fun flavor choices they had I felt some original flavors

Sister Bay Bowl is everything you want in a classic Wisconsin supper club experience. The…read morecombination of a traditional supper club and bowling alley gives it so much character and charm. If you want a true taste of Wisconsin, start with a brandy Old Fashioned--nobody does them quite like Wisconsin, and theirs was excellent. We visited on a Friday night and enjoyed the classic Wisconsin fish fry. The food was outstanding, the service was exceptional, and I have to mention that they serve the best blue cheese dressing I've had in a long time. Our waiter was incredibly sweet, attentive, and made us feel right at home. One of the highlights of the evening was meeting the owner, Penny. She took the time to share the history of the supper club, which was especially meaningful to me because my own parents owned a supper club. Hearing the stories and traditions behind the place made the experience even more special. Great food, wonderful people, and authentic Wisconsin hospitality. Sister Bay Bowl is a Door County gem that I highly recommend.

Hidden and historic gem; definitely a diamond in the rough. Yes, you can bowl. Yes, there's a bar…read more But the food is what keeps us coming back. Excellent fish and great servers. Wait times can vary and favorites can run out, so we try to go early.

Overall- it was a super nice visit. We were able to sit…read moreoutside on the patio. Perfect night to eat outside. Our waiter was super friendly - and attentive. We had a set time for later plans and they were able to accommodate us easily and we didn't feel rushed at all.

Cherry Bombs and the best salmon entree!! Service is friendly. Great family game area outside and…read morewe love the bartender!