Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sugar Mama Bakery

    3.8 (42 reviews)

    Sugar Mama Bakery Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sugar Mama Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Grant A.

    Got 3 cupcakes. All were pretty sweet. The top to the S' Mores one was tougher than I would have imagined. The other 2 were just soft enough and the taste was just right.

    a long table and chairs
    Mr. S.

    This is my favorite bakery in the area! The staff is amazing and incredibly friendly. The baked goods are so good! You were definitely want o enjoy a gooey bar and sit in the cool atmosphere.

    Unicorn poop that melts in your mouth
    Jesmin N.

    If you've got a sweet tooth or a craving, this is the place to go! This randomly came up on my instagram as a sponsored page. After looking through all the pictures I knew I had to get my hands on their goodies (we went after work the same day!). What I loved is that along with regular cupcakes, they offer mini versions of all their flavors!! We got a half dozen - creamsicle, chocolate hoohah, birthday cake, snickerdoodle, snickers, and peanut butter. Every single one of them were delicious. It was hard not to eat them all in one sitting! I'll definitely be a repeat customer.

    Marble Drip Cake.

    Sugar Mama has improved over the years, and I like their new location. I ordered a cake for my mom's birthday. It was decorated beautifully, the size was perfect, and the taste was even better. Almond buttercream with vanilla cake inside. Everyone loved it and commented on how rich it tasted. I would definitely recommend this bakery.

    They are really fast, I order the cake at 9am, I picked it up at noon. Really good service, loved the work. Little too pricey for me, thats the only issue I have. 4.5 rating easily.

    White cake with chocolate icing

    One of the best bakery in town !!! The cake was moist and delicious. The cake deco came out perfected and just how I wanted it. I love the fact it looks how it taste (amazing) !

    Cherry Pie and Salted Carmel cupcakes

    See all

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Sugar Mama Bakery

    You might also consider

    Denny's Doughnuts & Bakery

    Denny's Doughnuts & Bakery

    4.0
    (52 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $

    Breakfast is the main time to come to this long time favorite in Bloomington. Denny's Doughnuts…read morealways has a variety of sweet treats on hand. It also has an indoor dining area if planning to sit and stay. Coffee is basic but it's hot at least. There's also bagels as an option. A pretty worn out looking bakery from the looks of things in here. It's obviously been here quite awhile, and is one of the few breakfast places around for locals. The main thing is the doughnuts obviously. Has a few other things to get started in the morning. It's about $2 for coffee, which is pretty basic stuff out of a well. A few flavors. There's nothing really interesting about it. It's about $1.50 for a bagel. These again are pretty basic, with limited options as far as toppings. Come here if getting a pretty basic breakfast. It's basic coffee and lots of doughnuts. There's also some bagels but these are unremarkable.

    Oh my goodness--thank the universe for Denny's Doughnurs & Bakery! Traditionally, our marching band…read moreeats cookies and drinks hot chocolate after a long day of competing. In the past, the cookies were purchased in the suburbs of Chicago and driven to the Bloomington area. After many failed attempts to source cookies within the band budget, it was suggested we call Denny's! Not only were their cookies $6 cheaper (PER COOKIE), they were willing to customize them to match the show theme of wolves. The price was so nice, we ordered 2 for every high schooler! The cookies came out exactly as I imagined and they were so delicious! We enjoyed some leftovers back home for a couple of days. I am already dreaming about the cookies for the 2026 marching season!

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Half dozen donuts $7.50
    Half dozen donuts $7.50
    Entrance

    See all

    Entrance
    Sugar Art

    Sugar Art

    1.5
    (2 reviews)
    2.3 mi

    Let me preface this by saying the ONLY reason this business didn't get one star is because…read more.. bottom line... the cake was yummy. Hands down it WAS what I ordered, and it WAS pretty. Be forewarned, the owner doesn't like to do cakes, she'd rather do meal catering. Also be warned her business closes at 4 pm (even though there are no hours posted on the door- and this information wasn't offered at the time the order was placed) If you go to pick up your surprise birthday cake for an event that starts at 5, and if you get there at 3:55 you will find yourself standing in front of a locked bakery, calling the business number repetedly in vain and swearing profusely. You may get lucky and a store neighbor might see your meltdown and even though THEY also don't know how to reach the owner, they might let you know that her brother owns Monster Pawn (yea Monster Pawn). They answer their phones at Monster Pawn! The owners sister in law might jump through hoops to get you to your cake before your party self-destructs. That's nice. The owner did eventually contact me, but she did not come back to the store and her sister-in-law saved the day.

    Sugar ART?? What a joke!! I ordered a custom cake for a baby shower for a girl. NOTHING about…read morethis cake indicates it's for a baby shower! The paint job looks like alligator skin, and the fondant "mother to be" on a motorcycle looks like a Mr. Bill claymation done by a grade-schooler. When I called to complain, I got attitude from the "manager" and was asked to bring it back for them to fix it, even though I had a house full of people coming in an hour and a half and I live in Danvers. The entire cake was horrific and became the joke of the baby shower. This place deserves a negative rating. You should be ashamed!!

    Sugar Mama Bakery - bakeries - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...