I wanted to get an incredible cake for the gf and her friends for her birthday and fired up my…read morehandy dandy Yelp app. While scrolling through some great options, I saw Sydney's Sweets pop up in the list and was so glad I did. Now I've known about them for a while but this was my first actually ordering from them. I called on a Saturday at about 3pm and Jermaine answered the call, both literally and figuratively. I nervously mentioned I needed a cake for the evening.. by 6pm, as I needed to be in Williamsburg by 7:15pm. He responded not to worry as they had a beautiful 10'' double chocolate, oreo cookie, multi-layered cake that would fit the occasion perfectly... my heroes! The gf and her friends absolutely loved the cake and were wow'd by how pretty, big and delicious it was. We had 7 people at the table and even after some folks took big pieces to go, we had nearly half the cake to take home!

Very pleased with Sydney's Sweets. I had a vision, and they nailed it. They were professional and…read moreresponsive, communication was great, and they understood the assignment. The cake was at the venue before I arrived, so I didn't have to worry about delivery, which was particularly helpful since the party was in Manhattan. The cake was a huge part of our 50th birthday celebration, and I'm so glad we used them. Not only was the cake flawless, but it also tasted good - it was red velvet with cream cheese frosting. I would definitely use this company again, you won't be disappointed.

My daughter was very adamant that she wanted a Cake with her favorite Anime show on it for her…read morebirthday . She was very specific with the characters she wanted on her cake as well . And every wish she wanted, Holy Sweets made come true . She was so happy and that really brightened our day on her birthday . Holy Sweets is as good as it gets . And the cakes looks and taste as righteous as it's name .

I must say that her cupcakes are absolutely delicious and I'm sure the cakes are just as good. Not…read moreonly are her cakes beautiful but she's a beautiful person as well.

Totally amazing!! I had to order a custom cake for my daughters bday and she was kind enough to…read moreaccommodate me last minute( a day before). The cake looked amazing and was loved by everyone. It also tasted great. Red velvet with chocolate filling!!!!!!

So we have worked with this place 4 times. And twice they have been great and twice they have been…read moreok. Our wedding cake was amazing and perfect. It had everything that we wanted in a cake. For my son's baby shower we we're going for a beach theme and that was ok. I guess my expectations were kind of high because of how the wedding cake turned out. Then for my son's 1st bday party I wanted cupcakes with something from the Incredibles. They came up with printed edible sheets on top of the icing. And then recently for my son's 4th bday party we asked for a lightning McQueen Cake. While cartoony we didn't have crazy high expectations and my son loved the toy on top of the cake. Everything that was made for us tasted great. Can't complain about the taste. And price is very reasonable. I just know now that if we something fancy like a wedding cake to definitely come here.

It's not as good as I remember, but definitely still sells fresh tasty baked goods. The staff was…read moreefficient and although it's not aesthetically instagrammable inside, it's your typical old-school Italian bakery... nothing wrong with that!

Four stars because I was only there once. The sfogatelle was amazing. it was light and very crunchy…read morewith the perfect amount of filling. I went back and bought a dozen to bring home. (P.s. reheat in a toaster oven next day if any are left): The semolina loaf and the assorted Italian cookies were very good. Next time I'm out that way I'm dying to try the cannolis, which I read in the reviews were also very good. The ladies were very nice, place was well kept and clean. Old school Italian bakery. Hope they don't change.

The cake was so Beautiful. Order process was quick and easy online. The cake was ready for pick up…read more I loved the whole experience. The place itself is gorgeous, and I will definitely order from there again.

I wish i could give zero stars! Horrible customer service and extremely rude staff! I ordered a…read morecake for a birthday party, and it arrived cracked. When I contacted the bakery for assistance, the staff members were not only unhelpful but unbelievably rude. There are so many other bakeries in the neighborhood that value their customers and stand behind their products. I would not recommend this bakery.

I chose the cheesecake almond toffee cone and the rainbow cookie cheesecake and both were very…read moregood. I found them both to be a tad bit too sweet but they are sweets, after all. The almond toffee cone is a really ingenious idea and I loved the idea of the crust of the other cheesecake being rainbow cookies. I'll definitely be back to try other things in the future.

Old time Brooklyn Italian pastry shop they been there for many many years I'm 65 they have to be…read morethere 80 yrs best cannoli best pastry and cookies just amazing almost life changing place is spotless I wish I didn't live so far from there but worth the drive for me

Great cake and they payed attention to the details I wanted. I had came in just a day before to…read moreplace an order and they were able to work with me. Good flavor of dulce de leche and my guests loved it !

Small quaint business. Friendly service. Good prices. Delicious Dominican cake. Will be back.read more

I've been buying cakes and other desserts for years. I used to live around the corner then moved to…read moreanother county. Would still drive here to Dominican cake. Now, live out of state and still order cakes for special occasions.

We ordered a Dominican Birthday cake and were so disappointed! The cake was tough and not very…read moresweet. I grew up Dominican cake it's supposed to have a soft, spongy texture, and taste sweet (imagine the texture and taste of a twinkie-sans all the chemicals). The price was great and the decoration was beautiful, but nobody liked the cake. It was the first time I had so much leftover cake that I had to throw it out.