This is a great little store especially if you need baking supplies. This store doesn't carry…read moreeverything like big markets. They have great pre-made salads and sandwiches. Including a great deli to buy your meats or you can have a sandwich made. They were pretty busy when we went in so we just looked. They have a delicious homemade pizza crust and you can buy the toppings for it. I like the spices, dried fruit and baking isles the best. Stop by and take a look. Great little store.

Excellent prices and food variety !! Friendly service people great selection, variety of food…read morechoices, specials on many party supplies !!

Great lunch place. Everything seems to be made fresh and service was fast…read more Good daily soup and I had the small or half Dagwood with a cup of soup and it was plenty.

We stopped just passing by on a trip. I had the egg salad wrap, and my husband had the Corn beef…read moreand Swiss on rye. We also ordered a small order of the potato salad. Curbside was great, but the food for me was lacking. The potato salad tasted like it was store-bought. The egg salad seemed dry and tasteless. The folks were super friendly that brought out our order. We probably would not stop again when passing through. I appreciate service with a smile, but I love tasty food as well and this didn't hit a home run for me.

Good food. Wear a sweater. Cold inside. Cant get better food or service in this area. Much…read morebetter than any Amish restaurant.

So far, with two visits, it's probably a 3.5. Went 3-4 months ago, and tried the Asian salad and…read moreTex-mex egg rolls. Both were solid, I think I remember the salad being a bit small. This visit I got the beer-battered fish with fries and Cole slaw. I don't think I'd get that again. Ok, but nothing special.

Road trip and time for lunch. We wanted to grab a quick sandwich. Jersey Mike's is pretty…read moreconsisent from location to location. Restaurant was pretty clean. Service was mediocre. Interestingly, the person kept trying to convince my wife to move up to a much larger sandwich when she was thinking about a smaller one. Prep is slow. Mostly because of the business model of fresh cut meats. Having dedicated staff to do the cutting would make it a bit quicker. Again, a good sandwich that is consisent across locations.

We order here at least once every week and have CONSISTENTLY received fast, courteous service and…read moreaccurate, DELICIOUS sandwiches. The brownies melt in your mouth. Reading these other terrible comments from other reviewers is so completely opposite our experience with the location, and as I stated earlier, it's a family favorite that we frequent A LOT! Now that I'm thinking about it, I just might have to make a run tomorrow!

Stopped by on our way home from visiting the Amish Country and so glad we did. The food, service…read moreand atmosphere were amazing. Would definitely visit again!

Got the rangoons and they were delicious! Our waitress was attentive and the beers were definitely…read moredelicious ! I would love to go back.

The food was amazing; service superb and we got to meet and talk with the owners. It's a small…read morelocally owned place with that welcoming feeling

We had a great lunch at the Mill Street Diner on New Year's Eve. Not much was open in Amish Country…read morethat day so we felt lucky that they were open. They were steadily busy, but the staff was friendly and upbeat. It is in an old building that made you feel you had stepped back in time. Comfortable booths and high ceilings. Very homey feel. The food was hot and flavorful and not very expensive. We'll be back when we are in Sugarcreek again!

Great service - quality food with an extra homemade feel. Portions are large and the prices are…read moregreat. Their lunch menu is perfect for the person on the go.

My go to Italian restaurant. Good food. Reasonable pricing. Friendly service. Poor parking.read more

Atmosphere: When we walked in, we were immediately approached by an older couple who were very…read morefriendly and throughout the night would continue to joke with us, gamble with us and just be a delight. You could tell they were regulars to this bar. The severs and all the ladies working there were so nice, patient and accommodating (I was on crutches). We had a couple shots and were playing pull tabs before ordering any food and the server was just fine with that and regularly checked up on us. Food: my partner ordered loaded nachos with chili and I ordered the chicken sandwich. Both plates came out with hot food and great portions. The fries that came with my chicken sandwich were like fair fries. Perfect with ketchup, salt and vinegar. I will say, I took most of my meal home but mainly just because I wasn't that hungry. My partner said the nachos were a 7/10 but having some sort of taco meat would have been good on the nachos but we do understand why they wouldn't have that especially if there is nothing else on the menu that call for it. Overall: We had a great time. We live in Canton and were just in dover to puppy sit for a friend but we have definitely talked about returning to shenanigans once every couple of weeks to attend some of the events I see they have on Facebook and to try more of the food. The patio is so large, private and just a great vibe and energy. We know we would have a lot of fun there in the future.

Ordered the "thanksgiving" lol dish for this year, after having ordered it last year and was…read morepleasantly surprised by it and how good it was (except the cranberry sauce). This year's attempt fell short of the goal. Disappointed to say the least. It was not good and the serving size, compared to the amount, doesn't match the value or lack there of.